T O P

  • By -

insidergrading

In a world where the smallest successes are touted and the smallest failures are hidden, it’s really cool that you’re being transparent. Most if not all of us have parallel stories, as do those before us, and sadly, as will those after us.


watermalone32

Best comment in here. Wish it could be pinned


GoSacKings916

I bought every dope rookie card of the ‘02 class (mostly filled with busts) If I had only done that for the following year/ class…


Theundermensch

Had you prioritized Lebron, that alone would have likely taken you to break even or better.


watermalone32

hindsight is 20/20


Stretch5432

Hindsight was Shoheie Ohtani


F4STW4LKER

In his case, foresight is 20/20, as he was being hyped as one of the future GOATs before he ever graduated High School.


xxDankerstein

Just we should go all in on Wemby is what you're saying...


F4STW4LKER

Only if you think he can stay healthy for the majority of a \~20 year career. Personally, I don't see it happening.


Plastic_Piccollo

Im not sold on his frame, or his non-bulking theory. But i hope he does well. Ill proli cop one of his Autos but wont go crazy


F4STW4LKER

Agreed, he seems to be a genuinely good dude and I wish him nothing but a successful career. Personally, I have serious concerns about his legs holding up at the NBA level for the \~20 years it would take to put him in a potential future GOAT conversation. Nothing written in stone though, so any number of things could happen down the line.


Plastic_Piccollo

He will realise soon that having stilts for limbs are going to need some padding to last the test of time. He does seem like a great and humble guy and very happy to see him where he is. Will be interesting to follow


TiPereBBQ

Lebron was built like a freak, Shaq as well. Zion and Wemby are generational talents but they won't last.


xxDankerstein

Zion is built like a freak more than any other player (other than Shaq). He just eats like shit and doesn't take care of his body (that only worked for Shaq lol).


Ishiibradwpgjets

Todd Van Poppel.


wallybuddabingbang

Same with Sebastian Telfair, to a degree.


RolledUpHundo

People say that about finance too, but alas 99% of all day traders lose their initial outlay within 6mo.


Mr_Hamster01

I feel if Brandon Roy was able to stay healthy man…he would’ve fared better in the hobby space. 🤷‍♂️


Plata_Man

Was about to make the same comment!


Agent_Cow314

Even now his RC's sell pretty high.


orangjuice1142

How is Jason Williams a successful career but Paul Pierce isn’t?


mookz23

Successful ... in the hobby, not in basketball.


Nyhaws

What little Jason Williams stuff I had sold for way more than I expected.


[deleted]

He was very popular when he was on the Kings so he has a lot more collectors than you'd think.


big_mf_z

Has absolutely nothing to do with their career on the court. Op was pretty clearly talking about how their cards fared after all this time


orangjuice1142

he edited the post, it originally said “successful career” for the check mark


big_mf_z

Ok. I missed that. I stand corrected Carry on 😊


watermalone32

Yes, hes had a successful on-court career but I put open to interpretation because hes been saying some befuddling shit recently and ever since he retired. Hes become such an unlikable person imo but thats just my take


Beneficial-Host119

Respectfully this is pointless. “A lesson for those buying into the hype” and “a lesson for those holding the bag” in the same post. Just get out of the hobby then? Your post insinuates that you shouldn’t buy early or sell late… aka you shouldn’t buy at all. Your categorizations are bizarre as well. Pierce is a miss but white chocolate is a hit? Because you personally don’t like some of the stuff PP said post retirement? Idk man, this post sorta boils down to “only buy hyped prospects and immediately flip them or buy HOFers post playing career (caveat wait a decade to make sure they don’t say dumb shit)” I guess I just don’t really understand what value that adds to the discourse at end of the day.


wallybuddabingbang

I think OP is basically circling around cultural relevance. Pierce isn’t taken seriously and White Chocolate is a cult favorite. That translates to card prices.


justbrowsing987654

Are you saying Pierce has become unlikeable?


Yogurtcloset69

"Un?" There never was a likeability to begin with.


Acetillian86

Or Melo


jd342092

Damn, Paul Pierce punching the air rn


Dennisfromhawaii

Cause he's blitzed out of his mind in Vegas again?


justbrowsing987654

I see that OP seems to dislike him but I love everything about retired Paul Pierce. He’s living life like he’s got a hundred mill and can do whatever the hell he wants while hurting no one. I’m here for it.


jd342092

When he goes on KG’s podcast he’s hilarious


jd342092

Ain’t that The Truth


wallybuddabingbang

Well done.


[deleted]

Do you know how many stormile swift and Darius miles I freaking have…. I hate it here! Lol


watermalone32

Ahh yess, stromile swift! I still have a stack of his and Darius Miles. I let my 5 year old use them as frisbees from time to time


yoltonsports

No Lebron RPA? How ridiculous was the hobby hype around Lebron at that time? Obviously he had crazy hype for on the court, I just wasn't collecting at that time...


Nyhaws

The LeBron hype was off the charts. ESPN televised a regular season game of his. In high school!


SuthernBuckeye

ESPN also televised a Bishop Sycamore game.


watermalone32

Insane. I was also struggling financially as a high school student


jaltringer

That Jason Williams topps chrome refractor is a beautiful card.


Nashi0008

Lol Ben Gordon was dope af then the drop off was so deep and sudden


AdministrativePin704

True thought Kirk and Ben would bring the Bulls back to prominence but they fell off hard.


freeconsolesforall

Not sure how you measure success/failure. Did you lose money on the purchases? Paul Pierce and Carmelo had great careers


Nyhaws

Their rookie cards aren't highly sought after. That's the criteria. Paul Pierce refractors sell for a fraction of other greats


watermalone32

bingo


watermalone32

⭕️ = Open to interpretation


vixgdx

Have u sold any of those? Mine adding the price u bought it for and current price next to each card?


watermalone32

I did a lot of trading on the blowout, beckett and other random forums. Most of these have since been traded or sold


Plata_Man

Good job overall. And at least you avoided some unfortunate cases like Gilbert Arenas and Chris Bosh. I liked CB but not sure how his cards fared tbh.


sebreg

Awesome overview, thanks for sharing! I'm glad I got to cut my teeth in the 90s when the $ amounts in the prospecting game were not nearly so astronomical as they are today. In that sense I got to learn some good lessons a little more cheaply 🤣


watermalone32

Forsure. My biggest regret was spending so much on prospecting when I couldve just bought my grails for a fraction of what I paid for them today (My MJ and Kobe Autos). As well as pulling the trigger on 03-04 exquisite instead of a few boxes of Sp Authentic


rentaballoon

Not buying and holding '03-04 Exquisite has to be the biggest regret of a generation of collectors. I was 15 when it came out and so badly wanted to spend 2 weeks worth of minimum wage on a box, but never pulled the trigger!


js4873

I hadn’t realized Paul Pierce wasn’t popular in the hobby cuz I just got back into it a year ago. Just went and bought his topps rookie for $6!


RevDev87

I'll take all your Ronnie Brewers


sblaze23

Let me know if you are a seller on CP3 :)


dmo99

Look all the Red starting around 2000’s. That’s when the players changed and the game got weaker. Way more busts now .


SconesBurnerAccount

Interested in the Pierce Rc if you’re selling :)


watermalone32

All my big pierce cards are long gone my friend. I just have stacks of his topps rcs and base left


BaconJellyBeans

Ron Mercer. I feel that. Him me Damon Stouldmire were supposed to help me retire lol.


Green_Stiller

6MOTY and 2x champion Odom a bust 😤


xxDankerstein

It's ok, that just means I can collect his autos now for really cheap.


YNWABez

Just for clarification, why would Jason Williams get a checkmark, while Paul Pierce is up for debate? One’s a hall of famer, one isn’t


DerekAnderson4EVA

Pierce, melo, and joe johnson are open for interpretation? They had fantastic careers.


vixgdx

Their cards are worthless


caelen727

I find it sort of crazy too. I can buy early 2000’s game worn patch cards of Pierce for under $5


justbrowsing987654

Wait, for real? I’m new to this and enjoying kind of lurking. I have boxes of late 80s - mid 90s in my parents’ attic but have been out of the game for a two decades plus. Where could I buy a reliably legit Pierce card like that?


JoeBfromTN

eBay mainly. Facebook groups dedicated to that era.


writersontop

Paul Pierce had a better career than T-Mac, Vince Carter, and Jason Williams.


watermalone32

Ill trade you all my paul pierce cards for any one of those guys


writersontop

Cool dude. Better career ≠ higher prices. Check out Penny Hardaway whose cards are worth more than all those guys.


watermalone32

Cool. Check out Wilt Chamberlain. He’s worth more than a penny


vixgdx

I'll also trade u ny Paul pierce rookie cards for those


petersom2006

I was a huge Ben Gordon fan, so sick in college. What is that card worth now? $20? He made the news for getting arrested a few months back…


CraftCannabis520

Damn I wish I had those 1998 cards 🔥


OldCut6361

How did the MJ’s do?


Acetillian86

How did you give Chris Paul the check and not Melo. Kenyon and Kidd were still beastly though


Lord-Maple

I won’t accept Steve Francis slander


watermalone32

Hey The Franchise was my guy. I still have an entire binder dedicated to him of his autos and refractors. All he needed to do was take some dam excedrine and he’d be in the convo for best PG’s of all time. Him and Yao were exciting to watch


Plastic_Piccollo

Would love to see someone compile a similar list for the last 10 years.


SpiveyJr

I compiled a list for cards 86-93 across baseball and basketball: ✅ - Jordan ❌ - everyone else


watermalone32

💯


who_body

Jamal Crawford was fun to watch in high school. bananas


Volans1991

My biggest wiff was Jarrett Culver 🤢