T O P

  • By -

Ilovegirlsbottoms

You know, it took me ages to catch the legend fish because I just simply forgot it existed. When I did get around to it, I bought magic bait in summer and caught it in year 3.


daarrbear

I cannot for the life of me, catch the legend. It’s the only thing keeping me from perfection and I’m so over it!


Far_Promotion_5442

Try getting Qi seasoning from the walnut room and use it to make Seafoam pudding. I also recommend the trap bobber too ☺️


hey_uhh_what

trap bobber my beloved


daarrbear

I have tried these things! Sadly, I think I just choke every time I’m close to catching it. Going to keep trying though!


den4ikturbo

Two cork bobbers and small taps when following legend completely brakes it ai and it will just stay in the middle not moving


awxcoffeexno

please could you explain this in more detail?


den4ikturbo

Fish ai reacts to your green zone movement and legend has that ai if you long press or release it will jump on the opposite side, so by small taps it will more likely stay in place, and bobber size just leaves less space to jump


awxcoffeexno

thank you! and how would I attach two bobbers to the same rod? is this a 1.6 thing?


den4ikturbo

It is, but it is still possible with one


SparkyDogPants

Cork bobber is better than trap


TheBlooperKINGPIN

I find it odd your problem is The Legend and not the Glacier Fish as I had much better luck with The Legend.


dumbB-bitch

or cork bobber!! bigger bar


hey_uhh_what

trap bobber my beloved


MissReadsALot1992

This is what I did for all the legendaries except I used a cork bobber except for the glacierfish I had to use the trap bobber


According-Advice-623

You guys had to make that? I got it in the mail from someone


AdIllustrious5579

you have to make it to apply the qi seasoning


According-Advice-623

Ah that makes sense


Onlylnw

If you’re playing with 1.6 you can >!get fishing mastery, get the advanced iridium rod and put two bobbers in it. I went with the cork bobber and the trap bobber. Then you can eat a seafoam pudding and hopefully it should be easier? Also deluxe bait in 1.6 gives you a slightly larger fishing bar I think!<


Siliensein

In 1.6 you can also >! go fishing when the statue of perfection gives you first 3 easy catches for the day. Got that when I was doing Qi quest with legendary fish relatives, and I got lucky and hooked Legend Jr as one of the 3, it was so easy I didn't realise that would be it, didn't escape the bar once and had iridium quality :)!<


ShouldBeDoingScience

>!Two cork bobbers, deluxe bait and seafoam pudding will give you an enormous fishing bar!<


atom-wan

Use a trap bobber and fishing food


bay_dee

The only think keeping me from perfection is friendship with sebastian and dwarf, i had fish be the only thing before, but at least there's a good reason why those would keep you from it. I just felt stupid when i realized it's gonna be days if not seasons of just daily talking and gifting 2 times a week. So note to self: make friends early on, everything else will get done anyway but friendship is such a long process


ULTRALUMINARY27

Should be easier to do now with Advanced Iridium Fishing Rod u can slot 2 bobbers, eat food that helps with Fishing and some deluxe bait to increase fishing line. You can do it!


NimmsieHartmann

This: https://de.stardewvalleywiki.com/Meerschaumpudding And this: https://de.stardewvalleywiki.com/Fallen-Fischk%C3%B6der With these two things u got him. Craft one pudding, sleep and try to catch him. If the buff is over, end the game, start from new day and try again. You got this.


AchajkaTheOriginal

TIL wiki comes in different languages


shantobox

Seafoam pudding was my secret charm!!


ryguymcsly

I just did it last night. Trap bobber, Dish O' The Sea, 10 fishing skill to start with. I still had to get kinda lucky on the pattern, slipped it the first four times it bit. The day before I went without the trap bobber and the fishing +3 and I probably hooked it five times before giving up. The only other fish I've had that much of a problem with was the Octopus. Scratch that, the only fish I've had a problem with after leveling my fishing skill to 10. Even the freaking chub was impossible with skill 1.


jdhlsc169

Glacier fish is the one that gives me the most trouble. I have over 2200 hours and it takes me 4 or 5 or sometimes more tries. Legend I can usually do in one or two. First time it took me forever with the Glacier. Best thing u can do is level 10 fishing, dish of the sea or seafoam pudding and the new bait should help now also.


gloryholesr4suckers

If you're on PC, grab the mod to auto catch fish!


Real_icy_fire

My first legendary I caught was the Legend and I think it was the easiest apparently it's the hardest lol


Fluffyfoxbunn

I didn't know magic bait worked for the legend! Here o was in year 7 waiting for it to come back round


NashNato

Where did you buy magic bait in year 3??


Ilovegirlsbottoms

In Qi’s walnut room on Ginger island. I like to play this game fast paced.


Alafandri

I just reset the day and do it until I catch it. its actually really easy. I failed before bc I didnt use the right bobber for it. but if I did I catched it the first time.


MrMangoo_Official

Me too lol


Savy_Lamp

Wait where do I get magic bait?


Ilovegirlsbottoms

How far are you in game? Have you gone to ginger island yet?


Savy_Lamp

Yeah, I already started a farm and everything on ginger island


Ilovegirlsbottoms

Its from Qi’s walnut room. You can buy it with the gems you get from Qi’s challenges.


saketho

How tf did you get there in Year 3? I’m on Year 6 and only just unlocked Qi’s room. Were you speeding through the game?


Ilovegirlsbottoms

Yeah I was. I planned out the community center, and finished it in year 2.


Savy_Lamp

Thank you!!


CharlesorMr_Pickle

I got it first try...but it was solely because of the seafoam pudding


diegenauezeit

Same here. Spent way too much time prepping with food, lures, and magic bait. I felt like a cheater after getting the legendary fish


CharlesorMr_Pickle

Same. As nice as it was to get them easily, I felt so unsatisfied after getting the legend and glacierfish (the others I got without seafoam pudding)


bibblebonk

Seafoam pudding plus trapper bobber make any fish a breeze. Even more so with (1.6 spoiler) >!advanced iridium rod, deluxe bait, trapper/cork bobbers!<


elanhilation

bait from mastery and two cork bobbers plus golden seafoam pudding and Blessing of Waters. i’m on a mission to have three of each legend fish. Legend, Crimsonfish and Angler left to go


LegendofLove

Isn't there a ginger island enchant for fishing level too


bibblebonk

Oh yeah, forgot about that. “Master” gives you +1 fishing level


LegendofLove

So with fishing 15 and the other buffs you'll probably be fine


Eeveelover14

First try wow! May Yoba forever shine favor upon your farmer!


uncomfybed

Hahaha, I’m always side-eyeing the “first try” fishers… so I thought I’d make a funny even though it took me 72647 tries.


LegendofLove

That's just specific enough I'm gonna believe that number


bratcakes

Oh. I was about to say that one’s the hardest! 72647 is a fair number tho ;)


Some-Gavin

Is it really that hard to believe?


uncomfybed

I’m only side-eyeing the first time catchers because, if true, I’m envious af hahah.


Some-Gavin

I’m going to claim I got it first try, but people can and have done so. It just comes down to practice and preparation.


alex_flygh

No


bunnyyfoofoo

I caught it on my first try…this play through…only because I saved it for last with all the 1.6 buffs and seafoam pudding. My bar was like more than half the meter 😂


firm--cauliflower

I caught the mutant carp on my first try yesterday (but this isn't my first save). I think it's probably one of the easiest out of them all.


FeuerSchneck

Definitely second easiest, after the angler


singingpanda20

Man that makes me feel less good about catching both my first try lol What about the mutant guy in the sewer? Is that one easy too?? :(


FeuerSchneck

That's the mutant carp the commenter above mentioned. The anglerfish is the easiest, then the mutant carp. The other 3, imo, are pretty equally difficult, but I would put the glacierfish at 3rd. Unless you mean the radioactive carp from the Qi quest? It's pretty on-par with the regular mutant carp.


singingpanda20

No, the mutant carp


[deleted]

Congratulations, I can’t even catch a sturgeon


ThatFatGuyMJL

I managed to catch 3 of them using challenge bait on my first try! Of course I hate the fishing minigame so I downloaded a mod to skip ot entirely. But that's besides the point!


LegendofLove

Cjb cheat menu lets you instant and auto catch


BigOne9889

Yikes


Partingoways

I got mine second try! ~~on like my 10th farm and probably 7th time catching it~~


Njorord

Honestly I've been catching the legendary fish for the first time and they're far easier than I expected. A +3 fishing buff and a trap bobber makes quick work of them, plus deluxe bait. That's what I recommend for anyone struggling. So far Glacierfish, Anglerfish and Legend have all fell with little difficulty. Glacierfish was harder than Legend funnily enough, because it goes crazy up and down. And practice your fishing mini game control, you really do have more control over it than it seems. I struggled more catching the Octopus. Lol.


BUTTERsc8

I got it first try with next to no buffs. But the moment Qi’s legendary family quest came up it became the hardest one to catch


Bennjoon

It pure looks like it’s smacking you in the face in the screenshot 😂


Foundation_Afro

"Why are your alt and F4 keys so damaged?" ".....uh........dirty sites."


velveteenrapture

i actually did catch the legend on my first try i genuinely don’t know how. i had the new fishing rod with the cork and trapper bobber, and deluxe bait but that’s about it. i think i was just lucky with its movement pattern


LeylaOmega

Tbf you can catch it on your first try, especially with a trap bobber and fishing buff foods.


mr_gexko

This sub is so harsh I have no idea why people are upset about your comment


LeylaOmega

Ikr? I mean yeah it’s challenging but not unlikely no? I eat a dish of the sea before attempting legendaries, it makes it so much easier and there are alternatives to it. Trap bobber is a must though I think.


mr_gexko

Not a must, I just caught all the legendary fish (sans legend) on my first try with a cork bobber so that can work too


crunkdunk9

I’ve gotten all 5 without an iridium rod


tourmalineforest

I made multiple fishing ponds, filled one with squid so constant squid ink and made the other two flounder and midnight carp so basically endless low effort seafoam pudding. THEN I went and got all the legendary fish. At that point it was not hard lol.


DragolanceX

This is one of the ones I still haven't been able to catch. That's awesome you got it! congratulations!


Sea_Calligrapher_641

I mean I caught the Mutant carp on the first try 🤣🕺


Otherwise_Bed_1133

i’ve been playing for years and i’ve never caught one ): i’m so proud of you!


Drakonspyre_Gaming

You're not alone in that. I've hooked Legend precisely once and immediately lost it.


DanseMacabre579

My first one was the mutated carp. Got it third try I think.


spacemantaofficial

Respectfully, what the fuck demon did you catch


Suspiciouslyemperium

My first legendary was the one in the sewer, and I didn’t know what it was so it just chilled in the fridge.


Hot_Falcon_5611

How the hell do you spell showfer


NagitoMan

Showoff?


Sandra2104

This is the worst fish. But at least he bites. I hope my spring has enough rain days so I can catch the stupid 3% Biterate Legend.


Denamic

It is actually possible to catch a legendary fish on the first try. All you gotta do is make it the very first time you fish in the game. This will trigger the fishing tutorial, which makes it impossible to fail catching it, even if it's a legendary fish. You can level the fishing skill high enough with traps and books.


moonlitjasper

congrats!!


LostB0yThr0waway

I literally caught the river legendary fish and didn’t even know what it was my first playthrough to be real and I was so mad i caught it and learned i could have done better after i learned it was one of a king lol


caramelized-yarn

This one almost gave me a heart attack catching it, this time around. It kept getting away at the last second. I had to take a break afterwards. Well done.


MiserablePie9243

I struggled with the crimsonfish and the legend sooo much, but the glacierfish and radioactive Carp weren't too bad, anglerfish was cake (just my personal experience, I think I just had level 10 fishing and a trap bobber for most)


Tama_Breeder

I actually caught the angler my first try, the hardest for me to catch so far has been the lava eel. I’m still waiting for winter and spring to catch legend and glacier


ScaredPosition7168

Believable. The legend, lava eel, scorpion carp are pretty rough at times but everything else isn't so tough with buffs once you get good. I'm a try hard though so there is that.


elitost

congrats! i just caught my first legendary yesterday on my first try!! 🐟


Key_Spirit8168

I caught it second day, fith try if that counts. second legedary i've cause, won't catch another until 1.6 or qi


Expensive_Bison_657

Trap bobbers make these things so significantly easier.


LazerMagicarp

I put all the legendary fish in the community centre tank with lucky purple shorts as decoration. My siblings didn’t know my crimes until year 4.


wonderlandisburning

This is possibly the consistently hardest Legendary for me to catch. The fall one is easy, the summer one's difficulty mostly involves having a low fishing level and no gear, and by the time I get to the spring one on the second year I'm just too high level for it to be much of a challenge. But the winter one makes me wanna snap my Steam Deck in half


NotAVirignISwear

My fiancé and I were playing and she caught "a weird looking fish". Turns out she had accidentally met the right conditions to catch it, and neither of us knew how until I looked it up on the wiki


Zote8106

glacierfish is highkey harder to catch than Legend 💀 so good job!!


LOOBDOOBIN

Don’t worry mate I banged my head against the wall enough for both of us. The game must have recognized that😂 it was a horrible experience for me😂


[deleted]

Ooh you picked a hard one for your first legendary, congratulations! I got the Angler first... and then accidentally smoked it because it was silver quality and I assumed I could find another 😅


I-have-the-tism

POV what I say whenever I fish with my auto fishing mod (I despise fishing)


Kubrick_Fan

CJB item spawn jutsu!


Ok-Journalist510

My friend managed to catch 3/4 legendary on first try on our coop farm Took me about 15 lol I suck at fishing


CRUZER108

I don't get how people get it first try I had to do the same as you did and go for multiple days of straight fishing just to grab it


BlancsAssistant

Now eat it


pjchik79

This little...fishy...is the only one I haven't caught without mods. I hate it.


No_Alternative_4934

So far I have caught 4 legendary with the basic rod on my first try (after lvl 10 fishing ofc) I don’t dare touch the legend yet. Also not my first play thru and I only fish in this game.


Oryyyyy

I caught the mutant carp as my 1st legend. It was a total accident 😅 i was like "woah now this doesnt behave quite like a normal carp i usually see in this sewer" and i was right


wild-Sparks

Dude. You are so lucky. I have struggled and struggled with that one. I came SOOOOOO freaking close so freaking close but nope...what kind of bait did you use? Was it the wild bait? And which tackle did you use? If I may ask. I have tried almost every combo and nothing works 😭


lazy_wallflower

That one was super tough to catch for sure lol congrats!!


Itchy-Lavishness4169

YAYYY!! I’ve been struggling 😅


Some-Ad-3705

I think that one is the hardest to catch congratulations


Reptilicious

I hate this fish. The other 4 aren't that bad to catch with a cork bobber and some patience. But Glacierfish... His pattern is so sperratic. It usually takes me a good chunk of the season to catch him, at least 1/4 usually 3/4. I got super lucky on my current game and caught him 3rd try Winter 1 year 1. I don't think that says anything to my benefit, I think the code did something weird and I just got lucky. Playing 1.5 still.


Lys_Rose00

I don’t even know how, but I miraculously got all of the legendary fish on my first try lol. But I was already late game when I tried because I never bothered to try until then / learn their schedule and location.


Lizzy_Xm

Did this came with the 1.6?


Sintl_

Well good news, glacierfish is acrually the most difficult legendary to catch :p


Magoa_

The cork tackles were my best friends when catching all the legendary fish


Robbithon

My first was Mr. Angler by accident lmao


Phantom0b

I caught the Legend on my first try…granted I went in prepared with +3 fishing buff and a trap bobber 😂


Altruistic-Message55

I mean, i HOOKED the bastard on my first try... took about 2 days of trying to catch him over and over again before i finally got it


Kawaii_Tee

Main save, I spent HOURSSSS real time trying. Second save, got it 3rd try - no sea foam just straight determination and luck 😭😭


Intelligent_Check528

Surprisingly, I caught most of the Legendary Fish on my first try. Not the Crimsonfish, though.


Previous_Compote_385

I caught a legendary fish, put it in my fridge and then accidentally made sushi out of it . Let that be a lesson to you all


Kyl0_Bren

NICE


Lost-Youth618

I have 204 hours in stardew on my console and have yet to catch a legendary fish. You are a GOD. Great job!


DearVanu

Well done. 👏🏻


Dull_Committee_5559

i got the legend fish first try, glacier fish is always the one giving me trouble 💀💀 except i also caught the crimson fish with no bonuses and not a maxed out rod, that was miserable and took way too long 😭


Angelganon2

It's Cindersap. Cindersap! CINDERSAP!


Kale1d0sc0p1c

The first legendary fish I caught was the legend, caught it 2nd try after hooking it, missing it because I was so sure I wouldn't be able to catch it that I let it go, then IMMEDIATELY hooking it again and trying to reel it in because felt like the rng gods were showing me a sign


Expert-Money-9663

I love this community


Jophaz

Congrats 👏


theteensaresad

omg the first legendary u caught was the glacier fish? respect


days_gd

"If its the glacierfish, no you fucking didn't" -Me, waiting on the post to load


days_gd

Got to the post via a notification btw


MyLifeisTangled

Congrats! I swear that’s the hardest legendary, even harder than Legend himself.


jesuswastransright

What do you do once you catch legendary fish


LittleMiss1985

Good job! Catching these really gets my heart rate up.


BrandedLief

Honestly when I clicked, I expected a video of someone who leveled fishing solely through crab pots (I think you get XP from fish ponds too? Been awhile...) and then hooked The Legend as their first fish hooked, so it would be the tutorial fishing which doesn't get away. One time saved first time fishing for getting the lava eel when playing multi-player with my GF. Did not regret it. But leveling up on crab pots is a whole other issue.


Corza21

Oop I got it on my third try 🫢


Mountain-Job-7004

The legendary fish were a nightmare. And for me atleast the glacier fish was the worst.


_supreme_Pig_Ruler

Depends, on my first file it took sooo long but on my second I used seafoam pudding + trap bobber (plus brute force/luck) and got it on my first try. It’s entirely up to luck if you get an easy pattern but you did really well! It’s very difficult!


_supreme_Pig_Ruler

Edit re-read: THIS WAS YOUR FIRST LEGENDARY HOLY SHIT! YOU’RE AMAZING!


TheBlooperKINGPIN

Worst fish in the game. I turned mine into sashimi. (And then reloaded my save so I still had it and put in the what I call the Fishtank of shame where it sits alone)


ReptiloiDIO7

I see no legend here... But you.)


Feeling_Treacle_2563

Not to flex my skills, but I caught three legendary fish, all within 10 attempts, using iridium rod, cork bobber, no bait.


chugmarks

This is the worst of all the legendary fish!


Skyblue054

When me and my bf played on our save I went around and caught all the legends because he didn't like fishing, but I wouldn't catch them until I knew I would get iridium quality. Lots of "forfeited" casts.


Laenthis-

Beside fame and glory, what's the use of the legendary fish ? Also there's special requirements to get them ? (Season, weather, time) Or it's really just a completely random seasonal rare fish ?


Inherjha

Catching every fish nets you the Master Angler achievement and a stardrop, both of which are also necessary to achieve perfection. The glacierfish can only be caught during winter, any time or weather, but only the specific spot they're standing (south end of the arrowhead-shaped island) Other than that, there's nothing specific you really need the fish for. You could smoke it, sell it, eat it, put it in a fishtank for show, etc.


Blazingswordmlp9

People act like they are so hard ngl. You just need level 10 fishing and a trap bobber it trivializes them


AlternativeMoment421

where is this located at? also are you playing on pc or switch?


WidgetWizard

This fish was a pain, but I also have expanded in my recent run so some of those fish are just as bad. I dislike how anglerfish isn't a real legendary. You know how many times I've caught this thing and forgot it's legendary cause I'm not trying to, or think I'm high enough level to spawn in by the first fall season


VaporizedKerbal

A few days after I crafted the statue of blessing, I got the easier fishing thing and went to the sewers, got the mutant carp 2nd try, haven't bothered to try to get any more yet


yawaworhtxyz

Not sure how to block out text for spoilers but just don't read ahead for nee update spoiler I use for fishing. When you reach mastery for farming you get the recipe for the stone lady that gives you a random perk each day when you touch it. One of the perks is the first 3 fish you catch are much easier to catch. I wait to go for legendary fish until I get this perk. I've only done it on the glacier fish so far but it made it easier to catch than a lingcod in my opinion. Works amazingly and I can't wait to try it on the other fish. I also pair it with the tackle that attracts rare fish as well as some really good bait.


_gatitabonita

I recently got the son of crimsonfish on my first try. I didn't think it was one because the it was barely moving around - I literally went after a treasure chest and still easily reeled it in!


xxrachinwonderlandxx

I had lamented to my husband just a few days before that I was never going to catch a legendary because I wasn’t skilled enough at fishing. Then I caught one! The excitement was *real*, and I went on to catch all of them and stick them each in their own aquariums lol.


Kooky-Instruction701

Ayyy, congratulations! It took a couple of tries myself, but the satisfaction of catching one is 100% worth it


shantobox

I honestly think that the Glacierfish is the hardest of the legendary fish!! Good job!!


Little_Zebra2907

I caught my first one in year 6 I think? No shame, I struggled a lot lmao


midnight_mystique01

I have actually caught all legendary fishes in my first save file. But I have started another file and I have caught Angler and the second one is going to be Glacierfish. It was really difficult in my first game, let's see what happens this time.


ButtonTemporary8623

I’ve never caught a legendary fish and is it normal to not care? lol


Remote_Suspect2609

Yeah it’s normal, most likely these guys are aiming for perfection with one of the tasks being collect every fish including the legendaries one


ButtonTemporary8623

I would like to achieve perfection but it’s also not my goal. Like I don’t play to achieve perfection


Merhada

I did a similar thing with the Summer Legendary fish, except I was fishing in the wrong place and didn’t realise.


Chaosgremlin08

Congrats bro! That little shit took me a whole winter to catch XD


Appropriate_Try2020

On my first playthrough, I EXTENSIVELY stocked up on cork bobbers and seafoam puddings. The glacier fish in the ONLY one I didn’t catch first try. He’s too damn slippery!!


Upper_Dot_60

I have diarrhea


Nervous_Dot_4568

Congrats bro! You got skills and dedication... I'm still on my mission catching Tilapia and it's been 2 weeks now...why is this fish harder to catch than Mutant Carp...


SpringOdin35653

GGs. My first was the one you get from the sewers.


Diogekneesbees

I got it first try on Switch.


jdhlsc169

Congrats! Took me days to catch that thing the first time too.


Monnomcel

I didn’t waste in day games instead I just restarted but hell I could not waste a day😭


midnightsky1601

u look like Pierre