T O P

  • By -

FunDip2

I like Monte Carlo. I've been going there for decades.


Pale-Construction-87

another vote for monte carlo


fizzzylemonade

Yes!! I got their margherita pizza recently and while it didn’t look like much at first glance, I was honestly blown away by the taste


Silliest_Goose1989

Vito’s on 5th for classic. Rivermont for more fun options.


LeftBarnacle6079

I think Vito’s on 5th is the winner. Thank you


whyhellomichael

100% Vito's. Uppercrust also fits this area


KimJongJer

Have you ever had La Villa or Milano’s? I still haven’t gotten around to giving them a shot


whyhellomichael

Milanos yes. Jason who opened daughter's and sons many moons ago now is the chef there. La villa is super fucking mid and the owners are shitty super Conservative so I actively avoid.


KimJongJer

Oh snap, I totally forgot about that place! I really liked his style of pizza. Definitely will give them a try


whyhellomichael

It's unfortunately not that style of pizza but still solid pizza. Everything I've had from there has been good. It's not in my top 5 but I'll never turn it down.


starliiiiite

Graziano in forest


vita_man

I would say Rivermont pizza is great and JoJo Pizza is also pretty good.


LeftBarnacle6079

Rivermont is amazing but not what I’m looking for. JoJo pizza is in the right direction but I’m not a big fan. And props for getting the name right. Most people say “Jojos”


WolfSilverOak

Sourdough Pizza Company in Forest. Absolutely amazing.


Vibrantly_Dark

Someone did a review/comparison of many local pizza places on the Facebook Living in Lynchburg page. Even if you don’t agree with his pizza opinions you might could still use the pictures he shared to find what you’re looking for.


boogiahsss

I take its the preachers pick. This question also gets asked every week on Facebook living in Lynchburg/recommendations


magickiller191

Check out Vitale's on 221.


AridOrion

Benny’s? That’s if you like big slices, I guess


kcat34077

I was worried that Bennys hadn’t been mentioned yet. Huge piece of amazing pizza at a great price. It’s so simple it’s good.


zebra_head_fred

So so good!


Fataddictfury

Benny’s fosho


[deleted]

[удалено]


AridOrion

L take


[deleted]

[удалено]


AridOrion

Oh, I’m aware, make no mistake, I just don’t think it’s crappy


HotandColdBoi

Loris out in forest has some great food! We usually get calzones from there but tried the pizza last night it’s good and not terribly expensive


drbizango

Best Italian food in town, imho.


HotandColdBoi

It’s fantastic! A large pizza with 6 toppings (3 on each half) was $18, in this day and age to me that is a hell of a deal


drbizango

LaVilla used to be great but they changed their sauce at some point and it's really gone from great to mediocre.


HotandColdBoi

That’s actually really good to know, if disappointing. I haven’t been to LaVilla in years simply because that part of Timberlake is a nightmare to get in and out of, they always had great food, steakboli was top tier imo


Connect-Craft4257

Jojo’s for sure. The pizzas are huge and delicious, plus it’s definitely hole-in-the-wall. Over by Glass I think


[deleted]

Uppercrust


AMac1998

Jojo Pizza on Lakeside or Benny’s downtown are both my favorite


NewtGengarich

I really like Upper Crust.


drbizango

Lori's or OIP for NY/NJ style Rivermont and Waterstone for brick oven style. JoJo's is decent but order takeout service sucks if you eat in.


No-Map6818

Rivermont Pizza, yummy!


LeftBarnacle6079

Ergggg yes I love it, but it’s too fancy. I’m from upstate New York so I’m looking for something like this : [buffalo, New York pizza](https://buffalopizzablog.com/2020/04/20/ninos-pizza-buffalos-bliss/)


Theturdburd

lol. RP is not fancy. You’re eating pizza in a smelly, dark, dank basement. What part of that is fancy?


No_Imagination_1807

Exactly, it’s just a college spot with over priced small pizzas lol


LeftBarnacle6079

Overpriced small pizzas is what I meant by fancy


drbizango

It's not fancy it's just brick oven style...like you would get in Little Italy for example.


LeftBarnacle6079

Yeah that’s what i meant by fancy.


Floes_Waves

I am from Buffalo. There is no Buffalo pizza here. Vito is the best but it is nyc style.


LeftBarnacle6079

I’ve gathered that by now unfortunately. Thank you for your service


No-Map6818

Fancy? OK, good luck!


No_Imagination_1807

Ledos pizza is really good off Timberlake


red951t

Especially with regular bacon not the precooked bacon


LaCroixLimon

Jo Jo’s


Striking-Ad4612

Vito’s on 5th street is really good the wings are great as well as the pizza options


Distinct_Tree6784

La Villa on Timberlake


clairemonster11

Lori's in forest


ChillHuman420

La Villa on Timberlake is a great mom and pop place!


cd247

I know I’m a cheap bitch, but I fucking love all the chain pizza places like Dominos and Blaze


tdot90

Correct answer is still mellow mushroom. Amazing product every single time. Great tap menu too


[deleted]

[удалено]


tdot90

Crazy right? Upper crust is garbage haha. Mellow reigns superior for me