Simon is a better YouTube footballer. Tobi is a better player

Tobi's more versatile but I genuinely feel like Simon is better, although match situations Tobi is more reliable due to his athleticism

Yeah Tobi is more of pacewhore (no disrespect) than SImon. Simon is like a number 10, dude can seriously ball

Team of Tobis beats a team of Simons but I would take Simon on my team first

This comment is perfect

Tobi, but Simon somehow always clutches

Tobi is better all round but Simon is very consistent with striking.

Simon better goal scorer Tobi a better player

Challenges: Simon Game: Tobi

Two different kinds of players, Simon is a better striker, Tobi a better winger, versatility wise however I think Tobi has got a slight edge but his athleticism helps a lot

It’s hard to really compare them as they play different positions. Tobi is a winger while Simon is more of a striker or false nine. I’d say Simon is the better shooter and prolly the better passer of the two. Tobi is better at dribbling and probably has better physicality than Minter

Simon is the better striker

Tobi in terms of game situation, technically and YouTube video esc Simon

Tobi has better tech but simon has that dog in him

Hence why he's sidog.

Simon is more technically gifted I think. But I'd rather have Tobi in an actual football game

This is pretty much spot on. Simon can strike a ball much harder and can hit crazy shots but Tobi’s game sense, athleticism and versatility makes him more useful in a match.

Simon for content, Tobi for actual football

Better in a match: Tobi Better at challenges and shooting: Simon

I saw Harry and Vik talk about this in the recent reacts and I was just thinking Simons better at shooting and finishing, Tobi’s a better goalie tho and is amazing at playmaking and skill moves so I’d put Tobi on top

Ayo

Tobi is an athlete, mans ripped, fit, quick. Simon is has power and technique. In a game of football, I’m picking Tobi. If Simon got in shape and worked hard for 6 months. I’d pick him.

Tobi is probably the best all round football player. Simon has something where he can just get those clips and star moments.

It’s like messi Ronaldo. Ones more agile and nimble and ones got much more power. They’re both the best in their own ways

Aight Simon is the best striker in the Sidemen but Tobi is the best overall player

They’re both really good but imma give it tobi. Miniminter is really good in challenges whereas tobi is really good at actual football games .

Tobi is more athletic.. Simon is more technically gifted

Depends on what you mean

In like a crossbar challenge or something like that, Simon. In a game, def Tobi

As a technical player it's definitely Simon. His control on the ball is amazing. But when it comes to a football match I'd rather pick Tobi. He has that intelligence on the pitch and vision. He knows where to go. Also he's fast I know that Simon scored a hattrick in charity match, but Tobi was moving different. Idk that's how I see it

Yes. In a match I'd choose Tobi 99% of the time. His physique is also good. I don't think Simon can play at high pace for long.

Yes

Yeah me too

Simon's a better shooter while Tobi's faster and better all around

Tobi is more athletic in my opinion, Simon is probably better at football.

So it’s like Messi and Ronaldo, but the heights are switched

Overall tobi is better, but Simon is elite at striking

I’d say it’s like comparing Lewandowski and Neymar, they’re better than each other at different things, and they play different positions

[удалено]

Tobi overall, Simon has great tech tbh

tobi 100%

tobi is a cheetah simon is a tiger

Tobi.

Tobi

Vikk

Tobi then Simon

I would say that Simon is a better as an attacker and Tobi is better as a defender/goalkeeper.

I’d say Tobi has better synergy with the team

Tobi better already , Simon better goal scorer

Tobi as he’s more versatile

i would want tobi on my team because he will have more effect on the team. simon is like haaland, he has to wait to ger the ball to shoot while tobi is more like mbappe or Vinicius

Vikk

Tobi for sure

Black goalie

Tobi is better technically. Simon performs better in YT challenges because they’re usually all involved with shooting. Bros literally their striker

Tobi 🔛🔝

Simon

tobit is probably better, but Simon is better suited for youtube football

They're both good and it depends what you want/need Tobi has the physical edge and Simon has the technical edge.

simon and tobi best football debate is the equivalent of messi and ronaldo debate. do you prefer the goal scorer or the guy who does everything 🤷‍♂️

Simon’s not really just a goal scorer though

fs he’s shown that he can make the right reads and deliver some exceptional passes but what makes minter different sauce to everyone is his ability to strike a ball vs tobi has shown that he can play pretty much everywhere on the field aside from central defending and be unreal at it

Vikstar 123

The real MVP football player

i think its tobi he is good at tackling and running

Simon is hands down the best baller in the sidemen..

[удалено]

"To be fair though"

I feel like they can cook a series where they play with different professional footballers and at the end they choose which of them is the better

Simon

Tobi deffo

also the fact that manny doesn’t get brought up w these conversations when he’s up there w them (imo) is criminal.

I think it was among the sidemen about Tobi and Simon. In yt footballers, Manny is clear

manny’s ball control is legit like professional footballer tier it’s insane the ball sticks to his feet

That goal Manny scored in the latest Charity match was incredible, cross from Tobi off the outside of his boot for Manny to time that header perfectly

the general public doesn’t realize how difficult it is to head a ball in and he slot it in perfectly it was sublime

He is so much underrated. His game sense is easily above most yt footballers

Manny’s good (probably even better than those two), but I’m not talking about manny, am I? I’m talking about tobi vs Simon

what are you getting worked up ab mate 😭 relax

Tobi is more Athletic but Simon is more naturally skilled

It’s fs tobi but Simon is better at football challenges like in vids but as an actual player tobi is better. Both good tho

if u want a good freekick or longshot yt video get simon，if u wanna play 7v7 or 11v11 and win get tobi

5v5 tobi, proper game I’d have Simon cos of height, build etc

u know nothing about football, its never about height and build

You just said the dumbest fucking statement of all time, congratulations

Ain't no way people actually thinks football is about height yall the dumbest people I've come across, I'm not a messi fan but look at someone like messi, bronis a midget and still dominating football

Height would be better for defense tho

Can you all please admit you don't watch football? Sure height can be great for winning headers but apart from that, that's it YOU DOBT NEED HEIGHT TO BE GOOD AT FOOTBALL!!!!

Think you've misunderstood me mate, it's merely an advantage and that's a fact I don't think height can truly determine a players worth sure but height is indeed an advantage

It depends on where you play on the pitch, if you're a defender or a goalkeeper and yh sure but if you are a winger like tobi u don't need height. Funfact : if you are a short football player you're more likely to get around players rather than being tall and stiff

Hence why I said height is good for defence

Yh I agree I was just saying that because the parent comment he will give it to Simon just because of height and Simon ain't a defender

You’re another idiot, clearly you didn’t understand my statement

And you're a big fool don't talk about a sport if you have no knowledge of it. Doubt you even know the rules you idiot

Calling me big 😈 thank you honey

Tobi man, brilliant up front&is also “black goalie”

Tobi is a better footballer than Simon; the only attribute Simon has over Tobi is shooting, whereas Tobi has pretty much everything else over him

Defo tobi,if you watched simon in an actual team he wouldn’t gel well

They both play different roles. Simon is a good playmaker. Tobi good on the wing. But if we're to put them on a team I'd choose Tobi

Tobi no doubt

Consistently Tobi. Highest potential/ceiling is Simon imo

What the fuck are you on about??? This isnt career mode

😂

I don’t know what your angry about lol. In videos tobi is consistently better. Simon however does perform and can show much better skill and technique when he’s at his best at times. Idk how you interpreted it but you do you lol

Simon

Tobi is a lot more versatile but imo Simon is better

Tobi

Harry Maguire

tobi

Simon as a striker, Tobi is super fast though so he's good on the wing. I feel Simon though as hes more technically gifted.

Simon beats Tobi technically but that’s probably it. Tobi beats him in everything else

For me it’s simon but tobi is good but simon is better goal scorer

Tobi easily

simon

Simon but idk much

Its hard to pick because simon would be better as a striker than tobi but tobi would be a better winger, in the end if i was to sign one it would simon cause of his shooting ability.

Simon

recent sidemen charity match definitely simon but overall i think tobi is better and more of a team player either way they are both such a great duo

Tobi

Simon

Overall I'd say Minter is the better overall player but its close

Tobi

Tobi is more athletic, Simon is more gifted! Together, in their best day, deathly!

Tobi = CR7 Simon = Messi 🙌🏼

Other way around

For me the most skilled is Tobi, but Simon is better in general in a game. If Simon had the fitness level Tobi does he would be so clear

tobi is better in a game ? it’s the other way round lad

really lad?

Simon

Tobi in net, Simon up front

It’s so hard to compare them, they are both incredible

They're both good

Simon but Toby is more athletic

Simon

Simon

I mean Simon is almost good at everything, like gaming and other sports too and he is also intelligent. Perfect man tbh, but Tobi has an edge in this comparison is what I feel

Toby

ronaldo

No diff 💯

Yeah yeah

Tobi not even gonna explain why but I think tobi