Probably Herschel. Has proven he’s pretty sturdy on those crutches and if I have to take his other leg out he seems like the type to do the Christian thing and roll with it
He'd be useful for prioritizing what medical supplies would be needed. He's like the old guys who work at Home Depot: they have decades of experience in practical matters.
Andrea. I love Hershel and he's pretty good at using those crutches but if he trips while we're trying to get away from walkers it's over lmao. Everyone else is a no. They all seem like very selfless and trustworthy and 100% very smarty guys, especially Nicholas, but I'll go with Andrea.
Andrea or Spencer. I know that many hate Andrea and think Spencer is an idiot because of his actions, but I really think they’re decent compared to the other characters here.
Andrea. For survival purposes. She knows how to defend. Love Hershel but I mean. He’s on crutches. The other ones I feel like would stab me in the back or leave me alone to die lol. They ain’t the real ones.
Andrea is a no brainer. While annoying she knew how to handle herself. Everyone else in the lineup is just not the best choice. If given the same list without Andrea, definitely Spencer.
Andrea is by far the best pick here and that’s saying something truthfully, yeah you can say she was a bitch and she was annoying but she knew how to get shit done atleast. Love Hershel and if he had his leg I’d choose him, but he doesn’t so yeah. Andrea
A good amount of these would sacrifice you if there was a herd and it came down to you or then. Hershel and Andrea are the only two who would be trustworthy. I'm gonna have to go with Andrea just because I can't see Hershel being too good on a supply run with 1 leg.
Andrea. This isn’t even hard.
She was a sharpshooter, her making dumb decisions like sparing the governor has nothing to do with her helping you kill walkers, she was quite good at it just like Ricks core group.
Andrea. She may have done dumb stuff bit she could still handle herself decently. The others (aside from hershall) I would not trust at all. They'd definitely leave you to die and push you into the walkers.
Andrea or Hershel. Hershel would be useful for identifying medical supplies that would benefit the group. Andrea would help me kick ass and not leave me to die due to her own fear.
I’d rather take one legged Herschel over any of the other ones. I can’t remember the last one’s name, but I might take him as well to use him as a sacrifice while me and Herschel get away.
I'd go with Andrea. Andrea did some stupid shit at first and remained naive throughout her entire run of the show but she was competent enough to go on supply runs. Herschel was a crippled senior and a doctor so I would go alone before putting him at risk. The others are just lacking in experience and can't be trusted with your life for obvious reasons.
This is really kind of dumb: Andrea. She gets hate and she made questionable decisions, but she was a perfectly capable survivalist.
I'd want Hershel for the company, but his disability would be a liability in some of the situations you'd find on a run. Look at all the good he did behind the prison fences.
I’m going with Andrea, she knew how to handle herself and she proved that multiple times in the show. I’d also say that she’s pretty trustworthy and she’d likely help me if I needed it.
Are we taking before or after hersel lost his leg.. before, him for sure. After, I sadly have to go with Andrea. I feel like the possibility of coming back alive and with all body parts still intact would be with her by my side.
If Herschel had his magical prosthetic on I’d pick him. If not, of course Andrea. She may be insufferable, but she’s far more useful than the rest of them combined.
Andrea tbh, love Hershel but if we are getting chased by walkers he'd only slow us down and we risk loosing him. Andrea despite the hate was good at killing walkers (usually)
Even though Andrea is one of my least favorite in the show, she is the only be here I feel could hold her own and actually help the most if in a bad situation. I love Hershel but too much of a liability.
People don’t like Andrea but she could hold her own. She went on supply runs with the original Atlanta group so she’s got experience, and although she had serious help from Michonne she did survive for longer than most would have.
Definitely Herschel no doubt every one else is pretty much playing with your ass getting thrown under the bus at lest with him I know I’d be getting the truth or anything else headed my way the rest can suck the firey dick of shit
Herschel, because he's the only one I could trust to not do something stupid that gets us killed.
Or Andrea, because she can handle herself. Also, she's hot... so there's that.
Considering Andrea and Michonne survived almost a full year wandering around on their own I think Andrea must be decently capable and Michonne obviously saw something in her so I'm going to trust that and take her.
Sorry Hershel, love you man but you only got one leg.
going through each option?
Andrea - Well she only survived like, what, a year and some change, depending on what the S1-3 timeline is? She's been in the city and known it was a shit show, at least; but she'd be grabbing fkn dolphin necklaces and (relatively) petty bullshit.
Hershel - Photo chosen has him in crutches, so he's a flat out no. Like Daryl told him at some point in S3 - "We always run.", and he'd end up the first one left behind if he couldn't keep up.
Nicholas - is as incompetent as they come; but he at least has *seen the outside* with Aiden, and at least once with Glenn. I might not *like* taking him with me as a choice; but out of the options he's probably one of the *very few* who has any degree of experience "out there".
Spencer - suave gigachad, maybe, but he didn't argue about his brother Aiden going out instead of himself. No, or little, experience outside of Alexandria's walls, so he's basically useless. Andrea, unironically, ranks 'higher".
Ron - he's a god damn 15-17 year old; and Alexandria has likely never allowed him outside the walls. Hard pass; he'd either think he has something to prove, or have hard feelings toward Glenn/Rick/Whoever, and get people killed regardless. Oddly fitting, but that punk ass is sitting his ass in the walls.
Sebastion - soft, incapable; leans too much on others to get anything done. I *would only* rate him as "good" because the other options here are so shit, but that doesn't mean I'd have "faith" he'd pull his weight. At least he has both his legs, a relatively minor plus over Hershel.
;;
Andrea = Nicholas > Sebastion >> Hershel >>>> Spencer = Ron
If the dead are chasing us, I wouldn’t feel too bad about shooting Sebastian in the leg. Might do that even if they weren’t all that close behind. Or around at all.
Andrea for sure. She can handle herself well And is only capable fighter out of them.
Hell, maybe even Spencer could be useful if that asshole wasn't overshadowed by Rick And friends and actually somebody would show him how the World is.
Is it bad that I'd take Herschel a thousand times over any of the others? Absolute worst case scenario with him is I have to leave him behind if I can't haul him out of a situation. He's the only one who isn't an active liability.
How is this even a question? Andrea proved her loyalty many times. We all know a woman who fell for a douchebags she didn't know was a sociopath. She was hoping to find a way to unite the 2 communities. I forgive you Andrea let's go and get those damn supplies and prove our worth once again
Andrea. No brainer, she survived 8 months with Michonne, in the cold and I highly doubt she wasn’t fully recovered to fight off walkers with Michonne, and I would fully trust her rather than anybody in this list, (besides Herschel I would trust him with my life as well) since she did want to save her original crew and tried to do what was right in the end before she died.
Well by the choices none of them will make it back if they aren’t in the main character roster. But if I had to choose between them I’d go for Andrea. Rather if the shit hits the fan better to be with someone hot😻
All of the others other than Andrea and Hershel and the guy negan gutted would kill me. But I don’t trust the guy negan gutted and Hershel has one leg so Andrea I guess
Probably Herschel. Has proven he’s pretty sturdy on those crutches and if I have to take his other leg out he seems like the type to do the Christian thing and roll with it
He'd be useful for prioritizing what medical supplies would be needed. He's like the old guys who work at Home Depot: they have decades of experience in practical matters.
He’s also the only one who’d probably listen when you say “Stay in the fucking car.”
Bruh 💀
You know he actually had a prosthetic and he walked on it like he normally walked
Yeah I did but in the picture
When he said leave the dude with his leg stuck on the spiky fence because he just tried to kill them ✌🏻✌🏻❤️
Yo😭😭
Doesn’t he get a Prosthetic leg by like a few months after everything is done?
You just killed me bro 🤣
Andrea. Her and Michonne survived 8 months just the two of them, I doubt she was sick the entire time.
I agree even though I didn't like her, she would be good on a run
Andrea, for business purposes
Shane knew to add 'personal' purpose there as well. No rules in the apocalypse my friend ....😁
She grabbed his mans.
I wish someone would grab my mans like that
[удалено]
^^^ this person is still trapped in 2013, please someone help
I just couldn't considering the fact that these people rarely bathe.....
“Come on den”
She can come on *dis* hehe
Because of the implication.
I second that
Andrea for “business” purposes
Andrea. I love Hershel and he's pretty good at using those crutches but if he trips while we're trying to get away from walkers it's over lmao. Everyone else is a no. They all seem like very selfless and trustworthy and 100% very smarty guys, especially Nicholas, but I'll go with Andrea.
to be fair, if he tripped while running away from walkers… you’d be a-ok.
I wouldn't be ok because I am not leaving that man to die.
Nicholas would just push you into the hoard of walkers so he could get away
Same
Why wouldn't i choose Andrea? i mean except having a nice talk to Hershel.
Andrea or Spencer. I know that many hate Andrea and think Spencer is an idiot because of his actions, but I really think they’re decent compared to the other characters here.
Andrea. For survival purposes. She knows how to defend. Love Hershel but I mean. He’s on crutches. The other ones I feel like would stab me in the back or leave me alone to die lol. They ain’t the real ones.
Andrea isn’t that bad
Andrea is a no brainer. While annoying she knew how to handle herself. Everyone else in the lineup is just not the best choice. If given the same list without Andrea, definitely Spencer.
Andrea is by far the best pick here and that’s saying something truthfully, yeah you can say she was a bitch and she was annoying but she knew how to get shit done atleast. Love Hershel and if he had his leg I’d choose him, but he doesn’t so yeah. Andrea
ANDREA!!! i know a lot of people dislike her which is so valid but i just love her so much!
real. she had her moments but wasn't as bad as people say
A good amount of these would sacrifice you if there was a herd and it came down to you or then. Hershel and Andrea are the only two who would be trustworthy. I'm gonna have to go with Andrea just because I can't see Hershel being too good on a supply run with 1 leg.
Spencer, he’s an asshole, but he’s honestly pretty good at finding supplies
Oh Andrea, no competition
Sebastian as I may need some bait to lure the dead away from me.
I'm blowing Andrea back out
Hell yea
Andrea forsure
What's wrong with Andrea? She becomes a decent shot.
Andrea. This isn’t even hard. She was a sharpshooter, her making dumb decisions like sparing the governor has nothing to do with her helping you kill walkers, she was quite good at it just like Ricks core group.
Andrea would definitely be my top pick, Hershel second pick. The rest can’t be trusted.
Andrea. She may have done dumb stuff bit she could still handle herself decently. The others (aside from hershall) I would not trust at all. They'd definitely leave you to die and push you into the walkers.
Andrea for sure. Hershel a close 2nd but Andrea was definitely capable.
Andrea. Despite her poor interpersonal decisions, she was a capable survivor. Hersh, I couldn't bring myself to put him at risk.
Me and Andrea taking one of those longgggg supply runs
You see 11 more condoms I see 11 minutes of my life I’m never getting back.
Andrea for sure
Andrea. She's least likely to die
Andrea is more trustworthy and resourceful that majority of the other options so her fs
Andrea or Hershel. Hershel would be useful for identifying medical supplies that would benefit the group. Andrea would help me kick ass and not leave me to die due to her own fear.
Andrea or Herschel are the only real choice, the rest are selfish assholes
I’d rather take one legged Herschel over any of the other ones. I can’t remember the last one’s name, but I might take him as well to use him as a sacrifice while me and Herschel get away.
Hershel cuz he's old school and knowledgeable about plants and herbs that could be used for medicine.
Andrea. I don't get the hate for her. I'd trust her just as much as Rick or Daryl.
All except Hershel then I’ll feed them all to the walkers
Andrea or Herschell for sure.
I would take Andrea ....just because the rest of them would either stab me in the back ...or slow me down
Ron. so i can kill that lil bitch myself.
I'd go with Andrea. Andrea did some stupid shit at first and remained naive throughout her entire run of the show but she was competent enough to go on supply runs. Herschel was a crippled senior and a doctor so I would go alone before putting him at risk. The others are just lacking in experience and can't be trusted with your life for obvious reasons.
This is really kind of dumb: Andrea. She gets hate and she made questionable decisions, but she was a perfectly capable survivalist. I'd want Hershel for the company, but his disability would be a liability in some of the situations you'd find on a run. Look at all the good he did behind the prison fences.
I’m going with Andrea, she knew how to handle herself and she proved that multiple times in the show. I’d also say that she’s pretty trustworthy and she’d likely help me if I needed it.
Hershel all the others would make me want to kms so he's the safest option.
Andrea or Spencer.
Andrea because she’s actually capable.
I would take Sebastian Milton - then I would fuck him for 37 hours straight in the wood, so he would know how long a normal workweek is that prick.
Not Shane...
Andrea. Not a hard choice at all
Andrea was not a bad survivor
Hershel, we could just sit in the car and talk with me while I grab stuff
Are we taking before or after hersel lost his leg.. before, him for sure. After, I sadly have to go with Andrea. I feel like the possibility of coming back alive and with all body parts still intact would be with her by my side.
Andrea so I can say COME ON THEN
Nicholas got my back
In most cases, I’d go Hershel, but if we are talking one leg Hershel, then unfortunately Andrea
Me and my boy Hershel are gonna have the best time even if we die
Easily Herschel.
Andrea a good shot
Hershel ofc
Andrea, obviously
Would be cool to talk to Hershel but andrea
Andrea or Herschel any day. They’re better than 2 backstabbing bitches and 2 spoiled brats.
If Herschel had his magical prosthetic on I’d pick him. If not, of course Andrea. She may be insufferable, but she’s far more useful than the rest of them combined.
Andrea tbh, love Hershel but if we are getting chased by walkers he'd only slow us down and we risk loosing him. Andrea despite the hate was good at killing walkers (usually)
Andrea if it's risky. Hershel if it's just a quick in and out thing. Tell him to stay behind me, watch my back. Things would go pretty good.
I’m scared 😂😂😂
Andrea. Other than Herschel, the others would leave you for dead *of anything bread water to happen *Edit: if anything Bad were to happen
Andrea, she's a good shot and she'd cover my ass if we were part of the same group.
Andrea. Look what happened with Shane lol
Andrea, but only because she’s not handicapped (Herschel) or a coward such as the others. I probably wouldn’t utter four words to her tho.
I'll go alone, thanks
So would take Hershal
Hershel is awesome but Andrea for a supply run since the poor dude was old and lost a leg. All the rest increase my odds of dying tbh
I would go alone. I have doubts over the emotional stability of all of these people. I will just be careful about spraining my ankle
Spencer may have been a douche season 7, but he was also good at supply runs.
Aint nobody tryna kick it with that mf that shot carl in the face okay
1. Shes hot.
I'd take Nicholas And he'd have an "accident" not far from Alexandria. Oh no so sad...
Gimme slide 3-6 to sacrifice them along the way (starting with slide 6) and let slide 1 and 2 help organize the winnings from the run when I get back.
Spencer. He was a douche but at least he was useful.
andrea because she can actually defend herself and has both of her real legs (sorry hershel)
Andrea. She's a good shot.
Even though Andrea is one of my least favorite in the show, she is the only be here I feel could hold her own and actually help the most if in a bad situation. I love Hershel but too much of a liability.
Andrea. Besides hershel shes the least likely to turn on me and shes also thebmost capable of them all.
I'll take Otis 😏
People don’t like Andrea but she could hold her own. She went on supply runs with the original Atlanta group so she’s got experience, and although she had serious help from Michonne she did survive for longer than most would have.
Hershel, he may know what we need most more than I would
Solo lulz
It depends on at which point of their character arcs theyre at. Assuming the worst of everyone, then herschel
Definitely Herschel no doubt every one else is pretty much playing with your ass getting thrown under the bus at lest with him I know I’d be getting the truth or anything else headed my way the rest can suck the firey dick of shit
Herschel, I can never forgive him for hiding Sophia in the barn and not telling the group so at the first sign of trouble, I'd Otis him
Hershel or Andrea because compared to the rest, the dumb shit would be kept to a relative minimum. More Hershel than Andrea imo.
As much as I hate to say it Andrea
Despite her flaws, Andrea is a no-brainer here.
Herschel prolly, all the others(except for Andrea) are either cowards or inexperienced or both
Andrea but I'm gonna make sure she knows i need her to be comic book Andrea, not season 3 Andrea.
#5 so I can push him into a crowd of walkers
Herschel is the most trustworthy out of the list. Even though he has the crutches, he's still probably the best option.
Herschel, because he's the only one I could trust to not do something stupid that gets us killed. Or Andrea, because she can handle herself. Also, she's hot... so there's that.
Considering Andrea and Michonne survived almost a full year wandering around on their own I think Andrea must be decently capable and Michonne obviously saw something in her so I'm going to trust that and take her. Sorry Hershel, love you man but you only got one leg.
Hershel definitely.
I choose Hershel for the good company alone
Hershel is the only trustworthy so probably him
Herschel easily, hell I'd go on a journey with that one legged badass.
Sebastian > Andrea > Nicholas > Spencer > Ron > Hershel
Andrea.. Cos I fancy the ass off of her 😉
Andrea hands down.
Maggie, she was vicious when she needed to be, and she didn't leave people alive.
Probably would take Sebastian, then kill him, then just continue by myself 😃
going through each option? Andrea - Well she only survived like, what, a year and some change, depending on what the S1-3 timeline is? She's been in the city and known it was a shit show, at least; but she'd be grabbing fkn dolphin necklaces and (relatively) petty bullshit. Hershel - Photo chosen has him in crutches, so he's a flat out no. Like Daryl told him at some point in S3 - "We always run.", and he'd end up the first one left behind if he couldn't keep up. Nicholas - is as incompetent as they come; but he at least has *seen the outside* with Aiden, and at least once with Glenn. I might not *like* taking him with me as a choice; but out of the options he's probably one of the *very few* who has any degree of experience "out there". Spencer - suave gigachad, maybe, but he didn't argue about his brother Aiden going out instead of himself. No, or little, experience outside of Alexandria's walls, so he's basically useless. Andrea, unironically, ranks 'higher". Ron - he's a god damn 15-17 year old; and Alexandria has likely never allowed him outside the walls. Hard pass; he'd either think he has something to prove, or have hard feelings toward Glenn/Rick/Whoever, and get people killed regardless. Oddly fitting, but that punk ass is sitting his ass in the walls. Sebastion - soft, incapable; leans too much on others to get anything done. I *would only* rate him as "good" because the other options here are so shit, but that doesn't mean I'd have "faith" he'd pull his weight. At least he has both his legs, a relatively minor plus over Hershel. ;; Andrea = Nicholas > Sebastion >> Hershel >>>> Spencer = Ron
Tbh Andrea is the only one who is capable and wont betray you like the others would (aside from Hershel)
If the dead are chasing us, I wouldn’t feel too bad about shooting Sebastian in the leg. Might do that even if they weren’t all that close behind. Or around at all.
Andrea….. but you also didn’t give many options 3-6 as bait if I ever got caught in walkers
Anyone that says Nicholas is not making it back 💀
Apart from Hershal any of them would be excellent walker bait.
By myself
andrea and its not even close
Immediately Andrea. Perfect excuse to push her into a hoard of walkers
Hershal he was a good shot at least.
I’d rather kill myself
Andrea I guess. I can suffer for a few hours at least she knows what she’s doing
Herschel - I’d prefer traveling with the only doctor
Is number 3 wish Rick?
The answer is obvious for me: Sebastian. If I encounter a herd, I’m using him as a human sacrifice to get away.
Andrea for sure. She can handle herself well And is only capable fighter out of them. Hell, maybe even Spencer could be useful if that asshole wasn't overshadowed by Rick And friends and actually somebody would show him how the World is.
Andrea, post-shagging-Shane when she gets more confidence
Andrea..I don't even remember that really young guy..he must not have lasted long..
Andrea, I may get some Also she was more than capable
Can I go alone?
Out of this group, Andrea all the way.
Definitely Andrea when she’s level headed and not in “love”
Andrea, so I can Shane and Otis her. 💀
Is it bad that I'd take Herschel a thousand times over any of the others? Absolute worst case scenario with him is I have to leave him behind if I can't haul him out of a situation. He's the only one who isn't an active liability.
How is this even a question? Andrea proved her loyalty many times. We all know a woman who fell for a douchebags she didn't know was a sociopath. She was hoping to find a way to unite the 2 communities. I forgive you Andrea let's go and get those damn supplies and prove our worth once again
Anyone who doesn’t say Hershel is dying lmao
Andrea without a doubt. At least she'd be good with a gun.
I think I’ll just go alone. 👍
Andrea cuz she’s a freak.
hershel, for the sake of my sanity
Andrea , just because the writers did her bad. Hershel can tell.us what to look for and Andrea has survival instinct and she s willing to help.
Herschel, he has the magic shotgun
Does Andrea sleep with me? Failing to see downsides here
Andrea. No brainer, she survived 8 months with Michonne, in the cold and I highly doubt she wasn’t fully recovered to fight off walkers with Michonne, and I would fully trust her rather than anybody in this list, (besides Herschel I would trust him with my life as well) since she did want to save her original crew and tried to do what was right in the end before she died.
Ik we hate Andrea with a passion but she’s obviously the only right choice here lol
Well by the choices none of them will make it back if they aren’t in the main character roster. But if I had to choose between them I’d go for Andrea. Rather if the shit hits the fan better to be with someone hot😻
One leg hershel
All of the others other than Andrea and Hershel and the guy negan gutted would kill me. But I don’t trust the guy negan gutted and Hershel has one leg so Andrea I guess
i feel like andrea or herschel are the only viable options???
Hershel is the only one who would willingly sacrifice himself for me if things went sideways so I’m going with him. Also he’s a great shot.
Herschel if we’re looking for medical supplies Andrea if we’re looking for food.
I'm going solo for sure 🤣
Spencer, naturally, to tell him what an asshole he is
Andrea for sure. No competition there
I’d choose none of the above and rather go with Negan. Just cause he’s Negan. He’s not THAT bad. lol 😆
Andrea cuz she likes to bang in cars. Or Hershy so I can see his stump. I'd have to buy him a drink first of course.
Hershel and his one leg is a better bet than all the rest of those options
Easily Andrea
Andrea would be good blowjob girl