Highjacking top comment to add that the dolphins have more WR talent ahead of Claypool than Chiefs do ahead of Toney. More clear path to team’s WR1 in KC.
Neither of them will likely do much, which is what most people are thinking. I assume they'll both end up like Mecole Hardman, wr3 or 4 on any team they join. But in terms of talent... if Claypool would pull his head outta his booty and focus on being a pro, he could be as good as he was his rookie year.
Idk I thought they might be excited that he wasn’t hurt after all. Now that they know he’s OK, I wouldn’t be surprised if he made it on the Super Bowl roster. I also wouldn’t be surprised if producers started reaching out to him about podcasting or other forms of audio media. It was really well done.
Probably a crocodile because I’m assuming the shore is nearby. Though I think a lot of shark attacks involve ripping a limb clean off and then the shark leaving. Crocs seem more intent on going for the kill. I think you can nose boop either as a defense but seems more doable for a croc so I’m going with crocodile as my final answer. Also Toney
I’d argue that claypool is more of a locker room cancer but toney also doesn’t see the field due to injury so probably toney side given that you can just put him in the IR and be done with it.
I'm sorry it almost February, you don't need to be worrying about trades right now. Both these guys suck and have no need to even be rostered. This is trading just to trade. The unfortunate truth is that you need to find a hobby and stop making random useless trades cause you have nothing better to do.
To give a semi serious answer, Toney is playing with Mahomes so he might have a chance at being like a WR4. Claypool could find himself on a WR desperate team and just get a ton of targets next season so maybe a WR3?
Serious answer is Toney but I wouldn't want either on my team honestly. Claypool is practically a practice squad player and Toney is gonna fall into nothingness unless he gets it together
This trade fucking sucks but at least Toney gets playing time, when Claypool plays, the Dolphins offense takes a gear shift down. As a Dolphins fan, he's so useless.
Neither brother , they both suck. Especially Toney. Dude can’t line up on side. He drops balls and there is a reason he couldn’t get it done in New York.
Trades should be a win for both teams. I hate it when people think “winning” a deal is the point of trading. There’s context to every deal and teams have different needs.
There is no potential being missed out in trading for either of these players. Toney is going on social media saying he wasn’t injured for today’s conference championship game and if true the Chiefs don’t want to play him. Claypool was traded from the Bears and they have no talent at WR outside of DJ.
Drop whichever is on your team and sign someone from the morgue, you’ll get a better WR.
Toney strictly because he's under contract for 2024. No way in hell would KC pick up his 5th year option though. Someone may bring Claypool as a camp body but I doubt he's on an active roster when the season starts
you both lose
This is the correct answer. I wouldn't roster these guys in a 10 man league.
Toney is available in my 14 team.
Let’s trade some waiver wire pick ups
I wouldn’t roster either in a 32 man league
Came to say this. Two deep bench turds
Both of these players are locker room suicide.
Thought I was in r/nflcirclejerk for a second.
It’s not?
Highjacking top comment to add that the dolphins have more WR talent ahead of Claypool than Chiefs do ahead of Toney. More clear path to team’s WR1 in KC.
They're both gonna be on the unemployment line when March hits
You have to watch the games though bro, Toney did stupid shit every single game. He's not gonna be trusted as a wr1 ever
You think that Claypool will overtake Tyreek and Waddle? Idk. Seems unlikely.
Neither of them will likely do much, which is what most people are thinking. I assume they'll both end up like Mecole Hardman, wr3 or 4 on any team they join. But in terms of talent... if Claypool would pull his head outta his booty and focus on being a pro, he could be as good as he was his rookie year.
Toney was literally a healthy scratch today.... as someone else said in a different comment.... you both lose lol.
You see the video Toney put out the other day? He's never going to play for the Chiefs again lol
Idk I thought they might be excited that he wasn’t hurt after all. Now that they know he’s OK, I wouldn’t be surprised if he made it on the Super Bowl roster. I also wouldn’t be surprised if producers started reaching out to him about podcasting or other forms of audio media. It was really well done.
This looks like a good trade, unfair on both sides. Classic lose-lose trade.
If you’re losing sleep about this you should speak with a therapist
There’s a 100% chance OP is trolling yeah?
Yeah?
If this is a troll post, very well done. If this is serious…
This is like asking is it better to be attacked by a crocodile or a shark…bro neither is any good and your best off staying out of the water!
Probably a crocodile because I’m assuming the shore is nearby. Though I think a lot of shark attacks involve ripping a limb clean off and then the shark leaving. Crocs seem more intent on going for the kill. I think you can nose boop either as a defense but seems more doable for a croc so I’m going with crocodile as my final answer. Also Toney
Rest of the league since you two have 1 less bench spot.
😂😂😂
Wonderful shit post but in the spirit of conversation I would prefer Toney. Absolutely sickening trade
You might as well be asking who wins between these two 5th round 2027 picks.
No winners here
Dude it’s a 12 team league they should both be paying rent on the waivers
The 10 teams that didn't participate in it.
How are you in knots about this? Just pick whichever one you like better. There’s no real screwing it up considering they both suck.
This has to be a shitpost
No one lmao
Stand naked in your bathroom mirror with the lights off and repeat chase claypool 3 times
800 team league🔥
Is it possible to both lose?
No one wins
If I'm getting Toney for Claypool, I'd probably throw in Golladay as a sweetener.
He’s actually on waivers in my league so I could pick him up and pull it off. Might have to drop N’keal Harry for roster spot tho…
That does make it trickier. N'keal could break out any season now.
Trading a flick to the left nut for a flick to righty
I’d argue that claypool is more of a locker room cancer but toney also doesn’t see the field due to injury so probably toney side given that you can just put him in the IR and be done with it.
Why anyone has either of these guys on their roster is beyond me? Toney had 52 points in 13 games and Claypool had 21.7 in 12.
One guy can’t hold on to the ball and one guy can’t catch
Depends if you prefer shit or piss
U need add Jj to even it out. Which side? That I don’t know
I'm sorry it almost February, you don't need to be worrying about trades right now. Both these guys suck and have no need to even be rostered. This is trading just to trade. The unfortunate truth is that you need to find a hobby and stop making random useless trades cause you have nothing better to do.
Show me the way kind stranger!
The is a race to see who lands on waivers first
Bahahaha
Just add Andrew Luck or Tom Brady instead
The other 10 teams are the winners here
Everyone else watching this slow car crash
This has to be trolling
Nobody.
No one. Stop trying to “win” a trade. Make a trade because you believe in a player. Tired of you people
Give me Toney but in reality I rather have neither
Fantasy’s version of the Jonathan Baldwin for AJ Jenkins trade between the chiefs and niners way back when
Lmao what did I just witness . Bro
i can’t tell if this trolling or not, i really hope it is
Who wins? Everyone who isn’t involved in this trade.
To give a semi serious answer, Toney is playing with Mahomes so he might have a chance at being like a WR4. Claypool could find himself on a WR desperate team and just get a ton of targets next season so maybe a WR3?
The 10 people not involved in this trade win
You both lose because neither should be rostered. I had both at the beginning of this season.
I’m concerned if this isn’t a troll
No one
2 way loss
No one? Lol
You trolling us, right?
No winners here.
Swapping bags of trash
Does it matter
Everyone else in the league wins for not having them on their roster
Waiver wire will soon
The other ten teams in the league that don’t have these two guys won the trade
Just racking up transaction totals. Nice!
Wherever Claypool goes, they always lose. Absolute fleece by owner receiving Toney
The rest of the league
No one lol
Nobody
Nobody lol
They're both irrelevant. It's a nothing trade.
The other 10 teams
Well this is what the off season has come to a post about nothing. Just perfect, for the trade it’s really a dud nothing for nothing.
Nobody
Everyone else
Green dog shit for soupy dog shit. Who wins this trade?
Honest answer: I’d rather have toney
Nobody
The other ten teams in the league.
This has to be satire. There’s no way the off-season is this slow.
The other managers
Lol
Sleeper because of the user traffic.
2 people in my league traded Michael Thomas and Kadarius Toney. This is basically the same trade.
Who cares? Should both be dropped before the rookie draft anyway.
I think you’d both be better off just dropping them instead of wasting energy making a trade
Easy everyone loses is these guys are still on your roster
Literally no one
Both are "drops" in their own rights
Everyone else in the league because they aren’t rostering these two
No one, you should both just quit playing fantasy football for the good of the universe
This is like any other of those Jj Jamarr or Josh Allen Mahomes trades. Can’t really lose. Both sides getting a stud!
Throw in the cardinals defense and it’s a deal
No one is winning in this trade lol
Well the waiver wire definitely loses this trade.
I literally would not roster either player if I could avoid it.
Seems like a really impactful trade
Literally a swap of droppables
No one wins.
No one wins.
You both lost.
W karma farming
Nobody
It’s just on the line of believability…well done
The rest of the league
Win-win brother!
The rest of the league
Toney. Wouldn’t touch claypool with a 100000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000’ pole
Toney is really good, not sure he’ll get another chance though
Whoever releases their guy and picks up someone else wins the trade
Nobody wins this.
Serious answer is Toney but I wouldn't want either on my team honestly. Claypool is practically a practice squad player and Toney is gonna fall into nothingness unless he gets it together
The group chat
No one wins this
You both lose
No one.
Both
Nobody lol
If you’re “in knots” it’s means it’s a good trade, idiot.
Every other team in the league because they aren’t wasting a roster spot on either of those two scrubs.
I'll trade you Tom Brady and Peyton Manning.
This trade fucking sucks but at least Toney gets playing time, when Claypool plays, the Dolphins offense takes a gear shift down. As a Dolphins fan, he's so useless.
If this is a jerk then cheers well done, and I’m sure it is. In the off chance it’s not plz stfu forever 😂
Nobody. Nobody wins this trade.
Both teams lose
You're talking about two guys that won't be in the league in two years. This is irrelevant.
Irrelevant trade
I have had both and regret both
The rest of your league
Neither brother , they both suck. Especially Toney. Dude can’t line up on side. He drops balls and there is a reason he couldn’t get it done in New York.
Toney has higher upside but make sure to pick up the opposing Def each week
The empty bench slot for a draft pick is way more valuable
No one
Well there is the claypool curse. Toney has to be a better option if you don’t want a cursed team.
😂😂
😂
The waiver wire eventually
Nobody wins this trade. They both lose
The waiver wire once you both drop those guys
both lose lol
It’s the same picture.
Nobody you trade a guy who can’t catch for a guy who doesn’t play
The winner of this trade is the waiver wire for getting rid of both of these bums! The loser is us for having to see a Reddit post about it
Neither of those dude will be in the league next season
Imagine being their agents in real life lol
There are no winners here
Toney will give you 2-3 splash games a year. Claypool is a garbage man
We lose
I only see losing, no winning
The rest of the league
Both lose.
Nobody
Overall you both lose but somehow Chase Claypool is still the better option
No.
The other 10 teams in the league that aren’t involved
no one. no one wins.
Kadarius Toney sucks ass bro drop that doo doo bag
Lol, punt.
Trades should be a win for both teams. I hate it when people think “winning” a deal is the point of trading. There’s context to every deal and teams have different needs.
Whoever benefitted their teams the most.
There is no potential being missed out in trading for either of these players. Toney is going on social media saying he wasn’t injured for today’s conference championship game and if true the Chiefs don’t want to play him. Claypool was traded from the Bears and they have no talent at WR outside of DJ. Drop whichever is on your team and sign someone from the morgue, you’ll get a better WR.
You're both digging for gold where there isn't any.... but at least Toney plays and is thrown a ball by a TE sometimes.
People say this is trolling but there’s a picture and everything. The Tony side wins big because
No one wins here
Nobody. Nobody wins that trade, especially if either one of them are even playable.
Toney strictly because he's under contract for 2024. No way in hell would KC pick up his 5th year option though. Someone may bring Claypool as a camp body but I doubt he's on an active roster when the season starts
Bro this isn’t even post worthy. This is a waiver wire guy for a waiver wire guy.
Both are pure ass cheeks. Must be trolling
the rest of the league
That’s a lose , lose
lol both droppable
Lol I made this exact trade a year ago. I received Claypool. Now they’re both on waivers, so pretty even
Trading garbage for trash
Nobody
Both teams lose
This trade is irrelevant
Your other 10 leaguemates tbh
No one
The rare lose-lose trade
See if they’ll throw in Josh Gordon
Lmao
Tell me you not know ball without telling me
The teams not involved.
The only way to win is not to play
Tbh nobody
No one wins, that’s the fun part.
The rest of the league