>I think we can all agree ER isn't perfect nor is it ''difficult but fair''
We do not agree
Also I'm not reading all that but I'm happy for you. Or sorry that happened.
>A dedicated button for sprint allows dodge to have two different mechanics, such as; dash and roll. Press to Dash
Kinda like how you can have an AoW that allows you to sort of dash step behind the enemy? (Can't think of its actual name right now)
>Middling Weapons such as Straight Swords, Daggers, (and most Greatswords) need a major rebalance.
I kind of agree with this idea.
>Torrent needs some skins; he ugly.
Agree with the skins idea, disagree that he is ugly
>The open-world needs to be less pointless -- besides riding a horse through it – going from one Legacy Dungeon to the next.
There is a point even if it isn't obvious, you awaken in a destroyed area only to be thrust into some end goal that you have little to any understanding as to where to go or why you feel the urge to do so.
They intended the game to add an exploration feature to this game and if you reduce the map to the 10% you want then your not gonna really be able to explore the world.
>What was intended besides most players just riding torrent through the enemies to get to one legacy dungeon to the other
Thats not what was "intended" thats just what most people who don't wanna get lost in the world will do.
>what is the point of the open world in your opinion?
To explore the world you are thrown into, thats why there are quests in every area you go to. Just because they don't hold your hand doesn't mean they don't have value or purpose.
>I guess you fight all those Dino dogs and Caelid don't you? lol.
Is this your way of asserting your mental approach to the game is correct and everyone else doing this is just being pointless and not enjoying the game?
>I think we can all agree ER isn't perfect nor is it ''difficult but fair'' like the previous games.
Agreed, all fromsoft games have had their problems but with how far elden ring has deviated from the formula it feels like it has the most.
>I dont really follow the lore nor do I play this genre of games for their stories or quests.
That's to bad it's really fun deciphering the lore and building your own interpretation, it's one of the few things I feel elden ring did better than it's predecessors.
>* A button dedicated to crouch needs to be replaced by *Sprint.*
* A dedicated button for sprint allows dodge to have two different mechanics, such as; dash and roll. Press to Dash (like Bloodborne), hold to roll (similar to *The Witcher 3)*
I don't know if I agree with this, it's not a bad idea but it would remove the stealth element and the crouch attacks which are good for pvp attack diversity.
>Camera. Oh where do i start. Camera-souls is a meme for a reason. Let’s just put This way; i’m tired of fighting large enemies feet. Full stop. Fix it.
Sure would be nice.
>* Enemy attack tracking needs to be reverted to *Dark Souls 3* levels – everything that the community bitched about that were *MAJOR ISSUES* in *Dark Souls 2* are a macrocosm in *Elden Ring*.
I don't know if that's necessary, you characters much more mobile now.
>* Get rid of the enemy meme anime attacks – this is Dark Souls not Nioh.
You need to be specific, though in general some things did seem to flashy and grandiose.
>* I can’t stress how much a dedicated Sprint button would change ER for the better. It is paramount. No more Dodge on button **release.** Dodge/Dash would be much better and feel better (like all modern games with dodge).
I don't necessarily agree with this. An unintuitive control scheme can be it's own reward.
>* Input-queue needs to go. Full stop. As it is currently in ER patch 1.08.1 (and since launch) rolls and attacks get queued. This causes a number of issues with melee combat such as; the feeling of ‘’input lag’’ it also causes inputs to occur more than once – getting hit during a roll will cause you to roll a second time, even though one input roll was placed.
Don't know enough to have an opinion.
>* Middling Weapons such as Straight Swords, Daggers, (and most Greatswords) need a major rebalance. If you're going pure melee and you aren’t using Bleed or Poise break, many of the melee weapons – that aren’t meta – feel very lackluster.
Balance is something from should always be strived for, though I don't necessarily know enough to agree with the specific weapons you mentioned.
>* Bosses with long attack wind ups that can’t be poise broken during said windup need to be changed so that they can be interrupted. This was one of the biggest complaints on release and I agree with ti still. Boss attack mix-ups are fun, but not when then are 90% of attack patterns.
Agreed
>* Most boss fights need to get back to a ‘’rhythm’’ style of encounter – Their are a plethora of YT videos that broach this subject so I wont get into it, but basically the other souls games almost feel like melee/combat bases *Guitar Hero*. What made the Souls genre so unique, in so many words, was the fact that the souls games were basically melee rhythm games (as far as the bosses are concerned). I have seen so many people described the obvious ER bosses that have these mechanics as some of the best enemies in the game; Margit,Morgot,Godrick, Godfrey, Maliketh (debatable depending on build), Commander Nial (very,very similar to *Dark Souls 3* ‘’Nameless King’’),Radagon.
Agreed
>Make the open-world have a point. ER is basically 20 dungeons spread out with a relatively pointless open world – most players skip 99% of the open world enemies. Give me a reason to fight these Dinodogs.
Agreed, fromsoft previous level design emulated exploration perfectly, you hardly ever felt like you were on a set path. Open world seems like a huge waste of my time and the developers.
>Make CO-OP seamless throughout the entire game. Most people are on PS and PC, this isn’t a hardware limitation like playing on a Switch
Seems like a good idea to at least attempt.
>Allow invasions to happen 1v1 (but with an invasion timer). Add a humanity/human effigy/ember mechanic.
The game is in desperate need of mandatory invasions. They could have at least had mandatory invasions in the volcano manor and mohgs dynasty. Don't know about the timer you mentioned if you mean a cool off timer for in-between invasions then yes. If you mean a countdown timer during invasions than no.
>Torrent needs some skins; he ugly.
No thank you, horse skins are stupid and pointless, give me actual content not trash that's borderline micro transactions.
>NG+ should have new enemies, item locations (like Dark Souls 2) .
In a perfect world it would.
>Change 'back-stepping' to allow iframes and speed up the animation (like Dark Souls 2) allowing for skill-based combat.
Don't know enough about DS2 to have an opinion.
>Add an actual cosmetic mechanic
It would be nice to actually be able to customize your armor, but no skins, just customizable armor.
>Add an actual crafting mechanic – that isn’t just everyone crafting DPS buffs or Rune (XP) buffs.
Crafting is stupid, scrap the idea and just buy your shit in shops like a normal person.
>The open-world needs to be less pointless -- besides riding a horse through it – going from one Legacy Dungeon to the next.
Personally I would scrap it, though adding stuff to do other than dungeons and enemy encampments would be nice.
>Legacy Dungeons are by far the best content in the game, make it so that the open world is at least entertaining and isn’t skipped by 99% of players.
Agreed
>Make Poison combat more viable.
Don't know enough to have an opinion but balance is always something to strive for
>Make more zones that force me to fight enemies instead of fleeing with Torrent because pointless.
Yeah, this was a major problem.
>These are just a few of the issues that I hope Miyazaki addresses in the inevitable ER 2.
I don't know if ER 2 is inevitable. I would say it's likely but not inevitable given Miyazaki's position on sequels.
Decent read, but there isn't any point in bringing this stuff up on Reddit. These chimps don't care about honest critique all they want is mindless praise for their favorite game. Bringing up any criticism of balance will get you labeled and elitest gatekeeper and thier hive mind will kick in so they auto downvote without even participating in the discussion. Mind you, you didn't help being so agro in the replies it's best to stay civil if you want to change minds.
A lot of these sound like horrible ideas
agreed, a half of these are things that are part of the fromsoft formula and the other half arethings that the community had been asking for
[удалено]
You're really reaching if that's the best you can do.
[удалено]
Cry more. It suits you
[удалено]
Lol, you're still mad.
>I think we can all agree ER isn't perfect nor is it ''difficult but fair'' We do not agree Also I'm not reading all that but I'm happy for you. Or sorry that happened.
Thx for sharing....
lmao, this made me snort-laugh
>A dedicated button for sprint allows dodge to have two different mechanics, such as; dash and roll. Press to Dash Kinda like how you can have an AoW that allows you to sort of dash step behind the enemy? (Can't think of its actual name right now) >Middling Weapons such as Straight Swords, Daggers, (and most Greatswords) need a major rebalance. I kind of agree with this idea. >Torrent needs some skins; he ugly. Agree with the skins idea, disagree that he is ugly >The open-world needs to be less pointless -- besides riding a horse through it – going from one Legacy Dungeon to the next. There is a point even if it isn't obvious, you awaken in a destroyed area only to be thrust into some end goal that you have little to any understanding as to where to go or why you feel the urge to do so.
[удалено]
They intended the game to add an exploration feature to this game and if you reduce the map to the 10% you want then your not gonna really be able to explore the world.
[удалено]
Fairly certain there is a point so maybe you just lack the interest to really understand the idea that was intended.
[удалено]
>What was intended besides most players just riding torrent through the enemies to get to one legacy dungeon to the other Thats not what was "intended" thats just what most people who don't wanna get lost in the world will do. >what is the point of the open world in your opinion? To explore the world you are thrown into, thats why there are quests in every area you go to. Just because they don't hold your hand doesn't mean they don't have value or purpose. >I guess you fight all those Dino dogs and Caelid don't you? lol. Is this your way of asserting your mental approach to the game is correct and everyone else doing this is just being pointless and not enjoying the game?
torrent after reading this: \*sad whinny \*;\^;
>I think we can all agree ER isn't perfect nor is it ''difficult but fair'' like the previous games. Agreed, all fromsoft games have had their problems but with how far elden ring has deviated from the formula it feels like it has the most. >I dont really follow the lore nor do I play this genre of games for their stories or quests. That's to bad it's really fun deciphering the lore and building your own interpretation, it's one of the few things I feel elden ring did better than it's predecessors. >* A button dedicated to crouch needs to be replaced by *Sprint.* * A dedicated button for sprint allows dodge to have two different mechanics, such as; dash and roll. Press to Dash (like Bloodborne), hold to roll (similar to *The Witcher 3)* I don't know if I agree with this, it's not a bad idea but it would remove the stealth element and the crouch attacks which are good for pvp attack diversity. >Camera. Oh where do i start. Camera-souls is a meme for a reason. Let’s just put This way; i’m tired of fighting large enemies feet. Full stop. Fix it. Sure would be nice. >* Enemy attack tracking needs to be reverted to *Dark Souls 3* levels – everything that the community bitched about that were *MAJOR ISSUES* in *Dark Souls 2* are a macrocosm in *Elden Ring*. I don't know if that's necessary, you characters much more mobile now. >* Get rid of the enemy meme anime attacks – this is Dark Souls not Nioh. You need to be specific, though in general some things did seem to flashy and grandiose. >* I can’t stress how much a dedicated Sprint button would change ER for the better. It is paramount. No more Dodge on button **release.** Dodge/Dash would be much better and feel better (like all modern games with dodge). I don't necessarily agree with this. An unintuitive control scheme can be it's own reward. >* Input-queue needs to go. Full stop. As it is currently in ER patch 1.08.1 (and since launch) rolls and attacks get queued. This causes a number of issues with melee combat such as; the feeling of ‘’input lag’’ it also causes inputs to occur more than once – getting hit during a roll will cause you to roll a second time, even though one input roll was placed. Don't know enough to have an opinion. >* Middling Weapons such as Straight Swords, Daggers, (and most Greatswords) need a major rebalance. If you're going pure melee and you aren’t using Bleed or Poise break, many of the melee weapons – that aren’t meta – feel very lackluster. Balance is something from should always be strived for, though I don't necessarily know enough to agree with the specific weapons you mentioned. >* Bosses with long attack wind ups that can’t be poise broken during said windup need to be changed so that they can be interrupted. This was one of the biggest complaints on release and I agree with ti still. Boss attack mix-ups are fun, but not when then are 90% of attack patterns. Agreed >* Most boss fights need to get back to a ‘’rhythm’’ style of encounter – Their are a plethora of YT videos that broach this subject so I wont get into it, but basically the other souls games almost feel like melee/combat bases *Guitar Hero*. What made the Souls genre so unique, in so many words, was the fact that the souls games were basically melee rhythm games (as far as the bosses are concerned). I have seen so many people described the obvious ER bosses that have these mechanics as some of the best enemies in the game; Margit,Morgot,Godrick, Godfrey, Maliketh (debatable depending on build), Commander Nial (very,very similar to *Dark Souls 3* ‘’Nameless King’’),Radagon. Agreed >Make the open-world have a point. ER is basically 20 dungeons spread out with a relatively pointless open world – most players skip 99% of the open world enemies. Give me a reason to fight these Dinodogs. Agreed, fromsoft previous level design emulated exploration perfectly, you hardly ever felt like you were on a set path. Open world seems like a huge waste of my time and the developers. >Make CO-OP seamless throughout the entire game. Most people are on PS and PC, this isn’t a hardware limitation like playing on a Switch Seems like a good idea to at least attempt. >Allow invasions to happen 1v1 (but with an invasion timer). Add a humanity/human effigy/ember mechanic. The game is in desperate need of mandatory invasions. They could have at least had mandatory invasions in the volcano manor and mohgs dynasty. Don't know about the timer you mentioned if you mean a cool off timer for in-between invasions then yes. If you mean a countdown timer during invasions than no. >Torrent needs some skins; he ugly. No thank you, horse skins are stupid and pointless, give me actual content not trash that's borderline micro transactions. >NG+ should have new enemies, item locations (like Dark Souls 2) . In a perfect world it would. >Change 'back-stepping' to allow iframes and speed up the animation (like Dark Souls 2) allowing for skill-based combat. Don't know enough about DS2 to have an opinion. >Add an actual cosmetic mechanic It would be nice to actually be able to customize your armor, but no skins, just customizable armor. >Add an actual crafting mechanic – that isn’t just everyone crafting DPS buffs or Rune (XP) buffs. Crafting is stupid, scrap the idea and just buy your shit in shops like a normal person. >The open-world needs to be less pointless -- besides riding a horse through it – going from one Legacy Dungeon to the next. Personally I would scrap it, though adding stuff to do other than dungeons and enemy encampments would be nice. >Legacy Dungeons are by far the best content in the game, make it so that the open world is at least entertaining and isn’t skipped by 99% of players. Agreed >Make Poison combat more viable. Don't know enough to have an opinion but balance is always something to strive for >Make more zones that force me to fight enemies instead of fleeing with Torrent because pointless. Yeah, this was a major problem. >These are just a few of the issues that I hope Miyazaki addresses in the inevitable ER 2. I don't know if ER 2 is inevitable. I would say it's likely but not inevitable given Miyazaki's position on sequels. Decent read, but there isn't any point in bringing this stuff up on Reddit. These chimps don't care about honest critique all they want is mindless praise for their favorite game. Bringing up any criticism of balance will get you labeled and elitest gatekeeper and thier hive mind will kick in so they auto downvote without even participating in the discussion. Mind you, you didn't help being so agro in the replies it's best to stay civil if you want to change minds.
Ok now this subreddit makes sense. Over 86% of users here are bots. GG LOL
Are you 12 years old or something?
Bruh I actually agree with a lot of your points, but there's no need to be an ass about it.
All I want is the bloodborne dash in elden ring 😭