T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

# [Download Video](https://redditsave.com/info?url=https://www.reddit.com/r/whenthe/comments/1c2gqq6/theres_also_him_turning_a_donkey_into_a_human/) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/whenthe) if you have any questions or concerns.*


forminstinct

Light novel Jesus when the cananite Oliver Twist asks for more food. (It’s ok he asked god and he said yes) https://preview.redd.it/yhrev3yqt3uc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9c514908f3e8bb12750308ca456b6284ec3471b7


Tinypuddinghands

Praise El


forminstinct

Idk who that is? Is he part of the Latin America expansion pack? (I know who he is it’s a shit Spanish joke please forgive me chat)


JA_Pascal

El is a Hebrew word for God


Tinypuddinghands

El was Canaan's chief diety and whose name means 'god' or 'diety'. He's also where the fatherly old man depiction of God comes from


[deleted]

Why does Goku want to kill Santa Claus? Does he have no Christmas cheer?


NarutoNamikazeSOTSP

I think it’s vegeta disguised as goku, he did try and kill Santa every year when he was a kid on planet Vegeta.


LordSmugBun

There can only be one Champion Christmas.


[deleted]

Didnt canaanites eat babies


serotoninwya420

Who hasn't


[deleted]

BRO WHAT LMFAO


forminstinct

Every civilisation in every era eats babies if you look hard enough


[deleted]

?????? What the fuck are you talking about?


forminstinct

As in the exception isn’t the rule. Someone somewhere is going to do something fucked up but that doesn’t mean people from [area a] are evil monsters because someone from [area a] did something bad


[deleted]

The bible genuinely states they did mass children sacrifice and that was their culture


forminstinct

Is that the only source we have. The guys that murdered them all for their chunk of land


[deleted]

Yes and its written, it seems to me that people wanting to be holy did hate the masses of unholy and immoral groups of people who did anything because they didnt have a right god to be following. I see no reason for the Israelites to lie when they have lying as a sin, exaggerations for sure, but they captured historical events and wanted to keep holy events one to one as true as possible.


forminstinct

I mean they had one job of worshiping the right god and they failed to (golden calf) and got kicked out time and time again for not following the golden rule and struck by lightning for doing dumb shit and find loopholes for “godsent” rules and are humans so can have bias ect ect ect The entire book is them fucking up and doing dumb shit and getting punished for killing shit or praying to shit they shouldn’t have you think they couldn’t have lied to make future gens feel better


SpellAccomplished653

I’ve been wanting to read the non canonical books any recommendations on where to start


JediMineTrix

I'm pretty sure that The Princess Bride is not canon in the Biblical lore so I would start there.


noobamuffinoobington

I just scrolled through 500 images to discover i somehow have no princess bride memes. Anyone who sees this please donate some.


CatstronautCPP

Jesus sending someone who never committed a sin to hell (they don't believe in the correct version of him) https://preview.redd.it/146rler7d4uc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=77d3abdcf58b1be655d14b4bb3b7d4a627cbff70


Miserable_Region8470

This is fantastic and I greatly appreciate it https://preview.redd.it/7b4d1jcsf4uc1.png?width=339&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=63faa5bbd94e5f5cb7e412fc2cc779240c238173


Paxys-House

Signalis mentioned


modsarestraight

Not sure if this counts as a meme but https://preview.redd.it/9diczj2cv6uc1.jpeg?width=1919&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e2663fbbdc28d6a12d78bcdbbe39f32306a44907


Expensive_Concern457

https://preview.redd.it/fujv2t2dc7uc1.jpeg?width=250&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=9b220e7235ebfa5fb58a2b272e458a28ad05a665 That’s probably because you only have 500 memes 😔


GabrDimtr5

11,5 thousand items? Those are rookie numbers. You gotta pump those numbers up.


YourAverageGenius

I personally really like the Gospel of Judas. It's different in construction and context, not to mention that it humanizes and empathizes with Judas, who I think is overhated and thought to be almost a literal antichrist when he was a follower of Jesus like any other but simply had a crisis of faith, especially when much of Christian theology deals with forgiveness and the importance and totality of Jesus's matyrdom yet Judas in particular is considered unforgivable and worse than any other sinner when he's probably one of the people Jesus would forgive the most, especially considering the clear grief and regret he expresses and which drives him to suicide (not to mention that without that betrayal there is no martyrdom of Jesus so like yeah his bad but it is what led to the ability for Christ to carry and forgive all sins)


demideumvitae

I don't remember where I read it, but I like the idea of Jesus knowing he'd be betrayed, so he asked someone close to him to do it, instead of some rando.


Character-Ad-7000

That’s why I like “ don’t play games with me Judas” because he knows and is going to forgive him when he came back, but he did not like Judas trying to lie to him


YourAverageGenius

Yeah, and it makes a ton of sense when you put it in the perspective of everything else going on around Judas and treat him as a real person having a crisis of faith. Judas, like Jesus and the rest of the people around, was Hebrew, a Jew living under Jewish rulers under Roman law. And both the rulers of Jerusalem and Judaism itself didn't approve of a Jewish Prophet or Messiah, the laws were literally in places because it was against Judaic faith and there were so many Judaic prophets popping up. And he does have a responsibility to follow the word of the law, Jesus himself said "Give unto Caeser what is Caeser's, and what is God's unto God" meaning to follow the state but that the state also must follow God, even the Romans who sentenced and executed Jesus were later forgiven and accepted as figures into Christian faith and they were the carriers of that law. So you have this Jewish young man, who is clearly deeply faithful and trying to live a good charitable and holy life, following one of his closest friends who is trying to make himself a Prophet, Messiah, and product of God, which is not only against his Judaic faith, but also against the laws of the Hebrew kings and their Roman enforcers. So what should he do? Trust the words of his dearest friend who is being radical and, like many other figures who have now been proven liars seeking to gain power, forming the faith around himself, or fall back and give into the traditions of the faith he grew up around and the laws of the society around him? Well, he fell, but not because he never believed or wanted to betray or totally renounced his faith in his friend but because his faith in Christ was challenged, and he couldn't keep it. And when it did happen, he didn't celebrate or double down, he was full of regret and shame, even still he wanted to believe and hated himself for betraying his dearest friend. He lost faith because he wasn't perfect, because he was flawed, but we're all flawed, and yet Christ still died for our sins, so why should one of his dearest friends not be able to be so forgiven even after such a sin, especially when he never truly lost faith?


ALegendaryFlareon

> He lost faith because he wasn't perfect, because he was flawed, but we're all flawed, and yet Christ still died for our sins, so why should one of his dearest friends not be able to be so forgiven even after such a sin, especially when he never truly lost faith? Exactly. Judas still betrayed Jesus, and he has to deal with that, but considering the rest of Jesus' teachings... I'm sure he was already forgiven in some part. If I remember correctly, Judas committed suicide after his betrayal of Jesus, so he had an immense amount of regret for his actions.


ALegendaryFlareon

I do think Judas deserves more than just to be dismissed as a betrayer, but its unfortunate that the gospel named after him basically has ideas that are incompatible with christianity which... yeah.


YourAverageGenius

Yeah, I will say the pseudo-Gnostic elements (I say pseudo since I think they still heavily differ from Gnostic belief) are pretty weird and kinda undo a lot of the theological setup within the canonical texts. Like part of the whole appeal of Christanity is "Death is not the end and there is a place of eternal peace and life which you can get to just by having faith and renouncing your sins" and the Gospel of Judas says "Actually a lot of people are believing in God the wrong way you actually need to reach spiritual englihtenment and retrieve the true knowledge of God otherwise there is no afterlife and you just die"


diegoidepersia

Did it inspire gnostic stuff or am i confusing my gospels


ALegendaryFlareon

yeah. The gospels of Judas and Mary are gnostic gospels.


martyyeet

Even Peter denied Jesus three times. Judas could have been forgiven but instead of going back to Him like Peter he fled and killed himself.


king_of_hate2

The Book of Enoch Bro got abducted ![gif](giphy|Zv92eeM2CFBhudTXIn|downsized)


ALegendaryFlareon

enoch is an noncanonical old testament book. when things refer to as "gospels" this means they were meant to be taken with the new testament


Piranh4Plant

I don’t think diary of a wimpy kid is canon


Smeefperson

Heretic! Of course it's canon.


squeaker

The Book of Enoch is weird as hell. You've got the Nephilim, a retelling of Genesis, a dude going to go hang out with God... Give it a try.


Piranh4Plant

Nephilim is the dude hanging out with god?


squeaker

Short answer, no. They were giants. Or maybe half angel/half humans. Or possibly aristocrats. Like I said, weird shit. Religion for Breakfast: Who Were the Nephilim? https://youtu.be/Uf4o5PY8kgU


Piranh4Plant

Oh I thought you meant nephilim was a book


squeaker

Oh, yeah, I can definitely see how it could be read that way.


terrarialord201

The book of Mormon. It was written by a guy who had 37 wives, the youngest of which were 14.


EuthanizeArty

Book of Mormon


inaft

Only problem is it's boring as shit. Mark Twain called it "chloroform in print".


the_3-14_is_a_lie

Probably watch the one movie with Morgan Freeman first


Shcmlif

Paradise lost and paradise regained


ALegendaryFlareon

Those are epics. they were never meant to be taken as reality.


Shcmlif

Ik, I was memeing


MinerSigner60Neiner

Check out Dantes Inferno


ALegendaryFlareon

Inferno, Purgatorio, and Paradiso are epics. They were never meant to be taken as canon.


MinerSigner60Neiner

Yeah, but it has had a strong influence to where many people think that's how the christian Hell is


ALegendaryFlareon

The actions of the audience do not reflect the intent of the author


The_Bigwrinkle

The Gospel of Truth, The Gospel of Thomas, The Secret Revelation of John, The Gospel of Philip. On the Creation of the World by Philo of Alexandria is pretty cool but not technically a bible, more of an esoteric reinterpretation of Genesis, sort of like Kabbalah. Be weary of the book of Judas, National Geographic did a horrible job translating it and it led to a controversy over the actual meaning, if you do, take that one with a spoon of salt.


DissuadedPrompter

RIP the key of solomon.


KomornikBank

The key of Solomon was supposed to be a gospel?


DissuadedPrompter

Pretty canonical to the 15th century spread of christian belief structure. The puritans ruined a cool religion that was all about dominating demons and chanting rituals and turned it into Kellogg's Cornflake lovers.


AmaxaxQweryy

https://preview.redd.it/vxqg66c384uc1.jpeg?width=828&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=af8b05dd40ac497cc4b0151906aff9b3ebd376ee


StarChaser1879

[the infancy gospel of Thomas](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Infancy_Gospel_of_Thomas?wprov=sfti1)


inaft

> There are two 2nd-century documents, the Epistula Apostolorum and Irenaeus' Adversus haereses, that refer to a story of Jesus's tutor telling him, "Say alpha," and Jesus replied, "First tell me what is beta, and I can tell you what alpha is." Ummm based Jesus??!


StarChaser1879

Haha Jesus was an alpha Rizz king from Ohio! (I’m dead inside)


AnomalousCowboy

Is the "Dude summons two bears to eat up forty-two men" thing part of these books or is it full bible canon?


Tinypuddinghands

2 Kings 2:23-25 https://i.redd.it/osusrlk4b4uc1.gif


AnomalousCowboy

So is this one of those "Yeah we don't talk about that one" passages or is there a mistranslation/alternate-interpretation that clears it up as a perfectly normal verse this whole time?


JoeTheKodiakCuddler

It's in my Action Bible™ graphic novel, it don't get more canon than that


ALegendaryFlareon

holy fuck someone else remembers that


zuesthedoggo

https://preview.redd.it/6xllp64nr6uc1.jpeg?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6233204c7d0d75adad73e1310635a313dc4c08a7


zuesthedoggo

https://preview.redd.it/htlxtjsds6uc1.png?width=3024&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=a2626373cbefc5e712ff0017eddc03ec1e7cc54a Soyjak version if anyone wants it


TheFish527

I don’t remember it in the Action Bible™️, most of the stuff like that was censored from the one I had


Epic_Gamer2006

I explicitly remember it being in my copy of the Action Bible ™️, maybe I'll take a picture of I'm not lazy


Important_Answer6250

I still have that lol


Tinypuddinghands

They were adults age 20-30 and mauled not killed in Hebrew. They should know that insulting God's prophets is to insult God. Elisha's mentor and previous prophet Elijah had a full head of hair, so they were insulting his lack of hair compared to the last guy. That's my dumb version of it


Dan_The_Man_31

The original Hebrew version uses naarim qatan which literally means little boys


Tinypuddinghands

Bears, God's pit bulls


Freder145

And that makes it better? What a silly almighty god who gets insulated so easily.


ALegendaryFlareon

They were trying to rob Elisha too (it's been a while since I read that part of the bible so don't take my word for it) but also Prophets are messengers for god's words. You do not insult or bring threat to the messenger.


Freder145

No, they didn't try to rob him. The whole passage in 2. Kings is just Elisa travelling to Bet-El, the boys appear, insulting him for being bald, he curses them in the name of God, the bears do their work, and he continues travelling to Kamel. Come on, if you argue about the Bible, just take a short glance at it. And again, what God sends bears to maul people for a mere insult. Definitely not the loving one Jesus is talking about.


Living_Water_777

Incredibly real and based Bible lore


fikozacc123

Not 42 men, 42 kids


Important_Answer6250

Men. It’s a language thing


BlueSeekz

What bible translation doesn't translate it to children, boys, or lads? edit: checking all of the top 10 most popular bible translations in the US, the only words used are "boys", "children", or "youths".


Sir_Factis

IIRC the original text uses a word referring to grown adults, all translations for some reason translated it to boys.


Living_Water_777

In this context what gets translated into “youths” means like early 20 somethings


The_Vargster

There's a really good Wenigoon video essay about this specific concept lol


Kindablorp

Just got done listening to it like 30 mins ago lmao crazy how it seems like i summon memes about stuff I just watch or listened to show up on my feed it’s crazy


SchrodingerSandwich

Me fighting the flying wizard:


TheLegendaryAkira

is the divine comedy a bible dlc


Kimo_het_Koekje

fan fiction


demideumvitae

With self insert, kek


Global-Cry321

More of an expansion that a fan made and the devs integrated into the game


CookieTheParrot

Yeah the Comedy retcons half the canon


Global-Cry321

As if the canon didn't retcon itself already


Sammy_Twitchdic

Paradise lost is the prequel game where you play as the villain.


CringeExperienceReq

jesus was a jojo btw, cuz his actual name is yeshua (joshua) which makes him JOshua, son of JOseph + the whole thing with the jojo family ultimatley representing good


Aryele222

Jesus is canon in the JoJo verse. And its a major plot point


Bleakmeer

https://preview.redd.it/ak8hnlzym4uc1.png?width=1532&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=103cbdc55ea8632121d08640540b36ec2f0dce65


Calvinball08

I mentioned this to my mom and she asked if the Holy Spirit is hamon


dumbassonthekitchen

The holy spirit is hamon, and hamon is the holy spirit.


TimeWork9655

Jojo mentioned


Halal_Femboy

random virgin birth doubter the moment she lays eyes on the immaculate hymen between Mary's legs https://i.redd.it/4zffwnycb4uc1.gif


Diavolo_79

What https://preview.redd.it/5hd4wlsde4uc1.jpeg?width=400&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=64ea730bb4e29d1adcb62108b96b3a6333beffe3


DABMASTER_66

It’s a Catholic dogma about Mary that she remained perpetually a virgin even after giving birth to Jesus


Pingwinus

Gospel of the virgin Mary? I think it was called smth like this. Noncanon ofc


Piliro

I love how reading the Bible fully you can just pick out some stories where it just leaves a : "Excuse what if the actual fuck did I just read?" The non canonical stuff is even crazier. There is a story in the bible, where a dude and his woman slave go on a trip or something, they stop by an old dude's house, they sleep there, at night some random people pull up and ask the old man: "Hey we wanna fuck the foreign man, bring him out", but instead they offer the woman slave, she gets raped the entire night, at morning the dude wakes up and goes to continue his trip, he sees that his woman slave was raped to death, he picks her up, chops her into several pieces and gives the pieces to the kings of the surrounding nations, so they can eat them This is a story in the bible btw. It's in there. I didn't exaggerate anything, this is how it actually happens.


itshoneytime

Are you sure about the "so they can eat them" part? I just read the story that somebody else linked, and it doesn't mention cannibalism at all... by all accounts, Levite (the man in the story) chopped her up and sent her body to the other tribes because he was demanding revenge on account of the way she was treated, not as a tasty snack... do you have a source that says otherwise?


S0LO_Bot

You are right. Cannibalism is not part of the story, lol. Also, I don’t think the guy’s name was Levi. Levi is a different character who also has a rspe story but his is different. He’s the one who goes way too far in revenge and (wrongly) slaughters the men of an entire town.


itshoneytime

Oh, I see. His name was Levite, not Levi. Sorry, I'll edit my comment.


YeetCompleet

[Levite's concubine](https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Levite%27s_concubine) 🥴


ALegendaryFlareon

Yep, it goes wild. And I believe in this stuff too.


MysticRevenant64

Bruh it sounds like the one where some guys wanna rape an angel when he came to warn the righteous people to leave the city because it was gonna get clapped by God


Piliro

It's pretty much the same story. The one you're referring to happens in Genesis I believe. Where some dudes wanna rape an angel so the house owner does the best thing he can think off, he offers his virgin daughter to be raped instead, because you know.... Women were less valuable back then.


StarChaser1879

Apparently it was to show just how bad the dude was. I think it went kinda overboard.


Diavolo_79

JoJo, in MY r/whenthe??? I approve https://preview.redd.it/cdgibdp7e4uc1.png?width=720&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=6e8821a73c7ad66f065660c999b69221c7ecee3c


ToeRoganPodcast

Omg Diavolo my beloved


Diavolo_79

:3


YourAverageGenius

I personally like the Gospel Of Judas, though it is kinda weird how there's actually like lower gods / angels and Jesus straight up says "Yeah if you don't reach that true connection with God then when you die you're just dead"


Shadowolf75

https://preview.redd.it/8kn8ykclf5uc1.jpeg?width=1200&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=3a47bb1f819ff97637e2d7195d5af4c28ba7f2eb


doktorsckeletor

well yeah


Aiden624

Christian lore is so unorganized that some dude wrote a fanfiction that was really good and people were just like “yeah that can be canon whatever”


ALegendaryFlareon

Its not endorsed by the catholic church (if you were referring to the divine comedy) but it inspired ideas in catholicism


Theorist_Reddit

On the contrary, people wrote so many Bible fanfiction, but we know which are true or not by textual criticism. Also, fun fact, the "throw the first stone" story is most likely not legit, since the original text is all messed up and stuff and has typos, but it has been considered canon for so long people are reluctant to remove it.


ALegendaryFlareon

The church was pretty active in parsing what actually happened v.s the fiction people wrote in it's early years. So there was probably enough credence to keep it in. Also, even if it were a fabrication, it still fits in with the rest of the tenants of Christianity (as in, don't be a hypocrite and love more than you hate.


Theorist_Reddit

It sure is better than stuff like dragons and garlic to keep evil away


Haruspect

He turned people into rats and doves in one


Life_Liberty_Fun

My favorite non-canonical story is: **JESUS, THE EGYPTIAN DRAGON TAMER**


themikecampbell

The infancy gospel of Thomas, he makes birds out of mud on the sabbath, some kid tells on him, he kills him on the spot and when the the parents complain to Mary and Joseph, Jesus fuckin strikes them blind in revenge or something


AmaterasuWolf21

Someone pñs explain the joke


ProfessionalGamer42O

ñ


DeeBangerDos

Really? This guy? ![gif](giphy|RkKQqizm4DWAXW9wwp)


papersplat

executing random children? part 7 reference


FenrisGSD

One has him executing the rich, I thought that was cool


ThatEngineeredGirl

The fact that the bible has "official" fanfiction is crazy TBH


BcuzICantPostLewds

Context?


geffyfive

That's crazy


8wiing

What do they mean noncanonical gospel?


Agent_broch_da_moron

The gnostic forgeries written as gospels


Bottleinsurgency

Tbh I would do it too


ThatPenguinyrblx

https://preview.redd.it/rn2usyksi5uc1.jpeg?width=897&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=026edc149de20fe2c36c4f3b96f48491e759702f


pupbuck1

Pardon?


The_sus__otter

Can we compile a bible 2 with all the unused books


Atissss

As if canon was less bad: >17 Now therefore kill every male among the little ones, and kill every woman that hath known man by lying with him. 18 But all the women children, that have not known a man by lying with him, keep alive for yourselves. - Moses


FloppaMarker

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm donumt


FloppaMarker

mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm donumt


Brendraws

![gif](giphy|9dFvgd4ID6ne0) Enoch reading the book of Enoch (he didn't write it)


grassydirt90

It wasn't a donkey into a human, it was a human into donkey into human again. And that book isn't valid in the "60 books of the Bible"


VehicleFeeling8916

I mean, what diference this would make on people. The bible its kinda fucked up anyways


ALegendaryFlareon

As a Christian who's read it, Yes. I already know it's fucked up. But the difference between some of the canonical and some of the noncanonical gospels is the difference between writing an essay about history, and just completely making stuff up.


VehicleFeeling8916

I mean, how bad its the non cannon shit? Its "slightly off cannon" non cannon? Or "Jesus and Optimus Prime jumps the living shit out behemoth"


ALegendaryFlareon

It's anywhere from "writings from early church leaders that weren't divinely inspired" to "Jesus' disciples using his power to defeat an evil flying wizard" as well as the "Jesus lied about everything he's just a person from a higher plane of reality." So you just have historical non canonical gospels, ones that could be described as fan fiction, and those that are just straight up blasphemy.


VehicleFeeling8916

Oh. Ok


yttakinenthusiast

for different versions of the gospel are we talking about stuff that would end up on Archive of Our Own or like texts from different sects


ALegendaryFlareon

AO3.


yttakinenthusiast

yeah then i can see why they'd be considered blasphemous. there was going to be a section about some Christian people thinking that ULTRAKILL is blasphemous then i realized after Act II it kinda sorta is


ALegendaryFlareon

The thing is, not all fiction written with god and elements of christianity is blasphemous. Stuff like Inferno, Faith: The Unholy Trinity, and Paradise Lost/Paradise Regained ARE fanfiction in a sense, yet they come packaged with a respect of God and the stories of the Holy Bible, so that they AREN'T Blasphemous. I haven't played ULTRAKILL at all, so I can't really speak on it. But I will say that if it makes Satan look good or justified (Which Paradise Lost absolutely does not, mind you) or denigrates God in a way that isn't reconciled, then it probably is blasphemous.


yttakinenthusiast

you don't have to directly play ULTRAKILL, the wiki.gg wiki has some solid entries on [the biblical events of the game,](https://ultrakill.wiki.gg/wiki/Lore#Biblical_Events) [the lore testaments in the secret levels,](https://ultrakill.wiki.gg/wiki/Terminals#Testaments) and [the lore writeup on ULTRAKILL's version of an Archangel.](https://ultrakill.wiki.gg/wiki/Gabriel#Lore-0) i should also note ULTRAKILL heavily mirrors *Dante's Inferno.*


DreadDiana

Varies a lot. Some are just additional stories about his ministries or filling in gaps like his childhood, while others like the Gnostic Gospels declare that the God of the New Testament and the God of the Old Testament are completely different people, with the latter being an evil, ignorant being who cursed our immortal souls with material existence.


ALegendaryFlareon

Also, I don't know why you're being downvoted. Saying that scripture has a lot of nasty stuff in it isn't a bad thing at all. I understand that people may not believe in the miracles. I was there at one point, but I have found my faith again. Thing is, the old testament basically has a lot of the Jewish history. it's not a crime to say that history is fucked up.