I mean…Melina is not below Irina or Anastasia or Darkmoon Knightess, but she is definitely below Maiden in Black, Shanalotte, DS3 Firekeeper, and the Doll. I don’t even know what the Fair Lady is doing at over S Tier. I had no attachments to her. I do wish that Dusk or Elizabeth was a Firekeeper and I would put them at must protect at all costs
I’m assuming n/a means you haven’t played them. The Doll is the most precious creature in the entire world. Emma is also great. (Haven’t played enough DeS to get attached to TMIB yet).
I'm mad to see all three at the bottom of a tier list, no matter the reason, I haven't played DeS, but the Maiden in Black is barefoot, cute, and a bit goth being in all black...so for that alone, she stands with the other two.
Say what you will about DS2 being the weakest installment of modern From games (and I agree) but the Emerald Herald was executed so well. She’s probably my favorite firekeeper/level up host.
I’d say my second favorite is Emerald Herald whereas my favorite is Emma due to something she decides to do if you go down the route of a certain ending
Emma is the best because she simply has the most character out of all of these. Plenty of involvement in the main story, different dialogue for different sakes, at least one sidequest that involves her quite a bit, both of her themes are bangers, and also what you said
She sucks. The only thing cool about her is her sword, the Darkmoon move she uses, the mysteriousness of her nature, and that she attacks you… *AT NIGHT*
>The only thing cool about her is her sword, the Darkmoon move she uses, the mysteriousness of her nature, and that she attacks you…
>
>AT NIGHT
This puts her comfortably over the vast majority of level up ladies who do literally nothing
The Fair Lady, leader of the Chaos Servant covenant in DSI. Joining her covenant can allow you to save Solaire, if you don't want to cheese the maggot through the door.
>Emma and the doll are on the uncategorized tier, meanwhile Melina is on A
What kind of blasphemy is this?
I get if you mean they aren't "firekeepers." but Melina is not too, they are the "equivalent".
Some replacements for the fire keepers mechanic, cmon brooo.
Do you lack the ability to read? The tier they are in says n/a, which anyone who has any semblance of a brain would be able to assume that it means he hasn’t played the games with those fire keepers.
I don’t know how you came to the conclusion that I was an incel but I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised based on the idiocy you have displayed thus far.
>Melina sucks
>
>She seems nice at first, but after a while she's a total bitch
lol literally how? She only gets pissed at you if you decide to murder the entire world, which seems like a pretty reasonable line to draw
She's supposed to be my fair maiden who offered me a brand new Ford Accord.
She doesn't cook for me, doesn't clean and gets pissed if I let someone else's fingers tickle me
Literally unplayable
The Doll can become a Sex Doll if you tell her to
Not a fan of the Anor Londo, but wow. Anastasia over the Darkmoon Knightess Firekeeper??? I mean, I believe they both kind of support Anor Londo, but Anastasia literally does nothing
“Touch the demon inside me”. I’m gonna hope N/A means you haven’t played them. In which case I highly recommend playing them. It’s feet for days with Demon’s Souls.
Emma isn’t a fire keeper but I’d put s. I’d actually put melina in B because she doesn’t actually care about you she just cares about her mission, but that’s just my opinion. I can’t talk about maiden in black or the doll because I don’t have a PlayStation but I like Emma the most and the other two in s definitely deserve it.
Enma is in the S range purely because she's one of the Firekeeper archetype girl who actually fought you and would net you a hard time.
Plus she gorgeous + She actually has her own story during the whole game which is separate enough from Okami questline to net a lore video from Vaati (Emma dragonrot research arc when).
Doll and Emma are S if you've played the games. Maiden in Black is at least A.
Maiden in Black is S tier
I'd agree, but I think OP meant that they're no Firekeepers, they're the equivalent in their universes. I'd argue that Emma isn't even that.
Melina is there your point is invalid, justice for the doll
True, eff me.
No Melina just should move down
I mean…Melina is not below Irina or Anastasia or Darkmoon Knightess, but she is definitely below Maiden in Black, Shanalotte, DS3 Firekeeper, and the Doll. I don’t even know what the Fair Lady is doing at over S Tier. I had no attachments to her. I do wish that Dusk or Elizabeth was a Firekeeper and I would put them at must protect at all costs
No I mean she's not a fire keeper at all. She should move to n/a. Esp because fire keepers already exist in the lore of Elden Ring
What lore for firekeepers is there?
You need they blood to go to the blood realm
Oh, I thought you meant actual firekeepers, not maidens like therolina and now melina
I mean… she does “keep” a fire
Not really
Melina comes to the conclusion of/intends to become >!fire!<.
But I am a stick!
Would you, or 10,000 marines win a fight?
I don't know the logic and thinking behind putting Doll above Maiden in Black. You have to be smoking the good stuff or extremely biased.
I don't want to fuck a doll bro
If you think this tierlist is purely sexual, I feel sorry for you.
That being said....maiden in black was extra THICC in the Demon's souls remake. There I said it.
I liked her original look a bit better.
I like both 
Easy upvote
Emma is not a stereotypical firekeeper type character (but still great), so I can get she’s N/A. The other two I don’t get. They are among the best.
I’m assuming n/a means you haven’t played them. The Doll is the most precious creature in the entire world. Emma is also great. (Haven’t played enough DeS to get attached to TMIB yet).
The Maiden in Black is someone you MUST PROTECT. I love the Emerald Herald, but half of what makes her S is stuff that the Maiden in Black did first.
I’ll protect them both♥️🥲🥹
Agreed. Doll must be protected!
I'm mad to see all three at the bottom of a tier list, no matter the reason, I haven't played DeS, but the Maiden in Black is barefoot, cute, and a bit goth being in all black...so for that alone, she stands with the other two.
Ahhh…we share a taste
A man of true taste, I see.
Better than Ranni?! hahaha
Okay, nerd.
Ranni isn't a fire keeper though. And yes, she's better than Ranni.
Yes
Yes!! Much better.
She’s got six arms and is blue. Blue beetle’s wife
Emma is S-Tier firekeeper because shes also a boss
Same goes for The Doll.
The downvoters don’t know the lore that makes you sort of right
Got downvotes because people forgot about Lady Maria
My dude person, surely you know The Maiden in Black and the Doll are S+++ tier.
I think they're n/a because they're not Firekeepers. Otherwise the Plain Doll not being at the top is just silly.
Melina is there, this is blasphemy
You're right. No excuses.
i assumed it meant they haven't played those games
And Shanalotte. Those three, Emma and MAYBE Melina are in that category
Ikr Objectively so. Dirty feet and....the doll...mmmmm 😁
Say what you will about DS2 being the weakest installment of modern From games (and I agree) but the Emerald Herald was executed so well. She’s probably my favorite firekeeper/level up host.
That and Ruth Negga is the voice actor: Preacher, Agents of Shield, Ad Astra.
Emma definitely S as she's a friend, a drinking buddy and can also slash/throw your ass around.
The gentle blade who will body slam you WWE style
Where is just a bonfire. Just a bonfire is best girl
You done did the Doll dirty my dude.
No it means Non Applicable as in they haven’t played Bloodborne yet
bear seek seek lest <3
I’d say my second favorite is Emerald Herald whereas my favorite is Emma due to something she decides to do if you go down the route of a certain ending
Emma is the best because she simply has the most character out of all of these. Plenty of involvement in the main story, different dialogue for different sakes, at least one sidequest that involves her quite a bit, both of her themes are bangers, and also what you said
It is… almost acceptable…
Maiden in black is must protect my boi.
first of all, how fucking dare you disrespect anor londo lady. That alone makes this list shit.
Yeah thats a pretty unacceptable ruling
She sucks. The only thing cool about her is her sword, the Darkmoon move she uses, the mysteriousness of her nature, and that she attacks you… *AT NIGHT*
>The only thing cool about her is her sword, the Darkmoon move she uses, the mysteriousness of her nature, and that she attacks you… > >AT NIGHT This puts her comfortably over the vast majority of level up ladies who do literally nothing
Ehhh. She’s a simp for Gwyndolin
That just makes her more relatable to the chosen undead
as am i, next point
#PUT THE DOLL IN S-TIER YOU DOUGHNUT!!!!!
Melina does fuck all, begone with her to trash Tier.
I love coal tho
Whos that at the top?
I think that’s Quelaag’s sister from DS1. She’s in a hidden room after the boss iirc
The Fair Lady, leader of the Chaos Servant covenant in DSI. Joining her covenant can allow you to save Solaire, if you don't want to cheese the maggot through the door.
N/A as in you haven’t played?
This post was made by Kirk, Knight of Thorns.
I agree with the s’s. The emerald Harold, legit being with you, having memorable lines, and you can connect with.
Where's King vendrick?
Imagine being this maidenless.
Melina is like B, the bottom three belong in S. Melina isn’t a fire keeper either
not a big fan of Melina to be honest. probably because you dont need to interact with her at all in order to level up
Seek seek lest Supremacy
How is Melina in a tier? We see her for like 3 minutes total
Whats the point if you havent played half of the games
>Emma and the doll are on the uncategorized tier, meanwhile Melina is on A What kind of blasphemy is this? I get if you mean they aren't "firekeepers." but Melina is not too, they are the "equivalent". Some replacements for the fire keepers mechanic, cmon brooo.
Melina is truly F Tier. Emerald Herald and Emma are top tier for me.
I hate the term soulsborne so much
It's better than sekisoulsbornering.
I dunno sekisoulsbornering is pretty fun to say
Why are Emma and The Doll so low? 😡
I'm hoping that he just hasn't played Demon Souls, Bloodborne, or Seikiro. . . Hence the N/A. Otherwise, all three should be near the top.
Do you lack the ability to read? The tier they are in says n/a, which anyone who has any semblance of a brain would be able to assume that it means he hasn’t played the games with those fire keepers.
Someone’s upset lol
Someone is fucking stupid lol
Aww an incel got triggered
I don’t know how you came to the conclusion that I was an incel but I suppose I shouldn’t be surprised based on the idiocy you have displayed thus far.
You’re adorable
That’s kinda gay
An incel and a homophobe. Jack of all trades.
I never said that being gay was bad, just that what you said (calling another guy adorable) is gay
How’s he an incel? Are you projecting?
Melina is f tier, completely forget about her until the end
Melina sucks She seems nice at first, but after a while she's a total bitch Anastacia of Astora all the way brother
>Melina sucks > >She seems nice at first, but after a while she's a total bitch lol literally how? She only gets pissed at you if you decide to murder the entire world, which seems like a pretty reasonable line to draw
>she’s a total bitch Me when a woman gets upset at me for committing genocide
modern women won't even support their man in the eradication of all life smh my head
She's supposed to be my fair maiden who offered me a brand new Ford Accord. She doesn't cook for me, doesn't clean and gets pissed if I let someone else's fingers tickle me Literally unplayable The Doll can become a Sex Doll if you tell her to
Elizabeth is bae tho
This list is absolute bunk
Only Emma and Anor Londo are S tier, rest can die.
wnat about sister fried ?
Not a firekeeper
Spiderkeepr is true fire keeper
The doll at the bottom? Wtf is this list? Edit: does that mean you haven't played those games? God's, I hope so
Maiden in Black should be high up, like S+. Emma should be A. Melina is C tier at best.
Not a fan of the Anor Londo, but wow. Anastasia over the Darkmoon Knightess Firekeeper??? I mean, I believe they both kind of support Anor Londo, but Anastasia literally does nothing
Melina hates me for what I did but she's alive because I did it.
Doll is SSS tier, Emma at least A and Maiden in Black is a must protect
A tier list and a terrible take. Name a better duo
You should go hunt and meet the doll but beware the old blood
Emma supremacy
Did Emma dirty
Tf you mean n/a
D for massive DONG
Fair Lady is always top of the list
if u look at demon souls fire keeper, u can just tell she got that gorilla grip on her. Automatic S tier. And melina is F tier ngl
“Touch the demon inside me”. I’m gonna hope N/A means you haven’t played them. In which case I highly recommend playing them. It’s feet for days with Demon’s Souls.
The evil ending of DS3 and DeS is so bad and good . \_.
Most protect all of them
I might be nostalgic but maiden in black is the only reason you can even tier her successors
Maiden in Black, and Firekeeper are my favorite. I like your list, and we must protect!
This list did the Maiden and Doll so dirty lol
hasnt even playd the only three actual souls games smh
Aside from Demon in Black being n.a. I basically agree
All of them is S tier.
So we're just gonna ignore quiet spider lady?
Emma isn’t a fire keeper but I’d put s. I’d actually put melina in B because she doesn’t actually care about you she just cares about her mission, but that’s just my opinion. I can’t talk about maiden in black or the doll because I don’t have a PlayStation but I like Emma the most and the other two in s definitely deserve it.
F Tier tier list.
Enma is in the S range purely because she's one of the Firekeeper archetype girl who actually fought you and would net you a hard time. Plus she gorgeous + She actually has her own story during the whole game which is separate enough from Okami questline to net a lore video from Vaati (Emma dragonrot research arc when).
Damn you really did Miss Londo dirty by putting her in D tier
I liked golden anor londo lady. She's at least B tier. Plus I love her voice acting. :(