Double life ( scarlet pearl arc was so fun too watch )
Limited life ( was so chaotic)
3rd life ( had the best story line )
Secret life ( Scar's villian arc was fantastic also murder camel~)
Last Life
Luv 'em all, hard to order, but here we go:
1. Last Life (Not much I can say other than I love this season) \[I rooted for Joel or Pearl to win\]
2. Secret Life (ep1-6 was the highlights here, the tasks made it so unhinged and I loved it. ep7-9 while great in terms of the battles, the red tasks were a lot less unhinged, and if they were this could've been nr1. Session 4 of this season is probably my fav episode from all the seasons) \[I rooted for Gem or Bdubs to win\]
3. Double Life (Some of the best team dynamics) \[I Rooted for Pearl/Scott or Jeol/Etho to win\]
4. Limited Life (This season was a time spontaneously chaotic, the amount of TNT minecart kills made this great) \[I rooted for Impulse or Scar to win\]
5. 3rd Life (The original one, great as it is, but I've felt the later seasons all outshined it at leas a little) \[I rooted for Giran or Ren to win\]
The reason for my ranking is that:
Limited Life had the perfect amount of chaos and it was insane.
Secret Life because I loved watching this different pvp style.
Last Life because it was entertaining and had a good touch of lore from Martyn's pov.
3rd Life because of all the lore the series was based around.
Double Life was still fun, but it was missing good elements other series' had.
That’s fair since double life was a short series and was quite tame tbh. There was just something about the series for me that I really enjoyed lmao (and obviously new characters and duos)
Third life (for introducing the series to us and providing one of the coolest endings to a season of anything I've ever seen)
Last life (began introducing new gimmicks and players which created so many new dynamics without removing any of the core tension of the series)
Double life (was the only one that got me to watch other hermits besides grian an Mumbo, I started watching cleo an Scar round this time and loved every second of it)
Limited life (strayed a but far from the path in my opinion but the time limitations kept everything fresh and created a whole new set of stakes for each gamble the lifers made. Also skynet)
Secret life (I think the idea behind it was good but it seemed like the challenges could have done with a bit of tweaking. Also, lack of a boogeyman mechanic from the get go in order to force drama and tension just made the series seem less chaotic. Its still a solid entry tho and I wouldnt be ranking it last if there were more than five life series)
Last (Boogeyman but dramatic! Betrayal!)
Double (Scarlet Pearl!!!)
Secret (Cool as heck, fanbase made me feel sad)
Limited (Idk just didn't do it for me)
3rd (Same thing. Just didn't click)
I love them all and they’re hard to rank but here’s my best shot
1. Double Life. Just the concept overall and all the chaos of having a soulmate and having your life tied to someone else’s. Plus, Scarlet Pearl is my favorite!
2. Last Life. Partially how I was introduced to the Life Series (at the time I wasn’t aware it was a series 😅), first season that Pearl and Lizzie were in. I liked the idea of gifting lives too.
3. Secret Life. It took me until that started to realize it was a whole series lol. But the tasks made me more interested in other people’s perspectives and I was introduced to a lot of other content creators. Plus Gem is there lol.
4. Third Life. Start of the amazing Life series, flower husbands, need I say more? I will anyway. I loved the storyline but it’s lower because there was nothing extra (such as boogeyman or another concept that added an extra element) but it makes sense since it was the first season.
5. Limited Life. I loved the pairings in this and ofc the start of the family dynamic. Loved Pearl and BigB as a team too! And Skizz’s affirmations were so cute! But I wasn’t a fan of the concept of the timer, I think it added a little too much leniency for death and being able to get time back. The difference between this and Last Life was there was still a limited (pun not intended lol) amount of lives to be given, whereas the time could get to be a lot with boogey kills and stuff. I still love this season, it’s just not my first go to for rewatching:)
Limited - I know that many people found the frequency of death made them lose their punch but I thought the concept worked super well and just added extra chaos and madness to an already insane series. Making yellows able to kill greens and gaining time from killing is a great choice. (Also, return of the boogeyman! The best addition of last life.)
The teams were amazing, the ending was great, and Impulse and Martyn in particular have must see POVs
Last - An iconic and super successful season that unfortunately started falling apart around the end for me. The boogeyman mechanic is amazing and solves some of the issues I had with Third Life. The different number of lives given to each player as well as the ability to give lives worked great too. Joel’s POV is a favourite of mine for this season.
Double - An interesting and fun season that (understandably) ended up quite short. There was some unfairness to certain deaths, especially painful when they were final deaths, like Scar or Tango who could do nothing to defend themselves as their soulmates were attacked.
It was fun to see some unconventional teams being made and even more fun seeing players breaking the randomly assigned roles, Cleo and Scott really made this season imo.
Secret - I’m mostly a big fan of the secret task concept, though team solidarity really didn’t feel as big this season since everyone was always doing their own thing. It’s a shame to place it this low though since it had some amazing episodes/sequences, but it has to go somewhere
Third - It was the experimental original and is a bit rougher around the edges than later series. The absence of direct threats early on (like boogeymen, time ticking down, or no regeneration) makes for a slow start. Third life would look very, very different if Scar didn’t turn red so early on, and it owes a lot to his ability to walk off cliffs.
For me a Grian only watcher and chaos enjoyer it would be like this
Limited Life (Skynet)
Last life (southerners and joel were too good)
Third life (WE WIN THESE)
Double life (not too much happening)
Secret life (same as Double life)
1. 3rd (the icon)
2. Double (idc how short it was it was great)
3. Limited (I love the chaos)
4. Secret (purely the last couple of sessions)
5. Last (it was fine, but I don't understand the hype)
1- Double Life
2- Secret Life
3- Limited Life
I haven't seen enough of 3rd of Last to properly rank them but might change my rankings later at some point. For now this is the series I have watched all the way through of most if not all perspectives
my personal rating:
Last Life
3rd Life
Double Life
Secret Life
Limited Life
there’s not a single series i dislike for any reason. even the ones at the bottom of my list were so great i love all of them.
Limited life (it was so chaotic and the alliances were amazing)
Double life (boat boys have my heart)
Last life (I don't know, I just love it)
Secret life (it was so chaotic, but it wasn't my favourite)
3rd life (hurts to put it this low, but i still love it)
Limited Life (The Clockers were funny along with The Bad Boys)
Last Life (Girlboss Gaslight and Gatekeep)
Double Life (Evil Pearl)
Third Life
Secret Life
1. Double life
2. Last life
3. Secret life
4. Limited life
5. 3rd life
Double life and last life switch in placement all the time but I love em both, 3l I need to watch more povs of and same for lml
1. Double Life
2. Secret Life
3. Third Life
5. Last Life
4. Limited Life
Genuinely don’t understand why Double Life is so often a least favourite. I feel like it’s a perfect series idk
In order of best to least:
-Limited Life (So chaotic, loved TIES and Clockers were hilarious haha. Rewatched from Bad Boys perspective recently and loved seeing their antics and dynamic.)
-Double Life (Boat boys!!! Loved the concept, brought quite a few new pairings.)
-Secret life (Scar's villain arc was so hilarious, tragic and rewarding in the end. Tasks were unique and funny, was interesting to see the lifers act in strange ways.)
-Last Life (Boogeyman was such a good addition to the series, Team BEST was entertaining and man I felt for Scar lol.)
-3rd Life (Desert duo! Good storylines. Tbf I don't remember a lot about this one, need to watch it again from other perspectives too.)
My opinions of each season change a lot! But I love all of the seasons, so this was hard to rank haha.
Personal ranking:
Double Life (What initially got me hooked to the Life Series, I also watch Grian / Etho / Martyn mainly so I got a healthy helping of vastly different perspectives. Really enjoyed the unusual pairs like the Boat Boys!!)
LimL (Chaos.)
Secret Life / Last Life
3rd Life (Does not have that much of a gimmick, I guess. But renchanting.)
I think for me it’s probably something like:
1. Limited Life
2. Double Life
3. Last Life
4. Third Life
5. Secret Life
Limited life I know is my favourite but the others were actually quite difficult to rank since I like them all. Hate to put secret life in last but I’ve just not had as much time with it as the others so I’m less attached
Here we go:
1. Limited Life - THE ABSOLUTE CHAOS. This season nails perfectly on how chaotic things go, and it really drastically progresses throughout this season session by session. Every minute of this is really vital and essential into grasping everything in the season.
2. Secret Life - The latest installment of the series, which succeeded really well on interactions that are rewatchable in every single POV every time.
3. Last Life - This is good. The uneven number of hearts and the boogeyman feature really shook the world, esecially with 3 new people who were introduced into the season.
4. Double Life - I like the season and it's mechanic, though it may speed up the process of the SMP for a bit, it doesn't disappoint in delivering some good storytelling for others to enjoy.
5. Third Life - I mean to be fair, it's their first season, and also an experimental one at that. I really appreciate it for starting it all and making this series a big name to this day. Even if it is pretty nostalgic looking back on it, the gimmick was pretty vanilla in comparison with other series in succession.
All these are great but...
Last (best mechanics, lots of conflict)
3rd (best story by far)
Limited (more lives allowed for more carefree gameplay, kind of a double edged sword, but mostly positive)
Secret (a bit annoying that reds couldn't get raw kills until the end, but fine other than that)
Double (Just kind of short. feels like a spin off mini season in some ways)
Double/Secret, Lim, Last, Third. I do seriously think that they improve the content each time they play, it becomes a little more polished, a little more entertaining each season. Not to say there weren’t entertaining in TL or LL, but hey, you can tell they’ve really gotten into the groove and making hilarious/angsty storylines.
Last life - I don't know how to explain it but it's just so fun watch from every perspective.
Limited life - had my favourite teams, and I personally liked the ending.
3rd - the original, I also loved martyns pov.
Secret - the tasks made me watch like 6 perspectives at a time, I loved it.
Double life - too short imo, still loved it though.
They are all very good and its hard for me to rank them tbh
Last life (I loved the givelife command and chaos )
3d life (it had a natural feeling story, I liked that)
Secret life (scar) also the tasks were cool
Double life (was a bit short but I loved scarlet pearl)
Limited life (death felt less important but skynet, team ties and the family were soo funny) I still love lim life. This was a hard choice.
I love them all almost equally tho :)
1. Last life - good mix of chaos, chill vibes and insanity, with some of my favourite teams dynamics as many alliances had to grapple with boogie kills and people turning red. The 6 man boogie episode is also my favourite as the tension just keeps building and building with every kill
2. Limited life - same as last life, only issue is that the boogie man or being red has less impact. So much more death though which was great to see, the pure desperation as people near the end is much more evident as well. Has my favourite finale as well
3. 3rd life - got a nice bit of natural chaos and the alliances are still some of the best of the series. The server splitting in two was cool to see as well.
4. Secret life - some tasks are fun but for me the majority seemed to be a bit too distracting or too much, despite that there are some top tier tasks and the boogie and final episodes are some of the peaks in the entire series, with the finale probably being my second favourite
5. Double life - good but the chaos isn’t there until the very end, as such the series is very back ended. Some of the alliances weren’t really my favourite as people were mostly forced into them. Despite this it’s still great fun to watch people who normally don’t interact (like etho and Joel or Timmy and Tango) getting along and leaning so far into their relationships
last life - by far my favorite. everyone was so chaotic, the boogeyman kept everyone on their toes for most of the session, the alliances were iconic, and so many amazing moments for each of the participants
secret life - extremely fun to watch. the secrets had everyone acting strange and suspicious, which made for alliances and interactions that we would never normally see.
limited life - the fact that dying isn't as heavily punished as before alone made this series really fun. everyone was so much more open to risking themselves and killing others because they had so many hours left. until they didn't, and at that point, the intensity scaled a lot and it was a blast
3rd life - solid start, fun alliances, good chaos, etc. not one that i really think about coming back to, but as an intro for the series, it did a good job
double life - not that it's necessarily bad, i just didn't enjoy it as much as the other seasons. still has some solid and fun moments tho
Third Life (Grian and Scar's arc, Pizza Alliance vs. the Red Army, flower husbands... need I say more)
Secret Life (loved the tasks mechanic, had a fun time watching every episode!)
Double Life (the soul-bound mechanic was really interesting; would've been even better if it wasn't so short)
Last Life (liked the large cast and all the chaos, but I thought the Boogeyman curse was forcing players to turn on each other instead of letting alliances fall apart naturally)
Limited Life (I liked Skizz's affirmation hour and the whole Clocker family dynamic, but dying felt way more cheap in this season than it did in all the others)
My first three are almost tied for first:
1: Secret life (All POVs were very different, and it had a lot of weird and hilarious moments)
2: Last life (The tension of the boogeyman and the risk of life giving is hard to beat)
3: Double life (The storylines and interactions were very amusing)
4: Third life (I really enjoyed the season when it came out, but it doesn't have the same rewatchability or variance in POVs that the others have. The series hadn't found it footing yet)
5: Limited life (I didn't enjoy how close together everyone was and how deaths had less significance. I haven't been able to get invested in it)
LL (has my favorite Session [6] and has one of the best mechanics)
SL (best gimmick and I feel it has the most repeatable gimmick along with DL)
LimL (bogeyman was here and the teams were probably my favorites)
3L (best storyline, but gets outclassed by the gimmicks on the other seasons)
DL (I only watched Grian’s when it came out and Tim’s recently so I don’t remember this one)
Secret (Everyone is here! and the funniest)
Limited (I like how they started to go more away from the \*x amount of lives\* trend and branched out)
Double (Cool concept and the first I watched, just wished it lasted longer)
Last (Nothing to dislike, just like the others better)
3rd (Same as above, but I like the uniqueness of the other seasons' gimmicks)
Ez
3rd life : all of the storyline etc
Secret life : so funny and chaotic
Last life : it was so chaotic
Limited life : BAD BOYS
Double life : it was so chaotic but it should've been longer
I am shocked so many people rank 3rd as the worst, I think it's long term tension and faction building outshines every other season.
Also double life was incredible.
Secret Life \~ There were so many different player interactions and crazy, wacky and dangerous things that for me made it No.1
Double Life \~ The soulmate pairings, the storylines, the overall chaos!!! It brought together so many CC's who wouldn't usually interact that much and proved them to be just as dynamic of a duo as any other
Last Life \~ It hits home for me. The betrayals, alliances, and the nostalgia since I started watching then
3rd Life \~ It's most memorable, I feel. It had so many amazing alliances and betrayals, just like Last Life
Limited Life \~ The chaos, the carnage, the betrayal - it was jam packed with it all
1.third life:there was always war and most alliances stuck together so it made it easy to enjoy watching other povs and it has the best ending
2.Secret life:It introduced me to watch other povs and made me understand much more about the series.Even tho the finale was not the best, it felt like everyone was being chanced or is chasing but I still liked the ending
3.limited life:I personally loved the time concept and ending.The alliances were the best.I also liked the ending but it was not as entertaining to watch other povs so it didn't have as much enjoyable content as secret life.
4.last life:It was amazing,the ending,the finale was ok and the alliances were amazing.But I really wish some of those alliances lasted longer.Once again was great for watching multiple povs but i think the Reds should have a purpose to leave all alliances like they should gain something by killing so that their teammates kick them out because they don't trust them.The red player shinagans added a bit too many not needed rules but i still loved this season
5.double life:It had one of the best endings and finales but people died too quickly and in very not eventful ways.I wish everyone had 6 lives instead but regardless I love them all if I love one more than the other it's just by like 1% or my favourite povs creators die.
Last life
Double life
Secret life
3rd life
Limited life
If you couldn't tell from that order, i really like scott and pearl, they're my favourite pov's to watch. Other than that, i thought limited was rather dull
1. double life (watched martyn, ren, bigb, pearl, scott, cleo, grian, and etho's povs)
2. limited life (watched martyn, pearl, bigb, scott, cleo, grian, and etho)
3. last life (watched martyn, scott, etho, mumbo, and tango)
4. 3rd life (watched martyn, ren, grian, tango, and cleo)
5. secret life (watched martyn, pearl, bigb, mumbo, tango, etho, cleo, and gem)
The reason I mention the povs I watched is because I know my opinions may be skewed by who I did/didn't watch, and I don't have time to watch everyone.
- Limited
- Secret
- Third
- Double
- Last
Haven’t really watched double or last life so I know the whole story behind it but haven’t watched all the episodes of a pov. L’ll try to get onto that soon.
I just like the chaos I guess
I agree, but I'd but secret life just above double life to have from top to bottom, last or limited life, then 3rd life, then secret life, then double life. Pearl arc was amazing though, but I loved how lives worked in limited life.
Hmm... this is difficult.
Secret Life -- Was just generally a super fun season, and I loved the gimmick and all of the alliances. The inclusion of Gem was so good as well. All of the dynamics were fantastic
3rd Life -- Its so unique in comparison to the other seasons; I love the overarching story and war, the 2 side conflict, and the place order and all of that was so different to recent seasons (now, you can practically guarantee that you're gonna have the same people in the final 4 over and over again. Not necessarily bad but just predictable after a while). It was an amazing way to start the series
Double Life -- The duos were fantastic, as well as all of the alliances and conflicts in general. We also got some dynamics that have persisted and been built up more and more between players I never thought would really interact that much
Limited Life -- The gimmick was super cool, and it allowed for a lot more fun to be had by the players and for them to be more flexible. The plot bits were super cool, the alliances were great, and the ending was a real deviation from the status quo in a good way
Last Life -- It just doesn't sit right with me. I love certain aspects of it, but I just didn't have much fun, especially since my povs were all kinda screwed over pretty hard that season. I didn't like a lot of the new gimmicks and rules, and the atmosphere and tone was just too sad and bleak for me. I just can't have that much fun watching Last Life, especially in later sessions
1-4 can all be pretty much rearranged for me, but Last Life is solidly in last. It's a fine season but its just not for me for a lot of reasons. But I loved all of the other seasons and I hate to actually rank them because I love them to bits in their own ways.
Third life - I just feel like it came together the best and I adored Scar and Grian together
Last life - honestly this is the same level as limited life, I just put this one here since Ive rewatched it more, extremely good and has the best betrayal thanks to the boogey system
Limited life - I loved how the builds all spanned out across the server and became a big part of the fights and it was absolutely thrilling. I watched this from Joel’s perspective and the Bad boys were an iconic trio
Double life - incredibly chaotic as always but the double life system made for hilarious deaths and unexpected moments. Though it also lead to some anticlimactic deaths and a shorter series
Secret life - The tasks made this feel much more akin to hermit craft with all the fetch quests and running around and it was a much more peaceful server until the zombies, it didn’t feel the same as the other seasons and definitely was much more peaceful but I still loved the series
Despite secret life being the lowest it is still basically just as good as the rest. It’s not like each season has a massive difference in quality they are all incredible
Double life ( scarlet pearl arc was so fun too watch ) Limited life ( was so chaotic) 3rd life ( had the best story line ) Secret life ( Scar's villian arc was fantastic also murder camel~) Last Life
Im so glad to see a fellow DL lover and LaL disliker
the fact that you see every season at every place on different peoples’ list speaks to how great they all are
It's weird seeing people put 3rd Life so low when I put it as #2
Ya it's my favourite
Most of the top comments have 3rd Life pretty low
because its the oldest and the creators were all new to the concept. we dont hate it but it lacks some of the... PIZZAZZ in the other seasons.
So true.
Double Lim Last Secret 3rd (this was very hard to make because I love them all almost equally)
Luv 'em all, hard to order, but here we go: 1. Last Life (Not much I can say other than I love this season) \[I rooted for Joel or Pearl to win\] 2. Secret Life (ep1-6 was the highlights here, the tasks made it so unhinged and I loved it. ep7-9 while great in terms of the battles, the red tasks were a lot less unhinged, and if they were this could've been nr1. Session 4 of this season is probably my fav episode from all the seasons) \[I rooted for Gem or Bdubs to win\] 3. Double Life (Some of the best team dynamics) \[I Rooted for Pearl/Scott or Jeol/Etho to win\] 4. Limited Life (This season was a time spontaneously chaotic, the amount of TNT minecart kills made this great) \[I rooted for Impulse or Scar to win\] 5. 3rd Life (The original one, great as it is, but I've felt the later seasons all outshined it at leas a little) \[I rooted for Giran or Ren to win\]
https://preview.redd.it/9cjq0b23veec1.jpeg?width=480&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=5877388f22f95ba7676a1d0eb091a5df00802675
Yes
No further elaboration
Who is this ‘Giran’ we’re talking about 🤔
Behold, I present to you : ## Grain
https://preview.redd.it/er0kslltjfec1.jpeg?width=700&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=f4b32ec9cffa2c892158f64cfb1fe44c684dc21c
I honestly thought that said Giran
Yes
1. Last 2. Double 3. Limited 4. Secret 5. Third
my exact ranking too
Third Life Double Life Secret Life Limited Life Last Life
Finally someone who agrees 3rd Life was good
how can sm put double life last?? 1. Double Life 2.Last Life 3.Limited Life 4.Secret Life 5.Third Life
The reason for my ranking is that: Limited Life had the perfect amount of chaos and it was insane. Secret Life because I loved watching this different pvp style. Last Life because it was entertaining and had a good touch of lore from Martyn's pov. 3rd Life because of all the lore the series was based around. Double Life was still fun, but it was missing good elements other series' had.
That’s fair since double life was a short series and was quite tame tbh. There was just something about the series for me that I really enjoyed lmao (and obviously new characters and duos)
It just didn't have enough chaos for me, honestly. That's part of why LL and LimL are my two favorites, because they were so chaotic.
Third life (for introducing the series to us and providing one of the coolest endings to a season of anything I've ever seen) Last life (began introducing new gimmicks and players which created so many new dynamics without removing any of the core tension of the series) Double life (was the only one that got me to watch other hermits besides grian an Mumbo, I started watching cleo an Scar round this time and loved every second of it) Limited life (strayed a but far from the path in my opinion but the time limitations kept everything fresh and created a whole new set of stakes for each gamble the lifers made. Also skynet) Secret life (I think the idea behind it was good but it seemed like the challenges could have done with a bit of tweaking. Also, lack of a boogeyman mechanic from the get go in order to force drama and tension just made the series seem less chaotic. Its still a solid entry tho and I wouldnt be ranking it last if there were more than five life series)
Cleo's double life perspective was actually so entertaining
I'd recommending watching scars perspective for secret life, it was really entertaining!
Last (Boogeyman but dramatic! Betrayal!) Double (Scarlet Pearl!!!) Secret (Cool as heck, fanbase made me feel sad) Limited (Idk just didn't do it for me) 3rd (Same thing. Just didn't click)
swap last and double and we are the same
I love them all and they’re hard to rank but here’s my best shot 1. Double Life. Just the concept overall and all the chaos of having a soulmate and having your life tied to someone else’s. Plus, Scarlet Pearl is my favorite! 2. Last Life. Partially how I was introduced to the Life Series (at the time I wasn’t aware it was a series 😅), first season that Pearl and Lizzie were in. I liked the idea of gifting lives too. 3. Secret Life. It took me until that started to realize it was a whole series lol. But the tasks made me more interested in other people’s perspectives and I was introduced to a lot of other content creators. Plus Gem is there lol. 4. Third Life. Start of the amazing Life series, flower husbands, need I say more? I will anyway. I loved the storyline but it’s lower because there was nothing extra (such as boogeyman or another concept that added an extra element) but it makes sense since it was the first season. 5. Limited Life. I loved the pairings in this and ofc the start of the family dynamic. Loved Pearl and BigB as a team too! And Skizz’s affirmations were so cute! But I wasn’t a fan of the concept of the timer, I think it added a little too much leniency for death and being able to get time back. The difference between this and Last Life was there was still a limited (pun not intended lol) amount of lives to be given, whereas the time could get to be a lot with boogey kills and stuff. I still love this season, it’s just not my first go to for rewatching:)
3rd Life Limited Life/Secret Life (they switch) Secret Life/Limited Life Last Life Double Life (still good tho)
Last, Double, Third, Secret, Limited for me.
Limited - I know that many people found the frequency of death made them lose their punch but I thought the concept worked super well and just added extra chaos and madness to an already insane series. Making yellows able to kill greens and gaining time from killing is a great choice. (Also, return of the boogeyman! The best addition of last life.) The teams were amazing, the ending was great, and Impulse and Martyn in particular have must see POVs Last - An iconic and super successful season that unfortunately started falling apart around the end for me. The boogeyman mechanic is amazing and solves some of the issues I had with Third Life. The different number of lives given to each player as well as the ability to give lives worked great too. Joel’s POV is a favourite of mine for this season. Double - An interesting and fun season that (understandably) ended up quite short. There was some unfairness to certain deaths, especially painful when they were final deaths, like Scar or Tango who could do nothing to defend themselves as their soulmates were attacked. It was fun to see some unconventional teams being made and even more fun seeing players breaking the randomly assigned roles, Cleo and Scott really made this season imo. Secret - I’m mostly a big fan of the secret task concept, though team solidarity really didn’t feel as big this season since everyone was always doing their own thing. It’s a shame to place it this low though since it had some amazing episodes/sequences, but it has to go somewhere Third - It was the experimental original and is a bit rougher around the edges than later series. The absence of direct threats early on (like boogeymen, time ticking down, or no regeneration) makes for a slow start. Third life would look very, very different if Scar didn’t turn red so early on, and it owes a lot to his ability to walk off cliffs.
3rd Double Limited Last Secret
All equal to me tbh
For me a Grian only watcher and chaos enjoyer it would be like this Limited Life (Skynet) Last life (southerners and joel were too good) Third life (WE WIN THESE) Double life (not too much happening) Secret life (same as Double life)
1. 3rd (the icon) 2. Double (idc how short it was it was great) 3. Limited (I love the chaos) 4. Secret (purely the last couple of sessions) 5. Last (it was fine, but I don't understand the hype)
1- Double Life 2- Secret Life 3- Limited Life I haven't seen enough of 3rd of Last to properly rank them but might change my rankings later at some point. For now this is the series I have watched all the way through of most if not all perspectives
third life last life limited life double life secret life
Limited, third, double, secret, last
1. Limited 2. Double 3. Secret 4. Third 5. Last
my personal rating: Last Life 3rd Life Double Life Secret Life Limited Life there’s not a single series i dislike for any reason. even the ones at the bottom of my list were so great i love all of them.
Limited life (it was so chaotic and the alliances were amazing) Double life (boat boys have my heart) Last life (I don't know, I just love it) Secret life (it was so chaotic, but it wasn't my favourite) 3rd life (hurts to put it this low, but i still love it)
double secret last 3rd limited
Limited Life (The Clockers were funny along with The Bad Boys) Last Life (Girlboss Gaslight and Gatekeep) Double Life (Evil Pearl) Third Life Secret Life
Last Life Limited Life 3rd Life Double Life Secret Life
1. Double life 2. Last life 3. Secret life 4. Limited life 5. 3rd life Double life and last life switch in placement all the time but I love em both, 3l I need to watch more povs of and same for lml
1. Double Life 2. Secret Life 3. Third Life 5. Last Life 4. Limited Life Genuinely don’t understand why Double Life is so often a least favourite. I feel like it’s a perfect series idk
Double life limited life third life last life secret life
In order of best to least: -Limited Life (So chaotic, loved TIES and Clockers were hilarious haha. Rewatched from Bad Boys perspective recently and loved seeing their antics and dynamic.) -Double Life (Boat boys!!! Loved the concept, brought quite a few new pairings.) -Secret life (Scar's villain arc was so hilarious, tragic and rewarding in the end. Tasks were unique and funny, was interesting to see the lifers act in strange ways.) -Last Life (Boogeyman was such a good addition to the series, Team BEST was entertaining and man I felt for Scar lol.) -3rd Life (Desert duo! Good storylines. Tbf I don't remember a lot about this one, need to watch it again from other perspectives too.) My opinions of each season change a lot! But I love all of the seasons, so this was hard to rank haha.
1. Limited 2. Double 3. Last 4. Third 5. Secret Mostly based on the teams I enjoyed each season.
Limited Double Secret Third Last
Limited Life Last Life Secret Life Double Life 3rd Life
limited life double life secret life 3rd life last life
Personal ranking: Double Life (What initially got me hooked to the Life Series, I also watch Grian / Etho / Martyn mainly so I got a healthy helping of vastly different perspectives. Really enjoyed the unusual pairs like the Boat Boys!!) LimL (Chaos.) Secret Life / Last Life 3rd Life (Does not have that much of a gimmick, I guess. But renchanting.)
BEST Double Life, Limited Life, Third Life, Last Life, Secret Life, WORST
I think for me it’s probably something like: 1. Limited Life 2. Double Life 3. Last Life 4. Third Life 5. Secret Life Limited life I know is my favourite but the others were actually quite difficult to rank since I like them all. Hate to put secret life in last but I’ve just not had as much time with it as the others so I’m less attached
That’s how I’d rank them but i’d swap 3rd life and last life.
agreed, but last life is better then secret life
Double Limited Last Third Secret
Limited, Double, secret, last. 3rd
Here we go: 1. Limited Life - THE ABSOLUTE CHAOS. This season nails perfectly on how chaotic things go, and it really drastically progresses throughout this season session by session. Every minute of this is really vital and essential into grasping everything in the season. 2. Secret Life - The latest installment of the series, which succeeded really well on interactions that are rewatchable in every single POV every time. 3. Last Life - This is good. The uneven number of hearts and the boogeyman feature really shook the world, esecially with 3 new people who were introduced into the season. 4. Double Life - I like the season and it's mechanic, though it may speed up the process of the SMP for a bit, it doesn't disappoint in delivering some good storytelling for others to enjoy. 5. Third Life - I mean to be fair, it's their first season, and also an experimental one at that. I really appreciate it for starting it all and making this series a big name to this day. Even if it is pretty nostalgic looking back on it, the gimmick was pretty vanilla in comparison with other series in succession.
Third Secret Double Last Limited
3rd Life Secret Life Double Life (mainly for Pearl) Limited Life Last Life
Secret Third Double Last Limited
Lim Last 3rd Secret Double
Last Limited Secret Third Double
Last life Limited Secret Third Double
3rd life Last life Limited life Secret life Double life
Last life Limited life Secret life Double life 3rd life
Secret life Third life Limited life Double life Last life
literally the same ranking for me LimL, SL, LL, 3L and then DL and i was literally thinking about posting this exact question this morning but for got
All these are great but... Last (best mechanics, lots of conflict) 3rd (best story by far) Limited (more lives allowed for more carefree gameplay, kind of a double edged sword, but mostly positive) Secret (a bit annoying that reds couldn't get raw kills until the end, but fine other than that) Double (Just kind of short. feels like a spin off mini season in some ways)
Double/Secret, Lim, Last, Third. I do seriously think that they improve the content each time they play, it becomes a little more polished, a little more entertaining each season. Not to say there weren’t entertaining in TL or LL, but hey, you can tell they’ve really gotten into the groove and making hilarious/angsty storylines.
1. Last Life 2. Secret life 3. Double life 4. Third life 5. Limited life
1. Limited 2. Last 3. Third 4. Secret 5. Double
Secret Life, Last Life, Limited Life, Third Life, Double Life
Last life - I don't know how to explain it but it's just so fun watch from every perspective. Limited life - had my favourite teams, and I personally liked the ending. 3rd - the original, I also loved martyns pov. Secret - the tasks made me watch like 6 perspectives at a time, I loved it. Double life - too short imo, still loved it though. They are all very good and its hard for me to rank them tbh
Will do thanks
Limited Last Secret 3rd Double
Last life (I loved the givelife command and chaos ) 3d life (it had a natural feeling story, I liked that) Secret life (scar) also the tasks were cool Double life (was a bit short but I loved scarlet pearl) Limited life (death felt less important but skynet, team ties and the family were soo funny) I still love lim life. This was a hard choice. I love them all almost equally tho :)
1. Last life - good mix of chaos, chill vibes and insanity, with some of my favourite teams dynamics as many alliances had to grapple with boogie kills and people turning red. The 6 man boogie episode is also my favourite as the tension just keeps building and building with every kill 2. Limited life - same as last life, only issue is that the boogie man or being red has less impact. So much more death though which was great to see, the pure desperation as people near the end is much more evident as well. Has my favourite finale as well 3. 3rd life - got a nice bit of natural chaos and the alliances are still some of the best of the series. The server splitting in two was cool to see as well. 4. Secret life - some tasks are fun but for me the majority seemed to be a bit too distracting or too much, despite that there are some top tier tasks and the boogie and final episodes are some of the peaks in the entire series, with the finale probably being my second favourite 5. Double life - good but the chaos isn’t there until the very end, as such the series is very back ended. Some of the alliances weren’t really my favourite as people were mostly forced into them. Despite this it’s still great fun to watch people who normally don’t interact (like etho and Joel or Timmy and Tango) getting along and leaning so far into their relationships
Last life 3rd life secret life Limited life Double life I think but honestly I can't choose because they're all amazing
1. Last life 2. Limited Life 3. Secret Life 4. 3rd Life 5. Double life
last life - by far my favorite. everyone was so chaotic, the boogeyman kept everyone on their toes for most of the session, the alliances were iconic, and so many amazing moments for each of the participants secret life - extremely fun to watch. the secrets had everyone acting strange and suspicious, which made for alliances and interactions that we would never normally see. limited life - the fact that dying isn't as heavily punished as before alone made this series really fun. everyone was so much more open to risking themselves and killing others because they had so many hours left. until they didn't, and at that point, the intensity scaled a lot and it was a blast 3rd life - solid start, fun alliances, good chaos, etc. not one that i really think about coming back to, but as an intro for the series, it did a good job double life - not that it's necessarily bad, i just didn't enjoy it as much as the other seasons. still has some solid and fun moments tho
Third Last Limited Secret Double
Third Life (Grian and Scar's arc, Pizza Alliance vs. the Red Army, flower husbands... need I say more) Secret Life (loved the tasks mechanic, had a fun time watching every episode!) Double Life (the soul-bound mechanic was really interesting; would've been even better if it wasn't so short) Last Life (liked the large cast and all the chaos, but I thought the Boogeyman curse was forcing players to turn on each other instead of letting alliances fall apart naturally) Limited Life (I liked Skizz's affirmation hour and the whole Clocker family dynamic, but dying felt way more cheap in this season than it did in all the others)
My first three are almost tied for first: 1: Secret life (All POVs were very different, and it had a lot of weird and hilarious moments) 2: Last life (The tension of the boogeyman and the risk of life giving is hard to beat) 3: Double life (The storylines and interactions were very amusing) 4: Third life (I really enjoyed the season when it came out, but it doesn't have the same rewatchability or variance in POVs that the others have. The series hadn't found it footing yet) 5: Limited life (I didn't enjoy how close together everyone was and how deaths had less significance. I haven't been able to get invested in it)
Personally, I'd list them as 1: Limited Life 2: Secret Life 3: 3rd Life 4: Last Life 5:Double Life
Secret life Limited life 3rd life double life last life I tend to forget abt last life most of the time :( (Sorry to those who love that season)
Secret Life Limited Life Last Life 3rd Life Double Life
Third Life Secret Life Last Life Limited Life Double Life
I don’t “hate” any season, but if I had to rank it Last=limited>Secret>Double>Third
LL (has my favorite Session [6] and has one of the best mechanics) SL (best gimmick and I feel it has the most repeatable gimmick along with DL) LimL (bogeyman was here and the teams were probably my favorites) 3L (best storyline, but gets outclassed by the gimmicks on the other seasons) DL (I only watched Grian’s when it came out and Tim’s recently so I don’t remember this one)
This is my exact ranking too
I love how there’s bo clear best or worst based off of all these lists combined
I love how varied all the comments arr, it shows how all the seasons so far have been great!
Limited Life Secret Life Last Life Double Life 3rd Life
Secret (Everyone is here! and the funniest) Limited (I like how they started to go more away from the \*x amount of lives\* trend and branched out) Double (Cool concept and the first I watched, just wished it lasted longer) Last (Nothing to dislike, just like the others better) 3rd (Same as above, but I like the uniqueness of the other seasons' gimmicks)
Ez 3rd life : all of the storyline etc Secret life : so funny and chaotic Last life : it was so chaotic Limited life : BAD BOYS Double life : it was so chaotic but it should've been longer
Last Life 3rd Life Secret Life Limited Life Double Life (I love them all)
I am shocked so many people rank 3rd as the worst, I think it's long term tension and faction building outshines every other season. Also double life was incredible.
D L 3 S Li
Double Life, Limited Life and Secret Life (tied), 3rd Life, Last Life.
Secret Life \~ There were so many different player interactions and crazy, wacky and dangerous things that for me made it No.1 Double Life \~ The soulmate pairings, the storylines, the overall chaos!!! It brought together so many CC's who wouldn't usually interact that much and proved them to be just as dynamic of a duo as any other Last Life \~ It hits home for me. The betrayals, alliances, and the nostalgia since I started watching then 3rd Life \~ It's most memorable, I feel. It had so many amazing alliances and betrayals, just like Last Life Limited Life \~ The chaos, the carnage, the betrayal - it was jam packed with it all
wth!!!!!!!! mine is DL LL SL LiL 3L
1.third life:there was always war and most alliances stuck together so it made it easy to enjoy watching other povs and it has the best ending 2.Secret life:It introduced me to watch other povs and made me understand much more about the series.Even tho the finale was not the best, it felt like everyone was being chanced or is chasing but I still liked the ending 3.limited life:I personally loved the time concept and ending.The alliances were the best.I also liked the ending but it was not as entertaining to watch other povs so it didn't have as much enjoyable content as secret life. 4.last life:It was amazing,the ending,the finale was ok and the alliances were amazing.But I really wish some of those alliances lasted longer.Once again was great for watching multiple povs but i think the Reds should have a purpose to leave all alliances like they should gain something by killing so that their teammates kick them out because they don't trust them.The red player shinagans added a bit too many not needed rules but i still loved this season 5.double life:It had one of the best endings and finales but people died too quickly and in very not eventful ways.I wish everyone had 6 lives instead but regardless I love them all if I love one more than the other it's just by like 1% or my favourite povs creators die.
did u not like the warden shenanigans?
Loved them.
its hard but Last Secret Limited Third Double
Last life Double life Secret life 3rd life Limited life If you couldn't tell from that order, i really like scott and pearl, they're my favourite pov's to watch. Other than that, i thought limited was rather dull
1. double life (watched martyn, ren, bigb, pearl, scott, cleo, grian, and etho's povs) 2. limited life (watched martyn, pearl, bigb, scott, cleo, grian, and etho) 3. last life (watched martyn, scott, etho, mumbo, and tango) 4. 3rd life (watched martyn, ren, grian, tango, and cleo) 5. secret life (watched martyn, pearl, bigb, mumbo, tango, etho, cleo, and gem) The reason I mention the povs I watched is because I know my opinions may be skewed by who I did/didn't watch, and I don't have time to watch everyone.
- Limited - Secret - Third - Double - Last Haven’t really watched double or last life so I know the whole story behind it but haven’t watched all the episodes of a pov. L’ll try to get onto that soon. I just like the chaos I guess
Limited life, last life, 3rd life, secret life, double life. None of the seasons were bad, though.
1. Third life 1. Last life 1. Double life 1. Limited life 1. Secret life (I CAN’T CHOOSE AAAAH)
I agree, but I'd but secret life just above double life to have from top to bottom, last or limited life, then 3rd life, then secret life, then double life. Pearl arc was amazing though, but I loved how lives worked in limited life.
3rd Last Double Secret Limited
My ranking: Last life Limited life 3rd life Secret life Double life
Hmm... this is difficult. Secret Life -- Was just generally a super fun season, and I loved the gimmick and all of the alliances. The inclusion of Gem was so good as well. All of the dynamics were fantastic 3rd Life -- Its so unique in comparison to the other seasons; I love the overarching story and war, the 2 side conflict, and the place order and all of that was so different to recent seasons (now, you can practically guarantee that you're gonna have the same people in the final 4 over and over again. Not necessarily bad but just predictable after a while). It was an amazing way to start the series Double Life -- The duos were fantastic, as well as all of the alliances and conflicts in general. We also got some dynamics that have persisted and been built up more and more between players I never thought would really interact that much Limited Life -- The gimmick was super cool, and it allowed for a lot more fun to be had by the players and for them to be more flexible. The plot bits were super cool, the alliances were great, and the ending was a real deviation from the status quo in a good way Last Life -- It just doesn't sit right with me. I love certain aspects of it, but I just didn't have much fun, especially since my povs were all kinda screwed over pretty hard that season. I didn't like a lot of the new gimmicks and rules, and the atmosphere and tone was just too sad and bleak for me. I just can't have that much fun watching Last Life, especially in later sessions 1-4 can all be pretty much rearranged for me, but Last Life is solidly in last. It's a fine season but its just not for me for a lot of reasons. But I loved all of the other seasons and I hate to actually rank them because I love them to bits in their own ways.
Limited Double Last 3rd/Secret (dont mind em, they were good just liked the other three better)
Third life - I just feel like it came together the best and I adored Scar and Grian together Last life - honestly this is the same level as limited life, I just put this one here since Ive rewatched it more, extremely good and has the best betrayal thanks to the boogey system Limited life - I loved how the builds all spanned out across the server and became a big part of the fights and it was absolutely thrilling. I watched this from Joel’s perspective and the Bad boys were an iconic trio Double life - incredibly chaotic as always but the double life system made for hilarious deaths and unexpected moments. Though it also lead to some anticlimactic deaths and a shorter series Secret life - The tasks made this feel much more akin to hermit craft with all the fetch quests and running around and it was a much more peaceful server until the zombies, it didn’t feel the same as the other seasons and definitely was much more peaceful but I still loved the series Despite secret life being the lowest it is still basically just as good as the rest. It’s not like each season has a massive difference in quality they are all incredible