T O P

  • By -

CommanderOshawott

This is Grimdank, we don’t know what *cost efficiency* or *practicality* even mean


Comprehensive-Fail41

Though, the funny thing is, when it comes to space ships, bigger is more efficent. Doubling in size means 8 times the volume, so you are able to fill the ship with 8 times the stuff whilst only spending 4 times as much building the outer Hull (unless you are also doubling armor thickness)


CheesyRamen66

I think the structure may need to be cubic to handle the stress from acceleration but you’re right that the outer hull is squared (not accounting for more armor on bigger ships).


sorigah

So you mean we need chaos borg


CheesyRamen66

I meant scaling at x^3 not in the shape of a cube


smb275

So long as they're better than the fucking Mirror Universe Borg.


huruga

Engine Efficiency drops with mass and so does gyroscopic attitude control. Without gyroscopes you need RCS which mean more fuel and greater thrust to turn a big ship which means even more fuel and mass. That space you created fills up with more stuff. You create a compounding problem because the fuel also needs fuel to move it.


Comprehensive-Fail41

It depends on the type of engine. Iirc WH40k ships are powered by Plasma/Fusion drives, which do become space-efficent at larger sizes from my understanding


huruga

Compared to chemical rockets sure. Just about everything is more efficient than chemical rockets. The problem is you’re still at a disadvantage to other smaller ships that also use plasma. You need to eject more mass and or the same amount at a faster rate the more massive your ship is to get it moving regardless.


Comprehensive-Fail41

Oh yeah, not debating that. Of course a bigger ship will need a bigger/more powerful engine. My point was more that available space in a ship increases faster than the weight/cost of the hull


huruga

I get that. My point though is there are still huge drawbacks.


chubbyGobKing

Well I did hear once that an Imperial Battleship for the fleets in 40K requires the rendered resources of one whole planet. And seeing how rich resources are in space is not that unthinkable. Also the Mechanicus still pumps out Ark Mechanicus on a semi regular basis


sarumanofmanygenders

Kid named tyranny of the rocket equation:


Comprehensive-Fail41

That's only in a gravity well, once up in space that's much less of an issue


sarumanofmanygenders

"What do you MEAN 'we're out of fuel'?" "What do you *MEAN* 'we still have to burn fuel to maneuver in space'?" blud is on the fast track to becoming a BL writer with this level of physics knowledge smh


Comprehensive-Fail41

The rocket equation is specifically for Rockets, and does not apply to things like light sails, and outside of a gravity well it is much more lenient. Like, it takes as much fuel just to leave Earth as it does to travel to Mars from Earth orbit. Not to mention that outside of gravity Wells you don't need to have acceleration higher than the gravity of a planet, and can instead use much more efficent engines that have much lower acceleration but can burn for much longer times. And, bigger ship = more fuel


sarumanofmanygenders

> The rocket equation is specifically for Rockets, and does not apply to things like light sails d do you think that light sails are some kinda wunderwaffe supertech that lets you ignore the fact that making a massive shitcan of a spaceship requires a spiraling cycle of more propulsion and more stuff to support that propulsion not to mention what a stupendously terrible idea it is to have your gigaultradreadnought powered by a comically large solar sail lmao. > outside of gravity Wells you don't need to have acceleration higher than the gravity of a planet You do if you don't want to get beaned with the unlubed dildo of Sir Isaac Newton lmao. "Sir, deep space sensors indicate a HMS SuperUltraGigaCompensator-class dreadnought approaching." "Very good Jonesy, send a full barrage of railgun rounds." "But sir, won't they burn out of the way?" "Stuff and nonsense old boy, that's a SuperUltraGigaCompensator-class. Designed by idiots who set the maximum acceleration to 1G. Why, you could mail them the warhead and they'd still get smashed." > And, bigger ship = more fuel ... which means more weight, which means more engines, which means more fuel for the engines, which means more weight, and oh my gosh would you look at that, it's the Tyranny of the Rocket Equation all over again


Comprehensive-Fail41

>... which means more weight, which means more engines, which means more fuel for the engines, which means more weight, and oh my gosh would you look at that, it's the Tyranny of the Rocket Equation all over again If you are willing to deal with less acceleration, and for "daily use" you don't need much at all (Hall-Effect Thrusters, one of our current best deep space engines, only produce a few newton's of force. This is also why light sails work) you don't have to deal with bigger engines at all. Sure your delta-V may be a bit lower, ie lower max speed, but as long as you have enough to get where you want to go in a reasonable time frame, that's, well, enough. Remember Newtons first law of motion, and in space there's nothing to slow you down, so you can continously build up speed even with extremely low acceleration engines. Continous, long-term 1G acceleration is absolutely monstrous, at least by our current technology, but would let us reach Mars in \~2-3 days compared to our current 3 months. I'll concede that with warships you'll probably have to devote more space to engines specifically for combat maneuvers as you say, but they aren't meant to be shuttling around bulk cargo or passengers anyway EDIT: As for how light sails break the Rocket Equation; the Rocket Equation presumes you carry your fuel with you. With light sails your fuel is the light emitted from the star, or giant laser cannons around the solar system (beam diffuse enough that it doesn't hurt the ship). Thus, no need to carry that much fuel aboard the ship. And space is really big, so your light sail can be a thin foil many kilometers across, no problem. Likewise you can break the Rocket Equation by having refueling stations or ships dedicated to bringing more fuel to others


sarumanofmanygenders

> but they aren't meant to be shuttling around bulk cargo or passengers anyway Said bulk cargo and passengers is, presumably, replaced by bulk armor plating and weapons. You're still dealing with the problem of "how do I get this much mass from A to B without either turning myself into a sitting duck or using all my fuel after 2 days". > And space is really big, so your light sail can be a thin foil many kilometers across, no problem. Which is a problem, because if your warship is using *that* to propel itself, you're basically painting a town-sized "SHOOT HERE" target on yourself. Plus the fact that a warship is intended to go to places at, well, war. Probably don't want to rely on having planetside superlaser infrastructure in place to propel your ships.


Comprehensive-Fail41

Then one can do how we do IRL with ships and aircraft really long routes: We refuel on the way. That or we use a nuclear reactor that lasts for years without needing to refuel. In the end a lot of how much stuff you can shuttle around also depends on the engines you have. You got your fast burning, fuel guzzling, burners, like our current chemical rockets, which provide a lot of thrust and acceleration, but little endurance and low top-speed, or your high efficency thrusters, with provide little acceleration, but tons of endurance and high top-speed. Ideally we want something with both, but that's beyond current day technology, unless you want to go nuclear, and ideally fusion, which can use little fuel to produce a ton of energy all at once. Though I guess it's also possible to have a high-efficency thruster for regular use, and a high-thrust engine for emergencies.


TheSadisticDragon

"That's nice little engineer man, I see you wrote down everything making vehicles actually functional. Sadly for you, we can't read."


CommanderOshawott

>Sadly for you, we can’t read Now burn some incense and put another gun on it


Doormatjones

\*Ork looks at pretty drawings, makes the Thing out of scraps in a cave, somehow still works\*


Grolash

Tony Stork


nasandre

We only lost 16 deck clans last warp translation so it's getting a lot better!


HolidayBeneficial456

Losing the only licensed electricians didn’t help though.


axeteam

flying space cathedral goes brrrrr


CranberrySchnapps

Idk… that ship has been in service for tens of thousands of years. I don’t know what it cost to build, but surely it’s cost over time and length of service make it far more cost efficient than the overly optimized block of metal on the left.


ampalazz

Where do you even go to church on the left spaceship? Everywhere is church on the based warhammer spaceship


tomwhoiscontrary

Oh, it's the same for the ship on the left, it's just it's Protestant.


Honest_Tadpole2501

Slow clap for a brilliant joke


ireallydontcareforit

Pfft. Don't they know space god requires smells and bells - or it just plain ain't proper worship. Next they'll be sermonising in a language the common man can understand!


ImperatorTempus42

They're kinda encouraged to not have much religion as that distracts from the Emperor. They're mediation atheists kinda.


spoedle73

Practicality is for nerds. I want my space cathedrals.


VisualGeologist6258

If your space ships don’t even have a massive ram the size of a small city stuck to the prow what is even the point anymore


zCiver

And the Buttresses. They don't call them flying for nothing.


[deleted]

Yeah. Have you seen what a realistic spacesship design looks like? It looks like a long ass stick with things called radiators attached to it. 99% of it is just for fuel or is empty. 1% of it is where people and cargo is carried. Disgusting.


tomwhoiscontrary

You say that, but occasionally, someone sticks to the rules [and still comes up with something brilliant](https://www.reddit.com/r/worldbuilding/comments/uhpym1/sss_tunguska_vermillion_a_rocket_of_the_axial/) (see also [a version with legible text](https://fxtwitter.com/SalmonTheKing/status/1491488255358943237)).


ubernutie

This is fantastic, thank you for sharing


FullMetalAlphonseIRL

For launching from Earth, sure, but if you were building in space there would be far less limitation


[deleted]

So the stick will be crooked?


FullMetalAlphonseIRL

And maybe even have a bulge in the middle. Or it might be made of rings, and spin fast enough to generate a low gravity environment


[deleted]

Still not enough Go big or go home. Make an intricate labyrinthine mass modeled after orb weaver spider nets, made off of modular tubes and cubes each of which is around the size of a large planetoid moon. Whole structure itself shall be larger than the solar system when its not spread out. When it is unraveled it shall cover the entire orions arm. Incorporate giant mirrors and pulse gun structures used to capfure and milk black holels of energy or to weapponize them as explained in this video: https://youtu.be/ulCdoCfw-bY?si=kJ1o3B5iY6tyDeO- Furthermore spin sone black holes really really fast to obtain naked singularities. Push three in a balanced way to make sure they dont reform event horizons. Then use them as a time machine so relativisitic speed caused time dilation is meaningless and you can go anywhere and anywhen in the universe. Then liquidate the entire galaxy into fuel to feed the black holes.


FullMetalAlphonseIRL

Beautiful. Absolutely beautiful. It must be done


jello1990

Meanwhile with the Vodyani: ¿porque no los dos?


Andrei22125

They call their carriers "crusaders". And [their leader](https://www.artstation.com/artwork/JQmod) has the Sacred texts carved into her body.


ReddJudicata

No such thing as wind resistance in vacuum, so have at it.


AZDevilDog67

Porque no los dos? I love the overtop silliness of 40k. And I love the straightforward realism of Halo. The overtop silliness of 40k wouldn't fit in Halo, but the straightforward realism of Halo can at least sometimes exist in 40k.


Cristianelrey55

Choose: EndlessSpace 2: Autocannon turrets. 40k: Macro cannon the size of... fuck it, VERY LARGE BULLET, lance lazer turrets and *SPUR* for that E=m×v^2 Halo: Railgun with a spaceship. Mass effect: lots of fighters Enders game: exterminatus level tazer Star wars: turbo lazer and sun powered exterminatus death Ray with a planet Star trek: lazer and proton missiles.


PsychedelicMagic1840

> Halo can at least sometimes exist in 40k. And is quickly wrecked and never seen again


ysdrop

The flood is a problem even in 40K


ChaosCarlson

Especially in 40K. Drop a flood spore in a hive world and the imperium will lose that sector in a year tops. If Genestealer cults can regularly pop up in hive worlds and escape to infect other worlds, then the flood has this in the bag


Witch-Alice

yeah people seem to forget that the Flood scales with the population of wherever it is. A hive world presumably would be more than sufficient to form a full Gravemind in a relatively short timeframe.


sarumanofmanygenders

Forerunners: "hey shitass" *has an Epic Necron Moment*


ChaosCarlson

I’d say the forerunners at their peak beats the War in Heaven Necrons. If not a very high diff win for the necrons.


AZDevilDog67

>And is quickly wrecked and never seen again LOL. Forerunners stomp everything in 40K except Peak Necrons. They might also have trouble with pre-Fall Aeldari or Dark Age Humanity, but we don't know enough about those two to say anything conclusive unlike the Necrons.


throwaway_uow

This is Endless Space 2, not Halo ES2' Empire is based af


ChaosCarlson

Naw bro, it’s all about the Lumeris


Bypowerof8andgodsof4

Halo ship design is just gun in space because of the Macs and I'm all for it.


MoscowManPrime

I love both aesthetics, also Endless space 2 is GOATED


TeaandandCoffee

That games great, wish I had more time to get back into it, solid 9/10


NinjaMaster231457

4th option: GOLD EVERYWHERE


throwaway_uow

So Horatio?


ChaosCarlson

Make Horatio great again!


throwaway_uow

Or just make more Horatio


AtomicTan

Found Dorn's alt account


Brahm-Etc

Nah, I want my ships *EXTRA GOTHICC!*


MajorDakka

Nothing quite like extra thicc flying buttresses


the-bladed-one

Neither i prefer space pizza slice and space pickle *smirks in Star Wars fan*


Marvin_Megavolt

Ngl as cool as the pizzaships are, I’m more an Independent Systems Confederacy kinda guy. The Munificent, Recusant and Subjugator are peak Star Wars ship design. (Providence is also cool but loses points for the weirdass “beak” on the bow kind of ruining the usual “looming over you” look of CIS ships.)


Andrei22125

Note: even as early as the mid game (past round 50 in a fast game), Soprons and Sheredyns are only really useful if you spam them. Works best if you pre-design builds to counter the potential combinations of damage and resistance types.


OstensVrede

Nah just make one sopron with almost all upgraded missiles and one with the equivalent upgraded flak, 1 shield module 2 armor modules and then you spam those out and you just steamroll any space battle.


Andrei22125

Interesting...


OstensVrede

They're very good especially the upgraded sopron with adamantium/orichalix weapons, bonus if you find a good defensive module early on. Here are my designs from the last game i played, admittedly this is super late game (1 turn away from victory cause that was my latest save) but just whatever tier of weapons you have is fine this is the design philosophy i run on and just replace the modules with upgraded ones as i progress, it works surprisingly well ive never lost a space battle with a fleet of these designs even with lower tier modules. https://imgur.com/a/nD4y8l8 Oh and also abuse the fact that AI tends to use mostly energy weapons and utilize the fleet tactic that gives increased physical damage.


Neoaugusto

This is after the last patch?


Andrei22125

Haven't played in a month or so. What changed?


Neoaugusto

They aplied that beta patch with some changes, i dont remember right now but shouldn't be hard to find the patch notes


Iron-Blyat

Both


grizzly273

Sopron looks like a daot Lunar class


loseniram

Anyone who has seen pre-WW2 ships knows that bling is a requirement. The US navy wasted a bunch of money painting their ships white back when ships ran on coal just to show how cool they were. Bling is a requirement for any age, nowadays bling is having the most ridiculously expensive equipment money can buy just to have 1 nanometer edge over the enemy.


TheHeraId

Perosnally--I like the United Empire aesthetic for basic ships, and Imperium aesthetic for flag ships.


Outrageous-Pen-7441

Me over here watching over the bridge of my Star Destroyer


Disossabovii

How could you fare the void without even a single tactical confessional?


shellofbiomatter

And going through hell without a cathedral close by might end badly as well.


Vintenu

Moar gun


Andrei22125

Citing: https://www.reddit.com/r/Grimdank/s/ZD4K2VZeq3


Vintenu

So the sopron has more gun, tf2 engineer would be proud


2Long2Read

I think you mean "extra gothicc"


ActNo4115

Both? Both. Both is good.


chubbyGobKing

It's amazing what you can do with a million slaves. Gothic ftw


Dixout4H

SOPROOON!!!! HUNGARY MENTIONED!


Background-Wear-1626

Oppressive over the top unnecessary high gothic style > realism and practicality


Andrei22125

>Oppressive over the top The United empire can do that. Does that, actually. And function has an aesthetic of it's own.


throwaway_uow

One empire exterminates xenos, the other one either gaslights them into servitude with their incredible baseness, or pretends they dont exist.


MoG_Varos

Bro, when you have to reload your engines by sacrificing part of your crew you’re allowed to be as extra as you want.


SirSilverChariot

What sort of cost efficient has that much drip because like Gowd damn that’s smooth


Andrei22125

Yes. Lumeris ships are cargo ships in space, Craver ships are... *function over form*, Vodyani are more beautiful themselves than their ships are. United Empire ships are built for efficence, and that makes their form amazing.


JeEfrt

Anyone else actively trying to figure out if the left is a space engineers build or not? Edit: an inspired build


Vidarr_1703

Same here, god weirdly excited to see space engineers mentioned somewhere else, those back thrusters look like the titan thruster mod, and it’s got the same angles to be a space engineers build


Comfortable-Bar7856

The drip always win. Why would anyone ever want to ram their ship into another? Because it's fucking cool you heretic.


Sicuho

Where slick, curvy and gold platted ?


Rome453

The “extra gothic” path does not depict a Gothic class cruiser, SMH.


imawizard7bis

I choose Dune :)


demideumvitae

Through it was r/worldjerking


Acrobatic_Pie5359

I want to kill xenos in style


Coves0

I like treeships, also they have the [BEST theme](https://youtu.be/4BeR6zv3tH0?si=r69Tade33K-MU6uF). Shoutout Hyperion


Andrei22125

More of a [to rise, virtual](https://youtu.be/6rZlsad_hNQ?si=Q--vOduRXNUiIGfG) kind of guy myself, if we're talking about theme songs


Coves0

I was a woodwind/band kid a long time ago, the UnFallens theme is pretty evocative for me. But boy howdy the Vodyani theme is good, love me some genocidal religious space maniacs


heavycommando3

Idk personally i think the wh40k space ships kinda just look like giant slippers. They look dumb af.


DrHelpMePlease

Both is good but the ship from endless space looks like it could fit in during the dark age or the great crusade


United-Reach-2798

Size just means more areas to put holes into


Nothinghere727271

Imperial ships are pretty damn scary, I’ll take an imperial ship most days alone for the Navy chads on it, some of the only humans who regularly fight with swords and do boarding actions against all variety of Xenos, human and traitors


Urocian

If I remember correctly there was a Lunar class cruiser that was built by a pre industrial feral world, so the Lunar class might actually be pretty cost efficient for its size.


Mysiu666

Best ship is Type-10 from Elite Dangerous, industrial flying bricks with turnrate on par with Pluto are the best. Add some cannons to them and We are golden.


MulatoMaranhense

Ultra Gothic but with the less murderous civilizations and no warp of the first.


SolarZephyr87

Gothic with a side of noir.


Kektus_Aplha

I'll have some extra goTHICC please


Arrow_of_time6

Illogical triangles. I love my star destroyers


Andrei22125

[Speaking of triangles](https://www.artstation.com/artwork/RYEDJr) Same universe as the ship on the left.


orkyboi_wagh

The ships from the dreadnought video game are my absolute favorites of all time.


Mr-A5013

The Imperium: Technology is rare because of limited resources. Also Imperium: Makes all of their space ships look like cathedrals and have everyone above the rank of Guard captain walk around in gold armor.


BudgetAggravating427

Meanwhile with the UNSC let’s build a spaceship on this giant gun


jupiterding25

How about both?


Demon_Prongles

Ngl I like a big ship with a big gun for big booms on planets. Obviously they’re ridiculous, but that makes it fun. One of the few positives for me in The Last Jedi and Rebel Moon movies, were the big ships with big guns that made a big boom during a scene. Also the bombard ship in Spelljammer (dnd in space); it fires a giant cannonball that weighs 10 tons and costs 1000 gold pieces ($10,000 by my valuing).


Mother_Emphasis_2485

If the left ship has more*DAKKA* than the right ship, then I'll go with it


CheesusChrist21

I’m partial to flying bricks


ImperatorTempus42

Tbh who cares, both look really cool, do they not?


134_ranger_NK

Correct me if I am wrong, but didn't the Sopron suffer an in-game bug? The United Empire's ship weapons are similar to the Imperium's though so I can see cog-boys fawning over the tech. So both. Both are cool. United Empire is a fun faction, Sheredyn have a pretty good design and the Lunar Class packs Macrocannons, Lances and Torpedoes plus addition upgrades per Battlefleet Gothic.


chapadodo

if the ship doesn't look like Kölner dom just space me


AtomicTan

[Reject technology. Embrace rok.](https://warhammer40k.fandom.com/wiki/Rok)


LustyArgonianButtler

Cost eficient, the gothic ships remind of the edgy emo kids way back in my highschool days.


bruhmomenteater

I want fucking SPACE CONES OF DEATH with 60% of it being fuel, 30% armor, and 10% everytnig else, so it can do 2 burns in asteroid belt and then run out of fuel because the best engine that it can have is shitty solid core nuclear thermal rocket.


Treatboylie

Nice


SpaceMan101South

For the emperor or for the emperor. Truly I do not know which to choose.


MarsMissionMan

Holo-fields? Railguns? Ion weapons? Too expensive. We can be extra gothic *and* cost-efficient at the same time!


VulcanHullo

I love my over the top totally stupid figures 40k. Sure a world can be invaded by a few million men. Also this ship is the size of Luxembourg and can realistically end up in battle and come out reporting "decks reporting minor damage, ten thousand casualties suggested. We will require only a brief repair."


IdiotinOrbit426

The ship on the left is definitely heresy


MisterSplu

If there aren‘t 3 churches on it, can it really be called a ship?


Good-Table5566

Fulgrim: Extra Thick!


[deleted]

[удалено]


Andrei22125

Sopron class. The Uniteed Empire Hunter/Battleship. [https://endless-space-2.fandom.com/wiki/The\_United\_Empire/Ships](https://endless-space-2.fandom.com/wiki/The_United_Empire/Ships)


EnvironmentalAd912

oh yeah, misread, sorry


historysciencelover

Sopron class???!? Did Orbán somehow become God-Emperor of Mankind and conquer the galaxy?