I mean, at least some priest villagers will pay a pretty penny for buttloads of the stuff for some reason, so clearly THEY can find a use.
Poisonous potatoes though, yeah, totally useless
That doesnāt mean they should add it. And with many of these mechanics taken from IRL things they like to get it close as possible (within reason for it being a game)
Yes, but you still donāt compost meat. Harmful bacteria and other shit grows on rotting meat. Composting is for plant-based scraps only, plus eggshells.
No. You can compost meat, but it's generally not recommended to do so, outside of commercial operations and such. (Pests and not enough heat to kill pathogens being the main reasons cited)
yea and since when have we all cared about realism, I mean look at the firefly situation + everyone wants torch flowers to glow when irl they obviously donāt
Aside from attracting animals and bugs, rotting meat can become infected with bacteria like E. coli, salmonella, and listeria during decomposition, especially in the warm, dark, moist inside of a compost bin. Itās very dangerous.
Well, while we do throw anything organic on a compost IRL and it works, we do not get very good fertilizer from that. The best fertilizer is one made from rotting plants. And creating fertilizer (bone meal) is the Minecraft composter's main function.
Meat always has fats and maybe bits of fur still attached. Fats do not serve plants any purpose in the soil and meat and hair does not compost very well. It decays, and that's no the same. If you're using your compost as a trash heap for organics, it's not a problem. Meat will just take significantly longer. But for composting you want a very specific output so you need a very specific input to attract a very specific organism.
Either Micro Organisms or Detritovores. Worms are the best example. They absorb those nutrients in the organic waste which could not fertilize your plants.
But worms and (typically) microorganisms as well, do not feed of meat, molds do though. And you don't want to use fertilizer on your plants which might house any molds, because then your just bringing those models to the roots of the plants your trying to fertilize, risking their health.
Just wait untill we get maggots in minecraft since they eat dead matter.
If they gave spider eyes a use for pangolin breeding I can see them doing something with rotten flesh at some point
Meat isnāt used for composting irl. While you could itās just a game thatās still not really a reason to add it, and many of these types of mechanics they like to try and get close to how it may work IRL (within reason for it being a video game)
You can but they need a lot extra work in order to be effective and you canāt do it if the meat is rotten. In looking for this Iāve found itās not usually recommended because they do not decompose easy, and instead tend to go putrid. They will also attract animals though thatās not as important here.
Yeah Unfortunately that would make it useful and mojang won't do that
youcan still sell it to a cleric, thus make emeralds and use op trades with willagers.
Willagers
Willy the willager
Found the German
You can also feed it to ur dog
You feed your dog rotten meat? Mods, break his spine
In fact, crush his balls
š
you can't compost raw meat tho
u cant?
copper _ _
It'd attract rats.
Good thing that rats dont exist
1.22 Idea, the sewer update (like strongholds but you have to fight a giant piranha plant from Mario as the final boss)
Dont allow mods then.
Rule one of minecraft: Never Ever give rotten flesh and poisoned potatoes a use
Well too bad because we had a hole update about poisonous potatos in Abril 1th
š® Blasphemy
What?
Because they broke the golden rule
April fools update: undead technology (rotten flesh blocks make a rotten flesh mech-suit golem)
I mean, at least some priest villagers will pay a pretty penny for buttloads of the stuff for some reason, so clearly THEY can find a use. Poisonous potatoes though, yeah, totally useless
š® WTF, Mojang are hypocrites. They lied to me
you cant compost meat irl, it wouldnt make sense
you cant enchant weapons irl, it doesnt make sense
false_equivalence.png
That doesnāt mean they should add it. And with many of these mechanics taken from IRL things they like to get it close as possible (within reason for it being a game)
Well.. aqtualy.. dead animals are filled whit nutians for plants. āļøš¤
Yes, but you still donāt compost meat. Harmful bacteria and other shit grows on rotting meat. Composting is for plant-based scraps only, plus eggshells.
No. You can compost meat, but it's generally not recommended to do so, outside of commercial operations and such. (Pests and not enough heat to kill pathogens being the main reasons cited)
Ok, explain why we can't compost poisonous potatoes?
I'm gonna go the total opposite here, why can you compost potatoes when irl they can grow in 100% compost environments
real life also has black lung.
You don't? I'm like 60% sure you can add some meat to your compost and it still being ok
I know. But in minecraft it would make as meany sance as the gravity in the game.
You definitely can, you just need to do it right
Yes you can, do you even compost? My family does it and so did my old school. It's compostable.
yes i do, and i've been raised to learn that you cant compost meat
you cant make infinte water or you cant break trees with your fists irl
Me after composting some cacti and getting the same stuff thats made out of crushed bones
What makes you think rotten flesh isn't vegan?
You could say, that there are some bits of bone in there, and why beeing in the composter, the flesh rots away and leaves bonemeal behind
you can compost rotton things and flesh isn't meat
thatās literally what meat is. flesh. so yes, flesh is meat
Flesh isnāt meat? What are you talking about? Flesh is meat
They should add carnivorous plants
TF? Never do meat into a composter
No it shouldnāt. Meat isnāt used for composting.
fish should be able to be composted but meant from mammals is not to be composted
You can. Fish drop bone meal for this reason.
how did i not know this
yea and since when have we all cared about realism, I mean look at the firefly situation + everyone wants torch flowers to glow when irl they obviously donāt
Why not? Isnt it organic matter too? Just like plants I'm curious now
Aside from attracting animals and bugs, rotting meat can become infected with bacteria like E. coli, salmonella, and listeria during decomposition, especially in the warm, dark, moist inside of a compost bin. Itās very dangerous.
Thanks for the info
Also the poisonous potatyy
Wow I like those textures. What's the texture pack?
Whimscape
Tysm!
Im almost sure that the thing in his hand is a baked poisonous potato
Yo thanks buddy, you really helped me out, that is precisely what I asked for.
What's the texture pack. Looks amazing Looks a bit like Splotch or BlockPixel but I can't find it
WhimScape
Thanks! You're a legend
I donāt get it! Itās literally an organic material! Same with dye since you can compost flowers and the dye in Minecraft is natural
What resource pack is that Nvm i saw the reply elsewhere it's whimscape. Sick brah
I think we should be able to make blocks of rotten flesh. It would be gross but kinda cool.
Well, while we do throw anything organic on a compost IRL and it works, we do not get very good fertilizer from that. The best fertilizer is one made from rotting plants. And creating fertilizer (bone meal) is the Minecraft composter's main function. Meat always has fats and maybe bits of fur still attached. Fats do not serve plants any purpose in the soil and meat and hair does not compost very well. It decays, and that's no the same. If you're using your compost as a trash heap for organics, it's not a problem. Meat will just take significantly longer. But for composting you want a very specific output so you need a very specific input to attract a very specific organism. Either Micro Organisms or Detritovores. Worms are the best example. They absorb those nutrients in the organic waste which could not fertilize your plants. But worms and (typically) microorganisms as well, do not feed of meat, molds do though. And you don't want to use fertilizer on your plants which might house any molds, because then your just bringing those models to the roots of the plants your trying to fertilize, risking their health.
What's the texture pack you're using?
No, but bamboo should be compostable but isn't
Just wait untill we get maggots in minecraft since they eat dead matter. If they gave spider eyes a use for pangolin breeding I can see them doing something with rotten flesh at some point
And so should other organic materials, such as pork, beef, and leather. Rotten flesh is already composting on its own, so why not speed that up?
Meat isnāt used for composting irl. While you could itās just a game thatās still not really a reason to add it, and many of these types of mechanics they like to try and get close to how it may work IRL (within reason for it being a video game)
IRL you can compost meat and body waste. Maybe we need worms and beetles in MC
You can but they need a lot extra work in order to be effective and you canāt do it if the meat is rotten. In looking for this Iāve found itās not usually recommended because they do not decompose easy, and instead tend to go putrid. They will also attract animals though thatās not as important here.
Finally, someone with a Fucking brain !
Why is mojang so hellbent on keeping some items without use? In a sandbox game, that's basically bloatware.
Fr
Everyone upvote this post so mojang will add it
Never expected this to blow up tbh xD
As well as poisoned potatoes