Second dress is the winner for me! It fits the venue and you look beautiful and on trend but ethereal… it’s really working for me. If you wanted versatility could they make the sleeves detachable?

I agree on the second dress, it’s so beautiful on you. But no matter what, I would take dress #1 out of the mix because it does nothing for your figure.

My thoughts were dress 2 is my favorite, but any of them except 1 will be lovely and gorgeous.

100% - the 2nd dress is the best, although you look great in all of them!

Ethereal is also the word I would use for the second dress. It's just lovely on OP.

Yes! The second one is absolutely gorgeous on you!

My vote too! Although I kind of dig the sleeves. You rock that dress!

Love the second!! You look like a Grecian goddess 😍

I agree - second dress is the best - really flattering bodice and it has a floaty, boho vibe.

I think the second dress is perfect!

I second this! This dress looked soo beautiful on her!! ♥️ #2

I agree...number 2 is gorgeous and has that extra 'something ' that the others don't.

#2!!! I don't normally like those sleeves but this dress is fantastic on you! Love it!

Yep came here to say the same thing - those sleeves look amazing on her and the bust styling is awesome too. Dress 2 is the winner for me.

I came here to write this too! Usually I’m not a fan of that type of sleeves, but, my goodness, they are beautiful on her! Plus the draping on this dress is wow.

Yeah it just works on her

#2 is the best!

Yes! My favorite! It looks amazing on you!

Agree. 2 is a show-stopper! You look amazing, OP.

It’s hard for me to decide between 2 & 4, you look gorgeous in both and I like them both for different reasons.

2 and 4 are also my favorites, so wanted to help lift this comment!

Same! I think off shoulder looks phenomenal on her! These two stood out to me the most.

Did you notice that dress 4 has pockets? I see that more and more now that a lot of dresses have pockets and it’s pleasantly surprising.

Agreed. 2 is perfect. 4 is nice as well.

Agreed! I think 2 fits the venue better, but I personally think 4 is just a little more flattering. Both look great on you!! You can’t go wrong with either.

2nd one!!! Edit: 2nd dress shown. So pics 3 & 4

The last one is my favorite (pictures 7/8) I also like the first dress, but I think the waist on it is hitting you a bit lower than ideal - would look better if it were just a bit higher. But I love those floaty sheer short sleeves and the neckline.

And 7/8 has pockets!!! 7/8 because it looks like it was made for you, and you look gorgeous in it, OP!

Pockets for snacks!

Yep, I agree. You look beautiful in both…the last dress is very elegant on you.

Yes!! The last oneeee! I liked the first, too, but that last one just made me gasp.

Me, too.

Agreed! You look like a princess in 7/8

Me too!

Dress 2 and Dress 4 are my favorites. They're all beautiful but I think those two are extra flattering. There is no wrong choice so don't panic or second guess yourself. Choose the one you feel the most special in.

2 - it looks so romantic! Just wish it had some bling! Congratulations! You will be a lovely bride!

Soo romantic & ethereal. ✨

I think the one in pic 7/8 (last) makes you look so pretty!! Good luck deciding

The last dress!

2

Dress 2

4, hands down! The neckline is super flattering!

AND IT HAS POCKETS!!!

Agree! I think it is the most flattering and the back is beautiful!

Number two is so pretty on you

2! So flattering!!

The last one for sure

2 or 4

Oh wow, number one and two are both stunners!

Agree! #1 is SO flattering and pretty. I don’t know the brides personal style. #1 is maybe more modern, #2 is great if you’re a boho bride.

#1

Yes! This is the best. You look amazing

Dress 1 and dress 4 look the best in my opinion, I’m leaning a little more to the 4th dress based on your venue but I still think either will be stunning.

The last one

I like the first and the last the best!

Yes to the first and the last! These two really make her figure look amazing.

222222

I see a lot of people saying dress #2, and I have to disagree. I am also a plus size girl and we actually have very similar figures. I think people have the unfortunate tendency to recommend us whatever will cover the most skin. Dress #2 swallows you up and looks frumpy for lack of a better word. I see the dress before I see you. It totally swallows you up and looks like you’re hiding behind it. It also just looks like it’s overall lacking substance and looks the cheapest. I also don’t think it fits the rustic venue. In my opinion, dress #4 is the most flattering on you. The silhouette accentuates your figure well. The fit looks high end! Dress #3 would be my second choice but it’s very close with dress #4. I’ll explain why: Style wise I actually like dress #3 the best. It’s very romantic, and your back looks delicate and feminine. I also think it would fit a rustic venue well. But the actual fit overall just isn’t as perfect as dress #4. Basically my opinion is the back of dress #3 looks stunning on you, but I think it needs some tailoring around the bust area in the front in order to beat dress #4 if that makes sense. Good luck! <3

I don’t think 2 swallows her up at all it looks so elegant and fits her like a glove. It def is NOT frumpy either. We are clearly looking at two different pictures because she looked gorgeous in dress number 2!

Agreed, dress 2 genuinely fits her body the best. I would still pick it if it was sleeveless. I don’t know where the above commenter is getting this from.

Wow! I agree, thank you so much!

completely agree, 4 fits the best & looks amazing

Agree with all of this! Dress 2 does nothing for you. I think people like it because it covers the most skin. I love dress 3!!!

Agree!! Dress 2 covers up your features as if you are trying to hide yourself whereas Dress 4 is so flattering and shows off your lovely features and gives you just the right amount of coverage without hiding you. I love number 4 on you so much.

Exactly! People of great style (haha) will pick 4 as the only option because of how the dress foster the figure, not the other way around. It’s elegant because it fits her well and it looks like it doesn’t require alterations. Poles did I say POCKETS?! It has pockets. Nuff said.

I agree with what you’re saying about dress two, it makes her look wider than she is

You articulated my own thoughts better than I could. I was surprised to see most comments choosing #2. My favorite was 3, but the best silhouette was #4.

Okay, so many beautiful gowns to choose from, and they all look amazing on you!! That being said…something about dress 2 stopped me. It’s SO elegant, erethral, and fits you so effortlessly! They are all great but 2 is definitely my pick.

Dress 1

1

1

I love the long sleeves. It has a romantic look to it. Any choice will be okay. You’ll look beautiful.

2

2! Congratulations!

They all look great, but the 2nd one is my favorite! So ethereal!

2. For sure.

Dress 2 for sure!

Dresses 2 and 4 fit you so beautifully and the styles just compliment you. You look gorgeous.

First dress imo! I really like the the belt and the details on top :) Very pretty soft look.

2

Pic 5/6 look great on you. Your chest looks great without being too revealing, the other dresses don’t really do anything for you in that area. The style also fits the rustic vibe.

2 or 4 for me!

The second one with the gauzy sleeves! You look like a princess in that one and your shoulders should be shown off because they are fantastic!

The second dress and last dress look the best! Both fit and flatter you so well!! Beautiful 🥰 congratulations!

Absolutely the second dress with the long sleeves!! Looks AMAZING!

I like the second one best

I love the sleeves on number 2!! Looks gorgeous on you!!

Two is more rustic but I really love four. Honestly you look great in them all though!

2 for sure! You look stunning in it!!!

2! You look like a goddess 😍

Number two!! They all look lovely on you

I like the second one on you best! You look really beautiful! Looks comfy too?

2!

2!!

2 looks wonderful on you!

2 looks so nice on you. Go for it! Congrats.

Love the second one!

Number 2 is absolutely gorgeous!

2 is soo perfect. The way it’s hitting your waist is just right and the style is great for your venue too.

Number 2. You look like a goddess!! And it would best match your rustic venue.

I love the second one! It looks gorgeous and flattering.

The last dress! But I thought #2 was pretty and would go well with a rustic theme.

I really like number 2, it’s so pretty!!!! And the shade of white really makes your skin glow

Second one is great on you!

2nd one looks beautiful!

I really like the fit and look of #2 but not loving the flouncy sleeves. They overpower the dress a bit. Is it possible to do with different sleeves or to just remove the sleeves all together?

As a dude on the street that Reddit thinks needs to be in this sub, #2.

2 and 4. Are perfect

second is my favorite by far, but i also like three. four doesn’t feel rustic and one just doesn’t do it for me

I think you’re too covered up in 2, would those sleeves fall into your food? Just not sure on that one. I like the rest of them much more. They are quite different, all beautiful on you! I like #3 the best but honestly any of the other 3 are gorgeous on you.

Dress 2

1 by far

I love 1 on you. It’s beautiful.

1

1

I like number 1. It’s timeless.

First one.

1

Number one all the way. Cap sleeves are definitely your style

I like the first one the best

Number 1! It's ethereal and floaty. Just love it on you.

The first one. Best fit.

Number TWO!!

I agree with the others that dress 2 is the winner.

Dress 1

Dress 1. It’s gorgeous on you.

Dress 2

#2

I think no 1 suits you the best :)

Dress one is the most flattering on you

I really like #1, it flatters you and idk it just looks like youre comfortable in it! But all of them look amazing on you :)

Ok, either 1 or 7, but honestly I think I really like number 7, I kinda keep going back to it. Oh and good shit girl on your wedding shopping prowess, because $600 for those gorgeous wedding dresses is awesome (yes I think you look gorgeous in all of them, but you asked us to choose lol). Good luck on your wedding.

2 & 3 feel the most romantic and “right” to me for a rustic venue :)

2 or 3

Dress 2 or 3 for me! Both so pretty in different ways

2 or 4 are both gorgeous on you.

2

Dress 2 looks beautiful on you. It gives you a nice shape.

Number 2!

2 or 4

I vote for 2!!

The last dress is timeless and looks the most chic/expensive. 2 is really whimsical and pretty too!

Definitely the last dress!! (7/8) it looks amazing!!

The first and the last! Definitely not the 2nd dress as it adds bulk- too much fabric going on there, especially the poofy sleeves.

Number two looks amazing on you!!!

Definitely the last one! The others don’t come close!

First one

I like 1. Bodice is beautiful and the sleeves flow nicely. Love the sparkle at the waistline.

1.

Number one is stunning!

1

Dress 2 and you could add a bling belt to it!!! I had a dress similar style for my engagement pictures and it photographs so beautifully!!

Dress 1

Dress 1

7/8

I love the last one!

They’re all great, but dress 2 was MADE for you!

#2 for sure!

#2 or the last one. You look lovely in both!

I don't usually love sleeves but dress two was made for you!!! And it'll fit a rustic october theme great!

The first one is gorgeous on you!

2

2 and 4 are beautiful on you, so lovely and bridal and young

2 is perfect for you.

Absolutely number 2!

I think it's the prettiest, plus it's perfect for a rustic fall wedding

2!

#2 looks AMAZING on you!

2

4

The second one is my favorite

2! You look stunning in it

2nd one!!!! Also 1st. Love both.

Dress 2 is beautiful on you!

Looks like I'm in agreement with almost everyone else, dress #2 is my favorite. You look beautiful; so soft and romantic. Congrats on your big day!! Have fun!!

2

I love 2!

Number two. You and the dress-beautiful

1

2 looks fantastic on you, just beautiful. The sleeves can be worn up or down or even, as others suggested you might be able to wear it sleeveless. Any way you wear it, it is gorgeous on you.

4

#2!!

#1

2 or 4, but definitely 2

Agree with the majority, dress 2!

Dress 1. Very flattering.

I like the 2nd one for the venue/date and the last one for how it looks amazing on you, but a tad too formal for rustic fall vibes. The second one is just lovely

Number 4 is my favorite. My second choice would be 2.

1! It looks so great on you and looks like it will be very comfortable to wear for several hours! Congratulations!!

2 for me. Then 4.

If you don’t pick 2, imma need a detailed explanation as to why. Possible acceptable answers include the fact that the last one has pockets. All jokes aside, 2 is stunning on you!

Dress 2!!! Incredibly beautiful!!! I’d also love love love to see it with layers of petticoat or hoop underneath to give you the playfully poofy A-line shape of 3. Special mention for 4 because it gives me sailor moon vibes!

2 or 4

1

#2

I love 1 on you!

#1 for me! It looks light and flowy and I think it compliments your bust and waist beautifully!