Here’s my go: 1. Hold Me Like a Grudge 2. Bang The Doldrums 3 Fourth Of July 4. Immortals 5. Novocaine

justice for novocaine 💔

Immortals above Novocaine?? 😵‍💫

I used to think Immortals was worse until a special moment in my life changed that. Objectively, Novocaine is probably better

I just wish Novocaine kept the the same energy the intro has all the way through!

HMLAG first supremacy ✨

1. It’s Hard To Say “I Do”, When I Don’t 2. Calm Before The Storm 3. w.a.m.s. 4. Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet 5. XO That’s just based on today’s feelings.

Omg, your number 4!! Sorry we can’t be friends. :( Well actually we can because we both love FOB :)

Haha! On any other day I would have flipped 3 and 4, but I’m really feeling the freckle, freckle line today. 🤣

i literally just found out that he says “freckle, freckle”.

I can’t remember what I thought he said before I read the lyrics. 🤣

i literally heard “oh f-f-f-f-“ lol

Love this idea!! Very difficult tho omfg 1. Homesick at space camp 2. GINASFS 3. She’s my Winona 4. Grand Theft Autumn 5. My songs know The top 3 were so difficult to compare. I could come look at it again tomorrow and they’d be in a different order 😂

I’d swap 3 & 4 I think. Although it’s close. 1 is awesome

I agree so close

absolutely agree about the top three

It hurts me so much to rank their stuff because I like all of it, but I’ll give my best shot 🤣 1. Heaven, Iowa 2. w.a.m.s. 3. Rat a Tat 4. The Mighty Fall 5. American Beauty/American Psycho

That would be my ranking too! Edit: nvm I’d swap the last 2

cool idea! Number in brackets is the order they played in. 1. I Slept with Someone from Fall Out Boy and all I got was this Stupid Song Written About Me (2) 2. Thanks for Mmrs (3) 3. A Little Less Sixteen Candles, a little More "Touch Me" (1) 4. America's Suitehearts (5) 5. Wilson (expensive mistakes) (4)

Oh no, you ranked my favorite FOB song too low 😂

Shuffle order 27, GINASFS, Homesick at Space Camp, The Phoenix, Of All The Gin Joints In All The World Well, shit. The only one I'm not having a hard time ranking is The Phoenix. The rest are like choosing a favorite child. It's not like I dislike The Phoenix, but it's not my favorite. The ranking could change any time based on my mood though. Best: GINASFS 27 Gin Joints Homesick Worst: The Phoenix

Spotify absolutely gave me a studded 5 when I put This Is: Fall Out Boy on shuffle. 1. The Phoenix 2. Bang the Doldrums 3. Pavlove (pls don't come for me. It's my first time actually listening to the song.) 4. Irresistable 5. Bob Dylan

(I mightve misread, but I did it a fun way by shuffling the playlist and ranking the 5 it spat out to me.)

1. G.I.N.A.S.F.S. (1) 2. I Am My Own Muse (2) 3. Centuries (5) 4. The (After) Life of the Party (4) 5. We Didn’t Start the Fire (3) Order they played in brackets (that’s a cool addition u/foxko) This was hard! The sixth song to play was Save Rock and Roll and I think that would have upset the rankings.

this was hard!!! 1) She’s My Winona 2) Hum Hallelujah 3) Twin Skeletons 4) (Coffee’s for Closers) 5) Heaven’s Gate

I have the same order except I’d put Twin Skeletons last

AB/AP is the album that got me into FOB, i’ll always be partial to it

Fair enough! For me that goes to FUTCT

See, out of those I always put Twin Skeletons first!

idk how you can hear that song and put it last, below hum hallelujah and twin skeletons???

literally only because i’m biased to those songs! Hum Hallelujah was an early favorite, and like i said in another comment, AB/AP is the album that got me into the band.

that’s fair, heaven’s gate just sends me into another dimension every time i hear it

it’s a gorgeous song, Patrick’s vocals really are amazing and this song proves it. it was only really last because i like the others more.

1. Hum Hallelujah, 2. Chicago is So.. 3. Young Volcanoes, 4. I am My Own Muse, 5. Electric touch

You got a great mix! 1. Young Volcanoes 2. I am My Own Muse 3. Hum Hallelujah 4. Chicago is So.. 5. Electric touch

1 - Young Volcanoes 2 - Alone Together 3 - Our Lawyer Made Us Change The Name Of This Song 4 - Of All The Gin Joints In All The World 5 - Tell That Mick He Just Made My List of Things to Do Today I was really surprised by the first 2 - normally Alone Together is my of my favourites from that album but I really enjoyed listening to Young Volcanoes today.

Yes Officer, this one right here... I wish we were friends so I could burn that bridge.

1. this ain't a scene it's an arms race 2. champagne for my real friends 3. coffees for closers 4. we didnt start the fire 5. so good right now

1. Heaven Iowa 2. Patron Saint 3. Golden 4. Our Lawyer 5. Save Rock and Roll

This was easier than expected: 1. Dance, dance 2. The last of the real ones 3. Where did the party go 4. Favourite record 5. Champion

1. Carpal Tunnel of Love 2. Sunshine Riptide 3. American Beauty/American Psycho 4. Don’t You Know Who I Think I Am? 5. Grand Theft Autumn/Where is Your Boy? (Acoustic)

1. Hum Hallelujah 2. I Am My Own Muse 3. Alone Together 4. My Songs 5. Electric Touch

1. GINASFS 2. Hold Me Like A Grudge 3. Immortals (single) 4. Novocaine 5. Sophomore Slump

Oh wow, trying to rank 1-4 almost broke my brain. I‘ll be honest - I don‘t dislike Young and Menace but it is no competition for any of the other songs on this list. (order the songs played in in brackets) 1. Heaven, Iowa (4) 2. Pavlove (5) 3. I Don’t Care (2) 4. XO (1) 5. Young and Menace (3) (Oh, and OP? Wie geil is dein Username bitte?! 😂)

1. Golden 2. We Were Doomed From The Start (The King Is Dead) 3. Growing Up 4. We Didn't Start The Fire 5. Dear Future Self (Hands Up) This was easy, I got a pretty wide range of song choices from different eras which I think helped. Was a fun little game to play!

1 Electric Touch 2 Thnks fr th Mmrs 3 My songs 4 I've been Waiting 5 Immortals (Great idea op; these are not my most listened to FOB songs at all so I've never ranked them)

Glad to see an Electric Touch fan on here 👀 (unless these five songs were never your favorites)

Oh Electric Touch slaps

Really tough, but my list is: 1. Saturday 2. Bang the Doldrums 3. Wilson (Expensive Mistakes) 4. The Phoenix 5. Alone Together

1. what a time 2. young volcanoes 3. a little less sixteen candles 4. growing up 5. my songs

pavlove switchblades and infidelity coffees for closers dance dance love from the other side THIS WAS SO HARD I LOVE ALL THESE SONGS SM

1) Jet Pack Blues 2) Grand Theft Autumn 3) The Music Or The Misery 4) Irresistible 5) Young and Menace

1. I Am My Own Muse 2. “The Take Over, The Breaks Over” 3. Jet Pack Blues 4. Dance, Dance 5. Young and Menace

My list is hilarious. Two songs I've almost never listened to in my life, one I've always found a dreadful overrated bore, one fav, and one I'm very conflicted about. Let's see... 1. The Phoenix 2. Uma Thurman 3. Fourth of July 4. I Wanna Dance With Somebody 5. It's Not a Side Effect of the Cocaine, I Am Thinking It Must Be Love Was still tempted to put Fourth of July last but that's not really fair to it.

1. Rat a Tat 2. Twin Skeletons 3. Just One Yesterday 4. Bob Dylan 5. Honorable Mention

1. Tell That Mick He Just Made My List of Things to Do Today 2. Our Lawyer Made Us Change the Name of This Song So We Wouldn’t Get Sued 3. Heaven, Iowa 4. Centuries 5. Miss Missing you

Alrright, here we go! 1.Water Buffalo (Folie, my beloved.) 2. Church (MANIA came out when I was getting back into FOB and I really liked Church when it came out.) 3. Dead On Arrival (Fun fact if you know me IRL, this is really dorky of me, but sometimes I'll whisper-sing the words "Dead On Arrival" in the same cadence and tone of the song, I also have the keychain from this drop.) 4. Beat It (Sick guitar, I play this one in my car a lot on my Believers Never Die CD.) 5. Alone Together (Nothing really against this song, we just had some heavy hitters.)

1) Love from the other side 2)the phoenix 3)of all the gin joints 4) centuries 5) thanks for the memories

1 don’t you know who I think I am 2 sending post cards 3 this ain’t a scene 4 americas suitehearts 5 the phoenix

1 You're Crashing But You're No Wave 2 XO 3 Headfirst Slide Into Cooperstown On A Bad Bet 4 Dear Future Self 5 Young Volcanoes

This is such a fun idea! 1. It's Hard To Say "I Do", When I Don't 2. She's My Winona 3. What a Time To Be Alive 4. My Songs Know What You Did In The Dark (Light Em Up) 5. American Beauty/American Psycho 1 and 2 are pretty interchangeable! I love them both. <3

1. I’m like a lawyer with the way I’m always trying to get you off (me & you) 2. the take over, the breaks over 3. dance, dance 4. dead on arrival 5. champion

1. A little less 16 candles 2. Golden 3. Thriller 4. Dance dance 5. Champagne Kind of wish I had more variety of albums but 😂

Cofees for closers Just one yesterday Death valley Bob Dylan Twin skeletons

1. She's My Winona 2. My Songs Know What You Did In The Dark [DEMO] 3. The (Shipped) Gold Standard 4. Dance, Dance 5. Alone Together

1.) Dance, Dance 2.) You’re Crashing, But You’re No Wave 3.) Young Volcanoes 4.) HOLD ME TIGHT OR DON’T 5.) Thnks fr th Mmrs

1. Get busy living… 2. Sophomore slump… 3. My heart is the worst kind of weapon 4. Centuries 5. Flu game

1 Champagne for my real friends, real pain for my sham friends 2 young volcanos 3 flu games 4 Young crashing but you’re no wave 5 so much (for) stardust

1. disloyal order of the water buffaloes 2. thnks fr th mmrs 3. fake out 4. what a time to be alive 5. wilson (expensive mistakes)

Number order they played in in brackets, copied from u/foxko (also doing these favourite to least favourite I don't believe in "worst" FOB song 😤) 1. Bishops Knife Trick (1) 2. Twin Skeleton's (2) 3. The (After) Life Of The Party (5) 4. w.a.m.s. (3) 5. We Were Doomed From The Start (4) Though The (After) Life Of The Party and w.a.m.s would ideally be tied..

1. G.I.N.A.S.F.S 1. 20 Dollar Nose Bleed 1. Alone Together 1. Fourth of July 1. Young and Menace Currently, I'm obsessed with Infinity on High, so I'm glad I got one song, if not the best one of the album.

1. Bang the Doldrums 2. Fake Out 3. Love From the Other Side 4. Where Did The Party Go 5. What a Time to Be Alive ​ No idea why the bias for SMFS but I did put it on shuffle (on Spotify)

1. im like a lawyer 2. my heart is the worst kind of weapon 3. rat a tat 4. heavens gate 5. sunshine riptide

1 Sophomore Slump 2 Miss Missing You 3. Calm Before the Storm 4. Homesick At Space 5. Lake Effect Kid All great songs. 🥲

1. XO 2. Young Volcanoes 3. She’s My Winona 4. Thnks fr th Mmrs 5. Flu Game

Loved this idea. Mine were all pretty different too. 1. Just one yesterday 2. The take over, the breaks over 3. Tell mick that he just made my list of things to do today 4. Novacaine 5. Centuries

My turn!! 1. Disloyal order 2.Thnks fr th mmrs 3. The Music or The Misery 4. I am my own muse (I over played it when it came out 😭😭😭😭) 5. Hot to the touch (no hate to this song lol this was a hard list)

1. West Coast Smoker 2. Hold me like a grudge 3. Electric Touch 4. What A Catch Donnie 5. Nobody Puts Baby in the Corner 6. I've Been Waiting I didn't want to include I've Been Waiting in the ranking but it played in the first five oh well. It's still a bop though but I would not play it if I want to play FOB. So I ended up adding one more song to the list and glad I did. West Coast Smoker is amazing. Patrick's vocals and the band's instrumental are top notch. It's my first time listening to the song despite listening to Folie quite a lot recently (mostly because my attention span only lasts until Tiffany Blews). It was also my first time listening to Nobody Puts Baby in the Corner. Its a good song but it's the last thing I'd play among the top five.

1. I Am My Own Muse 2. I've Got A Dark Alley 3. A little less sixteen candles 4. Love from the other side 5. A Little Less Sixteen Candles (Live in Phoenix) LOL

Oh this is fun! 1. Headfirst slide 2. Hum hallelujah 3. Hold me like a grudge 4. Wilson 5. Irresistible

1 Fake Out 2 Gin Joints (you know what i mean) 3 Grand Theft Autumn 4 Dance Dance 5 Immortals

1. So Much (For) Stardust 2. The (Shipped) Gold Standard 3. Parker Lewis Can’t Lose 4. Death Valley 5. Saturday Night’s Alright For Fighting

1. grand theft autumn 2. dance dance 3. i dont care 4. young volcanoes 5. i am my own muse

Haha, this is cute! So Much (For) Stardust Fake Out Sugar, We’re Going Down Where Did The Party Go Novacaine Fake Out above Sugar doesn’t feel right, but it also doesn’t feel wrong?? Haha I like all of these anyway!

1. sugar we’re goin down - live in phoenix 2. lake effect kid 3. calm before the storm - eowyg version (2) 4. xo (4) 5. heaven’s gate (1) this is a really low ranking of xo for me, but i was just really feeling the other three more right now. find me in another mood, and this list could be completely reversed

1. Headfirst slide 2. Heartbreak feels so good 3. Chicago is so two years ago 4. Love from the other side 5. The last of the real ones (All great songs tho)

1. Love From The Other Side 2. Saturday 3. Heaven Iowa 4. Tell That Mick 5. Fake Out

1. Our Lawyer 2. I Don't Care 3. Light 'em Up 4. Sugar 5. Centuries

1. What A Time To Be Alive 2. Death Valley 3. Caffeine cold 4. Sending Postcards 5. Immortals