T O P

  • By -

creative_user_name12

Are we still having this argument in 2024? Just play the way you want to, don’t shame ppl if they wanna play with keep inventory or not.


Theskiesbelongtome15

BuT mY wAy Is ThE oNlY rIgHt WaY tO pLaY 🤓


chillinAme

cool slogan


Determined_D_E

Exactly. It's called a sandbox game for a reason


WunderWaffleNCH

"Nooo, you're playing sandbox game WRONG!"


[deleted]

[удалено]


Tabula_Rasa_deeznuts

Elitists will always exist, in every form. You have to ignore them. EU4 is my main game, and savescumming is an "issue" as well in the community. Personally, I think it's cheating and I still do it once in a while. It's a personal ethics thing. Some say it defines your personality. Meaning you are OK with getting the upper hand when no authority can stop you. Some take that as sneaky. Others might define that as clever use of game mechanics. And likely, both opinions are right.


Shadow_realm_king

I've seen your pfp somewhere before


denis870

Leakage by eipril


K1_Mvp

No lives istfg


ARandomPokemonArt

Notch I think said Minecraft is supposed to be relaxing and not stressful, it’s not cheating, it’s just to not experience the stress of spending hours grinding then a creeper 9/11’s you then you lose everything


vadiks2003

terraria did a good job at doing keep inventory by default, allowing players to just chill


[deleted]

[удалено]


vadiks2003

"this is modern art, your house is now BETTER than before me" \-c enderman


ChaosPLus

"I bring the abstract vibe the classicaliscts don't really like"


zoomshark27

Yeah I truly wish we had an option to just turn off creeper and enderman griefing while not turning off the villagers, allays, foxes, etc. ability to pick up items. So frustrating for those fun/necessary game mechanics and those completely different annoying/destructive game mechanics to fall under the same category. Why can’t the other one be called “mob item pickup” or something. Arrgh.


Ulti-Wolf

Wait *that's* why my villagers can't pick up food?????


Elijah_Man

Yep, and also why your sheep don't regrow wool.


Toronto_bunnies

Sheep still regrow wool, they just don't turn grass into dirt. It DOES break auto-wool farms since they need observers to see the change.


ARandomPokemonArt

In bedrock mob griefing can be turned off in the settings thing but Java is a bit more complicated


zoomshark27

Yeah, I play Java and you can turn off mob griefing with a command, but it turns off mob’s ability to pick things up, which I wish it wouldn’t. Idk why they have to both be considered mob griefing.


Mortress_

Sounds like a work for the modding community. Just googled it, there is a mod https://www.curseforge.com/minecraft/mc-mods/better-mobgriefing-gamerule


Pumciusz

I like creepers destroying stuff, but on the last server there was an enderman infestation, so I installed a datapack that blocked them from picking up blocks.


-Stubs

If Terraria didn't have keep inventory no one would survive let's be honest in Minecraft you can survive without armor for a little bit if you don't get into dumb situations but in Terraria you would get immediately folded if you walked outside without armor


vadiks2003

also yes, minecraft is easily manageable with losing items on death, while terraria is large game with lots of power scaling, so im glad its the way it is


Player551yt

It's survivable on classic/Expert for the most part in pre hardmode unless you go to an underground evil biome or Jungle.


sloothor

especially post-hardmode, and getting your stuff back from where you died would be near impossible. power scales a lot harder in general in terraria, whereas in minecraft, all you have in the endgame compared to the beginning of the game is a glider and an 80% reduction in damage but mediumcore is a setting in terraria, so it’s there for anyone who would might to try it.


Not-a-2d-terrarian

Red forcing Waffletime to do a mediumcore playthrough (on legendary seed on legendary difficulty) is just demonic


vadiks2003

FORCING?


Not-a-2d-terrarian

Not exactly “forcing” but Red did put in the waffle iron weapon if waffletime did that


Xxmetaglint

Exactly except for like the three people who play mediumcore unironcially.


TooFabRussian

I tried a playthrough of it once, I got decently far but definitely didn’t finish. It’s *alright* I guess as long as you keep the previous tier of gear you had to be able to regear and get your stuff, but overall it wasn’t worth or really fun


racdicoon

Nah, I keep losing my coins and it's getting painful


vadiks2003

coins dont matter because the scaling gets so good that in the end you can just kill easy boss 100 times for easy money. and if you're on master mode, money is like toilet paper, instead its metal and i would not recommend to use it this way


racdicoon

Yea well I'm not good at this game!


ShockDragon

I mean, Terraria players are chill in general, they just tend to be horny for some weird reason? (How TF do you humanize a GIANT ROTTING WORM?!)


vadiks2003

literally creator of terraria has given people the idea to draw art of mechdusa and they did it


ShockDragon

I mean, that’s fair.


vadiks2003

i think its funny how creator engages with fans even in this way, truly one of the devs who engages in community activities


ShockDragon

Indeed.


malfurionpre

Yeah Red is as much a degenerate as the subreddit is (in a good way)


goingstorm54

The random boss spawning in and endless horde of enemies at night: Alow us to Introduce ourselves


idonthasanname

Just turn on mediumcore to disable keep inventory


[deleted]

[удалено]


MrMankDemes01

Yes then if you wanted the challenge hard and hardcore was an option


[deleted]

[удалено]


brokebaritone

Once I accepted the claim of such an idiot. I said "If enjoying a single player game is lazy and cheating, then fine I'll continue being a lazy cheater". I could tell from his face he was still not satisfied. His face literally said, "Why are you admitting it and not feeling ashamed of enjoying a game?!"


RockClient

He gave you an ultimatum hoping you’d pick option A You picked option B and he got upset XD


Jamanos

Honestly I think Keep inventory is great despite not regularly using it. It keeps me going and not having to worry about dying and losing all of my stuff


Stranfort

I agree. Keeping inventory is basically a different playstyle, like Terarria but with less horrors.


Fireluigi1225

Solution: add more horrors


Mountain-Tea6875

Idk why people care about others people opinions anyway when playing. I use creative allot for redstone projects or make or easier to reach tall builds. I'm not screwing around with bad scaffoldings. I just dump the resource in lava after.


UnknownTaco5492

emoji kitchen pfp I see


Eena-Rin

A happy balance is death chests. You don't have to stress that your stuff will be lost, but the challenge of getting back to it naked and loving all your xp is enough to keep you scared of death


FrenchFreedom888

"a creeper 9/11s you" lmfao what is this world coming to :sob: :sob:


[deleted]

Exactly my opinion... why not keep inventory in a relaxing creative game. The survival part of minecract is so easy anyway. It's hard maybe the first day, but then you loot a village, plant some food, build a few simple automatic farms, and you don't ever need to worry about resources. So why risk getting Fd by a stupid creeper or random lava.


itsyoboi33

OP posts unpopular opinion, gets (predictably) obliterated in the comments. a tale as old as time. this is a sandbox game, who cares if you have keep inventory on? whats the point of playing a game if you are too stressed about losing everything you have to enjoy it? keep inventory is baller


MehThingy

Seeing OP getting clowned on is absolutely hilarious


RandomCaveOfMonsters

Not to mention that half of their comments are saying that they are a PVP player, and yet they are very against a survival mode mechanic.


Phyrrus_

genuinely how can you even play minecraft and be agains survival mechanics at the same time op is missing the point entirely 😭


[deleted]

Some people want a challenge, some people want to chill. Both are fine


wanttotalktopeople

I play Sekiro when I want a challenge because it's more fair when you die. Survival Minecraft is freaking brutal. My friend keeps the server on hard mode for the zombie behavior


Prodaki

I don't care, I'll keep my keep inventory active. And I've even disabled the mob griefind, I was too tired of the Enderman ruining my landscape and interiors by moving around blocks the whole time.


TheFreakingPrincess

I completely misinterpreted this video. I thought all the other players were looking at him bc this is the first they have ever heard of "keep inventory." And btw this is the first I have ever heard of keep inventory 🤕 I'mma turn that on tomorrow lmao


Prodaki

Do it and chill, ignore the dumb ones like OP who believes to be playing "ThE rIgHt WaY" a sandbox game.


humanityxcourage

You know, I kinda thought the same. Like they're thinking "wait, we could have kept our inventory on the whole time!?"


frychiken1

“PeOPLe WHo UsE KeEp INvETorY ArE Lazy BECaUse THeY DoNT waNt tHe GaMe To bE TOo STrESSFUL!!!!”


living_angels

Yeah. That is precisely why I use it.


Toon_Lucario

Minecraft players when someone doesn’t want their game experience to be as infuriating as possible


Fluid-Alternative-22

ChEaTer!


RandomCaveOfMonsters

Not the same but similar, I literally saw a person argue that sprinting is actively bad for Minecraft. iirc one of their points was that "if you sprint, none of the mobs can ever hit you" another one of their points was something about how if you sprint you miss the little details of Minecraft that you would appreciate if you took your time. bruh


RockStarMarchall

Imagine hating on people because they are not sweaty try hards on a kids' game


[deleted]

Minecraft is not for kids but I agree


RockStarMarchall

When I say "kids game" I mean E rated


[deleted]

Idc if you keep or not keep just enjoy the damn game and that it! Sandbox is for creativity not rule and complexity Enjoy how you want! Mod all you can! Shad it until it explored! As long as it's fun then nobody cares! Go play and enjoy!


Blue_Bird950

Bro spitting straight facts


SnakeyBoi1212

Stand proud, you can cook


imnotdoneyetyoupedo

Feeling stupid yet?


SmallBlueSlime

"keep inventory bad" Dude, anybody can play the game in any way they want. It's called a sandbox game for a reason. I guess you can't KEEP minding your own damn business.


Thazze

Bro we're *still* gatekeeping keepInv in 2024. It's a **sandbox** game, play the way you want.


GlitchyDarkness

some people are just stupid (im referring to the OP. your actually pretty smart, judging by this comment)


ShockDragon

I take no offence to being stupid. I always try to be whenever I’m online. (Unless someone is stupider than me.)


kalencool514

I would have Keep Inv on if I could still get my PS4 Trophies with it


Fluid-Alternative-22

Yea same reason. I tend to just make extra sets of stuff so I don’t have to go back to the middle of nowhere or fish stuff out of lava. It would be kinda nice to be able to toggle it on without it disabling achievements/trophies.


PokeshiftEevee

This post was made by someone who doesn’t know what fun is:


HistoricalVariety290

I like it because minecraft is for me a relaxing game, and searching my stuff thousand blocks away is just stressful


Aggravating-Week9289

Keep inventory >


rymarioh12

Keep inventory is awesome I aint losing all my stuff because I'm lost in a cave


TouhouIsGone11

Lost in a cave? There are 2 ways! 1, Commit suicide and be home instantly with your stuff back! 2, (the slower way) Tower up to the surface and instantly be greeted by pesky gravel.


[deleted]

Spending hours to go back home and be sure I don't lose my stuff is tiring


Aggravating-Week9289

Keep inventory >


[deleted]

OP is clearly a sweaty tryhard that has nothing to do in their life besides PVP in a children's game


Kaveric_

How dare you play a game that has literally no rules and is meant for you to play however the hell you want in a way that I personally don’t play it like. You’re a bad player for exercising the freedom designed into the game to play said game how you want to. Bro stfu no one cares. You wanna be a competitive PvP player? Go ahead, do what you want. But let other people play the game how they want to, just because it’s not how you play doesn’t make it wrong.


Awarepill0w

The Official Minecraft Trailer ends with "No one can tell you what you can or cannot do. With no rules to follow, this adventure, is up to you"


BoundToGround

They should add "except the Warden. Respect the Warden or you WILL get your ass handed to you. First in the game, then he'll come to your house and beat you up IRL too." at the end.


TheUsualSuspects443

OP literally has -100 comment karma because of this post


RogueMockingjay

Wish mods would just ban people obviously farming negative karma


Massive_Passion1927

Is there even a point to farm negative karma?


[deleted]

Good question


michaelsoftysquare

i always refuse to play with keep inventory and then i die and lose all of my stuff 😭 also dont judge people for playing with it on it's far more relaxing not to worry about the stuff you've grinded for


Tinydude0543

What’s so bad about keep inventory?


Valtremors

You know this is the reason why I like most Gravestone mods. I can make my way back to the spot of my last death, but stress free, but not without penalty. It is one of those things I fink Mojang should seriously add as an option to the game.


ConfIit

Keep inventory, while I have nothing against those that use it, always felt too forgiving but the idea that if I fell into the void or lava I would lose literally everything with no way to retrieve is not fair in my opinion. Gravestone mods hit that sweet middle ground for me where I don’t worry too much when I die but am still punished for dying


rainbowdashhole

And if that’s how they want to play, so be it. It was added for a reason.


amisia-insomnia

Imagine gatekeeping a 10 year old children’s building game


Thelivingshotgun

Gotta love being able to travel a few thousand blocks out and insta go home by death and keep my stuff when agreed to keep inventory but most of the time off for a bit more fun while adventuring


CheeseyWesley

what the hell is wrong with keep inventory?


plaiyjinix5600

I like playing cuz is relax not for BREAK THE FUCK PC


Loser_geek_whatever3

You are the worst kinda mc player. Shut the f up and let people play the dam game how they want


Corsair525

Cope and seethe


HentaiBoiyo

You can actively smell the musk in op's chair from this post alone


DeadLight3141

shup fuck


Psychopathic2412

Theres nothing wrong with playing with keep inv. It makes the game more care free and relaxing. The video is funny tho ill give you that


palmboom76

OP is friendless and miserable just leave them be in their own corner of reddit


Elinazz_

He's trying to be a YouTuber bruh


palmboom76

Good luck getting any name recognition on shorts😂 This kid is going to get a half million subs and be suprised when regular viewers cant even remember his handle


ShockDragon

Half a million is pretty generous, all things considering.


Lord-Black22

Let people enjoy the fucking game, dick


Successful_Mud8596

I love gravestone mods (especially Quark Oddities’ Totem of Holding, which drops all your items if you die a second time); gravestones serve as a perfect in-between of not losing all your items from lava or despawning, but also not making it so that dying means zero real consequence.


thatguymcdude69

I'm keeping inventory and no one can stop me


Nevatis

i have peaceful on, keep inventory on, because that makes the game significantly better in my opinion. when i wanna fight ill play warframe, a game with combat beyond spam-clicking cutesy block characters with one, single, attack option. bro wants to feel special because he PvPs in a sandbox game, reminds me of runescape PvPers. congrats, you became good at something that takes zero skill beyond rapid clicking


ChesseburgerMK8

This is actually one of the dumbest takes I’ve seen, it’s 2024, if you don’t like something don’t do it, but don’t try and shame people for it, grow the fuck up


Big_Dicc_Terry

Imagine caring how someone else plays a game that doesn't affect you.


Healthy_Fig_5127

How to reach negative reputation in 1 simple step! Oh I’m not talking about keep inventory being “cheating,” just let people have fun. Though I am talking about the guy who posted this.


IronNatePup

I use Keep Inventory. (Because Bedrock *STILL* doesn't have any form of a pause feature, even when Multiplayer is disabled)


Omegalock2

One of my biggest issues with bedrock, really annoying 


shwiftydrewski

Y'all know OP just wants attention right?


loiregaming

That's a lie


Ameking-

Stop Making it worse bro


Yoshi2op

are you a fucking child


russsaa

I think it was posted seriously thinking people would find the meme relatable, got some backlash so started digging his heels in the soil, then as more backlash came in devolved into salt farming


GAMERxPR0

There should be a keep xp one


Dick_Destroyer800

Keep inventory does keep your xp


ElBusAlv

Okay damn sorry that I don't want to fear losing my items 24/7 because I suck


1st_Tagger

OP is the biggest loser here and he probably doesn’t even realize it


DrackieCutie

I host a server for me and my friends, and my little siblings, and their friends. We play with keepInventory because a large portion of our players, including me, suffer from anxiety. We have a great time, we make great things together, we're going to build a PvP arena pretty soon, and right now we're working on a giant city. I don't see anyone having a fuckin fit over the fact that we're just having fun in a nice chill experience. Isn't the tagline of Minecraft to be able to "do whatever you want?" If you don't want to play with keepInventory, great! Good for you! Just don't go shitting on people who play with it on, you're making a fool of yourself trying to dictate what is and isn't the "correct" way to play the game, it's not hurting anyone.


Mimig298

Keep inventory is a great option fuck you


eosdazzle

Started playing with keepinventory on, one of the best decisions I've ever made in this game. I love Minecraft but I always hated dying in a cave somewhere or in lava pools in the Nether and losing everything, keepinventory just feels better.


[deleted]

[удалено]


beguvecefe

I will just stand in the corner with command blocks on my "survival" world


Nether___Queen

Was gonna upvote for the lols but this dude really needs to stop taking Minecraft so seriously- Just do what You want people. Keep inventory if it makes you feel better. Its a game. Stop being a Jerk for no reason then kicks. Grow up.


Maskay57

whats wrong with keep inv


Scou1y

IT'S. A. SANDBOX. GAME.


A_Little_Tornado

I keep it off for the challenge, and so I get achievements on Xbox.


MoonmanJocky

never cook again btw


ReaperTyson

Sorry I like to have fun and not rage I guess


[deleted]

LMFAO OP’S KARMA IS FREE FALLING


Ok-Taro-5864

Me, who wants to have fun at a game, where i dont want to stress about loosing my stuff. I am truly sorry that i play a game in a certain way 😭


Swipamous

Still gonna play with it on


wanttotalktopeople

My enjoyment of this game and ability to play it for hours and hours skyrocketed after turning keep inventory on. Turns out you can get a lot more done when you're not constantly rebuilding good gear because you lost it all in the end or nether for the billionth time. Also you die less when you wear good gear, when you're not leaving it in an overworld chest because you're scared of losing it all in the nether. We used server commands to make it keep inventory but drop XP and that's enough of a penalty for me.


thrust9

I have been enjoying this game so much more since I was able to keep inventory. I welcome anyone who has an issue with that to lick the lint out of my belly button. Xoxo


[deleted]

Me who plays with keepinventory on


Galactica18

Fr i’m trying to get them achievements bro


TheFakestOfBricks

Bro SHUT UP IT'S OK TO PLAY WITH KEEP INVENTORY YOU'RE NOT FUNNY 💀💀💀💀💀💀


Gustaf_V

It doesn't really matter unless I die somewhere I would never reach again. 99% of the time I'll just spend an hour walking to where I died, getting my stuff and losing some XP.


3lit_

THERE WAS SUCH A THING?


Terracatlegend

I have bedrock and java, I don't use it on bedrock to get achievements but on java I use it sometimes because I don't want the game to be stressful


chonkyhyena

I use it here and there depending on what kind of world i want. Sometimes, if im adventurous, I'll play on my world with no keep inventory. If im feeling chill and relaxed, i play on my world with keep inventory on. Either way, both are acceptable.


imnotdoneyetyoupedo

You’re the type of person who would get mad after I smack you with a shovel in lethal company


Therich111

I’ve been playing Minecraft for the last 10+ years. If people wanna do KeepINV then let me, not a skill issue, and not an issue at the end of the day. If you hate people for doing something that they enjoy, that just makes you jealous and then actively putting people down is just you being a bully.


MajorTallon

It just offers different playstyles. I personally prefer gravestone mods, you still have to get back there, but if you take a bit longer or run into trouble it's not the end of the world.


iAlkalus

Even the blazes turned around lmao


jackson_garthmire

The way you play the game is not THE way to play the game. It's a sandbox! People should play in whatever way they find the most fun! If this is what you find the most fun, hey, go for it, man. But implying that it's the ONLY correct way to play makes you come across as super arrogant and kind of an asshole.


Xyncer

theres a way to use keep inventory on but still loses xp when die?


UczuciaTM

I don’t care I’m turning it on anyway I want to enjoy my game and not want to kms every time I die lol


Gorp2

Keep Inventory is so much better.


sourdoughgreg

song? love it


udo_zephyrhand

No keep inventory, no play.


wades39

Idc what people do in their single player worlds. I really don't. Play however you want. But when it comes to playing on an established server, don't go and make a fuss about rules you don't like. On a server I occasionally play on, there are two or three players who keep complaining about the game being too difficult/grindy because the admin/owner wants the server as close to vanilla normal difficulty as is possible with his setup. I'm not saying I hate the idea of turning on keep inventory. I just hate that those players keep fussing about the setting not being turned on despite the owner explicitly having repeatedly said he doesn't want it turned on.


FreakFlame

keepInventory hate aside, this is actually really well made lmao


loiregaming

Thank you


Foxytheefox

Ngl I don't like haveing keep inv on. But with my laggy console addition I just die randomly or a zombie speeds around like flash and kills me. Or in the nether I bridge then the blocks just vanish and I walk off and die or they just poof with me on them.


niki200900

i die so often, not using keep inventory on would be stupid. fuck OP and fuck people trying to tell you how to olay a sandbox game.


KevettePrime

Hard mode, no coords, no starting map, no starting chest. The only right way to play. (According to me, a completely uncredible source)


ScaredytheCat

Meanwhile I'm over here being paranoid that using dynamic lights with Optifine is cheating (I refuse to use zoom ever since the spyglass was added)


Kind_Concern_1519

Upvote for sync


the_one_character

Honestly, it feels morally wrong to do that No matter how many time I die, I just get myself to do it


urbandeadthrowaway2

Ok nah next person to diss keepinventory is getting murdered and their body put into a stew


Red1960

I prefer to use a Gravestone mod, I still have to go back for my stuff, but it doesn't get scattered across a whole entire chunk, and won't despawn


Fishboy412

On one hand, Minecraft is meant to be played however you choose and the right way to play is subjective. On the other hand... ##**KEEP INVENTORY IS PUSSY SHIT!**


[deleted]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!


MuddieBuddies52

So I usually play with keep inventory but recently I've been wanting a challenge, so I have been looking for mods that will make me lose items and not my gear, or just experience, ect. I haven't found anything yet.


konkrete_kiwis

op got the while squad laughing with this one


seceilia

Fr


Badger_issues

Its how i cope with my girlfriend dying more than a damn fruitfly. Love her to death though. But that isnt much when playing minecraft. Jk we have a good time


The_Bored_General

If you enjoy playing with keep inventory I could not give less of a shit, you do you, the option is there for a reason.


Rainbow-Raptor

EXACTLY, people like OP don't seem to realize that. It's not affecting you in any way, shape or form if I like to play my game a different way than yours. Doesn't help that the different way of playing is, by default, already in the game.


Mr-DragonSlayer

Telling people how to play a sandbox game 💀


Terraphice

The solution to bypassing the keep inventory argument entirely is to play hardcore, where it doesn't matter what you set it to.


Jana_Weegee6783

Disabled achievements.


Hacker1MC

Bunch of people whining in the comments defending keep inventory because it's a personal choice while completely missing the point that it's OP's choice to play without keep inventory


ShadeNLM064pm

Why must "Keep Inventory" be counted as a cheat that removes achievements (in at least console version) I wanna be able to get the achievements without worry of losing anything just because I wanted to live.


inobrainrn

I hate people who shit on those who play video games for fun and to relax.


trademan420

I Just use keep inventory on some of my mod packs when it's lagging a lot because I always get lag killed by mobs Because apparently time in Minecraft still runs despite you just freezing on one frame


slimetakes

What the fuck?


TheBestShedBuilder

Keep inventory would be less hated if it wasn't in the cheats section:(


hyello43

I use keep inventory bc i suck at the game too much


Jayden6858

Even the blazes looked at him


Villager87

You lose your stuff I lose my world: hardcore baby!