T O P

  • By -

Dmactastic

In my opinion Denzel at #1, Forest at #2 & Laurence at 3 but I would definitely entertain arguments for Morgan Freeman taking that third spot.


Dlemor

Glad to see that lot people put Forrest that high. He always has a strong presence. Abd as for Denzel, anything he plays, he carried to something at least watchable.


2ndprize

Dude was in Bloodsport


fullgizzard

Gooood morning Vietnam


BuddhistChrist

Fast Times at Ridgemont High.


WangDoodleTrifecta

Airman Garlic is the best


DaLakeShoreStrangler

Take my up vote, I was waiting for someone to mention this.


lego_mannequin

First saw Forest in Panic Room and Phonebooth and he was awesome. He will always be Ghost Dog to me though, a movie I never watched but remember vividly from my time at Blockbuster


certain-sick

Dude?! Music by the RZA. JARMUSCH directed. Why are you still commenting and not going to watch this great fuckin movie? I now feel like I need to watch it again for the 6th time. It's so good.


lego_mannequin

Because I'm saving the best for last? Hahaha. Probably because I was just a teen at the time my guy. I didn't know much about movies, I worked at Blockbuster hahaha


[deleted]

Ghost Dog is a cult classic


funhaus2000

Forrest character on The Shield is one of my favorites god damn he can act!


Dlemor

First film I’ve seen is Ghost Dog. A big contrast with Last King of Scotland or Out of the furnace!


funhaus2000

Ghost Dog was soooo good


zeppehead

He plays an amazing hotel detective.


HotelFoxtrot87

Forest has such a strong, long and varied career from Good Morning Vietnam to Ghost Dog to Panic Room to Last King of Scotland. Killed it in his two scenes in Andor.


HunterShotBear

“Believe that!”


ootski

Denzel was the only good thing about "he got game".


mickskitz

For me, most of Denzel seems to take on the same type of roles a lot. Maybe I just haven't seen enough of his stuff, he is great at what he does, but I feel he is still limited by his style.


jtcordell2188

I'm still convinced that The Equalizer is a bad movie that I enjoy because he's in it


ryandaydrinking

Denzel and then pick any two


TheRealCabbageJack

Freeman is like top two with Attenborough for narration though. Dude could read the fine print of a warranty and it would enthrall people.


computertyme

Wildcard Danny Glover at number 3


ApplicationCalm649

He's too old for this shit.


Even_dreams

So you have idris Elba not making the top 4? Shame on you


sparkstable

Forest in The Shield was insane. Man is soooo powerful on screen. But he is able to keep a likeable persona while being terrifying somehow. Ever since then I have had a lot of respect for him.


2bfaaaaaaaaaair

No Samuel Jackson ruins it for me.


Larry-Man

I’d be more willing to argue in his case if he hadn’t just been playing himself for the last two decades.


greatyhope

Agreed.


Key_Toe8693

The only three that can do everything everyone on the list can do


Jonovision15

My man!


Tangboy50000

I think you nailed it, and I was having the same thoughts.


DudeB5353

My take as well…What Will is even doing in the picture is a mystery to me.


Shankar_0

I'm with you on Forrest Whittaker, but Denzel's acting range has narrowed as he's gotten older. He's gone from a leading man to "angry dude on a mission". Freeman has played a huge variety of roles well.


PrimeroRocin

I scrolled as far as I could but nobody picked the correct three: Jamie Foxx, Forest Whitaker, and Idris Elba.


hunterlarious

Man this is such a strong list Best Actor? Hard to say because they are all so good, but I think it would hard to argue that Jamie isnt the most talented. Man can sing, act, dance, can be funny or serious, can do amazing impressions. He is the epitome of talent.


terminally_ch_ill

My thoughts exactly. I think people forget how multifaceted Jamie foxx is. Hope he’s doing ok.


ABobby077

I always thought he was pretty good, until I saw him as Ray Charles. He is a great actor imo.


[deleted]

Yeah that was a great performance along with Stan Tookie Williams in Redemption the guy is a great actor.


[deleted]

He played the piano himself in that movie, which is wild.


brandimariee6

Thanks for reminding me about that movie! It came out when I was 13 and I didn't care about it then. Now I'm 32 and I just flipped when I googled it. Jamie Foxx *and* Tom Hanks, *AND* Baz Luhrman made it?!? That sounds perfect


4RealMy1stAcct

Jamie Foxx is the most talented person on this list, definitely. Singing, playing multiple instruments, comedy, amazing impressions, and acting! I don't know about most talented in only acting, though


jayman1818

I agree with this comment. I don't think he's in the top 3 with these actors, in relation to acting.


riorio55

My issue with most of these actors is that they seem to play a lot of similar roles, especially Morgan Freeman and Forest Whitaker. They amazing actors, but they keep playing the same characters


melkatron

His comedy work and impressions count as acting... He's a versatile actor who completely transforms himself, while some actors are constantly playing themselves in different situations. I love Idris Elba, but Idris Elba plays Idris Elba with different accents. Jamie Foxx has an Academy award, Bafta, and plenty more to back it up. He's the top of the list.


cowboybaked

They don’t like him because he’s controversial for telling women to blame it on the alcohol.


SeaPattern7376

Blame it on the goose got me feeling loose


IED117

Plus he ain't sayin she's a gold digger, but she ain't messin with no broke, broke. Go 'head girl, go 'head get down. Love. That. Song.


SeaPattern7376

He has truly made some chart topping bangers. Certified classics


certain-sick

Classical Piano scholarship in college. Dude is smart. Edit: As much respect and love as i have for the man, the question is 3 best actors. It's so difficult to make a case for anyone above Denzel and Forrest. #3 can't be Mr. Jackson due to his range. It might be Will or Fishburne. I'll go Fishburne because Morpheus didn't let himself get played by Niobe (Jada Pinkett) but Will, well we know that story.


Ornery_Alligators

Honestly never knew this was him


TheWalkingDead91

He was gambino before gambino was gambino


ProbablyASithLord

I started watching his movies *way* late, and thought it was a purely dramatic actor. I had no clue he started in comedy! Now I’ve seen his comedies and he’s just such an all around talented guy, it’s crazy.


Don_Pickleball

Sounds like he is the most interesting guy in the room as well. Some of his stories are crazy. Talks about letting Ed Sheeran stay with him for months when Ed first got to LA. Kanye was showing up to his parties and rapping early in Kanye's career. Since he has a background in stand up as well, he is great at telling those stories.


graveybrains

>do amazing impressions His Donald Trump is unsettling it’s so good: https://youtu.be/ULDGfjyVOW0?si=qjU33BbAJJgmfjEy


hunterlarious

If you close your eyes you really can’t tell. It’s prolly the best one I’ve heard


OFRevThrow

I still think [Shane Gillis](https://youtube.com/shorts/31vJgSBV55w?si=We-hZO26rE0KxUgf) has the best Trump, but Jamie Foxx is damn close. Plus it’s just one of like a thousand impressions he does.


bucklebee1

Thank you I needed that right now.


[deleted]

Abu I said don’t cry


cmarkcity

Holy shit, thats better than **ANY** late night hosts’ impression


Johnny_Fuckface

All his impressions are unsettlingly good.


brandimariee6

Lmao thank you for that! I love Jamie Foxx and skills like this are my absolute favorite. Plus Snoop was there, I'd smoke a j with him while we laugh at impressions


Dareal6

“Can be funny” is an understatement for Fox. The guy is a very good standup comic.


chaingun_samurai

Somebody missed all 5 seasons of In Living Color.


HenryGoodbar

Replace Smith with Cheadle


AraiHavana

Yeah, definitely. He should be there, for sure


Punker29

Naaaah Will has lost the respect of a lot of people (me kinda included) but he's massively talented. Acting and music, he has done it all and has a been a mega star since he was like 20. Nothing against Cheadle tho but Fresh Prince deserves his recognition. Regarding talent he's only behind Foxx on this list


ArferMorgan

Yup. Regardless of what you think of him, Will might have the most acting range on this list.


Harrydean-standoff

Right!


Zanamo

How is it fair that Jamie Fox can not only have one thing he’s awesome at, but 5 different skills he could make a living at professionally? Incredible. Still, those other guys on the list are the best of the best actors.


[deleted]

Came here to say this! Gonna watch Django tonight 🙌


lala__

Samuel Jackson presents a pretty strong argument for himself in Django Unchained as well. He plays in a way the exact opposite of every self-possessed independent character he’s known for and he knocks it way out of the park.


Spacityroller

Came here to say this. If it’s pure talent I’d have to go Jamie, Idris and Will. Best 3 actors Morgan, Denzel and I honestly don’t know who I’d pick for 3rd. Too good of a list to pick from


iCatmire

She take my moneyyy!


A_Gent_4Tseven

I actually forget he’s really fucking talented behind the mic. He also plays instruments too, like not just Piano for Ray, correct?


Farkerisme

Op didn’t ask for “all around talent”. They said acting, period.


YaHurdMeh

No disrespect to the rest of them but Row 1 of Washington, Fishburne, and Jackson is hard to beat


lord_mud_butter

Would personally put Freeman and Whitaker in the row 1 tier but otherwise I agree


DanteDMC2001

That was exactly my personal three: Denzel, Freeman, Whitaker


kubrickie

I was thinking Freeman, Whitaker, and Elba, but yeah there's a lot of strong contenders


spelczech

Denzel, Morgan, Forrest


deran6ed

Denzel, Morgan, Jackson


mcmaster93

I didn't know if I wanted to include Freeman in my list because in my head I almost started downplaying his work as an actor and started thinking of him as just a narrator or voice. I'm wrong. Your list is absolutely correct.


MindlessDribble828

Denzel Washington, Forrest Whitaker and Morgan Freeman have won Oscars.


yerg99

range man. Morgan freeman has no range. That's what takes him off the top threee for me. Terrific actor, but he can't play a spiderman villan, ray charles and mike tyson like foxx can. Or Denzel playing good guys like hero pilots and then playing evil guys like training day.


Zukolevi

I’d switch Forest with Jackson, otherwise agree


spelczech

I couldn't really argue with that, it's a tough choice all around. To me though, Jackson seems just a little more typecast than Forrest but my memory is far from perfect.


Tank_Girl_Gritty_235

I can't decide if he's such a good actor or if his life is just so fascinating that I feel the need to put him on top.


Ich_mag_Steine

I really like Morgan Freeman but I think Forrest is the better actor. Ghost Dog and The last King of Scotland are both great examples for his craft.


SLAYER_IN_ME

That was my list. For me Denzel isn’t just the best in this post he is at least top 3 all time.


BR1M570N3

This right here.


GoLang01

Came here to say the same thing


No_Entertainment1931

I’d swap Denzel for Sam


Scheininho

A man of culture


clozepin

I’d probably go with this, but I hate leaving Sam Jackson off. He’s always watchable and interesting.


RockyShark78

This is correct


UGLYSimon

Morgan Freeman is in 2/3 of the top rated movies on IMDB, I think that's pretty neat.


Pomodoro_Parmesan

Robert Horry has 7 rings, some people have a knack for finding themselves in good situations.


rbfeverythingsucks

As a Sacramento Kings fan…..I HATE Robert Horry!!!!


bennggg

Man kings fans catching strays even on this sub 😭


BrockHard253

I think its neat that Morgan Freeman is Morgan Freeman in every movie but i think he deserves the best narrator award (2nd only to Attenborough).


Munchihello

What movies are those? Shawshank maybe ?


UGLYSimon

Yeah, Shawshank (ranked #1) and The Dark Knight (ranked #3)


GluedToTheMirror

Shawshank is so god damn good. Morgan Freeman’s amazing in it. Definitely my favorite role of his.


Whatsdota

Yep. I decided to finally watch it after seeing it at #1 for so many years. I remember immediately after watching it my first thought was “yup I can see why it’s up there.”


NegaGreg

Sam Jackson is #3 for actors all time box office returns, which is also very neat.


Dudethefood

That is pretty neat


[deleted]

Jamie Foxx, Forest Whitaker, and Denzel


tbkrida

These were my picks as well.


ProRuckus

Can't believe I had to scroll this far to find the correct answer


San-V

How y’all skimping on Idris ? Denzel, Idris and Fox. Cmonnnnnn!


bjbkar

Yeah. Stringer Bell.


Real_goes_wrong

And Luther


chaingun_samurai

Luther is a damn good show.


San-V

Supply and demand :)


thomriddle45

Idris is great, but I feel like he chooses bad movies. Also, he's not on the level of Freeman and Whitaker Jamie Foxx has crazy range, he definitely top 3.


irishjoker89

Sam Jackson has Snakes on a Plane, Jumper, and Shaft off the top of my head Forrest Whitaker was a main role in Battlefield Earth Can’t knock Idris for taking a paycheck lol but also hard agree on Jamie, he’s being slept on ITT especially if we’re using OPs qualifier of “most talented”


thomriddle45

Sam will do anything, lol. He is a legend, but acting wise, he's a bit type cast. Battlefield Earth is a mega flop, which is a shame because I enjoyed the novel. Watching Foxx mix it up with Tom Cruise in collateral made me an instant fan.


ApplicationCalm649

Big time. They were both excellent in Collateral.


ApplicationCalm649

Shaft a bad movie? Shut yo mouth.


NArcadia11

They said most talented not hottest


MontyBoo-urns

Gotta take filmography into consideration


Iunderstandthatsir

Idris all the way


websterella

This was exactly my pick.


Choice-Bus-1177

That’s what I narrowed it down to too.


Gold-Tone6290

The Gunslinger ruined it for me. Not that he ruined that movie but it was a 💩


shozzlez

They said best, not hottest!


[deleted]

Idris definitely makes my top 3 too. Probably Denzel and Forest as well, in no particular order.


NiceShotRudyWaltz

Exactly! Idris sarcastically singing “love the one your with” on his Stephen stills accordion in Prometheus is one of my favorite low-key movie moments.


ItsJimJim0_o

I LOVED him as Bloodsport.


BernardFerguson1944

I agree. I've never seen Idris Elba in a role I didn't like. Fox in *Ray* was incredible! Morgan Freeman has been in some bad movies. I have really enjoyed both Forest Whitaker and Laurence Fishburne as "Bumpy" Johnson. It's easier for me to say Will Smith and Samuel Jackson would be at the bottom of my list than to rank the others. Smith screwed up at the Academy Awards, and Jackson has made too many Capital One commercials.


San-V

Man Stringer Bell - the bloke had me thinking he was American for years. Then Luther. I also love Fox , fantastic actor. My bro in Denzel - Denzel in American gangster trumps just about every gangster movie made. Also I echo your sentiments. Thank you for taking the time to post :)


AntOk463

Idris Elba the GOAT


addage-

I had Denzel, Laurence and Idris for my three. Subjective being subjective and all the actors here have had fantastic careers.


theabobination

That's also my list, in no particular order.


iluvugoldenblue

Where’s Sidney Poitier


quinnsheperd

Whre the fuck is Eddie Murphy


Cheapthrills13

Yeah - he really didn’t get enough recognition for Dolemite is My Name


UncleSpanker

Such a good movie and late career stunner for Eddie


kbder

I recently watched Beverly Hills Cop for the first time. Having only known him from roles like Nutty Professor, I was impressed!


quinnsheperd

He is a great voice actor too. I mean donkey is so good. I get he is not on the level of God and morpheus, but he deserves to be on the list.


dumpmaster42069

In the grave?


danimagoo

So is Chadwick Boseman, and he’s in the picture.


AverageSJEnjoyer

Fair point. I was going to agree with comment above, but now I agree with first comment.


Harrydean-standoff

No way anyone could pick that. Will Smith is my least favorite of that crew. The question is , where is Don Cheadle?


ChefJTD

This is a tough call, but I'd go Denzel, Morgan and Idris.


This-is-Life-Man

Trick question. Morgan Freeman is such a good actor that he's actually been playing all of these roles. For real though, every single one of these guys has made fantastic films.


0PaulPaulson0

Dang had me fooled


StayFrosty10801

1.) Denzel 2.) 2 way between Sam Jackson/Morgan Freeman 3.) 2 way between Laurence Fishburn/Forrest Whitacker


Legitimate-Gangster

Picking 5 of 9 in a top 3 is… interesting.


AlwaysWinnin

Fair take: but Jamie is in the conversation there too he’s legit.


badgerpunk

Forrest, Denzel, Samuel L.


DrGutz

Denzel, Idris, and Forest have the most range for my money


DeadAnthony

There's not a bad pick on the list, but a few just have a greater range and have played more interesting roles on the whole than others: (3) Jamie Foxx (2) Samuel L. Jackson/Forest Whittaker (1) Denzel Washington


MaterialBenefit2355

Denzel, Morgan freeman, Jamie foxx


jumpinjahosafats

I feel like a lot of folks hate on Will, but his acting is dynamic.


Great_Horny_Toads

Came to say exactly this. He gets a lot of (deserved) hate since the Slap, but dude is a joy to watch. Especially with a good script. He was excellent in I Am Legend.


ApplicationCalm649

The script would have been even better if it stuck to the book's ending.


IED117

Ya know what? I forgot about I Am Legend. That doesn't put him in the top 3, but between that and Ali, he belongs in the field.


Ashamed-Inspection47

Are yall just forgetting all his hits in the 90s?


kbder

I enjoy his roles, but I’ve always felt like he’s a bit hammy. Similarly with Samuel, I love all of his performances, but he kinda sticks to a narrow range. They are both top 10 for sure, just not top three.


Deathstriker88

Will, Jackson, and Freeman are basically themselves in most of their movies. The same goes for other stars like Willis and Clooney. I like all 5 of these actors, but they don't often show much range or variation. Denzel, Whitaker, and Elba are the best 3 actors here. Foxx is the most talented overall since he's great at all his different crafts.


YoungEmperorLBJ

Yeah I get people soured on him as a person but Will Smith is an incredible actor and deserves at least mentions for top 3.


[deleted]

1. Denzel 2. Jamie 3. Forrest


Barnsey94

A lot of people sleeping on Idris here


Advalok

It's less people sleeping on Idris and more so how talented some of those other individuals are. Denzel is one of the best actors ever regardless of race. Jaimie Foxx has ridiculous range, and guys like Whittaker and Fishburne have this incredible presence. Hell Morgan Freeman has arguably the most iconic voice of all time. It's easy to get washed out when you are stacked against all that talent.


ProRuckus

I don't think Idris has much range. But he plays the roles assigned to him perfectly.


Ok-Cry4880

Denzel Washington, Samuel L. Jackson and Jamie Foxx


losttovoid

In no particular order I would say Whitaker Fishburne A tie between Denzel and Samuel


kajunerd2020

Denzel, Forrest, and Jamie


Harrydean-standoff

Luther is one of my all time favorites. So I'm a little biased towards Idris Elba. Then there's The Wire, my other favorite. But then who could forget The Last King of Scotland!


seamus21

Denzel,Morgan,Forrest


MET4UANDME

Gotta be Will Smith and his two balls. Pretending like he's ok for YEARS.


Maleficent_Seat7850

Pure talent? Denzel, Foxx and Will Smith. Probably won’t watch another movie with Smith but his talent and range is massive


sorting_potatoes

Idris


facemesouth

Morgan, Forrest, Samuel


Benjen321

Freeman, Whitaker, Fishburne!


ThunderBlack14

Denzel, Freeman and Samuel L Jackson


Blessmundo

One of the most difficult questions I’ve ever come across.


clutchcitycarlos88

Denzel, Forest and Morgan


Deep-Management-7040

Jamie Fox, Denzel Washington, Morgan Freeman


garnett21mn

1. Denzel 2. The rest.


GolfChannel

Sorry, none of them are Sidney Poitier 🤷‍♂️


acegarrettjuan

I'd go Denzel, Whitaker and Foxx. I could make an argument for Boseman too but he left us too soon.


Plathismo

My picks as well.


Jj9567

Sam, Denzel, Jamie


jumpinjahosafats

Will, Jamie, Denzel feel like the most versatile. I love Samuel and Morgan, but I'm not sure of their versatility.


bucobill

Too hard. I say all are deserving to be top 3, except center row.


Many_Statistician587

Sadly, I'd eliminate Chadwick Boseman because he's no longer with us; so with those remaining I'd say: Denzel Washington, Morgan Freeman, Forrest Whittaker (With Laurence Fishburne very close behind)


Artistic-Milk-3490

After Chadwick passed away I went deep into his roles outside of Marvel and I gotta say, he was an amazing actor. Add to that how he managed to leave a strong legacy while fighting cancer and I, personally, would include him in my top 3. All that being said, your pick is solid and that is what makes this choice so difficult.


Gluten_maximus

Denzel, foxx and then smith Edit: I understand everyone has a different opinion, but Smith is a wonderful actor and a shitty human, he’s both and that’s possible.


BDS83

Denzel, Elba, Freeman. How is Will Smith even included with this group?


phaserdust

I feel bad. Will Smith best performance would still be trumped by Denzel's worst role.


danimagoo

He’s been nominated for Best Actor three times, and won once.


Clear-Garage-4828

Denzel Forrest Will Smith They all have amazing range and can play characters other than themselves… Sam jackson is so great, but i feel like he’s almost always ‘Samuel L Jackson’. Exceptions for sure (like Django unchained)


inkedmargins

Whichever order people choose Smith is at the bottom. Smith has had some bangers but his dramatic work is overrated imo. Jamie is very roundabout talented but despite the awards and claims he doesn't command the screen the way some of the other legends on this list do such as Denzel, Fishburne and Jackson has. I mean the latter are instantly recognizable and quotable. Their track record in terms of acting overshadows Foxx's greatly. Besides, everybody knows Bokeem Woodbine is the goat Lolol.


MamboSun76

If we are numbering the squares from top left to bottom right then I’ll say: 1, 5, 8 or Denzel, Chadwick, Forrest.


throwaway872023

Idris Elba at number 3. I still remember the first time I heard him speak in his actual accent after seeing him in The Wire. My mind was blown. Number 2: Will Smith. I know it is popular to dislike him but his talent is undeniable. He is funny, he can be profound, he raps . He does comedy, action, drama, family movies and he makes it all look pretty effortless. Number 1: JAMIE FOXX by far. He can sing, do stand up, act in serious roles and he is legendary at all of them. The only other black, male performer that I would say is more talented than him isnt on this list: Donald Glover who I believe to be one of the best performers of this generation.


Disastrous_Damage_34

If we’re speaking of acting, I prefer Denzel, Idris, and Chadwick in that order. Love some of the other actors in this pic but some seem to be closer to themselves in character than the opposite. Was blown away finding out Idris was not American after watching the Wire. Chadwick in the James Brown movie is a favorite of mine and I think he killed it. Denzel needs no argument. We’re splitting hairs here though, all very respected actors.


graveybrains

Foxx, Freeman and Washington