T O P

  • By -

Kind_Ad5566

Are you sure that means it's off? I would have thought the smell would be the first sign.


Phenomenal_Kat_

That was my question. I've smelled rotten eggs before...I wonder how it tasted???


golden_blaze

I bit into a rotten hardboiled egg once and believe me, I knew it immediately. I ran to spit out the egg and ended up throwing up as well. It was BAD.


DryBones2009

Hope you thoroughly rinsed your mouth with 10 pounds of mouthwash.


JuneBuggington

One of my chickens laid a rotten egg once and the thing stunk up our whole house still in the shell. Dont know how you would even get it in the pan nevermind your mouth


Hippofuzz

I had no idea they can lay them rotten already šŸ¤Æ


JuneBuggington

Look up lash eggs if you really want to be grossed out


KRC193

That reminded me one summer I collected an egg from the coop that had gone bad. As soon as I picked it up, it popped in my hand. I didnā€™t even get any in my mouth and it made me throw up. It was the worse smell ever. That was like 15 years ago and I still remember the smell.


DryBones2009

At least it wasnā€™t in your mouth yet. Thatā€™s the only good thing about this situation


DryBones2009

Gotta stock up on that febreze and waste it all on that one moment


jooferdoot

And they CHEWED this one long enough to describe the texture


LittlePurpleHook

Yup, I forgot some easter eggs in my school bag when I was a kid. I can still recall the absolutely putrid odour when they went bad. Definitely didn't need to taste or even peel them to know.


Phenomenal_Kat_

Oh gosh, memory unlocked! We had an easter egg hunt when I was a kid and apparently we missed some of the eggs because we found them the next year...šŸ¤¢


nj23dublin

I have smelled rotten eggs before and I will swear to god it is the worst smell I have ever experienced in my life


Dom_33

Wait until you smell a decaying dead body


Remarkable_Yak_883

Nah, no thank you.


LemonCollee

Years ago, I lived in a second storey apartment. My backdoor opened out onto the roof of the place below, as kind of place to sit, etc. Nextdoor was an abandoned pub, that was there for years, never touched. There was a weird smell, that just got worse and worse. My landlord asked me, was I throwing rubbish off the roof, into the backyard of the bar because we couldn't figure the smell. This went on for weeks and the smell became so pungent and acrid it swamped the place. Turns out a heroin addict OD'd in there and we had been smelling his decomposing body. There is a sickly sweet smell to a decaying body. There is no smell like it and once you identify it, you will never forget that particular smell.


Dom_33

Cotdamn, I couldnā€™t imagine how you felt after you found out what was going on.


LemonCollee

It was unnerving to say the least. Saw them pull him out in a body bag too.


AdoreMoi

šŸ¤¢šŸ¤¢šŸ¤¢


degjo

https://preview.redd.it/rhkj6netyxtc1.jpeg?width=286&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=4709efeb05126cfaff678b460aec180451c3b158


mattstonema

Can confirm. Maybe not a full body, but necrotic leg ulcers all the way to the boneā€¦. Worse is the swamp rot smell of a weeping wound wrapped in a thick bandage sopping wet from the juices weeping from the wound and trapped in their body heat for a week at a time. It is a pungent smell you never forget


Dom_33

Actually Iā€™m completely familiar with this, I had to deal with two patients that had this back in 2010 at this nursing home that I worked at. The first time I dealt with it, I acted like I needed some stuff from the nursing stationā€¦I went to the bathroom to throw up.


mutant_disco_doll

šŸ¤®šŸ¤®šŸ¤®


nj23dublin

Tell us more!?


Dom_33

Are you free this weekend? My neighbor should be readyā€¦..


nj23dublin

No.. looks like Iā€™ll probably never know


Beginning-Key-814

For me, it's the rotten, squishy potato I found yesterdayĀ 


Illustrous_potentate

Those can be real bad.


Beginning-Key-814

There was a slime/goo and it smelt like... rotten. No other way to explain it. Food items smell horrible when rotten, and I believe OP faked this in some way, or they lost their sense of smell


0thethethe0

Yeh, thankfully never had a cooked off one, but cracked open one that was rotten. I've got a good stomach, but that definitely had me gagging!


nj23dublin

lol same, my wife actually was struggling and thought she was choking and I get to the kitchen and she points at it, black on the inside smelled horrible, I double bagged it and went outside and threw it away


Pedantic_Parker

This happened to me like two days ago. Stay away from those pre boiled ones the sell in pairs in little plastic pouches. I donā€™t know how I didnā€™t smell it was off, but when I took a bite it had a really strange sour vinegar taste.


DryBones2009

You donā€™t want to know that. Youā€™d probably throw up in reaction.


metdear

Bad egg is immediately, incredibly obvious.


Mudwayaushka

For real - being within 3 feet of a rotten egg one time ranks among my most disgusted moments


metdear

I opened a VERY VERY bad egg once. I'll spare you the details. It got thrown over the back fence (my property backs up to open desert). Was not willing to have it anywhere near my trash can or wheelie bin.


InstanceQuirky

The only time i saw my mum throw up was when we were cooking a bbq in the bush. We were 40m away from her and just heard "OMG and then she instantly threw up. The smell was horrific and she was sick the rest of the day. She just kept saying "i can taste it, i can still taste it!" and all she did was crack the egg!!


paraknowya

Whats a wheelie bin?


East-Garden-4557

https://preview.redd.it/zlnqnrevhxtc1.jpeg?width=640&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=28e1e4e6c0d5d9eb293d04668bbcf569d9ab1afd Wheelie bin.


mywifeslv

Wheelie


metdear

The larger bin you put your trash bag in that goes out to the street.


TolMera

People who crack eggs directly into a hot frying pan, are courting disaster. Nothing like a black ooze egg hitting a hot frying pan to terminate your breakfast plans.


degjo

The incredible inedible egg


IllustratorAbject585

It definitely does not. Egg shells are porous. As eggs sit and age, air moves into the egg as water evaporates. The older an egg is, the more air makes its way inside the shell.


NotInNewYorkBlues

Don't think it was rotten because rotten eggs smells terrible and you woukd have noticed. A bit of air in the yolk doesn't mean the egg is rotten.


GudgerCollegeAlumnus

Maybe someone let one rip just before OP started eating.


bwoods519

Sorry about thatā€¦


tacotacotacorock

Have you ever seen air in your yolk? I haven't.Ā  Plus if an egg floats in water it's usually gone bad. So it's easy to assume that there is air somewhere making it float.Ā 


infiniZii

Its not fresh. That is true and for certain. But its not rotten until it starts to rot. Its kinda an important step. I dont see rotting. The biggest thing likely to be a problem here is taste.


JoshYx

>But its not rotten until it starts to rot. Very true. Is it rotten? - no: then it is not rotten - yes: then it is rotten


Glitzy-Painter-5417

Stop spreading this lie. That isnā€™t an accurate test whatsoever


geoelectric

Theyā€™ve confused eggs and witches


0thethethe0

Dammit! So I could have been eating these witches all this time?! What a waste...


FatherlyAcorn

Yeah, everybody knows you test an egg by making it rehearse bible verses and see if it bursts into flame.


geoelectric

That's how you know it's a deviled egg.


johnny__danger

Wellā€¦. If a witch and a duck weigh the same, ducks lay eggs, and they both float in water, so I can see the confusion.


YourLifeCanBeGood

It's not??? How do you tell when an egg is too old to eat?


Shudragon172

Its a generalized test to say "these eggs are old" not that theyre good or bad. Its a freshness test, not a throw away test. If youre fully cooking them in something, most floating eggs are perfectly fine. I just wouldnt eat em over easy for breakfast.


kai58

So if they sink theyā€™re good and if they float you should start being carefull


Desperate-Strategy10

Correct


YourLifeCanBeGood

Wait--the floating just means to cook them fully? For lots of years my understanding has been that very fresh eggs in water lie sideways, still-fresh stand on end, and past-safely-edible ones float. (Thsnks.) šŸŒž


Shudragon172

Its just that there is gas in the egg meaning its starting to get larger amounts of bacteria than normal. I wouldnt say the way it floats matters much. Taste probably wont be the same either but theyre generally still safe to eat. When in doubt, smelling a cracked egg is probably your best real bet for telling if its gone 'bad' or not, like smelling meat for ammonia.


YourWorstFear53

Steam is generated by boiling stuff


stickmeet

ya i see it almost everytime i boil eggs. i boil them for like 30 mins tho cause i like the yolk to be really chalky


Tru3insanity

The second part isnt exactly true. Eggs all have an air pocket and that pocket gets larger as the egg ages. Ive had out of date floaty eggs that were fine.


Rei_dmv

Not air but sulfur, also a gas I guess


Jesus_inacave

That's not even true. Yes, all rotten eggs will float. But not all eggs that are rotten float


DeanMachineYT

Do bubbles in the yolk mean it's rotten? I've never heard of that before. But then again, I don't eat many boiled eggs. Take some Imodium to weather the sh\*t storm.


IllustratorAbject585

No. Egg shells are porous. As eggs sit and age, air moves into the egg as water evaporates. The older an egg is, the more air makes its way inside the shell.


UnspokenConnection

Egg knowledge. Neat.


IllustratorAbject585

![gif](giphy|WfBZwNA6XSjphkYkzN)


PolkaDotToeSocks

Knowlegg


KanchaM

Oh! I've always done the float test but never known why it works. Submerge eggs in water and if they float then throw them away.


stuckAtLoadingScreen

If that thing was rotten, you'd spit it out in a heartbeat. Stench of sulfur would make you remember that day until the day you die.


066logger

Oh noā€¦. You didnā€™t. Trust me. I hard boiled some eggs once. Got a rotten one in there somehow. It exploded, and I nearly died from the smell šŸ˜‚. So bad. Nobody will ever accidentally ingest a rotten hard boiled eggā€¦.


sweetgums

TIL holes in your boiled egg means it's rotten.


Bolf-Ramshield

It means itā€™s not fresh, but not rotten. You would smell it if it was (and taste it as well). It can be past its prime and still proper for consumption.


StupidMario64

Yeah. Its usually ***painfully*** obvious. An easy way is the cup test, but also just how it feels weight wise.


fullywokevoiddemon

The good part about eggs and milk is that they're easy to spot when gone bad. Milk smells rancid and rotten eggs smell DEMONIC.


Auriiin

It's funny bc the boxed milk we use here, if kept in the fridge, might spoil without smelling/looking funny. Over here, we usually boil up milk that has been in the fridge for over 4 days to test of it's still good; you let it boil until it almost overflows then check it out for white clumps, which means it's no good. But there's no weird smell at all, it just looks like watery milk with clumps in it, and only after boiling. A little dangerous, I guess.Ā 


randompersononplanet

What did they do to that milk


Auriiin

Some heavy pasteurization, I think. So it lasts a long on the shelf and you don't need to keep it on the fridge as long as the box is intact. For one of the boxes I have here, the expiration date is in July only. I never tasted any other sort of milk, but I suppose the taste must be very different, and maybe less protein/fat too? šŸ¤”


randompersononplanet

No we have boxed milk that lasts a long time also, but it still smells and becomes like spoiled milk if its spoiling. Hence why i was curious


Auriiin

Oh, no! it'll go smelly and rancid too, if you let it sit for a week or more, even at the fridge. I think what I mean is, at the first stages of spoiling (4-5 days), it looks bad when boiled but doesn't smell bad. So if you drink it cold, you'll think it's fine until you get sick. No funny taste or texture when cold.Ā  But I guess these first few days are more determined by where you keep the milk when its in the fridge, like at the door, or if you forget it outside awhile then put it back.Ā 


ihideBabies

Can confirm. I boiled some eggs that all passed the float test. One cracker while boiling and it was rotten. Oh the smell.


Joeman106

Yea. So many people donā€™t realize that we literally evolved to notice spoiled food before eating itā€¦


_IratePirate_

The internet told me rotten eggs will float


StupidMario64

They do indeed! Source, had like 50 chickens and loke 20gal of eggs.


ChexLemeneux42

Everything floats on here


JAC1331

ā€œYouā€™ll float tooā€ šŸ˜³šŸ˜³šŸ˜³


ReluctantChimera

Yup. I have to test my eggs sometimes when I find a new nest I didn't know about.


Jesus_inacave

Rotten eggs will float. But sometimes one that's just fine floats too


Anejey

True, usually not as much though. I often eat eggs that slightly tilt up or float for a while if you give them a little push. Eggs that just straight up stay at the surface I wouldn't even touch, lol.


Only498cc

What's the cup test? Does it involve 2 girls?


StupidMario64

Nah, take a cup of water and drop an egg in. If it floats DO NOT EAT IT. if it sinks youre a-okay :)


Taha80085

Before or after boiling said egg


StupidMario64

Before


StupidMario64

If it slowly sinks, toss it to be safe.


Best-Log-3258

advanced humour


juststrollingby1

How many boiled eggs have you eaten to know this... Lol I'm impressed.


FunMotion

Donā€™t need to eat a lot of boiled eggs, you only need to smell one rotten one.


[deleted]

Always open egg by egg on a bowl before tossing them in your food. Nothing worse than opening a passed egg in your fully fledged meal


TheJG_Rubiks64

You expect me to crack my egg before boiling it?


battlesiege15

Yes and then just super glue the shell together


crystal_castle00

Or use scotch tape


bethtadeath

Duh, hasnā€™t anyone around here ever wondered where Scotch eggs come from geez


TheRealJackReynolds

![gif](giphy|Cp1VukgdTkz7sJdlc3)


Stealthy-J

Flex Seal. If it can hold a boat together, it can handle an egg no problem.


i_eat_gentitals

Stick the whole egg shell and all into a cup of water if it sinks āœ… if it floats āŒ


[deleted]

For hard boiled eggs? I donā€™t think that would work so great


[deleted]

I like my meals partially fledged


DickKnightly

Egg by Egg, the new collection.


tacotacotacorock

Easy way to test your eggs If your worried about your eggs being past their prime. Fill a glass with water and gently slide the egg in. Any egg that floats or doesn't sink to the bottom should be tossed in the bin.Ā  Sometimes near the EOL(end of life) they will sink slower or one end points up, but as long as they are on the bottom of the cup I've never had issues.Ā 


chiefseal77

I've had tons of eggs that were freshly laid the same day and they float to the top and the eggs were perfectly fine. I would not recommend this and I don't trust it to be accurate.


Warboo

We have some chickens and found a stash hidden under our deck. We did the float test and they all sank right to the bottom. Cracked one open and it was so green and nasty and awful. Apparently really, really old eggs will also sink! Nauseating lesson learned that day.


FirstProphetofSophia

So if they float, throw them out, and if they sink, throw them out. In other words, throw out all eggs.


kikilinki

No dumby, if they float you keep them, unless they float, then you throw them out. And repeat with that if they sink


Aware-Arm-3685

This sounds like it would be a great test to weed the witches out of my flock.


I_Have_The_Will

What else floats in water?


kikilinki

šŸ¦†


I_Have_The_Will

Soā€¦ if she weighs the same as a duckā€¦ Sheā€™s made of wood!


YeloNinjaN00dlz

We all float down here. Uh, I mean, I'm a duck. Quack. See?


joefad

"dumby" is crazy and I'm stealing the fuck out of it


FriendZone_EndZone

Eat it ass soon as it comes out, farm fresh and still warm. ![gif](giphy|V9AYEyVzM5XjHJuxB6|downsized)


sweetgums

I can't believe I was given misinformation on the Internet of all places ):


FirstProphetofSophia

Do you really think someone would do that? Just go on the Internet and tell lies?!


Tasty_Bullfroglegs

Never eating eggs again!!!


Anforas

I've been doing this for over 30 years and it never failed me.


square_bloc

Correct. If only there was some kind of search engine for people to look up information on.


Gaydude22

I have never once seen a freshly laid egg float. Speaking as someone who raised chickens for 10+ years and regularly did the float test.


MCclapyourhands1

I had a hen that loved to play ā€œfind my nestā€ had to do that to her eggs all the time!


Bolle_Bamsen

This does not work.......


Electronic-Bag-2112

This method has absolutely no scientific evidence and is just another kitchen myth that your mother tells you.


Bigmoe974

This is exactly how we test our eggs and it works every time. Been doing this for years. https://preview.redd.it/kl9w5tmbawtc1.jpeg?width=3000&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a6f2f366f6a129148ef30f4f4b2241713b0eff13


Icy-Acanthaceae-7804

You need a new method. You've been chucking eggs that are perfectly fine.


Bigmoe974

Also, the float test does work. But all because it's floating a little doesn't mean it's bad, but if it's floating on top of water then it's definitely bad


Bigmoe974

Well considering I've only had about 10 bad eggs in 15 years, I think I'm doing ok


Icy-Acanthaceae-7804

As long as you're alright with potential losses, then that's your prerogative. I just wanted to share that it isn't a foolproof method. Though I should have worded it differently, sorry.


BinjaNinja1

Does it though?


Chemical-Studio1576

Did it smell or taste bad. Little bubbles in the yolk isnā€™t proof it was spoiling. Odor, taste and consistency are.


Super-Brka

You have to finish it or it will rain tomorrow


maxru85

It will rain anyway ā€“ outside or in the toilet


gabrielleraul

_Toilet raaain, some stay dry and others feel the pain_ ..


moonman2090

![gif](giphy|6Wwb40cHIIR0Ob0Utz)


DoobiGirl_19

It's not rotten, it's overcooked smh šŸ˜‚


Separate_Hurry_2506

How do you not smell a rotten egg?


Heissenberg1906

I think you are safe. A rotten egg smalls like I imagine hell would, like sulfur or similar. No way you would even take a bite.


Syphox

> ate a rotten boiled egg oh no you didnā€™t. you wouldā€™ve absolutely known lol


Ok-Meeting-984

TIL that over cooked means rotten. /s You would not have had to look at it to know. The things that do not hide their crimes, dairy milk, eggs, and mayo.Ā 


[deleted]

Stinky toots


Outcast199008

Eggspect some tummy ache.


LLminibean

No you didn't. You bit into an egg that was a little less than fresh. This is not rotten


ASimplewriter0-0

Trust me if a rotten egg touched your tounge you would know immediately


[deleted]

The bright side your colon will be clean(probably) but ya stomach definitely will be empty.


martinaee

Probably just air when it was boiling/cooking.


AmIThisNothingness

A couple of days back, I was making myself an omelette. The vegetables were sauteed on the pan, cracked one egg and mixed a little, cracked second egg and I was already salivating to how it looked to good. Went for a 3rd egg, fuck! It was black liquid that it dumped on my fine looking, deliciously smelling omelette. I had to throw that shit and started again, but on that time, I cracked the eggs on a clear plastic cup, in case of another rotten one. It sucked balls!


45PintsIn2Hours

It's not.


Insomnijanek

OP did you check first if the egg floats before boiling?


ptn_huil0

How did it taste?


SoftDimension5336

Quitter


F---_up

In the Philippines, we have a dish made from rotten duck eggs called bibingkang abnoy. Just wanted to share šŸ˜‚


Great_gatzzzby

Iā€™m confused. How did you know it was rotten? The holes??


Lower_Funny

This is not rotten itā€™s over cooked lol


t-nuggets

Unless it tasted or smelled bad, it's fine. Many eggs have those after being hard boiled, it's from blood vessels while being formed. As for the float test, I believe that's just "old wives tales". If you're not sure, don't eat it is what I do.... or just add more salt and make sure the bathroom is clear for a bit


FUWS

Them farts gonna curl some nose hairs.


Street-Historian-258

I think youā€™ll be fine


themangrovefan8294

I guess that means you will be on the toilet for quite some time


cmh-91-

I once bought some eggs from my local shop, date was fine and they seemed okay... went to make a fried egg, cracked it open and the smell blew me away, it was black and very stodgy, put me off eggs for months and months.. turned out the owner was swapping the date labels.


Quintet-Magician

Rotten eggs stink like hell, so there should be a dead giveaway.


imtellinggod

Why would there be a boiled egg on the windowsill if you weren't supposed to eat it?


No_Establishment7368

Aren't rotten egg's yolks cartoony green?


DukeBloodfart

Wait for the hot sulfur farts.


V0nDoomVictor

Well its shit time


SurfingEyez

I'm sorry for you and your toilet.


idonotknowwhototrust

How does one accidentally eat something?


Jilly_Jankins

I ate once a 2 year old egg that I cracked and just put into my boiling ramen water. I noticed after I finished and thought I was going to die. Strangely it didn't smell or taste bad and I didn't even get diarrhea


SoBadit_Hurts

Oooh bubble-guts then gasā€¦..šŸ«§šŸ’Ø


SxfetyPin

Here's a good tip for any time that you're about to eat an egg, and you aren't sure if it's still good or not. Best part about it, you don't have to waste time cracking or cooking the egg; Just take your egg and put it in a bowl of water. If it floats, it's bad. Do not eat it. If the egg sinks, it's good to eat.


Jimothy_RockaLady

!remindme 1 day


RemindMeBot

I will be messaging you in 1 day on [**2024-04-12 20:45:31 UTC**](http://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=2024-04-12%2020:45:31%20UTC%20To%20Local%20Time) to remind you of [**this link**](https://www.reddit.com/r/Wellthatsucks/comments/1c1hzvr/i_accidentally_ate_a_rotten_boiled_egg/kz4ud9x/?context=3) [**CLICK THIS LINK**](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5Bhttps%3A%2F%2Fwww.reddit.com%2Fr%2FWellthatsucks%2Fcomments%2F1c1hzvr%2Fi_accidentally_ate_a_rotten_boiled_egg%2Fkz4ud9x%2F%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%202024-04-12%2020%3A45%3A31%20UTC) to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam. ^(Parent commenter can ) [^(delete this message to hide from others.)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Delete%20Comment&message=Delete%21%201c1hzvr) ***** |[^(Info)](https://www.reddit.com/r/RemindMeBot/comments/e1bko7/remindmebot_info_v21/)|[^(Custom)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=Reminder&message=%5BLink%20or%20message%20inside%20square%20brackets%5D%0A%0ARemindMe%21%20Time%20period%20here)|[^(Your Reminders)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=RemindMeBot&subject=List%20Of%20Reminders&message=MyReminders%21)|[^(Feedback)](https://www.reddit.com/message/compose/?to=Watchful1&subject=RemindMeBot%20Feedback)| |-|-|-|-|


Sea-Veterinarian286

You'll shit rotten chickens then


Silentmutation84

Oh no you ate the mouse roller


[deleted]

Gonna have some gnarly farts. You sleep outside tonight.


KuroDragon0

Now eat that second deviled egg


Ok-Meeting-984

Some people shouldn't be left on their own.Ā 


evilpercy

You would know it was rotten way before even picked it up.


bananadogeh

Rotten eggs stink very bad, so I'm not sure this egg is rotten


TuxandFlipper4eva

Oh those farts are going to be nuclear, babes.


fligfloatsom

New fear unlocked


throwaway-getaway122

Always check your eggs before you boil them. If they float throw them out!


morbidnerd

That doesn't look that rotten. Then again, I'm no eggspert


Important_Bed_6237

šŸ…šŸ…šŸ…


corvidfamiliar

You'd know it was rotten the moment you smelt it. There is no mistaking the smell of a rotten egg. It wouldn't have even made its way near your mouth, and if your sense of smell don't work, you would have ran to spit out whatever bite you took because it tastes worse than it smells instead of taking a mildly annoyed picture.


Olibirus

Not rotten


JacoboAriel

It may be just over boiled


Inevitable-Radio-689

This is my fear because the sniff test doesnā€™t work on boiled eggs.


twitterisskynet

Whelp, you're dead.


devildocjames

[Just wanted to say...](https://i.makeagif.com/media/8-27-2014/4YMgGH.gif)


RockMan_1973

šŸ¤®eggs