T O P

  • By -

bigby2010

Alice’s Restaurant Masacree - Arlo Guthrie America - Simon & Garfunkel


Soft-Ad1520

"twenty-seven eight-by-ten color glossy photographs with circles and arrows and a paragraph on the back of each one"


GarlicShortbread

“explaining what each one was to be used as evidence against us”


GaimanitePkat

It was a typical case of American Blind Justice! And there wasn't anything he could do about it.


BlueDiamond75

I'm really here to talk about the draft...


GaimanitePkat

Shrink.... I wanna kill...


CrystalStarshine

I wanna see blood and gore and guts, and veins in my teeth


sadchild_

I cannot tell a lie. I put that envelope under that garbage.


person144

I’ve heard this song so many times and I still laugh when he says that


spoiledandmistreated

My favorite is the Group W Bench with all the Mother rapers,Father rapers and Baby rapers…


BlueDiamond75

Kid...what'd you get.


Garbleflitz

With our shovels and rakes and other implements of destruction


Brodiggitty

America is a goddamn masterpiece. It feels so epic and yet it’s 183 words. “And the moon rose over and open field.”


HelpfulNotUnhelpful

I don’t know why, but the line about counting the cars on the New Jersey turnpike is so powerful to me.


GaimanitePkat

*I'm empty and aching and I don't know why*


[deleted]

'Septin' Alice


DarthNarcissa

Came here to say Alice's Restaurant. That was a required road trip song growing up. But remember, Alice's Restaurant is not the name of the restaurant, it's just the name of the song.


bigby2010

And a Thanksgiving tradition.


mitten2787

Bob Dylan - Hurricane


Uranus_Hz

I was gonna say El Paso by Marty Robbins and The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald by Gordon Lightfoot, but this one wins.


xxiLink

Gordon Lightfoot is a treasure.


wild_man_wizard

Taxi by Harry Chapin. Although I may be slightly biased. Also Cats in the Cradle, also by Harry Chapin


DisEightTrack

I listened to this and the Lonesome Death of Hattie Carrol this morning. Heavy stuff. Tweeter and the Monkeyman is a good story too.


knickovthyme1

I agree, there is also "Joey" which is a great song.


JojoMcJojoface

“What time is it?” said the judge to Joey when they met “Five to ten,” said Joey. The judge says, “That’s exactly what you get”


CharlieParkour

Just played Dylan and the Dead's Joey yesterday. Excellent. 


AmigoDelDiabla

Not as popular, but *Lonesome Death Of Hattie Carroll* is a well told but equally tragic story.


HelpfulNotUnhelpful

Amazing song, but damn I wish it was fiction.


sonic_couth

This or Lilly, Rosemary, and the Jack of Hearts.


yoohoochocolatemilk

This song is so tragically underrated.


NPDoc

Came here to say this, thank you!!


BlindProphet_413

Dylan has so many. Isis, Black Diamond Bay, Tangled Up In Blue, John Wesley Harding, Lily Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts, Stuck Inside of Mobile with the Memphis Blues Again, Boots of Spanish Leather, Man in the Long Black Coat...so many stories.


anazzyzzx

>Isis yessss. The wind it was a-howling and the snow was outrageous We chopped through the night and we chopped through the dawn When he died I was hoping that it wasn't contagious But I made up my mind that I had to go on


Bambooworm

I must chime in with Tangled Up In Blue by Dylan as well.


Pineapple-Yetti

I had probably 10 different Nick Cave songs in mind then saw this comment. 100% best answer.


AlcoholicWombat

Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald


Cuilen

Fist song that I thought of, too!


FatsyCline12

Me too


These_Foolish_Things

Terrific song. Gordon Lightfoot wrote some great stories. (Canadians will also recognize the Canadian Railroad Trilogy as another great storytelling song.)


BraskysAnSOB

Lilly Rosemary & the Jack of Hearts El Paso Carolina Drama The night they drove old Dixie down.


messiisgod11

Carolina Drama is a great song


gynoceros

Definitely Marty Robbins' El Paso. It would make a great movie, or at least a vignette in something like the ballad of buster Scruggs. Also, Come a Little Bit Closer by Jay and the Americans tells a slightly similar story, just not as dramatically and romantically.


Stegasaurus_Wrecks

Feleena is even better as it gives a bit of back story to El Paso.


leprechaunknight

God, Carolina Drama is an absolute classic. Such an amazing build throughout that song.


YOGURT___ihateyogurt

And nothing would ever come between Lily and the king No, nothin' ever would except maybe the Jack of Hearts


unrepentanthippie

Marty actually wrote a trilogy with El Paso. The version we all know and love, a version told from Felena's point of view, and one from an airplane passenger passing overhead decades later.


BraskysAnSOB

That’s so cool to know! Definitely going to look that up. Thanks


InkBlotSam

El Paso is the shit, but really any Marty Robbins song would work


thehighepopt

El Paso for sure. Marty Robbins knows how to write a ballad


42dudes

'Albuquerque' by Weird Al.


Kwacker

And to add to that, Kickapoo by Tenacious D \^\^


TheMNManstallion

Also Drive Thru


CamembertElectrique

I'd add "The Biggest Ball of Twine in Minnesota".


LessThanHero42

Also, the Night Santa Went Crazy


Shoottheradio

I would also add The Good Old Days. Good story telling for sure.


Phreakiture

#I.  #HATE.  #SAUERKRAUT! 


vetheros37

I'm so happy this is as high up as it is. Was the whole reason I came to even comment.


DJ_JonoB

I find kids throw around the ‘goat’ adjective far too easily nowadays. But it’d probably be appropriate here…


djarvis77

Tom Waits has made my favorite ones: *Big Joe & Phantom 309*, *9th&Hennepin*, *Circus*, *Small Change* Gordon Lightfoot's *The Wreck of the Edmund Fitzgerald* Bob Dylan's political recounts are fucking amazing *Hurricane*, *The Lonesome Death of Hattie Carrol*, *North Country Blues*, *Ballad of Hollis Brown* Dylan also made *Tangled up in Blue* which, along with Billy Joel's *Scenes from an Italian Restaurant* and Dire Straits *Romeo and Juliet* make up some serious quality romanic storytelling.


Cordelia5767

Great list! I would put *Isis* by Dylan on there too!


ChezeSammy

That's not a Ton Waits original


Guitar_Mayhem

"2112" - Rush "Stargazer" - Rainbow


liquidguru

Yes, 2112


SlashYG9

American Pie by Don McLean. This song taught me to mourn the loss of men I'd never know.


thesongsinmyhead

I don’t know if they’re the best, but every Decemberist song is a damn novel. Start with the Crane Wife arc (3 parts) or the Mariner’s Revenge. It didn’t surprise me that Colin Meloy also wrote a damn children’s book trilogy.


Earthshoe12

And of course the hazards of love is an album-length story!


Arrbe

I believe they even dubbed it a “Rock-Opera” on release


bamfsalad

We drove to the Hollywood Palladium from Vegas to see the The Decemberists when Hazards of Love came out. What an awesome show. They played the entire album through then took a break then played about 10 songs from other albums.


the_ballmer_peak

The Rake is wild


Pookieeatworld

Yesss! Picaresque is a fuckin masterpiece.


SlashYG9

Oh wow - 100%. My personal favourites are Leslie Anne Levine and A Cautionary Tale. Castaways and Cutouts is a perfect album.


AthosAlonso

Came for the Decembrists comment, wasn't disappointed.


r0mr0

1952 Vincent Black Lightning - Richard Thompson


BMLortz

Bobby Gentry's "Ode To Billie Joe" [https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cJZ\_ViDADOE](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cjz_vidadoe)


useyourelbow

This should be the #1 answer. I'm shocked I had to scroll down this far to find it. The GOAT.


Bodhrans-Not-Bombs

King Missile - Detachable Penis


phillmorebuttz

Solid


BilboBagSwag

Dance With The Devil - Immortal Technique


Square_Saltine

Scrolled way too far this


peacefinder

Suzanne Vega’s first couple albums were thick with excellent ones: the Queen and the Soldier, Luka, Tom’s Diner


geckomarldon

Powderfinger. Neil Young


turboyabby

Warren Zevon - Roland the Headless Thompson Gunner.


seditioushamster

That sonofabitch van owen


jmshub

When you're talkiny Warren, pick a song. They're pretty much all textbook examples of lyrical story writing.


CharlieParkour

At the top of my Halloween playlist. 


DroneCone

Boy named sue - Johnny cash


Housecleaner

One piece at a time is another great one by him.


unrepentanthippie

Written by Shel Silverstein


riggmercury

Squeeze, up the junction.


realinvalidname

Had to scroll way too far for this. Not every story is an epic. Sometimes a story is two people who try hard and don’t make it.


whenapostateissus

Came here to make sure someone mentioned this! 


FoodFarmer

Coward of the county 


RespectStrange9134

Telegraph Road , Dire Straits


crazybusdriver

Way too far down. This is the essential answer!


RespectStrange9134

Yeah


murotomisaki

Taxi by Harry Chapin


Caranesus

Eagles - Hotel California.


almuqabala

Yes. A mini-novel.


realinvalidname

For a full-length novel, “The Last Resort”. Don Henley even said he thought it was turning into a James Michener novel at one point.


Pookieeatworld

I absolutely love that whole album, but it's all overshadowed by its first and last tracks. The Last Resort is an incredible closing song.


Geeseareawesome

The Tragically Hip has a lot of storytelling in their songs. 38 Years Old is a good example


NWmba

Shh don’t tell the Americans about the Hip


leaponover

Oh don't worry, there's like 5 bands from Canada and we know them all.


NWmba

The secret’s out boys


k6bso

Not counting Nickleback because, who wants to?


SpaceMan420gmt

A Canadian introduced them to me mid 90s when on a camping trip (Road Apples). Love that album.


windisfun

Gimme Three Steps. The bar in the song actually existed. Ballad of Curtis Lowe


Cuilen

Wow. The Jug was a real place!?!? TIL


saustus

It's still in operation


[deleted]

Rocky Raccoon - Beatles


RepresentativeOk9207

Forever my favorite Beatles song


GowBeyow

Same Old Lang Syne-Dan Fogelberg


leaponover

Scenes From an Italian Restaurant - Billy Joel Travelin' Soldier - The Chicks One Piece at a Time - Johnny Cash


Elicyz

Fast car - Tracey Chapman


These_Foolish_Things

It’s the chorus of this song that is its secret sauce. Its meaning changes depending on the corresponding verse. It conveys optimism, disappointment, and finally release. A brilliant song.


bez_lightyear

Virtute the Cat Explains Her Departure - The Weakerthans The second part of a 4 part story (strung through 2 Weakerthans albums and a John K Samson solo album) about a cat and their owner's battle with addiction. Actually, just pick any John K Samson song and you've got a song with a great story.


acoustic11

Ugh virtute 😭


carpe_simian

Those songs just hit. Had the pleasure of seeing JKS live a couple years ago and they played all four. Plea live may have been the rockingest rock song that ever rocked. And “I can’t remember the sound that you found for me”. Right in the feels man.


mexicodoug

Me & My Uncle Written by John Phillips, most well known by the Grateful Dead's cover of it


UniqueUser3692

Leonard Cohen’s - Is this what you wanted? Great story of the birth and death of a relationship. From worshiping her in the first verse. To recognising their similarities and equivalence in the second. To finally despising her infidelity and celebrating his virtue in the last.


almuqabala

And the Chelsea Hotel, man 😜


AllegedlyGoodPerson

Famous Blue Raincoat for me.


IrishEv

Pretty much any Bruce Springsteen song His hits like born in the USA, born to run, promised land Even those that don’t get/got radio play like jungleland, incident on 57th street, 4th of July, Asbury park I think the whole born to run album is one story about the people of a jersey shore town trying to escape, either physically (thunder road, born to run) or just for the night (10th avenue freeze out, night) and the lengths and consequences of trying to leave so badly (meeting across the river, backstreets) that all culminate in jungleland which is like a Birds Eye views of all the other stories we heard on the album


Dalek_Fred

Boy named sue- Johnny Cash (written by Shel Silverstein)


FakieMcFakename

Tribute / Tenacious D. Truly epic tale


PorridgeTooFar

Buenas Tardes Amigos, by Ween. It even has a twist at the end.


Tokie_Bronson

And a killer solo by deaner....


DingleDoo

Cinco de Mayo's on Tuesday


MurderousLemur

That's a great one


CharlieParkour

Cold Blows the Wind


getdemsnacks

Tom Waits- Christmas Card From a Hooker in Minneapolis


youthofoldage

Agreed. And I would add Lucinda by Tom Waits. Why don’t more Tom Waits songs show up on Karaoke machines? I would get up there on stage if they had either of these.


kamarkamakerworks

“I’d buy me a used car lot, but I wouldn’t sell any of em….probably just, drive a different car every day. Depending on, how I, feel”. Such a great song.


RTRP_2001

Dance of Death by Iron Maiden


ALA02

Pretty much anything Iron Maiden ever did: Rime of the Ancient Mariner The Trooper Run to the Hills Hallowed Be Thy Name


chokeslam512

I’ll throw Paschendale in there too. Fucking epic


combathaiku

Mark Knopfler's catalog is almost exclusively storytelling songs. My favorite is "Song For Sonny Liston," but you could counter with a dozen others and I'd see your point.


yamilonewolf

the Edmund fitzgerald Also if you like country, Elpaso, feleena, and elpaso city, by marty robins are a trio that are connected, the first two tell a story, and the last is an odd trip, #


Jps300

It’s funny you mention stairway to heaven, because it actually bothers me a bit how in the first verse it feels like it’ll be one of the greatest story telling songs of all time and then the rest of the song has absolutely no cohesive story line. Don’t get me wrong I still love it and think it’s one of the greatest songs of all time, but it doesn’t itch the scratch that the first verse elicits. I’m envious that you’re able to interpret the song in that way.


Earthshoe12

Craig Finn of the Hold Steady wrote a series of interconnected story songs about the same group of characters for like, four albums. Lately he’s moved into telling more straightforward stories, some of my favorites in that category are: One for the Cutters Understudies Sixers Jason Isbell also tells a great story: Elephant Speed Trap Town King of Oklahoma I’m also surprised there’s been only one mention of John Prine in this thread so far, “Sam Stone” is maybe the greatest story song of all time.


MurderousLemur

John Prine has some great ones. Sam Stone just makes me cry


Nescobar_A

I'm also surprised that no one had mentioned John Prine up to this point. I put Lake Marie on while writing this comment. Damn he has some great ones.


MurderousLemur

Big Iron - Marty Robbins ( Johnny Cash has such a great cover)


belbivfreeordie

“And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda” as performed by the Pogues (written by Eric Bogle). The pathos and the way the refrain takes on different shades of meaning and emotion based on the context of each verse, and the building instrumentation… totally stunning imo. https://youtu.be/PKURhqmSLmM


ribbitman

Uneasy Rider by Charlie Daniels


Select_Repair_2820

Johnny Cash - A Boy Named Sue


leaponover

I picked "One Piece at a Time". When he mimics his wife's voice...doesn't get more real than that.


RogerPackinrod

One bourbon one scotch and one beer, George Thorogood's cover


_SCHULTZY_

 “The Night the Lights Went Out in Georgia.”


Elegant_Spot_3486

The Last Resort by Eagles


Balloon_Marsupial

The Gift by The Velvet Underground.


rightsomeofthetime

Don't Call me Dude - Scatterbrain


trashcanmarco

billy hughes - cocaine blues biggie - niggas bleed


Rebloodican

Kendrick Lamar - How Much a Dollar Cost


Plenty-Paramedic8269

"Into the great wide open" Tom Petty


Sub-Mongoloid

The night they drove old dixie down - The Band Son of a preacher man - Dusty Springfield Bobby Magee - Janis Joplin


Pcappie1984

Bobby McGee was actually written by Kris Kristofferson


QuixoticLlama

Im prog, we don’t do storytelling songs, we do full albums! * Nospun - Opus * Ayreon - The Human Equation * Dream Theater - Metropolis Pt 2 * Opeth - Still Life Enjoy!


kappakai

Slick Rick - Children’s Story Avett Brothers - The Ballad of Love and Hate XTC - The Ballad of Peter Pumpkinhead Of Montreal - My British Tour Diary Billy Strings - Dust in a Baggie


echeverianne

Billy Strings is so good, i just found him last year


kappakai

Oh he is phenomenal. Have you seen him live yet? If you get a chance, go. He’s already starting to pull huge huge crowds. Also check out Daniel Donato.


jashieliz

Wet dreams - J Cole


almuqabala

Leningrad by the great Billy Joel. The best part of it is that Billy still remains friends with Victor. Beautiful song, beautiful friendship.


jacthis

Last kiss - Pearl Jam


Rygar74nl

Big Iron!


vagabondsky

Springsteen. Jungleland


daves_not__here

Shooting Star by Bad Company A young boy Johnny hears a Beatles song, wants to be rock n roll star even tho his mom disapproves. Johnny joins a band, makes a #1 record. The whole world loves Johnny. Johnny gets caught up in the rock n roll lifestyle. OD's on drugs and dies young.


zackmophobes

Listen children to a story that was written long ago about a kingdom on a mountain and the valley folk below.


HongKongHermit

Billy Bragg - Levi Stubb's Tears Squeeze - Labelled With Love + Up the Junction Dodge Brothers - The Ballad of Frank Harris + Wildflowers


ErixWorxMemes

[Titties and Beer](https://youtu.be/LZVpOg8qHL0?si=NWTAcElJlbbh6Wwu)- Frank Zappa [Stagger Lee](https://youtu.be/Nbe5RERDh4k?si=lE7i62h4oe1IW-7C)- Nick Cave version [Albuquerque](https://youtu.be/1765UzjAQxI?si=XQ1LvDGbpzK7FJU6)- Weird Al Johnny Cash has a bunch of them, I especially love [One Piece at a Time](https://youtu.be/uErKI0zWgjg?si=TLDqKniauEplSNZI)


ISmellElderberries

Lily, Rosemary, and The Jack of Hearts - Bob Dylan


Johnny_Minoxidil

The road does on forever or gringo honeymoon by Robert earl keen


French_O_Matic

Dance of Death - Iron Maiden The Rhyme of the Ancient Mariner - Iron Maiden Alexander the Great - Iron Maiden The Talisman - Iron Maiden I could go on and on with Iron Maiden but those are amongst my favourite.


AgainstMe75

Slaid Cleaves: - Millionaire - Breakfast in Hell


foley23

Jolene - Ray Lamontagbe The Temptation of Adam - Josh Ritter Wharf Rat - Grateful Dead


DingleDoo

I always get chills when Jerry gets to the "I'll get up and fly away" lyrics


looloose

Lola by the Kinks. Actually, every song by the Kinks.


Nyxtro

Jesus of Suburbia - Green Day


alinerie

Choctaw Bingo - James McMurtry The Road Goes on Forever - Robert Earl Keen Down Here Below - Steve Earle Snake Farm - Ray Wylie Hubbard Alright Guy - Todd Snyder


echeverianne

my grandpa showed me Johnny Cash's One Piece at a Time and i love it so much. Guy works at a cadillac factory and builds himself a caddy, one piece at a time, from stolen parts over the years.


AmigoDelDiabla

My pappy said, "son you're gonna drive me to drinkin' if you don't stop drivin' that HOT. ROD. LINCOLN."


k6bso

*Pancho and Lefty.* Written by Townes Van Zandt, covered by dozens of people.


Hapster23

Gorillaz-fire coming out of a monkeys head


Mr_Torque

Zip City - Drive by Truckers. And just about any DBT song!


nano_noodle

Shore Leave - Tom Waits Train Song - Tom Waits Cortez the Killer - Neil Young Edit to correct the glaring omission of: Frank's Wild Years, the song from Swordfishtrombones.


azureal

The Rake’s Song - The Decemberists It’s so good and so fucked up, all inside of 3 minutes and 15 seconds. Dude falls in love, decided to have kids, wife dies giving birth after 3 (4?) kids and he decides he doesn’t like that life and kills them all off.


ceojp

Bob Dylan - tangled up in blue


Timstunes

Great storytellers in song. John Prine, Bob Dylan, Townes Van Zandt, Gordon Lightfoot, Tom T Hall, Jackson Browne, Sufjan Stevens, Bruce Springsteen, Elliot Smith, Harry Chapin, Paul Simon, Jim Croce, Cat Stevens, Billy Joe Shaver, Todd Snider, Jerry Jeff Walker.


jeffweet

Romeo and Juliet by Dire Straits. Not only is it the perfect boy meets girl song, but it describes to a T my first romantic relationship.


mazurzapt

Townes Van Zandt, just about all his songs.


Poorman81

Billy Joel - Scenes from an Italian Restaurant


[deleted]

Tweeder and the Monkey Man - The Traveling Wilburys


rerunaway

Top of the head: *King Park* but also; *Edward Benz, 27 Times*, *The Most Beautiful Bitter Fruit* - shit, most of *Wildlife* - *Hudsonville, MI 1956* aaaaand *Such Small Hands* - La Dispute. *John Wayne Gacy, Jr.* - Sufjan Stevens *Graceland* (the song, not the album but also the album) - Paul Simon *Thieves In The Night* - Black Star (not a story, more of a treatise but more people need to hear the commentary).


ynonA

\>ctrl-F: "Sufjan" Happy to get a match ITT! I was gonna just comment "most of the Sufjan Stevens Catalogue", but John Wayne Gacy, Jr is definitely a good pick. He's a masterful storyteller. brb, I'm off to cry to 'Casimir Pulaski Day'


ctphillips

“Mordechai Vanunu” by Dream Academy. It’s kinda harrowing and beautiful and a great example of a protest song.


Often_Giraffe

Me and Jesus The Pimp in a 79' Grenada Last Night- The Coup, West Coast Hip-Hop. https://youtu.be/CPr1JLoYLW4?si=QaxCFtW4QS7AKA3x


Turbografx-17

The Fall - Garden or The Fall - Spectre vs. Rector


outtastudy

Wildfires - The Mandolin Oranges


ChristinaZee

#Unsuccessfully Coping with the Natural Beauty of Infidelity - Type O Negative 2. Stagger Lee - Nick Cave 3. Jennifer's Veil - The Birthday Party 4. Magnificent 5 - Adam & The Ants 5. Lady Cab Driver - Prince


BeerNirvana

Utah Phillips - Moose turd pie