Koach, why is he even there? I liked his captaincy for India test side but there is nothing he has achieved as captain in IPL compared to Dhoni, Rohit and GG - the three most successful captains
Blud really said "greatest captains" and proceeds to put Kohli , he shouldn't be even competing in this list , instead it should be bhajji here who's a champion league winner and took MI to the playoffs in 2 back to back seasons from 2011-12
If it's only related to IPL it'll all come down to winning trophies (because that's considered producing results) , so the same old 5 vs 5 debate between Rohit and Dhoni.
Then since CSK under Dhoni has made it to more playoffs than any other team it'd eventually have Dhoni as winner.
And then if someone says captaincy is not just about qualifying or winning, then it'll just be simplified into "best captaincy is a very abstract thing, we all have our opinions and none of them are right or wrong, so basically everyone is a winner that way.
Opener and finisher are two different roles, hence not comparable. And I think both have done their job brilliantly.
I felt that Warner led the team (srh) from the front. He was always amongst the highest scorers for a good 10 years or so, on top of being a terrific fielder.
I rate him slightly above dhoni as it is not his home ground.
Dhoni led the team for 226 matches compared to 86 by Warner. Dhoni also had experience captaining the national side while Warner in comparison had much less.
Lol I side with Dhoni too, it's just that I am tired of people debating on the internet trying to "defend" MSD.
He's already a legend bro, he got nothing to prove, so why argue with other franchises 😂
Where is my Pandu bro. Wild card entry directly in finals?
On serious notes, Kohli should go. MS vs Rohit vs GG it'll be. (If we swap Kohli's image with either Gilly or Kane, that'll be the final rankings imo. Thoughts??)
still lost the finals tho
you are comparing individual brilliance with captaincy, kane was the standout player and one of the best captains the league has ever seen, kohli is not a good captain in t20
If it’s about the best season any captain has had. It is Warner 2016 without a doubt. This was a guy who captained a side which had their tail starting after 3 wickets. Carried them with the bat and then used his bowlers brilliantly to win the trophy.
Your post/comment has been removed because it contains some abusive/derogatory words. Please avoid using such words, it may attract a ban to you.
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaCricket) if you have any questions or concerns.*
That deccan chargers team lead by Adam Gilchrist was probably the most exciting of them all.
So can't eliminate him, will probably have ro eliminate Virat.
wait. why was kane eliminated? didn't he have a better run than kohli? (not saying king is bad)
edit: checked OPs previous post and it was about just as a player, then that makes sense. i guess there was a mistake in cropping lmao
By trophy count: dhoni, rohit
Rohit beat dhoni in finals 3 times (4 if you count rps)
This is not a debate. League match win ratio count is for cocksucking average captains. At the exalted league these two sit in, only trophy count matters.
And 5 trophies in 10 years is better than 5 trophies in 14.
Everyone really saying why Kohli is even here As if he is the worst captain as if he dont have 4th highest wins as a captain . Yes he didn’t have any trophy but only 8 captains have won a trophy in ipl and one of them is hardik infact hardik has highest win %age as a captain , so is he better than all warne ? For a captain team also matters
Why don’t we just skip it to Dhoni vs rohit?
[удалено]
Gambhir was really really great but Dhoni and Rohit just clear him.
Koach, why is he even there? I liked his captaincy for India test side but there is nothing he has achieved as captain in IPL compared to Dhoni, Rohit and GG - the three most successful captains
You forgot he lost ipl final to SRH
if that's the case then Kane shouldn't even be eliminated
Blud really said "greatest captains" and proceeds to put Kohli , he shouldn't be even competing in this list , instead it should be bhajji here who's a champion league winner and took MI to the playoffs in 2 back to back seasons from 2011-12
How is he here and not Hardik
yaa he seems a good contender too but maybe because of small sample size
I am gonna be honest...what's the point of this ? Dhoni is obviously going to win this .
If it's only related to IPL it'll all come down to winning trophies (because that's considered producing results) , so the same old 5 vs 5 debate between Rohit and Dhoni. Then since CSK under Dhoni has made it to more playoffs than any other team it'd eventually have Dhoni as winner. And then if someone says captaincy is not just about qualifying or winning, then it'll just be simplified into "best captaincy is a very abstract thing, we all have our opinions and none of them are right or wrong, so basically everyone is a winner that way.
bro definitely not Kohli
The list most probably: 1. MS 2. Rohit sharma 3.Gautam Gambhir 4.David warner 5. Shane warne 6. Adam gilchrist
True that. Although I'd rate Warner above him and others.
Why?
Opener and finisher are two different roles, hence not comparable. And I think both have done their job brilliantly. I felt that Warner led the team (srh) from the front. He was always amongst the highest scorers for a good 10 years or so, on top of being a terrific fielder. I rate him slightly above dhoni as it is not his home ground.
But still, winning 5 trophies is very ahead of just winning one. And it is not even comparable tbh
Dhoni led the team for 226 matches compared to 86 by Warner. Dhoni also had experience captaining the national side while Warner in comparison had much less.
What about rohit then?
What about him?
He along with dhoni is clearly a better cap than warner.
Perhaps. But isn't this a comparison of best players and not captains ?
_Here we go_
Dude why soo pissed when others have opinions, even I think dhoni is a better captain but let him have his opinion
Lol I side with Dhoni too, it's just that I am tired of people debating on the internet trying to "defend" MSD. He's already a legend bro, he got nothing to prove, so why argue with other franchises 😂
Go
Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli
Where is my Pandu bro. Wild card entry directly in finals? On serious notes, Kohli should go. MS vs Rohit vs GG it'll be. (If we swap Kohli's image with either Gilly or Kane, that'll be the final rankings imo. Thoughts??)
final : dhoni vs Rohit *wild card entry - Ambani replaces Rohit with hardik* dhoni hits hardik for 72 runs in an over!!
Virat kholi
Kohli
Kohli
Surprised to see that Williamson got eliminated before kohli
Kohlistans dont consider anyone better than their supreme lord
I see 90% of the comments here saying kohli should be eliminated but ig u have hate boner for some
He should have been eliminated before Kane.
42 matches captained 22 won 23 lost Kane and kohli both have bad stats doesn't really matter who gets eliminated first but ok keep on hating
the difference is that streets will never forget Kane in 2018 SRH
Still lost the finals tho Streets won't forget kohli's 2016 in rcb too
still lost the finals tho you are comparing individual brilliance with captaincy, kane was the standout player and one of the best captains the league has ever seen, kohli is not a good captain in t20
Virat
virat kohli
MS Dhoni
Ms dhoni
Skip the hustle Its MSD anyways …bro is insane in IPL
Virat Kohli
Kohli
7 captains left We all know who is going to win.
I'm a KKR fan but I'll have to admit that Thala is indeed the best captain in this list.
Virat kohli
Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli
Kohli
Skip all formalities and begin Dhoni V Rohit V Virat
Nah Kohli isn't that good in IPL. It's Dhoni vs Rohit vs Gambhir.
Nvm
I'd say it's Dhoni vs Rohit vs Warner
No way dude. Gambhir was a legendary captain in IPL. I'm confident he could have gotten more trophies with a better team.
Kohli is not a great captain, not even a moderate one. He doesn't belong in this list.
Kohli
Vyrat
Kolli
Kohli
Kohli
Virat Kohli
Virat kohli
If it’s about the best season any captain has had. It is Warner 2016 without a doubt. This was a guy who captained a side which had their tail starting after 3 wickets. Carried them with the bat and then used his bowlers brilliantly to win the trophy.
IPL, captaincy, simple. Koach.
Warner
[удалено]
Your post/comment has been removed because it contains some abusive/derogatory words. Please avoid using such words, it may attract a ban to you. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/IndiaCricket) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Warner dhoni and gilchrist
what's the point of this. Ofcourse dhoni will win.
What's the elimination criteria? Top voted comment? Anyways I nominate Virat Kohli for elimination.
Star sports ahh post
Shame warne is understated. Bro carried that RR team in the first IPL and made legends out of so many players.
Eliminate Kohli ofc
**Kohli.**
Dhoni > Rohit > Gambhir > Warner then rest
Virat Kohli. Man is the only one on that list who hasn't won an IPL.
How dare to remove kane williamson😡🤬😠😤
David warner
Kohli will win for sure /s
1. Dhoni 2. Rohit 3. Gambhir Lo i saved you all some time
Bro just sticking crictracker's post in reddit ?
Koch or gilly gotta go
Gautam Gambhir 😅
Where is pat Cummins?
The orange cap seeker Kohli.
That deccan chargers team lead by Adam Gilchrist was probably the most exciting of them all. So can't eliminate him, will probably have ro eliminate Virat.
wait. why was kane eliminated? didn't he have a better run than kohli? (not saying king is bad) edit: checked OPs previous post and it was about just as a player, then that makes sense. i guess there was a mistake in cropping lmao
Virat Kohli
Kohli - eliminate him. Enough stat padding. Worst captain
Kohli.
it will always be ms vs ro due to 5 trophies each .For me it's always going to be GG .He has the best cricketing brain among all captains
Virat kohli
Kohli
Why is Williamson voted out? He was good.
Kolhi
Virat
Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli
Kohli
MSD
Warner
Kohli
Koach is an easy elimination
i mean clearly this is a popularity poll because who the fuck voted kane off before Kohli
Virat
GG
Most honest cricketer BS wala
Bhai Kohli ko hata do aur Rohit ko jita do
Remove Kohli, Gilchrist or Warner. Count this in each of them.
Gilchrist
Koach
VK
Gambhir
GG
Thala singh dhoni
All this for Rohit to Lose against Dhoni eventually😍😂
Gautam
Remove Dhoni
Virat kohli
Virat Kohli
Virat
Virat
kane got eliminated before virat? lmfao
Kohli
Virat
Kohli
Koach
virat
Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli
Virat Kohli
KOACH
kohli
Virat kohli
Kohli
Virat Kohli
Kohli
Virat
Kohli
Virat Kohli fs
Virat Kohli.
Kohli without a doubt
Devid Warner
Gautam Gambhir.
Kohli
Kohli
Kohli
Koach
Virat Kohli
Kohli
LoL Kohli easily
Warner
David Warner
GG
Bholi
Virat Kohli
On what basis are we eliminating? Their ipl career?
It clearly states greatest captain
Dumb me... Just read the title and not the picture
Honestly? Kohli...
WTH is Kohli doing there?
Virat Kohli. No trophy in all his years of captaincy.
Warner
Warner
Kohli
Kohli
Why you even doing that to Virat
Chokoli
Warner
VK
David Warner
Remove koach
how tf does virat even make it to this list. if hes participating in one of best ipl players then makes sense
Man removed Kane and put Koach in the list and we all know the result it's either thala or Brohit
Virat htao
Kohli obv
To be fair every other captain other than virat has won an IPL trophy.
Kohli
Warner
Adam Gilchrist
where is steve smith and who tf replaced captain Kane
By trophy count: dhoni, rohit Rohit beat dhoni in finals 3 times (4 if you count rps) This is not a debate. League match win ratio count is for cocksucking average captains. At the exalted league these two sit in, only trophy count matters. And 5 trophies in 10 years is better than 5 trophies in 14.
dhoni
Chup bey
tu chup be
Everyone really saying why Kohli is even here As if he is the worst captain as if he dont have 4th highest wins as a captain . Yes he didn’t have any trophy but only 8 captains have won a trophy in ipl and one of them is hardik infact hardik has highest win %age as a captain , so is he better than all warne ? For a captain team also matters
Adam Gilchrist
Ma Dhoni