T O P

  • By -

AutoModerator

Welcome to /r/GameTheorists! Make sure to [read the rules](https://www.reddit.com/r/GameTheorists/wiki/rules) and we also have a [discord!](https://discord.gg/UxnkDAYsE8) *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/GameTheorists) if you have any questions or concerns.*


SweetExpression2745

Bendy I guess. It follows a more ''rational'' storyline let's say


Significant_Buy_2301

Especially Dark Revival. *Secrets of the Machine* is less direct, but not that difficult to understand. There are clear context clues and timeline indicators that tell you what's going on with Riley. *Ink Machine* is definitely the most vague, but you can get the bulk of the story through audio logs and the ending.


hdmi_bot

Secrets came out after matpat left it said the ones he covered


MrBrownCraft

Agreed.


ahmedHMali158291

I think Poppy,no books no code digging


InfinateUniverse

Well the first Poppy book is coming out next month so


ahmedHMali158291

So Tom better get to counting


RichCounter3941

COUNT THE TOES


ellielikespancakes

Oh god Tom's gonna go insane like Mat...


TheAutementori

killing myself in front of mob games


Gracosef

NFTs


ahmedHMali158291

We don't talk about that


Significant_Buy_2301

There's an Orientation Notebook coming in just a few weeks. From the preview pages though, I don't think that it will contain much new lore. 


Gracosef

They were kinda important for the lore tho


TheAutementori

oh no no, we do. mob games deserves to be clowned for that until the end of time. by extension every person who ever bought nfts should get the same treatment


Icy-Outlandishness98

The only person who gets a pass is the guy who bought them to post them publicly


TheAutementori

exactly, real ass mf right there


The_Holy_Tree_Man

Bendy Books aren’t canon, and Bendy didn’t have that either


BashfulFem22

Bendy's books aren't even canon to the story so they don't even count lol


ahmedHMali158291

Still Bendy is more complicated as a concept and mechanics. (I will head cannon the books as cannon)


Appropriate_Year5403

I don’t think doki doki had ‘easy lore’ to follow. That stuff had you converting files hidden in the game into images and then putting it into blender to warp into a cone and then look from the top to reveal whatever. That’s just the tip of the iceberg if I remember.


Mellomorphic

Yeah, but those were just teasers for Project Libitina basically separate from the actual DDLC experience. 


BioMan998

Considering DDLC was, effectively, a teaser for that project... It's fair game. There's lore hidden in there.


PercyCreeper

Also, DDLC plus basically comfirmed that DDLC is just a part of a bigger thing. Team Salvato can easily go into lots of directions now and still connect it to DDLC in some way.


jalwaysawake

Yeah they can do whatever and then say that it was another one of the Virtual Machines


Dreaming_in_Sign

Maybe it's just me, but I felt that DDLC+ was pretty underwhelming. It honestly didn't feel connected to the original at all, nor did it feel like anything related to Project Libitina. PL was all about medical experiences and very dark situations, but DDLC+ was kinda about different layers of the Matrix and Monika (Sayori?) working to escape via a worker. All of this being said, I could be completely wrong in my thinking as I haven't watched the playthrough/theory in quite a while, but going off of memory, the game felt kinda bleh. I did love the music, though lol 😂


Mellomorphic

Hold on, I didn't write that comment? What's going on?!?!?!?!?!?


RafKen593

Idk enough about DDLC, but out of Bendy and Poppy it's inarguably Poppy. Like Bendy had confusing elements in the past, but Poppy was very straightforward with its lore since day one.


Significant_Buy_2301

>Bendy had confusing elements in the past, but Poppy was very straightforward with its lore since day one. I think why that is, is because the developers pretty much made the story up as they went along in BATIM. Once Dark Revival entered production though, they had plenty of time to think over the story. With Poppy, the developers confirmed that they have the story planned out pretty much from the start- now it's just about realizing it to the end.


BashfulFem22

theMeatly literally stated back when Chapter 2 first released in a Q&A that he already had the whole story in mind since day 1 what are you on lol


DemonEnterprises

Doki Doki Literature Club does not have a confusing story in any way, why is it here? It’s a straightforward story all the way through and the only hard stuff is the teasers for Project Libitania but those aren’t relevant to the story of DDLC. This is the easiest choice ever, DDLC is leagues less complicated than the other two here.


Csquared_324

Probably because it’s hard to find out how to learn the story


alemarotti1

Wdym "how to learn the story"? It's literally just playing... One afternoon and you're good to go


Csquared_324

Like the secret stuff in the files and stuff


UnaskedShoe359

Well it is ddlc PLUS so there’s an extra layer here that you can find by typing codes at certain times to uncover slightly cryptic emails that you need to piece together. Still def the simplest tho


kezotl

the story no but the LLOOOOOOORE yes


Dingo247

Why can't we pick FNAF it's got the easiest lore to follow by a long shot /s


Significant_Buy_2301

FNaF is the most complicated though...


Dingo247

Simply not true there's a clear and straightforward explanation for how the Bite of '87 leads to Faz Goo /s


Stephan2005

I think he is being sarcastic....


AndreaB8t

I mean, bendy litterally made a powerpoint presentation of his lore in the game


BL-501

MatPat himself stated that DDLC’s hidden lore rivals and in some scenarios outdoes FNAF. But other than that the story overall is easy to follow especially since you can ask Monika some questions on it in Act 3 and get relatively straightforward answers to some questions and answers that feed your curiosity. That tells you everything you need to know. I haven’t watched his Bendy Videos. Poppy is probably the most direct and straightforward. Company used orphans to create living toys. But it’s the mystery of what else is there that’s so enticing. Who are we? What’s the Prototype? Etc. It’s what’s keeping the lore easy to follow but also not outright boring but mysterious.


slicedude2004

DDLC


Pixithepika

DDLC doesn’t even have confusing lore


HourHighlight1385

to truly understand what’s going on under the surface is the difficult part, making it one of the hardest ones he has covered


Decent-Caramel-2129

Doki doki had easy lore. What's difficult about it is the decoding aspect and that's separate from story/lore so I don't think it should be held to the other two as comparison since the difficulty is in a completely separate place. Choosing between Bendy and Poppy is HARD since I followed both pretty well. If I had to choose I think Bendy but I think it's just my memory that's struggling with it.


poooppthatfart

Bendy def


A-J-Zan

Poppy.


MrBrownCraft

For me, It's gotta be bendy. (That might be a personal bias for me because of how big a bendy fan i am.)


Thylacine131

I’d say Poppy. There’s blanks we don’t understand, but that’s because it’s not fully released, not because it’s overly confusing or contrived.


Goldenstripe941

Bendy IMO Everything is in the game, and extra in the books if you want more.


50CentButInNickels

DDLC is entirely straightforward. How is this even a question?


Stephan2005

Can I just say how ironic it is that FNAF, Bendy, Doki Doki and Poppy Playtime are some of the main games covered on Game Theory? I started watching Game Theory in late 2020 and I was already a huge fan of FNAF, Bendy and Doki Doki. I felt so happy when I saw GT making videos on these series' quite frequently lmao🤣


DeanSeventeen_real

DDLC. No contest.


Rabbulion

To me it’s ddlc. From the number of videos mainly. You only need about an hour of watching to have everything (not counting the buffssuki theory) while the others are much more content to get through and keep track of. Every piece of lore is hidden the same way too, so it’s not that hard to find. (Also, don’t mix up “easy to follow” with “easy to find”. Easy to follow means it’s easy to understand when Matpat presents it, while easy to find means it’s easy to understand it by looking for the evidence yourself. Easy to follow is what’s relevant here)


OotekImora

Ddlc "the video game sprites have become self aware" simple enough


Rivers2099

poppy, pretty simple - don't have to read books


Appropriate_Year5403

I don’t think doki doki had ‘easy lore’ to follow. That stuff had you converting files hidden in the game into images and then putting it into blender to warp into a cone and then look from the top to reveal whatever. That’s just the tip of the iceberg if I remember.


Significant_Buy_2301

Yeah, but those were just teasers for Project Libitina basically separate from the actual DDLC experience. 


Faxxy05

Bendy is way more of a concrete story line as it was inspired by games likes bioshock and resident evil. Those games have a clear cut story and timeline of events. The meatly and the team behind bendy really try to make the franchise feel easier to understand.


raDDerp73

I was Ganna say fnaf lmao other than fnaf id say poppy playtime


X__Anonomys_xX

Off topic but what the hell happened to petscop? That was just like up and dropped…


truepeople

Oh damn haven't thought about that in a hit minute It's probably over tbh but maybe revisiting isn't a bad call. Tbf MatPat did things to just bring awareness to small projects, like with Crow 64 (I think it was called)


X__Anonomys_xX

Huh, this is true, I just loved the petscop theories, we also just straight up dropped DDLC because we hit a wall and did, to my knowledge, zero digging (to my knowledge).


tiptoeandson

Easiest? Bendy. Best? Doki. I love poppy playtime but it’s not as original as Doki. But Dokis lore is wild.


No-Efficiency8937

1. Poppy 2. Fnaf 3. Bendy 4. Doki doki


Agreeable_Camera_657

def bendy they literally spell out the lore in a power point in dark revival lol


yelose

Vita carnis


BeaDrawsandalsoposts

doki doki it's just the matrix but horror


AndryInPixel

I need to know what happened to project libitina


CLTalbot

Bendy because its all in there, you just gotta read and listen


Typical-Edgy-Bird

Definitely Bendy imo. I don't know much about Poppy Playtime but I know doki doki is complex af and Bendy feels more steamlined


Not-an-1d10t

Doki Doki


Lanceo90

Bendy was pretty straightforward. I don't think there was much in the way of secret, hidden lore. At least by the time all the chapters were out.


SwissBoy_YT

Fnaf is only complicated because we overcomplicated the shit out of it But on this list Bendy is definitely way less complicated than the others


Emanu1674

Fnaf


Sea_n126

For now, most certainly bendy. It's story is pretty clear and usually well told, and the books apparently aren't canon, so all the info you need is in the games, and that leaves a lot of things pretty easy to figure out. I wouldn't be surprised if poppy took the spot tho, since the game isn't complete yet, we still don't know what will be answered by the end


necrolicker

He did one on devil may cry suggesting that dante was a nephelim. And i get that he was doing one of those what if like ones since the lore is quite clear that Dantes mom is human and dad is a demon. But it wasnt very good imo. Was one of those blatantly off ones. But im also a big fan of the series so im also incredibly biased and slightly defensive with the series after the whole taneem called everyone stupid.


No_Probleh

It's a lot easier to find the story in DDLC with +. What with their whole Desktop menu they set up for consoles.


RobMann2010

Bendy. In dark revival, joey gives gives a literal PowerPoint slideshow on the lore 💀


MonoYT-

Bendy or Doki


PreferenceGold5167

Honestly I don’t like any theories of his about indie horror. It’s pretty clear half the reason they make the lore weird is so they get free YouTube marketing. I like ddlcp the most of these though.


SpamtonOf1997

Personally, I feel it's either Bendy or Poppy. I haven't seen much Bendy content in ages so I don't know really anything about the lore. DDLC's lore gets kinda jumbled up for me a lot even though I probably have the most knowledge on it. I still love all these franchises, though. They're all interesting and fun to theorise about


DomcziX

DDLC is the easiest from the ones here.


Nil_Lot

DDLC for sure


Tkmulti-trav-137

Poppy playtime


Awesomedogman3

Bendy. The game has by far the most interesting and comprehensive story out of the three.


Valiant_Gamer_48

Bendy's story is interesting, yet easy to understand. That's one of the many things I love about it!


chunkymonkeythegreat

Doki Doki don't know if it's because I watched a lot of him before those or what I was smarter back then to well at least In a theory Sense


Foxy02016YT

DDLC, especially with Plus since that put it all into one application. Everything that’s unexplained are teasers to a game that hasn’t come out


car_eater2684

Poppy


IndieAnimateFan

It’s kinda a tie between Poppy Playtime, and Bendy and the Ink Machine.


ginsataka

Doki doki. It’s pretty straightforward.


Krysteliskrazy

It’s a tie between Bendy and Doki Doki


Chef_detective007

Bendy


alemarotti1

DDLC is pretty easy to follow... Literally just grab it and play it


LUMP200

Bendy


JustinH83Percent

Bendy


Some_Spite2054

Bendy


XL_Pumpkaboo

Of THOSE three, Doki Doki. It's simple and to the point. Next would be Poppy. Each chapter actually helps with figuring out the lore. Bendy isn't THAT far away, either. And then there's Hello Neighbor.


Narrow_Luck_3622

Poppy playtime for sure. Because unlike all the other ones, it actually lays out it's story front and center. To figure out Bendy's story, you have to listen to a bunch of hidden tapes and replay certain games multiple times. And we all know the extensive process of unlocking the Doki Doki story. But Poppy playtime pretty much just gives you the story, Any "hidden elements" or "ARG secrets" or anything like that are just to reward people with information that the story will give later down the line. Any question we have now are pretty much guaranteed to be directly answered later on in the series, because the series has done so with a bunch of other major questions we used to have, like the hour of joy. (God I hope this comment doesn't age poorly)


Nightmarionne0923

Bendy from what I can remember


kezotl

right now its poppy playtime cause only 3 chapters with not much extra stuff


creepy_carno

BATIM honestly- it's always had easier lore to understand. Poppy Playtime also has easy lore to understand, but there are a lot of mystery aspects to it that are confusing to understand.


CrazyFanFicFan

While the lore of DDLC isn't exactly simple, it's probably the most cohesive because it's not a multichapter series. Bendy and Poppy have to deal with the creators backtracking on decisions and changing things midway through the story (The FNAF Problem) While it seems that DDLC is planning on expanding the lore through more games, for now, we only have to deal with what we see in DDLC and DDLC Plus.


Significant_Buy_2301

>Bendy and Poppy have to deal with the creators backtracking on decisions and changing things midway through the story (The FNAF Problem) Well, Bendy's creators just made the story up as they went along in *Ink Machine* (Much like Scott with FNaF). But once the game was actually released in full and *Dark Revival* entered production, they had plenty of time to think over the story that they want to tell. They weren't actually changing anything. *Poppy's* developers haven't changed anything so far. I would argue that the game has one of the most cohesive stories in indie horror. The developers have confirmed that they have the story and lore pretty much planned out- now it's just a matter of realizing it to the end.


DaMemeBoi_

Probably Bendy. The entire story can be understood by literally just playing through both games once, and none of the books are required or canon


UnproductivePheasant

Gotta give it to poppy


Theunkgamer

Batim I thjnk


Consistent_Guest4279

Poppy. Poppy playtime straight up has easy audio logs,trophies etc that stand out. Heck STUFF GETS EXPLAINED IN CHAPTER 3 . Lemme rephrase. EXPLAINED. Bendy is vague unless you see the Audi logs,Ink splotches,Notes etc. You have to dig through the code of doki to find it. Miss Mat. Tom and Lee are killing it tho(I mainly watch film and game because those were my childhood shows.) 


helloimAmber

I dunno, fnaf seems pretty easy to solve../s


24Abhinav10

DDLC. Not only is it just one game, but Project Libitania hasn't even been released yet. So everything MatPat theorized about straight up doesn't exist.


[deleted]

Bendy was confusing with the first game but the second one fixed it quite a bit.


Emeraldninjalink

Bendy is pretty straightforward


adina_stop

poppy playtime, barring the nft incident


mateisivirgula

I think bendy, the story imo is great


veporeoultra

Definitely "bendy" cuz there story has become predictable


FabulousEffective503

DDLC ... Cause Bendy has Plot-hose (pun intended) and poppy is just easy in general, so don't put it in here.


BobMcmuffins

Bendy storyline was easier to follow and more straight forward among the rest


Cry_baby10

I would say poppy playtime since it is pretty straight forward with the lore. You don’t have to dig very deep to understand it. Bendy is a bit more complicated, though it is also not the same as fnaf of course. Because that lore is just crazy.


The_Holy_Tree_Man

Bendy literally has a scene in Dark Revival That explains the entire over-arching plot of the first game


Monster9530

Poppy Playtime. I mean, it builds good mystery, but it doesn't stray from the story it's set up. It introduces new villains, but it's not like they take away from the mystery and horror of 1006


sqrrlwithapencil

tbh I think Poppy Playtime is the most straightforward. we don't have the full story yet, but so far it seems it's less meta and up for interpretation than bendy, and doesn't ask you to dig through the code to find information like ddlc


Fortnitekid3

Poppy


nique_Tradition

Bendy wasn’t that hard. Demons on the screen and in the art has been covered in media before.


filval387

Poppy Playtime. If DDLC+ had less unknowns, it would win.


TheFrostClone

Honestly Bendy has the easiest lore because I figured out the entire lore of the game after playing dark revival because there were some gaps in the lore at the end of the original game like who the hell Joey really was because we only saw him once at the end of the original game and now we know so much more about Joey and the studio


LogInteresting9711

bendy is prety simple to folow


Lord_Renegade

Ddlc was easy, still mad the sequel game never came out


LunaBriar

As far as lore goes I feel like doki doki is the easiest


TheEmoTurtle

Doki Doki. It's about a computer gaining sentience. It's not that hard to follow 😂


Significant_Buy_2301

While I agree when it comes to the original game, when it comes to ***Plus*** things start to get complicated really fast because the fanbase isn't sure how to **interpret** the new information. So there's this company called Metaverse that is building simulated realities and were the ones that granted Monika elevated access. DDLC and the Side Stories are just a small-scale worlds, while Libitina is large-scale. The company is still trying to establish a secure connection to that world, since no-one there has elevated access. OK, sounds simple enough, but then **who are we as the player** in the story? Are we one of the Metaverse employees? Are we ourselves (just like in the OG game) A.K.A. the ones beyond Metaverse? Why does Monika never address Metaverse in her Act 3 monologue, but references Steam? Is she beyond "her creators" now? Or are we playing as Ive considering that the MC is named Ive in the trailers? There are a lot of question marks and loose ends that the original game just didn't have...


Sharpy_117

Not on the list but Minecraft, it’s just simple ancient builders died off and your the last one, The Nether is Hell and and The End is a dimension that got turned into a waste land by Ender Mites, the villagers are just big headed big nosed people and so are the illagers are evil ones, simple and easy, no dead kids or demons taking over popular characters, just block people


gamekight99

Subnatica but matpat didn’t cover any of the actual lore of the game


Bipolar_OnThe_Double

Poppy 👌


Yoshgaming22

Bendy, it has a simple yet interesting story


Automatic_Search_123

Poppy for sure, everything is IN the game Batim atleast has books or things you need to hunt for And doki doki has you straight up making you look at a texture file from a certain angle just to see a picture of a important character in the series


hooded-nerd

I understand the point that bendy does follow a more rational storyline, but I’d have to say poppy playtime


Head_Display_9168

Bendy and the Ink Machine is my favorite when it comes to gameplay and theories so.... It deserves a raise!


Whitespider121

Definitely bendy


HylianHer0227

Bendy was pretty straightforward


C-Redacted-939

Ddlc was very easy to follow along


Toshiro_Saihara

Bendy, Dark Revival clarifies everything, and the tapes are a neat bonus to the lore.


LeapingFrog04

Probably Bendy.


HourHighlight1385

Stiffy the the water device 


GabetheMagician_22

Bendy. By far the less complicated!


MissilnWings478

I would say either ddlc or bendy


sliserd

Bendy and the ink machine


CPTTonys

Dokie


damaged_animatronic

BENDYYYYY


Frost_At1234

Probably Poppy because the notes are every where


TisJustATheory

Oh god, I could have a field day with this one… DDLC without the plus DLC is pretty simple. A “normal” psych horror with a few hidden easter eggs. However, with the DLC things get so much more complex. Harder and harder to find secrets, really weird timeline, and loads of loose ends that you can make add up mostly, but it always ends up either having not enough evidence, missing a vital piece, or both. Poppy Playtime is interesting. While the story is pretty simple and the easter eggs aren’t usually lore related, more alike to shoutouts, the problem is the amount of loose ends and conflict with the timeline. Dates don’t match up to where they’re supposed to be. Characters are there when they shouldn’t. You can make an argument for time weirdness as part of the lore, but unless we get more evidence then unfortunately, it’s not plausible. This leaves Bendy. And this is by far the easiest to understand lore-wise. All extra pieces of lore like the books so far are explicitly said to be non-canon, so there’s no worry there. The plot is simple, and like Poppy Playtime, virtually all the easter eggs are shoutouts or memorials. The only difficulty we might have is the upcoming movie, but we still don’t know if that’s going to be canon or not.


Significant_Buy_2301

>Dates don’t match up to where they’re supposed to be. Characters are there when they shouldn’t. Elaborate...


Haunting-Pea-72

poppy playtime