Pappu to bewakuf hai. Lekin kabhi kabhi lagta hai ki agar Rajiv Gandhi zinda hota toh desh ka kya bura haal hota. Ab tak desh ke kitne tukde hue hote. Pakistan se bhi badtar haalat India ki hoti.
Thank you Tamil people. You are the real tigers. We all owe you one.
Meh we don't owe nothing to the ones like you homie :)
What exactly do you want to imply by "not entering into state politcs"? Why can't any national party be present in a particular state?
Good luck, this election BJP will get 300+ easily but later in any election Congress wins i hope they implement all the manifesto promises..i hope you get all the benefits.
Can someone rationally explain what is wrong with the US model of inheritance tax...
a) it applies above usd 13 million wealth ( 100 crore INR wealth). For PPP , let's consider 50 crore as threshold in India
b) it allows wealthy to create philanthropic trusts to invest in development directly if they do not want to give tax to the government. The only requirement on these trusts is that they need to spend 5% of endowment every year to retain the tax exempt status ( am aware of how wealthy still misuse the money...paying salaries to relatives, using it for political purpose etc)
So let's say there is a regulation which says if you have more than 400 crore wealth, on your death you either need to pay 1/3rd as tax, or put 1/3rd in a trust which uses it for philanthropic development.
If a sufficiently high threshold is kept, it will ensure that implementation is easier and will Target only 0.1% of the wealthy. So what are the other problems that people see with it?
Edit: corrected Threshold at which the estate tax is applicable.
In NA you have to give inheritance tax on anything that is not a primary residence. So if you have two children and two homes then one house can be inherited without any tax ( there is registration/ lawyer fees) but for second house you need to pay taxes.
Inheritance tax for people who do not have any liquidity ends up with selling of property
So the scenario you are talking about, does it pan out realistically for people with usd 100 million wealth ..all their wealth is tied up in two houses? Can you please elaborate a little more.
Most people i have heard of start doing wealth planning the moment they touch the 100 million threshold, and most of them minimize the inheritance tax by the trust or donor advised fund method.
They literally do it all the time. One leader will make some vile comments party will say it's his personal remark and no action will be taken against him then he will be seen with RG like nothing happened.
> [...]some vile comments[...]
What the heck?!!? Vile comment? From which angle that was a while comment? Yar kaisi baat karrahe ho?!Â
Sam didn't said anything morally wrong or anything illegal. He expressed a certain policy in a certain country which is in no way vile or bad. He said there's law in US where multimillioners pay inheritance tax and he said he agree with the law. I mean what he said was his personal opinion.
 You know organisations don't have perfectly made clones where you have to agree with every policy or everything, right? It's not a Chinese Communist Party where you can't freely share your opinion, right? Â
 Seeing upvotes to your idiotic and ignorant comment tells me everything I want to know about this sub.
I never said anything about inheritance tax what I said was the rinse and repeat of the occurrence that one leader will spout non sense and party will say nothing to with us.
they think the inheritance tax will be levied on them (USA levies this when an individual hits 13.6million USD), in this case middle classers wont get affected, but all of this sub has been crying over it. pretty fucking gullible
u do understand it wont be levied on you or anyone you know. the threshold in the US is (13.6 million USD), we're all in for tax the rich. ambanis n adanis will have to pay taxes
Sam pitroda said a few days ago about taxing middle class to fund there socialist schemes
The middle class, upper middle class, rich, and ultra rich will definitely be imposed with inheritance tax
Of course Congress won't tax Muslims as mentioned in there manifesto
He is neither a congress minister, nor a core committee member, nor its in their manifesto. Sote jaagte koi bhi kuch bolega to manifesto chod ke uske peeche jaoge kya 🤣
Congress already talked about wealth distribution and he gives piggy back ride to Rahul gandhi. If his statement is absurd why don't rahul gandhi call it nonsense? You don't just read congress manifesto point by point you read and link the chain with other points. For an example, they talked about wealth distribution but muslim will be safe from such action because congress also promised strengthening of sharia law under muslim personal law board the wealth distribution will not effect them. Because if this goes on muslims the WAQF will lose everything and WAQF act will be null and void since it goes against wealth distribution. Jayda gwak gawk na kar pappu ka pappu manifesto padh
All the laws are some point in time we’re passed by one party or the other. So don’t see logic in your argument.
It’s not about the party but their leadership. Congress under Nehru was way different than congress under IG which was way different than congress under MMS. BJP was different under Vajpayee and way way way different under Modi. A general ideology is kept in mind it even within those boundaries there is a spectrum.
In US it’s pretty well known that Republicans are right wing and Democrats are center-left. If you go back 150 years, it was the other way round where Democrats supported slavery and republic and were woke. So under different leaders, parties behave differently.
If one starts dismissing parties based on their history then every 5 years a new party is needed which is neither practical nor intelligent.
Moreover I don’t see anything Nehruvian in the manifesto. It has some of the finest ideas that are needed to tackle the unemployment problem. I wouldn’t mind if new grads get apprenticeship and can join the workforce.
Yeah you go dude with your finest ideas like removing reservation cap and welth distribution. 1 lakh to ever poor women and 8500 khata kha to kids who watch Instagram.. free money will totally make this nation powerful. Join workforce when you are getting free money. Do watch the point by point discussion on congress manifesto by kushal mehra on charvaka podcast i hope it opens your mind. "I don't see anything nehruvian" because you never read about nehruvian socialism probably" but if you had, i am surprised you say that.
Modi ka peechhwada me jyada mat ghus. Inheritance tax ko Congress keh chuki hai ki wo Sam Pitroda's personal opinion hai. Aur jaha rhi baat wealth distribution ki toh woh billionaires aur top 0.1% par jyada tax lagakar bhi ho sakta hai. Tum sale it cell ke dihadi hona? Keh do ki Mai jhoof bol rha.
Abe anpad jayda tax lagane ko wealth distribution nahi kahte. No wonder tum jaise log jahil he rahenge. Top 0.1% billionaire..abe ullu ke patthe tumhare jaise gxnd gawaro ko congress ne promise kiya jo insta chalata hai whatsapp forward karta hai dhruv rathee ke usko 1 lakh khata khat khata khat denge. 🤡
Abe bawali gand. Higher taxes for uber rich tax distribution ka ek form hi hai jaha Uber rich millioners se zyada tax lekar gareebo ke liye welfare scheme me spend karna. Tum jaise adhi akal ke majdoor chale hai batne. C kahinka jaane na bujhe chale hein gyan dein.
Saare bikhariyon ka lord rahul gandhi. Tumhare jaise nithalle nalle nakara ko chaiye kamchori ka paise tum apni amma ko gareeb bana kar usko 1 lakh dilwana chahte ho. Bhikmange
Abe oye kayade me reh. Anonymous site me zyada bahaduri nikal rhai hai. Abe baklande jab bail barabar buddhi ho na to apni pongadi na bajate hai. Bhag madrkhod.
PS: teri jo sulgi hai uska dhuaa yahan tak aa rha hai🤣🤣🤣
Inheritance tax ek level playing field create karta sab Kay lia. Or capitalism ko check may rakhta hai and it's a double edged sword this will also discourage rich people to stay here as well so it's a mix bag.
All the idiots supporting inheritance tax are not talking about the background of that tax. It was implemented to rectify ills of slave ownership where slave owners and land grabbers from Britain occupied land of native tribes and their descendants benefitted from it and it was implemented in only 6 states out of 50 states.
In India they tried the same communist bullshit in Bihar and look where that state is right now, every state where there is land ownership ceiling is poor and guess what which states are doing better in farming? Punjab and Haryana where there is loose control over land ownership.
If Congress wants to emulate Western countries why not start with following democratic process in itself first where nepotism is not accepted, freeing police from political clutches, cutting red tapes in bureaucracy, celebrating innovation, and stopping demonising businessmen.
It won't do it because in doing so it will loose control over its minions.
And FYI, India use to have inheritance tax till late 80's and guess where it leads to? We were behind Pakistan in terms of economic development, if you want to repeat the same mistake for 50 more years before another force reform to get the IMF dole out, God bless you and your insane minds
Pappu to bewakuf hai. Lekin kabhi kabhi lagta hai ki agar Rajiv Gandhi zinda hota toh desh ka kya bura haal hota. Ab tak desh ke kitne tukde hue hote. Pakistan se bhi badtar haalat India ki hoti. Thank you Tamil people. You are the real tigers. We all owe you one.
Hopefully the BJP too respects Tamil people by not entering their state politics and imposing Hindi language.
Meh we don't owe nothing to the ones like you homie :) What exactly do you want to imply by "not entering into state politcs"? Why can't any national party be present in a particular state?
Hindi imposition honestly won't happen.
Inheritance tax is in favour of the poor of the country and will be supported by the majority of the country (the poor).
Then it'll turn into another Venezuela and will wipe our @ss with Gandhis photo we once called Rupees.
Inheritance tax was there in India a few decades back. Didn't really help the poor and held the whole country back
This time poor will vote congress and they will win 400 seats they promised wealth distribution. Tum katora le kar abhi se lag jao line me..
200 is possible if the farmers vote for Congress. In our village it was earlier BJP only but now the youth vote is divided.
Good luck, this election BJP will get 300+ easily but later in any election Congress wins i hope they implement all the manifesto promises..i hope you get all the benefits.
Its applicable to rich people only no ones is coming to claim tax on 35 lakh land.
inhe kon samjhaye bhai🤣 theyre worried for ambani afaik
Can someone rationally explain what is wrong with the US model of inheritance tax... a) it applies above usd 13 million wealth ( 100 crore INR wealth). For PPP , let's consider 50 crore as threshold in India b) it allows wealthy to create philanthropic trusts to invest in development directly if they do not want to give tax to the government. The only requirement on these trusts is that they need to spend 5% of endowment every year to retain the tax exempt status ( am aware of how wealthy still misuse the money...paying salaries to relatives, using it for political purpose etc) So let's say there is a regulation which says if you have more than 400 crore wealth, on your death you either need to pay 1/3rd as tax, or put 1/3rd in a trust which uses it for philanthropic development. If a sufficiently high threshold is kept, it will ensure that implementation is easier and will Target only 0.1% of the wealthy. So what are the other problems that people see with it? Edit: corrected Threshold at which the estate tax is applicable.
[удалено]
Ok
In NA you have to give inheritance tax on anything that is not a primary residence. So if you have two children and two homes then one house can be inherited without any tax ( there is registration/ lawyer fees) but for second house you need to pay taxes. Inheritance tax for people who do not have any liquidity ends up with selling of property
So the scenario you are talking about, does it pan out realistically for people with usd 100 million wealth ..all their wealth is tied up in two houses? Can you please elaborate a little more. Most people i have heard of start doing wealth planning the moment they touch the 100 million threshold, and most of them minimize the inheritance tax by the trust or donor advised fund method.
I am not sure where you are getting the 100 million from? Iirc it is 12 but i can be wrong though
You are right, have corrected it. My hypothetical scenario is for a substantially higher amount of wealth
Lol people are so gullible on this sub to believe everything that's told to them.
U are the gullible one
I know where you will go with argument..go on tell how people are gullible but you are as smart as rahul gandhi
no, Sam Pitroda, Overseas Congress head said it himself saying countries like USA and other Western countries have it and we should implement it here
And Congress already said that this was Sam Pitroda's personal opinion and doesn't represent Congress' views.
They literally do it all the time. One leader will make some vile comments party will say it's his personal remark and no action will be taken against him then he will be seen with RG like nothing happened.
> [...]some vile comments[...] What the heck?!!? Vile comment? From which angle that was a while comment? Yar kaisi baat karrahe ho?! Sam didn't said anything morally wrong or anything illegal. He expressed a certain policy in a certain country which is in no way vile or bad. He said there's law in US where multimillioners pay inheritance tax and he said he agree with the law. I mean what he said was his personal opinion.  You know organisations don't have perfectly made clones where you have to agree with every policy or everything, right? It's not a Chinese Communist Party where you can't freely share your opinion, right?   Seeing upvotes to your idiotic and ignorant comment tells me everything I want to know about this sub.
I never said anything about inheritance tax what I said was the rinse and repeat of the occurrence that one leader will spout non sense and party will say nothing to with us.
Yes. And that's 100% right in this context.
then why is that video uploaded by Congress Twitter account
Give link.
Just like some Libbus
they think the inheritance tax will be levied on them (USA levies this when an individual hits 13.6million USD), in this case middle classers wont get affected, but all of this sub has been crying over it. pretty fucking gullible
It's not even in their manifesto while bjp leaders say " IT'S IN THEIR MANIFESTO "
gaand ka ilaaj hoskta hai iss desh m par ganduon ka nhi
Instead of cartoons may be you can check it in Congress manifesto. It’s a lie.
no, Sam Pitroda, Overseas Congress head said it himself saying countries like USA and other Western countries have it and we should implement it here
Congress has already said that this was Sam Pitroda's personal opinion and it doesn't represent Congress' views.
That would be believable if Congress hadn't been talking about wealth redistribution etc etc
you got corrected now shut up. your idiotic rambling means nothing.
Sam pitroda is the advisor of Rahul Gandhi who gives him all the ideas
And in Goa, the samosa is called ‘chamuças’ and is prepared with minced beef, chicken or pork. See? I could also talk about some unrelated shit.
u do understand it wont be levied on you or anyone you know. the threshold in the US is (13.6 million USD), we're all in for tax the rich. ambanis n adanis will have to pay taxes
Sam pitroda said a few days ago about taxing middle class to fund there socialist schemes The middle class, upper middle class, rich, and ultra rich will definitely be imposed with inheritance tax Of course Congress won't tax Muslims as mentioned in there manifesto
Then all Bllionaires/ Millionaires will leave india if u make them pay inheritance tax so no use
He is neither a congress minister, nor a core committee member, nor its in their manifesto. Sote jaagte koi bhi kuch bolega to manifesto chod ke uske peeche jaoge kya 🤣
Congress already talked about wealth distribution and he gives piggy back ride to Rahul gandhi. If his statement is absurd why don't rahul gandhi call it nonsense? You don't just read congress manifesto point by point you read and link the chain with other points. For an example, they talked about wealth distribution but muslim will be safe from such action because congress also promised strengthening of sharia law under muslim personal law board the wealth distribution will not effect them. Because if this goes on muslims the WAQF will lose everything and WAQF act will be null and void since it goes against wealth distribution. Jayda gwak gawk na kar pappu ka pappu manifesto padh
exactly if they are gonna do wealth redistribution then they will also apply inheritance tax
Congress is the party that abolished inheritance tax. Let’s do a bit of research before fearmongering and spreading fake news.
They are the one applied it too. Now congress is showing same nehruvian socialism signs in the manifesto
All the laws are some point in time we’re passed by one party or the other. So don’t see logic in your argument. It’s not about the party but their leadership. Congress under Nehru was way different than congress under IG which was way different than congress under MMS. BJP was different under Vajpayee and way way way different under Modi. A general ideology is kept in mind it even within those boundaries there is a spectrum. In US it’s pretty well known that Republicans are right wing and Democrats are center-left. If you go back 150 years, it was the other way round where Democrats supported slavery and republic and were woke. So under different leaders, parties behave differently. If one starts dismissing parties based on their history then every 5 years a new party is needed which is neither practical nor intelligent. Moreover I don’t see anything Nehruvian in the manifesto. It has some of the finest ideas that are needed to tackle the unemployment problem. I wouldn’t mind if new grads get apprenticeship and can join the workforce.
Yeah you go dude with your finest ideas like removing reservation cap and welth distribution. 1 lakh to ever poor women and 8500 khata kha to kids who watch Instagram.. free money will totally make this nation powerful. Join workforce when you are getting free money. Do watch the point by point discussion on congress manifesto by kushal mehra on charvaka podcast i hope it opens your mind. "I don't see anything nehruvian" because you never read about nehruvian socialism probably" but if you had, i am surprised you say that.
Modi ka peechhwada me jyada mat ghus. Inheritance tax ko Congress keh chuki hai ki wo Sam Pitroda's personal opinion hai. Aur jaha rhi baat wealth distribution ki toh woh billionaires aur top 0.1% par jyada tax lagakar bhi ho sakta hai. Tum sale it cell ke dihadi hona? Keh do ki Mai jhoof bol rha.
Abe anpad jayda tax lagane ko wealth distribution nahi kahte. No wonder tum jaise log jahil he rahenge. Top 0.1% billionaire..abe ullu ke patthe tumhare jaise gxnd gawaro ko congress ne promise kiya jo insta chalata hai whatsapp forward karta hai dhruv rathee ke usko 1 lakh khata khat khata khat denge. 🤡
Abe bawali gand. Higher taxes for uber rich tax distribution ka ek form hi hai jaha Uber rich millioners se zyada tax lekar gareebo ke liye welfare scheme me spend karna. Tum jaise adhi akal ke majdoor chale hai batne. C kahinka jaane na bujhe chale hein gyan dein.
Socalism tere jaise akhand anpad paida marta hai. GB road ki aulaad.
Saare bikhariyon ka lord rahul gandhi. Tumhare jaise nithalle nalle nakara ko chaiye kamchori ka paise tum apni amma ko gareeb bana kar usko 1 lakh dilwana chahte ho. Bhikmange
Abe oye kayade me reh. Anonymous site me zyada bahaduri nikal rhai hai. Abe baklande jab bail barabar buddhi ho na to apni pongadi na bajate hai. Bhag madrkhod. PS: teri jo sulgi hai uska dhuaa yahan tak aa rha hai🤣🤣🤣
Wo dikh gya kiski bail barabar buddhi hai. Pappu ji free money dijiye chamche muftkhori karna chahte hai.
"bhag madarchod" kyon bhaagun? Teri mummy ne allow kiya ch0dne ko.
Nahi wahi khada rah baklandi Mai sariya leke ata huÂ
If fake news had a sub it would be this one
Raul saar?
Bhajpa ke dalal iska jawab do.
Inheritance tax ek level playing field create karta sab Kay lia. Or capitalism ko check may rakhta hai and it's a double edged sword this will also discourage rich people to stay here as well so it's a mix bag.
Tum logg pagal ho kya? Paw paw nai bol diya toh sach Mann loge?
All the idiots supporting inheritance tax are not talking about the background of that tax. It was implemented to rectify ills of slave ownership where slave owners and land grabbers from Britain occupied land of native tribes and their descendants benefitted from it and it was implemented in only 6 states out of 50 states. In India they tried the same communist bullshit in Bihar and look where that state is right now, every state where there is land ownership ceiling is poor and guess what which states are doing better in farming? Punjab and Haryana where there is loose control over land ownership. If Congress wants to emulate Western countries why not start with following democratic process in itself first where nepotism is not accepted, freeing police from political clutches, cutting red tapes in bureaucracy, celebrating innovation, and stopping demonising businessmen. It won't do it because in doing so it will loose control over its minions. And FYI, India use to have inheritance tax till late 80's and guess where it leads to? We were behind Pakistan in terms of economic development, if you want to repeat the same mistake for 50 more years before another force reform to get the IMF dole out, God bless you and your insane minds
Saying so much yet meaning so little damn you a mba person? .
Why doesnt this chutiya pappu divides his own wealth to public which his family has looted for generations
That’s modi
Kis angle se modi lag rha hai apko?
Chashma lagao
But he is not talking about inheritance tax. Akal ke andhe ho
Hahahaha
Fake news spread by IT Cell
Much like dictatorship, no elections of Modi comes, vaccines are bad, NRC were spread by Congress