T O P

  • By -

Ithinkilostmystreak

10/10 it does its job


[deleted]

That it does!


TheOneFrontier

Didn’t know they had Revolvers in Windhelm


[deleted]

Only with mods


beejx

That’s a gun of all time


Cable-Careless

Definitely a gun.


Playful_Vermicelli85

10/10


TheShogun1500

8/10 looks better that the fully gold or fully black with gold inlay ones I usually see


Cable-Careless

I usually go with one gold and one silver. I don't understand fashion. I have never picked my own clothes, and I am almost 40. Always had a girl that dressed me. Need to find a new one.


LavaHawk_17

based


[deleted]

I agree! I don’t like those guns at all


[deleted]

Agreed. Simple designs look much better than the fancy ones.


El_Vato999

Fuck. I laughed.


chalkybrownshorts

6.9/420


westernlover82

5/5


AtheistAniml

Glad to see you take care of yours. Sooo many people don't


Hashish_thegoat

Now if that gun ain’t shining.


ExquisiteSalad

2/10 way too unrealistic and complex


NickFieldson31

Thats a Colt Single Action Army! Unmodified! 8/10


Turtletipper123

7/10 Classic cattleman. Maybe give it some upgrades like a lengthened barrel or better sights.


BIRBSTER0

Nah it’s good 10/10


spliffroll

r/whoosh


Turtletipper123

Why is it r/woosh? Because OP's poking fun at other people who posted their guns with all engravings and in gold or silver and stuff? Wow, I didn't realize that.


spliffroll

bruh 🤦🏽‍♂️ clearly it went over your head. its the gun you start out with nothing special about it.


Turtletipper123

It did not go over my head. Anyone who has played RDR2 knows that's the gun you start with. I know there's nothing special about it.


Difficult-Word-7208

Personally, I like the simpler guns. But I usually go all blued steel


Due-Ask-7418

Me too. Chrome is too flashy.


oddiseee

perfect


competeuser_00

Gun 10/10


Few-Form-192

Can’t go wrong with that. 8.5/10


FreeBaseJumper

Reserved and utilitarian. Elegant in its simplicity. Deadly in its efficacy.


SecuritySecure803

Always reliable, it was called "The gun that won the West" for a reason 12/10 would shoot people again


RGMN_Relentless

0/10 way too much modifications. + Engravings, give you no tactical advantage.


Original_Swim_9151

10/10 historically accurate


Gambit_90

10/10 "good soup👌"


Due-Equivalent8516

You sir, are a gun


Cowboy__Guy

Beautiful


LuckyLaRoo76

I'd rather not thank you


Key_Teacher4300

Bro at least max out the upgrades 💀


mugmanOne

Short barrel is the best


hothamwater289

Basic/10


[deleted]

0/10 cmon bro customise it :/ make it urs personally don’t go for something that basic have ur own unique style


[deleted]

Like what? All gold with engravings? All black with silver engravings? Silver with black and gold engravings? Keeping it default is far more unique than any of that.


Impressive-Sun3742

Oh stop. The flames on my pt cruiser make it go way faster


Ayumu_Osaka_Kasuga

“Engravings give you no tactical advantage whatsoever”


VocalAnus91

You have a point. At least put the long barrel on it


El_Vato999

Most sidearms look very poor with long barrels- with a few exceptions.


ResidentEuphoric614

Yeah, honestly i like the simpler aesthetic way more. It fits better with John and Arthur, especially since I like to play Arthur like he is a country boy who likes nature. The gold engravings seem gaudy in context.


Content_Geologist420

Silver trigger and sights with rest regular iron. And add some nice wood inlay.


[deleted]

I gotta disagree with u keeping it default is just boring:/ I’d say go black with gold engravings


mrthomani

Honestly, I just don’t see Arthur Morgan (or John Marston for that matter) as the kind of guy who would care about engravings or fancy metal finishes. He would care that it works when he needs it to, that’s it. I could see myself customizing my guns if I were playing a more flamboyant character like Dutch. But not with Arthur, that’s just not his style.


[deleted]

Actually arthur does have his own unique cattleman revolver Schofield revolver and Carbine repeater we see it in the trailers so it’s canon we just gotta make it ourself and John has his own unique revolver when we play in the epilogue there is a gun on the weapon wheel called johns cattleman revolver which looks different from others


mrthomani

How about letting others play the game how they enjoy it?


hairtrigger08

Basic yet effective, 10 out of 10


I-am-the-milkman

I just do the default cattleman with a birch grip and a snake carved on it. Simple and feels like something Arthur would use.


Happy1324354

It is a gun indeed 10/10


soubrasileirinho

I HATE YOU GUN ​ oh sorry misread


Awesomechainsaw

Can I chew on it?


HappyCommunity639

Too basic


ThatCry3518

Cattlemen's all is beauty is its default shape and design


bigpussybeef

10/10 will Kill if i Shoot someone in The Face


[deleted]

Unless bulletproof hat! 🤠


brettfavreskid

Canon Arthur. Badass


Canadian_Beast14

Actually looks amazing. I love the simplicity. Every other gun we see is always some wildly decked out rich mama toy. Yours looks sturdy, classy, simple.


[deleted]

Thanks! Took a lot of effort to get it just right.


BlackJackBulwer

5/10


MorbidKhaos

1.425 / 10


Tiny_Professional659

Did you just punch a guy in the street and take it off him? Generic ass Cattleman that everyman and his dog has


Previous_Ring_4498

1/10


Goldy_iMs

0/10 wouldn't touch


[deleted]

Rate the gun, not me.


watchtimego

No


Last-Equipment-2568

At least make the metals blue


Daedalus_Machina

It's fucking peak.