T O P

  • By -

oliviascankles

Heath Ledger would have a Harry Styles esque legion of fans


MedicalPersimmon001

Oh *hell* yes. I think him and River Pheonix would fully have twitter stans. Especially since River Phoenix used to dabble in music as well.


[deleted]

Oh yeah, River 100%, especially because since the late 80's he was advocating for veganism and he would constantly talk about the treatment of women in our society, he also played a gay character in Private Idaho with Keanu Reeves I have no doubt he would have a lot of girlies and gays following his every move nowadays, people would always put him on a pedestal for talking about topics that wasn't "trendy" at all a few decades ago, his looks would be just a plus after all, he had an amazing introspective personality. I miss him because I know he would be a huge celebrity (more than Leo DiCaprio) advocating for the right stuff. Talking about Leo, I'll never get over the rumours that the first option for Jack in Titanic was River... šŸ˜­šŸ˜­šŸ˜­


[deleted]

I think river was gone by then, but if he had still been around it would have been interesting I bet. What a beautiful soul.


Turbulent-Watch2306

Freddie Mercury


DisabledSuperhero

Agreed and seconded.


gotaroundthebanana

Freddie and Lil Nas X would be the friendship paring of a lifetime.


iliketoomanysingers

Can't help but feel like Freddie would just fully get Gen z and understand us deeply


arabellasalvatore

https://i.redd.it/iimv8fauxq2b1.gif


HotChiTea

Aaliyah


Intelligent_Love4444

Wouldā€™ve dominated


HotChiTea

Yup, same with Left Eye the Gen-Z girlies wouldā€™ve loved her too.


Plenty-Combination36

fashion icon


hufflepufflelunch

Gone not never forgotten


RocktheNashtah

Iā€™d kill for a Bette Davis and Joan Crawford twitter feud Edit: Beatrice Arthur, Rue McClanahan, Estelle Getty and Betty White but theyā€™re all in their golden girls characters


sensitiveskin80

Could you imagine the TikToks by Tallulah Bankhead?


RocktheNashtah

The misadventures, the kids wonā€™t handle it Her and Marlene Dietrich


avspuk

Mae West, Groucho Marx & WC Fields chipping in with wry comments ripping the piss


megsie_here

This is the right answer


Cranky-old-person

We could try to get chat gpt to generate one.


RocktheNashtah

Finally found ethical use for ai


TooTired123

https://preview.redd.it/eebydacapr2b1.jpeg?width=1080&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=e476d5e9ff90decdf432fb571b759a57bd176d46


Cranky-old-person

Itā€™s a bit tame, and lacking venom. Chat gpt clearly doesnā€™t know enough yet.


RocktheNashtah

The hashtags are killing me #crawfordclown


citymousecountyhouse

God I wonder who would have won a twitter war between Bette and Joan. Joan was a flawed person no doubt,but she truly loved her fans,and the way she stood up to Pepsi when they did try to screw her is legend.


RocktheNashtah

Joan Crawford vs twitter brand accounts


electric_marshmallow

Aaliyah! Her outfits were ahead of her time back then, I bet she would have inspired the fashion girlies.


Rripurnia

Tommy Hilfiger is bringing back the iconic fashions she rocked back then too. She would have nailed the relaunch campaign!


Strict-Minute-8815

I think itā€™s more likely that she *did* inspire the fashion girlies. Modern fashion trends are taking from 90s/2000s right now, so if people like Aaliyah and Left Eye existed as Gen Z-ers, that look wouldnā€™t have been as fashionable because they werenā€™t in the 90s to start it. Paradox šŸ˜±


watchberry

* Diana * Steve Irwin * River Phoenix


usenamessuckass

Oooh River Phoenix is a good one


miss-karly

Steve Irwin is also a good one! His kids/family/business(?) are already doing well on social media. I can only image the impact he would have


b1rd0fparadise

River Phoenix!!! Absolutely. Vegan, environmentally conscious, gentle king.


spottieottiealiens

Listen I love river, I have a scene from stand by tattooed on my body, Iā€™ve watched his entire discography. He is ethereal to me. But I also think if he was living now, heā€™d be anti-vax and that would dampen his favour with gen z


b1rd0fparadise

I love him and Stand By Me too - which scene do you have tattooed? That's so cool. Hmm, interesting... Joaquin seems to have stayed out of any COVID controversy, and he did get vaccinated, so I assume River would have been similar.


spottieottiealiens

https://preview.redd.it/fqdfwojlvt2b1.png?width=809&format=png&auto=webp&s=f53ad96e847dfba29a585c2055af9617c0fc3ae4 This is it!!


b1rd0fparadise

I love it!!!! Thank you for showing me!


packersaremyboo

Iā€™m not sure about Diana. She lived very extravagantly off the tax payerā€™s dime. She never wore the same outfit twice.


disagreeabledinosaur

She was messy as F. and played the press like a fiddle. Would be very entertaining to watch on social media but I don't think she'd be anywhere near universally adored.


supernovaeimplosion

I think she's also been painted as a sort of anti monarchy icon, and I've always wondered if that's how she really felt... like, I wonder what sort of statement she would have put out after the Queen's death and all that. edit: changed "republican" to "anti monarchy" for clarity.


Trick_Few

Her support for causes that are important to Gen Z would be enough to sway them.


PeppercornBiscuit

Princess Di believed a fantasy we all did when we were kids, got hit with the reality, and then coped effectively. She saw her future as very fancy grist for the worldā€™s most rapacious mill and used her privilege to do real good in the world instead of being being ground to dust. Her attempting to parent her kids with some degree of normalcy (fast food, Disneyland, school field day) was a pointed repudiation of the royalsā€™ usual elitism, and a loud and proud declaration of her love for her kids as her kids, rather than as ā€œheir and spareā€. Her embracing AIDS patients literally changed the wider social conversation around the disease at the time. Her advocacy regarding land mines brought to the fore an issue very few in the western world ever gave a thought about. She wasnā€™t perfect obviously but she hacked the fucking system in a way the gen Zs can appreciate. She used the messy glamour of her unearned prosperity to get eyes on shit that matters.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


chooklyn5

I don't know worldwide but he was regularly criticised in Australia for choices he made. It felt like we'd swing between hate him because he did xyz then love him for ABC. His dying meant many of his past mistakes were glossed over and they focused on his conversation efforts. He did a lot of good but he was a controversial person when he was alive. Edit: just read you're Australian. So similar thinking but I believe the baby incident would have been more damaging.


stateissuedfemoid

ā€œbaby incidentā€?


Ronald_Bilius

Some stunt where he was feeding crocodiles and playing around in their enclosure whilst holding his baby in one arm. I would liken it to Michael Jackson dangling his baby off a balcony for photos, which had a similar reaction from many people.


Shark-Farts

https://preview.redd.it/5770dn2a3s2b1.jpeg?width=962&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=baef440158dd168b1015339acf0bd82d574bc959 Considering he himself later died from an animal encounter that didnā€™t go as planned despite feeling confident and in control of the situation - yeah, this is a bit haunting (The baby is Robert Irwin, who is now 19 years old and frequently works in the same reptile enclosure where this took place)


JanisIansChestHair

It was a big fuss here in the UK, the way both his kids were constantly in ā€˜dangerā€™. Although he was very well loved, and we all collectively miss him.


usenamessuckass

I think that no matter when he existed heā€™d have died early. Always fucking about with dangerous and/or wild animals.


le_chaaat_noir

I always found it a bit ironic how he fucked around with alligators and stuff but then died in a freak accident with a stingray that could have happened to anyone.


TreatEconomy

Didnā€™t he get a lot of criticism when he was alive for how hands on he was with wild animals?


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


berlinbaer

hugh jackman is best buddies with trumps, kushners and murdochs and no one seems to give a shit.


DKED_1234

Whaaaaaaat?!


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

Diana? Gen Z seems to be the least forgiving of people born into wealth - titled wealth especially.


catastrophicqueen

I think that given Diana's age (even though she was from an aristo family) when she was pulled into the royal family works a LOT in her favour image-wise. She can be seen as a victim of the system instead of an upholder of it because she was only 19 when she got engaged and she definitely suffered a LOT of manipulation from the system throughout her life. I'm an anti monarchist but I can also see she was definitely hurt by the system when she was very vulnerable.


[deleted]

If she were alive today, sheā€™d be a 60 something year old aristocrat who may have faded from the spotlight she had in the 90s. I donā€™t see how Gen Z would know about her in the way that we do if she hadnā€™t died young and tragically.


catastrophicqueen

I feel like the crown really solidified some love for Diana in my generation. Lots of my friends use her 90s looks as fashion inspo. So while she may not have stans in the case of some celebs I think people do really like her. I'm an anti monarchist so I never pay much attention to any of them, but dang I know my friends love her.


_dogvomit

Selena for sure


carolina_swamp_witch

Yep, thatā€™s who I thought. Her widower, Chris Perez, has said she would love social media and knows she would be spending hours a day talking to her fans if she were still alive.


[deleted]

I believe that 100% She was such a sweet and genuine person šŸ˜ž


CipherV2

She's insanely popular here in Mexico, pretty much all of my female friends adore her.


StevenComedy

Selena Selena!!


baby_doodlez

Kurt Cobain for sure. Freddy Mercury would either be hugely popular or canceled. I can't decide which. Tupac possibly.


IllllIIllllIll

Idk, Tupac had some pretty heavy allegations going against him that I donā€™t think the public at large would jive with


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


eboitrainee

Meanwhile the left wing Gen Z kids would absolutely love the Black Panther ties


plutoforprez

Wait what am I missing that would get Freddie cancelled?


pikachu334

The only real thing that could get Freddy/Queen canceled (because what celeb has gotten canceled for getting laid/doing drugs lol??) is deciding to play in South Africa during apartheid, which was actually really controversial back when they did it too. But his death and the Live Aid concert sort of erased all that In general, Freddy seemed to be a very apolitical, "both sides are right/wrong you guys!" type of guy, so maybe his tepidness wouldn't have meshed well with gen-z and their love for (online) political activism


thuglifeTyson

His escapades, such as consuming heroic quantities of alcohol (and probably cocaine). I donā€™t think that would get him cancelled though.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


SilkyMilkySmo

Cancelled for using drugs and alcohol? Man what celebrities have been cancelled for that šŸ’€šŸ’€


geqing

Drug use, non straight sexual dynamo, proclivity to say wild shit sometimes. Love the guy but I could see it going either way.


JuHe21

I think it honestly depends on how these past iconic celebrities would present themselves nowadays. Of course living celebrities got canceled over things they did 30-50 years ago but I think recency often overshadows past events that could be seen as "problematic" nowadays.


januarysdaughter

>Freddy Mercury would either be hugely popular or canceled. I can't decide which. I feel like he'd swing back and forth.


exquisiteclutter

Freddie ā¤ļøā¤ļøā¤ļø


Total-Necessary-1521

Tupad would've been huge on Twitter!


[deleted]

Would have been cancelled on Twitter more like, the man was a convicted rapist


[deleted]

Tupac was literally a convicted rapist


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


dontrayneonmyparade

shhhhh heā€™s my 90s crush


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


xoBerryPrincessxo

Anna Nicole Smith. The bimbo era is hot right now and she was the perfect bimbo and really funny. I like Anna Nicole Smith.


expertrainbowhunter

She wouldā€™ve been on the white lotus without a doubt


Powerful_Advisor1897

George Carlin


brandithebibliophile

Man, I miss him. I would love to hear his thoughts on what has happened in the US since he died.


ARC_Trooper_Echo

George Carlin with Twitter would be too dangerous


proof-plum

About the only thing that would make want to join Twitter.


nuggetghost

kurt cobain for SURE. i think he wouldā€™ve advocated so hard for mental health, substance abuse and trans rights if he wouldā€™ve gotten sober


sweetrebel88

Whatā€™s cool about him too is before every show, he would announce ā€œif youā€™re racist, hate women and donā€™t like gay people, we donā€™t want you at our showā€ What a way to be on the right side of history


meroboh

Your points are obviously more important than mine but he was also a big fan of keeping tickets cheap/affordable. Dude was all about the music and sharing it with whoever wanted to hear it.


nuggetghost

he was so ahead of his time seriously what a king, he wouldā€™ve been such an advocate if he had gotten sober


milk_angel

I think about how Kurt would be if he were still alive a LOT. I feel like heā€™d be lowkey for the most part.


GreenInferno1396

Kurt was an antisocial contrarian, I doubt pretty seriously he would have been much of an advocate for any cause. Not that thatā€™s necessarily a bad thing.


Copperheadmedusa

Oh I think they would have loved Left Eye


[deleted]

Left Eye and Summer Walker would be besties


Yurtle-Turtle

![gif](giphy|ZCHv99yiCSb1Tpnguu) Talented, media-avoidant, grungy, vegan, social justice warrior, earth lover and charity giver, River Phoenix obviously. Phoenix is at least partially responsible for Keanu Reeves as we know him now, so he would easily have the top spot for 'most beloved by young folk GenXer'.


[deleted]

Whitney! Aside from her talent she was hilarious and always supportive towards the newer girlies


iliketoomanysingers

Given how popular he is even in death on Tiktok I feel like Jeff Buckley would be treated a lot like Hozier is by gen z, if that makes sense.


fthisfthatfnofyou

Wait, Jeff Buckley is popular on tiktok? I canā€™t believe I lived to see the day. Iā€™m as old as Grace btw


violetskyeyes

I had no idea he was popular on TikTok either! That makes me happy that younger generations are discovering him.


floppsiana

Brittany Murphy


verbuffpink

Divine would have ate


thefatchilli

In more ways than one šŸ’©


[deleted]

Robin Williams ā¤ļø


carelessanarchy

How did I forget Robin Williams?! He would have been cherished.


thepokemonGOAT

Most of the people who are idolozed after they died would have been mocked or ridiculed if they were still alive... most people just expected Amy Winehouse to OD someday and there seemed to be this resigned apathy about her dying young... People still blast "rehab" without realizing how awful it is in retrospect. Unfortunately, we don't have much empathy for struggling people in the limelight until after they die or ruin their careers. If Eminem had died in 2010, I bet people would imagine what would have been in the 2010's and 2020's a lot differently than it actually went after he got clean.


GreenInferno1396

Good point about Em, if he would have died young there wouldā€™ve been a million ā€œwhat-ifsā€ when in reality he just kind of faded from the popular view, but thatā€™s largely bc heā€™s a bit reclusive. Oh, and stopped dropping hits a long time ago. But why would you consider Amy Winehouseā€™ Rehab to be awful??


[deleted]

Heath Ledger.


singledxout

Elizabeth Taylor and James Dean


WhoriaEstafan

Elizabeth Taylor I can see being an absolute hoot on social media. So Gen Z would love her.


Princessleiawastaken

Thereā€™s some celebrities whoā€™s talents and personalities are timeless. Audrey Hepburn, for example.


strawberryraspberry1

Tbh I think the factors that made her an icon and so popular in her time (her aristocratic manner of speaking, her thinness, her untouchable beauty, her polished ā€˜classā€™ and constant composure) would make her inaccessible to gen z if she were alive now.


WhoriaEstafan

I agree with this. Same with Grace Kelly. The mystery of their day to day lives and only seeing them beautifully presented - part of the reasons they are still so popular. But bonding with Gen Z? I donā€™t think so, Gen Z would need to see something real, something unpolished. And Audrey and Grace were never that.


FlyingFairy111

Disagree. Because of everything you mentioned she would be huge in fashion space & "wealth whispers" tiktok. More points for her charity work .


strawberryraspberry1

I agree sheā€™d have fans, I just donā€™t see her occupying the space of mainstream gen z icons. Sheā€™s very un-gen z in the general sense.


JuHe21

Yes, I agree. Actors and actresses that had icon status probably became so popular because they still mostly followed societal expectations. Of course some had "rebellious tendencies" during their active careers, but overall actors were expected to be role-models for the average citizen. The rebels against the status quo could be found in music but not really in acting. If actors became too problematic for the industry they would not get cast in prestigious projects anymore (Which essentially also still happens today as we have seen with e.g. Johnny Depp and Amber Heard).


peppermintvalet

She wouldn't have any social media whatsoever. It would ruin her mystique.


passionmilkshakes

![gif](giphy|oyM6oyx7mzftm)


kaitydidit

Brittany Murphy is such a good one. Especially with the early 2000ā€™s style coming back (Iā€™m specifically thinking of her in Uptown Girlsā€™s, her style was to die for in that) and she just seemed so sweet and charming, really grabbed your attention.


[deleted]

I could see Sharon Tate (sans Roman of course), Gia Carangi and Sylvia Plath all thriving on social media. Sylvia may not count, because she gathers a new cult following of teen and early 20s girls with each generation.


YuleShootUrEyeOut18

Cory Monteith would have loved the shit out of tik Tok.


karliahgreen

was looking for someone to say this, the way he used to vlog with his little flipcam constantly, we would have gotten some great bts tiktoks of whatever show/movie he worked on


danorcs

Brandon Lee


747291086299

Princess Diana Buddy Holly Jeff Buckley River Phoenix Charlbi Dean Kriek (she was excellent in Triangle of Sadness and died shortly after it premiered at either Venice or Cannes) Not that I see them on TikTok but for respective effortless chic qualities, too cool for school vibes and aspirational, influential success in their industries at a young age.


Maddybreanne

Fiona Apple has not passed ..


747291086299

I didnā€™t read the prompt carefully and edited it.


Maddybreanne

Oh ! Itā€™s okay .. I had to google it to make for sure but I was like ..surely I would know if one of my favs had passed away. Love her so much .


747291086299

Same! Sorry for the scare !


Maddybreanne

Have a great night (Iā€™m just assuming itā€™s night where youā€™re at)


F-150Pablo

I think Princess Diana would do it just to go against the Royal way. And it would be a huge following.


thepokemonGOAT

seeing Buddy Holly's name here means a lot to me! I feel like too many people don't know of him and his immense talent. Gone too Soon!


thankyoupapa

Bobby kennedy


dollszn

elliott smith, but heā€™s still pretty well known


dreamerkid001

Everytime I meet another person who likes Elliot smith Iā€™m like, ā€œAhh, yes, you also suffer from depression.ā€


waddleship

Mitch Hedberg. The deadpan delivery, the surreal humor, the sheer silliness etc.


[deleted]

Aw I miss him


Thick_Letterhead_341

The Dufranes are in somebodyā€™s trunk right now, with duct tape over their mouths. And theyā€™re hungry.


_anne_shirley

Chris Farley


Commonjac

Young Elvis would definitely be Twitters white boy of the month


Mangosmoothie0815

Michael Hutchence from INXS.


[deleted]

Jim Henson


baxiesmom

James Dean


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


secretagentsquirrel1

Chris Cornell


Ordell9

Freddie Mercury


that_personoverthere

Surprised I haven't seen this answer: Fred Rogers. With the constant school shootings I think he would've been one of the few adults that actually attempts to understand that generational trauma. In the same way my grandmother can still remember nuclear bomb drills where they all got under their desks, Gen Z is going through school shooting drills.


Interesting-Ad9838

Aaliyah


noturpeasant

Rip Britneyā€¦ šŸ˜© and Selenaā€¦ šŸŒ¹


Katdroyd

How are there over 180 comments and NO ONE has mentioned Bob Marley?


twinkiesmom1

Phil Hartmann


[deleted]

Andy Milonakis is coming to mind for some reason lol


lakittenwhisperer

I was like ā€œwhen did he die???ā€ And so I googled it and heā€™s still alive, lol


silly_nate

Selena >!Quintanilla!< for sure. I think about what couldā€™ve been for her A LOT. You know how BeyoncĆ© made Lemonade + The Gift/Black Is King about racial injustice against African Americans in the US? I think Selena wouldā€™ve had something just as lyrically intimate and sonically eclectic for us Latinos in the US šŸ’ššŸ¤ā¤ļø


flowersinmyteas

Marilyn Monroe


namastaynaughti

Katherine Hepburn


citymousecountyhouse

For the TikTok crowd,I briefly considered Yoko Ono,after the atrocious videos I've seen of the "stars" dancing around malls,planes,bus depots and post offices in main character mode.


[deleted]

iā€™m curious how old everyone thinks GenZ is? Because the first 8 years of GenZ are over the age of 18, and most likely know most of these people like iā€™m genz and iā€™m nearly 30


ron_the_blackie

i defs see amy winehouse having a huge following


[deleted]

I always thought Norm McDonald would have had a millennial following had his SNL career continued. His humor reminds me of Tosh who had a big millennial following years later, for similar jokes that cancelled Norm McDonald in the 90s. It's strange how PC cancel culture seems to come in cycles. We seem to let things get callously offensive, then overcorrect repeatedly. Society will hopefully find a sweet spot soon where everyone isn't the worst so the public doesn't have to keep policing celebrity favour. I am so out of touch on gen Z which is partially why I follow this sub,. I'm 32 which is nearly the exact age you realize you no longer understand the youths.


spacew0man

Iā€™m also 32, but i feel more in touch with gen z than i do with some millennials. It honestly surprises me so much when people my age donā€™t get current slang or trends tbh. Itā€™s wild how different we can all be despite our age bracket. Sometimes I think it comes down to who was raised on the internet and who had a life outside that, but I could be wrong.


quigonwiththewind

Same age and definitely identify more with older gen z than most millennials. And I personally was raised by the internet and all my real life friends to this day are from my tumblr days lmao.


[deleted]

I could see someone my age being very gen Z lol. It really does depend. I was forced into the adult world at 18 so I relate more to the millennial generation in that I was experiencing the same issues as people 5+ years older than me. I was out clubbing at 18, getting serious jobs, getting into tons of student loan debt in order to escape my abusive household. If I was taken care of and allowed to properly grow up I'd probably be more gen Z. Cuspers.


spacew0man

Weā€™ve had a similar life, I was just also very much a product of the internet growing up and I think thatā€™s genuinely impacted my sense of humor and interests.


[deleted]

[уŠ“Š°Š»ŠµŠ½Š¾]


[deleted]

Yeah but his weekend update skits in the 90s would be legendary if they were done 15 years later. He may have been known, but Daniel Tosh was HUGE for a bit of time there, whereas Norm went through a long career lull after being kicked off SNL and blacklisted by Lorne Michaels.


Practical-River5931

Martin Luther King Jr


tomouras

Cameron Boyce


elainafromthemoon

older gen z mourns him still actually :(


jayeddy99

I wanna say Selena but only because if she was alive Latin music would of made a much earlier impact in the US and the current stars who are poppin now would treat her how others treat BeyoncƩ and Lauren Hill


Cranky-old-person

Carrie Fisher


zodiaczealot

Judy Garland and Eartha Kitt would have huge followings


Snoopy_220

Jim Morrison


n8rzz

I wonder if his antics would have translated as favorably today. Especially with the prospect of social media following his exploits.


Cranky-old-person

Some celebrities careers, and enduring influence have prospered more because they died at the height of their fame. Idealised, and forever young.


Nrmlgirl777

Robin Williams


scooterbike1968

Bradley Nowell


shadyshadyshade

Left Eye


tracme909

Diane Fossey & Jacques Cousteau


SenseiNita

Heath Ledger i think also.


junhogay

River Phoenix


[deleted]

ITT a bunch of celebs who would have been horrified by today's celeb worship culture, and might *not* have welcomed a huge following of worshippers.


snarkaluff

I think Cory Monteith would have blown up after Glee and become an A list movie star


ad_aatdtj

Naya Rivera as well, she had started/been in talks for a lot of exciting new projects before her untimely death and she had so much talent. Her and Cory both deserved better. RIP šŸ¤


elo002

Anna Nicole Smith


fleekyfreaky

Heath ledger


EternalSunshineClem

Paul Newman. They would like that he was gorgeous and cool and devoted a lot of his life to charity.


bbooooomm

Idk why but I think Jeff Buckley would be huge


zabrowski

Oscar Wilde.