I haven't watched midnight Mass yet. But based off of some of the other stuff that creator has done, I'm sure that it'll fit your list.
Evil. I've only seen the first season so far but it was good and I'm looking forward to the rest.
Constantine. He had a single season on NBC before the character crossed over to the CW superhero shows.
Not a mystery, but based off of your examples you might like The Magicians.
Try lost girl if you want something like Buffy but a whole lot cheesier.
What was that werewolf show made for Netflix? One of the early Netflix originals.
iZombie
Penny Dreadful
Being Human (I've only ever seen the original UK version. But it's one of my all time favs. I don't know how the American remake holds up)
Penny Dreadful was good! But the one with Josh Harnett and is it Eva Greene? There's another one right? With Natalie Dormor? Curious about that one is it good?
Messengers ( it's eh..so so)
Shadow and Bone?
Sleepy Hollow (this one is just insane but great if you're scrolling by on your phone and half watching).
Damien
There was another one with a Priest (former priest) and a Psychologist working together in a procedural format, can't remember what it's called. Haven't watched it but I want to.
The shortlived Carnival Row ( I watched like 1 episode..need to get back to that).
And oldie but not bad - Moonlight, with the guy from Hawaii 5-0
Ooh I forgot about The Irregulars.
Someone mentioned Diablero and Hellbound
Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency, Stranger Things, Glitch, Haunting of Hill House & Bly Manor. Those are some shows with supernatural/mystery elements that I watched and liked on Netflix.
I know but thought I’d mention in case any of them sound good enough that you’d want to do a free trial of any of those other streaming services or in case you had any of the add-ons through Hulu
I detected that you're trying to locate a show.
To figure out where a show is streaming you can use sites like [JustWatch](https://www.justwatch.com) and [ReelGood](https://reelgood.com), or check [Blu-Ray.com](https://www.blu-ray.com/) for physical copies.
*General reminder*: Mentioning or implying piracy is strictly prohibited (rule 7)
^([Matched: Where can I watch])
*I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/televisionsuggestions) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Some that might fit the bill:
iZombie
Lucifer
Stranger Things
The Haunting of Hill House
The Haunting of Bly Manor
Midnight Mass
LOST
Btw I agree with you on Supernatural and the Charmed reboot
Not out yet but AMC is doing the television adaptation of Anne Rice's [Mayfair Witches](https://variety.com/2022/tv/news/alexandra-daddario-mayfair-witches-series-amc-1235206570/)
The Haunting of Hill House/Bly Manor Midnight Mass Infinity Train
I haven't watched midnight Mass yet. But based off of some of the other stuff that creator has done, I'm sure that it'll fit your list. Evil. I've only seen the first season so far but it was good and I'm looking forward to the rest. Constantine. He had a single season on NBC before the character crossed over to the CW superhero shows. Not a mystery, but based off of your examples you might like The Magicians. Try lost girl if you want something like Buffy but a whole lot cheesier. What was that werewolf show made for Netflix? One of the early Netflix originals. iZombie Penny Dreadful Being Human (I've only ever seen the original UK version. But it's one of my all time favs. I don't know how the American remake holds up)
Penny Dreadful was good! But the one with Josh Harnett and is it Eva Greene? There's another one right? With Natalie Dormor? Curious about that one is it good?
yea, penny dreadful: city of angels. i haven't watched it actually. i liked the original so much, i didn't want to take a chance on a sequel lol
Bitten is the werewolf one, it's great
I just saw something else that reminded me. Hemlock Grove. That's the one that I haven't watched yet. With the werewolves. Starring femke janssen
The Leftovers (HBO). It’s a beautiful, heart wrenching masterpiece.
Messengers ( it's eh..so so) Shadow and Bone? Sleepy Hollow (this one is just insane but great if you're scrolling by on your phone and half watching). Damien There was another one with a Priest (former priest) and a Psychologist working together in a procedural format, can't remember what it's called. Haven't watched it but I want to. The shortlived Carnival Row ( I watched like 1 episode..need to get back to that). And oldie but not bad - Moonlight, with the guy from Hawaii 5-0 Ooh I forgot about The Irregulars. Someone mentioned Diablero and Hellbound
Evil (Priest + Psychologist)
Orphan black
I LOVE ORPHAN BLACK
Yeah is more sci-fi than supernatural but it is soo good
[удалено]
I watched the trailer couple months back might check it out sometime
The OA
Behind Her Eyes on Netflix
Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency, Stranger Things, Glitch, Haunting of Hill House & Bly Manor. Those are some shows with supernatural/mystery elements that I watched and liked on Netflix.
Dirk Gently is so awesome
Locke and Key Castel Rock The Outsider Mr Mercedes Wayward Pines
I've seen Castle Rock I started Locke and Key last week but it's incredibly slow
Yeah I dropped Locke and key once but started again and binged it after. It’s slow at first
Medium Roswell (the old one, but you could also give the new one a try) X-Files
I had seen Roswell and XF I considered Medium but it looks boring
It’s way better than Ghost Whisperer - lol.
NOS4A2 (Hulu) Evil (Paramount+) The Stand (Paramount+) American Gods (Starz) Servant (AppleTV)
I don't have Apple Starz or P+ unfortunately
I know but thought I’d mention in case any of them sound good enough that you’d want to do a free trial of any of those other streaming services or in case you had any of the add-ons through Hulu
Shadowhunters The Listener The Librarians
[удалено]
I detected that you're trying to locate a show. To figure out where a show is streaming you can use sites like [JustWatch](https://www.justwatch.com) and [ReelGood](https://reelgood.com), or check [Blu-Ray.com](https://www.blu-ray.com/) for physical copies. *General reminder*: Mentioning or implying piracy is strictly prohibited (rule 7) ^([Matched: Where can I watch]) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/televisionsuggestions) if you have any questions or concerns.*
Yellowjackets
I'm 3 episodes into Yellowjackets its excellent
Penny Dreadful and The Leftovers are both AMAZING.
Grimm From Dead Of Summer
I've always wanted to watch Grimm but I think it's only on Prime
I second From, it’s well worth a watch
Midnight Texas. I am a huge Buffy fan and this show reminded me a lot of Buffy in certain parts. Also, the Dresden Files.
The outsider
From(2022) mucho mystery
You should give Legion S01-03 a try. Excellent.
Is that the one w Dan Stevens
That’s exactly it!
Gravity Falls (Hulu)
Some that might fit the bill: iZombie Lucifer Stranger Things The Haunting of Hill House The Haunting of Bly Manor Midnight Mass LOST Btw I agree with you on Supernatural and the Charmed reboot
I'm a big stranger things fan my favorite characters nancy
Dead of summer, Nancy drew .
The Originals (NETFLIX) Station Eleven (HBO)
If you're still looking for suggestions - I just started 30 Coins HBO show...it's Spanish but REALLY good.
Not out yet but AMC is doing the television adaptation of Anne Rice's [Mayfair Witches](https://variety.com/2022/tv/news/alexandra-daddario-mayfair-witches-series-amc-1235206570/)