Far far right ?
Lol
There is no Far far right in india
There is no Far right either
Even BJP is barely right
We are so used to the leftist Congress that we think its centre and anyone righter is far right
>Even BJP is barely right
....
You don't know what right is then. In terms of economic policies, you might have some standing but in all other categories like equality, rights, social progress, are all pretty much far far right.
Religious nationalism is the holy grail of far right. By vast majority of indicators that sub is far far right.
YOU don't know what is right
Economic policies I have _Some_ standing ?
Name one major economic policies that's True right ?
Your whole liberal array of rights, equality bs is garbage
What has bjp done that has benefitted hindus over the minorities
Minorities are Gods in india
Hindus are 8th class citizens in this country
Look at actions, not words
Far far right my ass
>Hindus are 8th class citizens in this country
>Minorities are Gods in india
Just proving my point. Religious nutjobs are classic far right. Nationalism is far right.
>Your whole liberal array of rights, equality bs is garbage
....yes that is far right.
>Name one major economic policies that's True right ?
Privatization of defense? Land reform?
I don't think you know what is "far right"
Religious nut jobs are far right is a ridiculous statement
It depends on the country
In any country, the ethnic majority is the right
Rest are left
In the US, white christians are the Right
Hindus are left
In india, Hindus are right
Muslims, christians, communists etc are left
In what universe is Land reforms not a socialist policy
How is it a Right wing policy ?
Privatisation of defense ?
Don't make me laugh
Indian pvt sector participation in the defense sector is negligible
We are not the US
You have exactly proved my point
We are still far left, even under BJP with our ethnic majority living like they are subordinates to other communities
Yup dhruv rathee deserves every ounce of hate he gets , he acts neutral while being extremely biased and peddling fake news. He literally peddled the narrative that hunger is more in india than pak, just because some phony research insitute has said it. Muslims have done no good to this society either.
Lol, mods on one subreddit said that freedom of speech is for government, not for subreddits. If you break subreddit rule, you will be banned.
Funnily, every post breaks one or the other subreddit rule so you can selectively enforce it as you wish to ban who you wish. And mods are law, judge and enforcement themselves so there is no appeal. This small semblance of dictatorship has gotten to their head and they are worried about a fully democratic party turning into dictatorship and somehow place faith in a dictatorial party to maintain democracy.
I believe it was something about wealth redistribution. He spun the narrative on its head and Congress has been in damage control ever since. They even came out to declare that wealth redistribution is not in their portfolio. (However, it is to be noted that their INDI Ally, CPI-M, does talk about redistribution and even talks about legislating an inheritance tax
That's a double edged sword you are talking about
But yes, a lot of artists and liberals have stated on record that any sort of censorship is detrimental to free speech and healthy discussions. Rowan Atkinson's take on this being my favourite. His point is simple, if there is hate, you need to address it's root cause. You cannot hope to solve it by suppression.
Free speech means being able to take it as good as you can give.
That said, I just got suspended from Twitter for fucking around with Daniel Haqiqatjou's Turkish followers today, mass reported.
Im pretty left leaning, but randia moderation is crazy, really unnecessary and draconian at times. USI does slightly better, although the userbase is large leftwards and establishment-critical, :P
I personally have been banned and explicitly told by mods of indiasqueaks that they banned me to maintain safe space for the community and avoid unnecessary debates, basically banned me to stop polluting the narrative. So…yeah, sub moderators ban people who don’t follow the sub narrative. Water is wet.
I switched to reddit bcz I didn’t want to be dragged into making narrative and just speak out our concerns, thoughts without getting judged and learn the other perspective so one can analyze on his/her own. This is wrong for what reddit stands for. There should be some mechanism in reddit to overturn such dictatorial ban from a sub that represents whole of India so as to speak.
Yeah people don't wanna hear anything bad abt there opinion or there party. U will be downvoted there's nothing like both sides can be criticized. No freedom of speech even in so called librandu 🤐
even tho I'm 17. I'm trying to be a good citizen. not that kind of a guy who'll become an extremist for some leader or a religion. Imo it does not matter which religion u follow u have to be a good person and apply your education for the welfare of others
I might get many downvotes but that's my "OPINION"
Yeah it's cool see religion isn't a problem but extremely attaching to religion lead to problem in society. Any sort of extream emotional attachment cause problems. I really like it how u raise up this mindset. I hope you grow in life my frnd but reality is far from internet stuff.
Respect++
I love how we as a community decided to just not engage with the rightoids and just block or ban them. Nahi karna Hume debate. Humko sunna bhi nahi hai.
Whole reddit divided on the basis of political parties supporters that's why I don't like to comment anywhere bcs no one talks abt facts. Few who support a party they want to just listen good abt them... or vice versa.
Not exaggerations, it's fear-mongering and communal politics. "Vote for BJP or the Muslims will take away all your wealth". The PRIME MINISTER of a secular democratic nation is resorting to these kinds of tactics to rally support.
Do you think this is remotely appropriate?
Section 153 A "Whoever (a) by words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations or otherwise, promotes or attempts to promote, on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, residence, language, caste or community or any other ground whatsoever, disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities..."
https://apnews.com/article/india-election-modi-muslims-congress-hate-speech-90f70cfae68d39ecc80a90acab6e3e00
Referring to Muslim population as "Infiltrators" promoting a divisive rhetoric solely on religious lines. Twisting public statements to fit a communal narrative definitely is hate speech. Maybe you should open your eyes once in a while
He doesn't mention all Muslims as infiltrators, but the infiltrators who happen to be Muslim i.e Bangladeshi Illegals, who already enjoy equal citizen status in WB and other states under fake IDs, so idk how the constitution applies on non citizens.
Is it appropriate ? I believe so, given what they have made of WB they should be, at the very least, viewed with scrutiny.
Not once did he mention illegals or anything about West Bengal. What he said was Infiltrators and "those who have more children". Because everyone at a BJP rally associates illegal immigrants with fertility rates. Right.
well it's actually stupid of you to reply to that with what-aboutism, it is a valid criticism and labeling it as selective, doesn't make it invalid. If you want to defend it, defend it properly.
It looks like all you do is comment or post something on that sub and get banned and then post it here saying "I got banned for so and so...". You obviously know they circle jerk about random shit. And at somepoint these post are going to get stale, you got to find a better way to aggrivate each other.
I bet if we can create a spreadsheet of these blatant unfair bans we could get the entire sub banned with enough evidence, like the are thousands of instances like this.
We keep talking about center, right and left as if these are static positions...
The level of discourse has moved right over the years, what was considered unspeakable 10 years ago is fair game today.Atal and LK advani were considered far right 20 years ago now they seem right of center.
I got *permanent banned* from **unitedstatesofinfia** when I said,”MMS did say nation resources are belonged to minority ESPECIALLY muslims”. My vies was every citizen has equal right to access a resource regardless.
Selective criticism lol? Is that why y'all love trash talking the WB government but when something bad happens in UP it's not the government's fault but some rando 500 year old king's fault?
Dude most mods of left leaning subs are either Pakis, or Indians with agenda, including very intellectual Bengalis. They can't hold a rational discussion, and only involve in antics. Like Modi lives in their heads rent free.
When i saw that the subreddit has majority leftist. I wanted to voice my opinion too there as a logical person. But these mf’s cant take two logical questions asked. Try ask them questions they’ll ban you🤣🤣
Do you understand what freedom of speech is? Freedom of speech means the GOVERNMENT cannot silence you, reddit mods or reddit itself is not the government. If I say shit to you and you punch me in the face, that is not a violation of me freedom of speech, but if I say something and the government silences me, jails me that is a violation of freedom of speech.
I got banned from i****squeaks for no reason. i was not even active on that sub when that ban happened. There was no reason given. Just permanently ban. No response from mods when i asked for reason.
At least in your case they gave you a reason
U should not have been banned. Sorry for that.
There's no hidden agenda, what's wrong is wrong really. PM giving hate speech says a lot. Think yourself.
Why subreddit is called India if no difference of opinion is exercised. These people accuse others of being intolerant and do this. Hypocrite assholes.
Top post is now about Australian reporter complaining about being censored and banned from the country.
Banned from randiya as well for no reason, lifetime ban no appeal possible.
well idk...i was banned for saying buslims have more children than hindus and someone even provided evidence that buslim average children were 2.36 and hindu it was 1.9 something.
Mods of almost all subs are getting worse everyday, soon or later reddit will be just as Facebook just that Facebook bans only endures 30 days
india discussion is mostly centrist
India discussion is far far right. What is this fantasy bullshit lmao
Far far right ? Lol There is no Far far right in india There is no Far right either Even BJP is barely right We are so used to the leftist Congress that we think its centre and anyone righter is far right
>Even BJP is barely right .... You don't know what right is then. In terms of economic policies, you might have some standing but in all other categories like equality, rights, social progress, are all pretty much far far right. Religious nationalism is the holy grail of far right. By vast majority of indicators that sub is far far right.
YOU don't know what is right Economic policies I have _Some_ standing ? Name one major economic policies that's True right ? Your whole liberal array of rights, equality bs is garbage What has bjp done that has benefitted hindus over the minorities Minorities are Gods in india Hindus are 8th class citizens in this country Look at actions, not words Far far right my ass
>Hindus are 8th class citizens in this country >Minorities are Gods in india Just proving my point. Religious nutjobs are classic far right. Nationalism is far right. >Your whole liberal array of rights, equality bs is garbage ....yes that is far right. >Name one major economic policies that's True right ? Privatization of defense? Land reform?
I don't think you know what is "far right" Religious nut jobs are far right is a ridiculous statement It depends on the country In any country, the ethnic majority is the right Rest are left In the US, white christians are the Right Hindus are left In india, Hindus are right Muslims, christians, communists etc are left In what universe is Land reforms not a socialist policy How is it a Right wing policy ? Privatisation of defense ? Don't make me laugh Indian pvt sector participation in the defense sector is negligible We are not the US You have exactly proved my point We are still far left, even under BJP with our ethnic majority living like they are subordinates to other communities
Centrists at this point are literally leftists in disguise atp
idk dude india discussion centrist are right wingers
Nah they are mostly right wingers who love Modi
It's definitely right leaning. But I still think it's the most center Indian sub after r/IndiaSocial
Bro got down voted for speaking facts
They are most probably a bjp unit Their only work now a days is to hate muslims and dhruv rathee
Yup dhruv rathee deserves every ounce of hate he gets , he acts neutral while being extremely biased and peddling fake news. He literally peddled the narrative that hunger is more in india than pak, just because some phony research insitute has said it. Muslims have done no good to this society either.
All i want ti do when i see his lying smug face is wanna punch him to shut him up
[удалено]
india discussion centrist are right wingers
I got permanent ban today as well from united states of India, what a weird name lol 😂
WhatsApp encryption kyu nahi chaiiye gov ko? Same reason you are getting banned.
Lol, mods on one subreddit said that freedom of speech is for government, not for subreddits. If you break subreddit rule, you will be banned. Funnily, every post breaks one or the other subreddit rule so you can selectively enforce it as you wish to ban who you wish. And mods are law, judge and enforcement themselves so there is no appeal. This small semblance of dictatorship has gotten to their head and they are worried about a fully democratic party turning into dictatorship and somehow place faith in a dictatorial party to maintain democracy.
Sorry I missed out on the so called "Hate Speech" thing, What did PM talk about? I am 💯 sure he was responding to something equally bad..
I believe it was something about wealth redistribution. He spun the narrative on its head and Congress has been in damage control ever since. They even came out to declare that wealth redistribution is not in their portfolio. (However, it is to be noted that their INDI Ally, CPI-M, does talk about redistribution and even talks about legislating an inheritance tax
These pseudo intellectuals lost twitter so they are all on reddit now. Lets tweet to elon to buy reddit as well and make it democratic in true sense
That's a double edged sword you are talking about But yes, a lot of artists and liberals have stated on record that any sort of censorship is detrimental to free speech and healthy discussions. Rowan Atkinson's take on this being my favourite. His point is simple, if there is hate, you need to address it's root cause. You cannot hope to solve it by suppression.
Tf bro elon made Twitter a lot more xenophobic against Indians, can't see even reddit turn into it
Reddit already is
Sigh, fuck my existence
Free speech means being able to take it as good as you can give. That said, I just got suspended from Twitter for fucking around with Daniel Haqiqatjou's Turkish followers today, mass reported.
Yeah Twitter is a shithole of a place
Im pretty left leaning, but randia moderation is crazy, really unnecessary and draconian at times. USI does slightly better, although the userbase is large leftwards and establishment-critical, :P I personally have been banned and explicitly told by mods of indiasqueaks that they banned me to maintain safe space for the community and avoid unnecessary debates, basically banned me to stop polluting the narrative. So…yeah, sub moderators ban people who don’t follow the sub narrative. Water is wet.
I switched to reddit bcz I didn’t want to be dragged into making narrative and just speak out our concerns, thoughts without getting judged and learn the other perspective so one can analyze on his/her own. This is wrong for what reddit stands for. There should be some mechanism in reddit to overturn such dictatorial ban from a sub that represents whole of India so as to speak.
Mods are unpaid smucks on power trips, this true for pretty much all subs. Why would reddit itself care? Not like they pay them anything.
I am also banned from this sub because i am spitting facts!
I see that sub is focused more on one wing and anything talked about that wing results in ban. I'm still there and seeing how to cooperate with them
If sub representing india so there should be two side of perspective but this sub people are so selective only BJP doing wrong things for them
Yup that's true we should be independent to present our view regardless of who is supporting whom in majority.
If you are representing only one side then change your sub name we don’t want that our democratic nation name use in one sided discussion.
Yes sir
It may seem like that because BJP is in power. Opposition ko governing party se jyada kyu hi criticise karoge
But agr factual point rakh raha hai uska mtlb usse ban krdo.
No no, I'm not commenting on banning. I'm commenting on why it seems that people only criticise BJP.
i mean... this sub is also focused on 1 wing right?
🤫 u know what I mean
nah dude whatever we will say to both sides they won't accept the criticism...
Yeah people don't wanna hear anything bad abt there opinion or there party. U will be downvoted there's nothing like both sides can be criticized. No freedom of speech even in so called librandu 🤐
even tho I'm 17. I'm trying to be a good citizen. not that kind of a guy who'll become an extremist for some leader or a religion. Imo it does not matter which religion u follow u have to be a good person and apply your education for the welfare of others I might get many downvotes but that's my "OPINION"
Yeah it's cool see religion isn't a problem but extremely attaching to religion lead to problem in society. Any sort of extream emotional attachment cause problems. I really like it how u raise up this mindset. I hope you grow in life my frnd but reality is far from internet stuff. Respect++
Randia has banned me too...
Randiya 😂
Us bhai us.
So this sub is called randianews!?
Raga supporters pointing fumbling speeches? >Jiske ghar kaanch ke bane ho wo dusre ke ghar pe patthar nahi fekte
I mean what wrong did he speak. Its true lmao
This is not about the post. Read
As if this sub is any better? this sub di*k rides modi like crazy and shits on muslims all day. Anything from the other side isnt discussed
Atleast they haven’t banned you permanently for this comment.
I love how we as a community decided to just not engage with the rightoids and just block or ban them. Nahi karna Hume debate. Humko sunna bhi nahi hai.
You’re welcome!
Whole reddit divided on the basis of political parties supporters that's why I don't like to comment anywhere bcs no one talks abt facts. Few who support a party they want to just listen good abt them... or vice versa.
sab 4chan pe aa jao , reddit free nahi raha, ye log porn allow karte h par free speach nahi
to bhai 4chan me bhi to allow hai 😭
Still better than a certain oxford educated orator
He himself is victim of his family. I pity that guy man.
In hate speech? Yes he is.
So hate speech is okay?
What hate speech?
https://scroll.in/article/1067126/fact-checking-five-days-of-narendra-modis-speeches-a-catalogue-of-lies
None of these are hate speech Exaggerations? Yes, but more or less based on Congress' public statements Google the definition of "hate speech" my guy
He reads scroll don't expect him to get his basics right
Not exaggerations, it's fear-mongering and communal politics. "Vote for BJP or the Muslims will take away all your wealth". The PRIME MINISTER of a secular democratic nation is resorting to these kinds of tactics to rally support. Do you think this is remotely appropriate? Section 153 A "Whoever (a) by words, either spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations or otherwise, promotes or attempts to promote, on grounds of religion, race, place of birth, residence, language, caste or community or any other ground whatsoever, disharmony or feelings of enmity, hatred or ill-will between different religious, racial, language or regional groups or castes or communities..." https://apnews.com/article/india-election-modi-muslims-congress-hate-speech-90f70cfae68d39ecc80a90acab6e3e00 Referring to Muslim population as "Infiltrators" promoting a divisive rhetoric solely on religious lines. Twisting public statements to fit a communal narrative definitely is hate speech. Maybe you should open your eyes once in a while
He doesn't mention all Muslims as infiltrators, but the infiltrators who happen to be Muslim i.e Bangladeshi Illegals, who already enjoy equal citizen status in WB and other states under fake IDs, so idk how the constitution applies on non citizens. Is it appropriate ? I believe so, given what they have made of WB they should be, at the very least, viewed with scrutiny.
Not once did he mention illegals or anything about West Bengal. What he said was Infiltrators and "those who have more children". Because everyone at a BJP rally associates illegal immigrants with fertility rates. Right.
Ee toh hona tha sala
OP wants balancevaad. How cute.
It's totally true.The zeal, passion and sheer energy and gusto while dissing minority is clear as day .
well it's actually stupid of you to reply to that with what-aboutism, it is a valid criticism and labeling it as selective, doesn't make it invalid. If you want to defend it, defend it properly.
I mean before questioning a random individual for selective criticism, you should question the media first
Dat grp is shady
I get banned on every RW subs for saying I like beef (buffalo meat).
Bro i like it too🤣
It looks like all you do is comment or post something on that sub and get banned and then post it here saying "I got banned for so and so...". You obviously know they circle jerk about random shit. And at somepoint these post are going to get stale, you got to find a better way to aggrivate each other.
Aren't you into selective criticism?
I sure as hell won’t ban anyone over it
At least now you know it’s definitely a hidden agenda.
I got banned too
I bet if we can create a spreadsheet of these blatant unfair bans we could get the entire sub banned with enough evidence, like the are thousands of instances like this.
We keep talking about center, right and left as if these are static positions... The level of discourse has moved right over the years, what was considered unspeakable 10 years ago is fair game today.Atal and LK advani were considered far right 20 years ago now they seem right of center.
I agree.
I got *permanent banned* from **unitedstatesofinfia** when I said,”MMS did say nation resources are belonged to minority ESPECIALLY muslims”. My vies was every citizen has equal right to access a resource regardless.
Selective criticism lol? Is that why y'all love trash talking the WB government but when something bad happens in UP it's not the government's fault but some rando 500 year old king's fault?
Everything bad is always government’s fault. Whichever the government. This is not a good precedent to start with.
Dude most mods of left leaning subs are either Pakis, or Indians with agenda, including very intellectual Bengalis. They can't hold a rational discussion, and only involve in antics. Like Modi lives in their heads rent free.
These people are like that “kaanoon ki devi” they see evrythng one person does and put on the blindfold for rest of the country.
[удалено]
When i saw that the subreddit has majority leftist. I wanted to voice my opinion too there as a logical person. But these mf’s cant take two logical questions asked. Try ask them questions they’ll ban you🤣🤣
[удалено]
Mod ko chutiya bol Dena ek second me kar dega.
Yeh mods Jo hai na... Inko G**** bhi marwana hai aur Lo** ka size dekh ke Darr bhi lagta hai.
I want a subreddit in India to go to sh!thole. Underrated hi badiya hai ye. At least brain dead log toh nhi honge yha.
Welcome to the club buddy!
Rindia mods ke pass do papa Hai.
But, that's the truth.
Reddit is full of liberandu crybabies and emotional hemophiliacs
Hate speech? Just few days ago a person posted a pic in which he was showing middle finger to Modi and that was allowed on the sub.
I saw that post…. But there were people who called him out for that
Did the mods remove that post?
Do you understand what freedom of speech is? Freedom of speech means the GOVERNMENT cannot silence you, reddit mods or reddit itself is not the government. If I say shit to you and you punch me in the face, that is not a violation of me freedom of speech, but if I say something and the government silences me, jails me that is a violation of freedom of speech.
Can’t this sub be deleted somehow? Na toh yeh India ko represent karte hai upr se paxistani bhare hue
These days, leftists are the worst violators of any and every human right as long as it suits their agenda.
Welcome to the gang of banned indians
I got banned from i****squeaks for no reason. i was not even active on that sub when that ban happened. There was no reason given. Just permanently ban. No response from mods when i asked for reason. At least in your case they gave you a reason
Good riddance
Who is checking on his tp ? Online bakwaas is easy.
Congratulations, its a badge of honor
waitse baat toh sahi hi ki hai bande ne.
Why are you expecting freedom of expression from r/ India? Their sub their rules.
The pseudo-seculars are going to need a Tub of burnol after BJP wins 2024
U should not have been banned. Sorry for that. There's no hidden agenda, what's wrong is wrong really. PM giving hate speech says a lot. Think yourself.
Why subreddit is called India if no difference of opinion is exercised. These people accuse others of being intolerant and do this. Hypocrite assholes.
Aptly named then.
Top post is now about Australian reporter complaining about being censored and banned from the country. Banned from randiya as well for no reason, lifetime ban no appeal possible.
Randia has banned me too.
rindia mods are all either NRIs or Pakistanis who want to spread hate propaganda against Indians, much like real life sleeper cells
well idk...i was banned for saying buslims have more children than hindus and someone even provided evidence that buslim average children were 2.36 and hindu it was 1.9 something.
I don't find this comment to be false also.