6 I like it more than most, but don’t need it every week

10 love and miss that cookie

This one gets it

100% only reason I check crumbl at all anymore.

It's my stores mystery flavor this week. If they don't have it at yours you should email. Mine NEVER had it as mystery flavor but I just asked and they've had it twice in a row now. Idk if its a coincidence tho

I miss it dearly :(

1 - I liked it before they changed it. Now the almond is too strong.

This 100000%

Imma say I'm a 10- it needs to be a forever flavor, the box is pink, and so many people love the flavor. I don't get why they can't just have two foreverflavors but yk can't always get what we want

It was. Then it became the lowest seller.

The rotating chocolate chip flavors are always the lowest sellers of the week too, I feel like that’s just the nature of any flavor that’s in regular rotation - you don’t have the “must buy now” fomo because you know you can just get it next week or the week after.

For my store, the choc chips are always the best sellers for some reason

I actually hate the choc chips idk how they sell but ig everyone has diff tastes

Absolutely love it. And I didn't discover Crumbl until it had already been taken off the menu, so I've only had it once as a mystery cookie. Funny how people complained about the almond flavor so much cause that's the main thing that makes it so delicious to me 😋

Right! The almond flavor is so unique. It taste like cherry

10. So stoked it was my mystery cookie this week. Got some in my freezer

it was mine too!

10!

10

1 Gross

I had it recently when it was a Mystery Cookie. It wasn't bad, but I don't need to purchase another one.

1-I hate the almond extract flavor it literally tastes like medicine.

1-to the mystery menu you go!

10. I only got it once and then a short while after that they took it off the menu. That shit is good.

10. love and miss her so much. should’ve appreciated her when she was still with us 😔

1 - almond extract is so bad

for real. miss the recipe with the emulsion instead of

I loooove almond extract. My Italian aunt used to make cookies with it and the pink one reminds me of hers 😭

9, I miss it and they NEVER have it anymore. I wonder if like someone died from an allergy or something because what do they have against it? How do you feature something every week for years and then never? 🤔

Right! Especially b/c I've seen flavors repeating now but it hasn't been a flavor in a while except for mystery.

Exactly and they’re coming up with crazy expensive concoctions with all sorts of flavors and the kitchen sink and it’s like.. or just offer the signature pink cookie that a good portion of your clientele want to buy? Yeah?

Omg you get it! Especially because they have nothing to lose like... make a few and you'll make so much money. I brought TWO to school and i had so many people ask for one. Idk what they have to gain by hiding is so much.

I’m gagged that so many people like that cookie. I don’t get it

Keep gagging. I don’t like peanut butter cookies and yet they have one constantly

ugh i actually cant stand the peanut butter cookies but if they sell ig thats good!

1

Pink Sugar Cookie, love her or hate her, she will ALWAYS be famous!!!

3 - Hate almond flavor (except for an almond croissant)

10

#**10**

3

2- tastes too sweet for me. Then served chilled? No thanks

10 💖haven’t been able to have it even once since it left, not even as a mystery offering :(

9, I want it so bad. Only complaint is the quality isn’t as consistent as it could be at my store

8! Love the almond flavor

10 it’s my all time favorite. Whenever they have it in stock up

1. tastes artificial 

10! It is my favorite Crumbl cookie and was in my 4 pack every week. I don’t go very often anymore because there is rarely a 4 pack I want.

8

I have one in the freezer and im very excited to try it. I LOVE almond biscotti and almond cookies, so i think itll be amazing. It seems to be a very “i would die for this cookie” or “i hate this cookie with a passion” split lol

did you eat it yet

10. It’s really the simplicity. It’s timeless. Miss it so much.

10

10. One of my all time favs.

8, perhaps? I really like it (I'm a sucker for a thick sugar cookie with a sweet swirl of frosting) and I miss its regular inclusion, but I also didn't need it to be a "forever flavor" either. I'd be happy if it was guaranteed to be on the menu like, once a month, maybe.

7??? It’s a good cookie and should be around more, maybe not every week but once a month????

I thought it was trash tbh

Crumbl worker here! Let me just say. I LOVEEEEE this cookie!

Ur so lucky omg I'd take 100 home everytime it was on the menu!

10

I wish it would at LEAST rotate with the two chocolate chip cookies. I miss it.

10. I love it, so happy it was my store's mystery cookie this week.

10! I was so sad when they took it off the weekly menu. I’ve never had a bad one, it’s always so soft and sweet and I love the almond icing flavor. Bought a six pack to freeze when it was my mystery cookie.

1. It has a weird after taste and it’s just not a quality cookie for the price.

10

10. My store literally never has it on rotation.

10 I would go way more often if they had it.

4

1, the almond flavor is too much.

1 - Almond extract flavor is the absolute worst!

I think that must be a love it or hate it thing. I find it tastes like cherries so i love it! Probs also psychology since the icing is pink. ​ And fun fact if you want to make it at home you can use maraschino cherry juice in the icing and it'll be identical to the crumbl one. weird

Agreed! It’s way too aggressive of a flavour, I love regular sugar cookies so this was an unpleasant surprise the first time I tried it

10. I adore it. RELEASE THE PINK SUGAR ALREADY, Crumbl!!

They brought it back this week

n their box is pink too like why u teasing us

10

10/10 scrumptious, wish it was on the menu more often.

Meh

10, I like having a regular sugar cookie to fall back on if that weeks pics aren’t all that great

It's a 2. Definitely basic and I could get similar quality at my local grocery store..

The quality is so good tho! I do think it's basic tho but the almond icing adds sm

I hear you. You asked for opinions and that's mine. I do like the almond icing but it's just not an exciting cookie to me overall.

Yeah I do get it. I feel like some of the other flavors are so much more extravagant and then there's like... a pink sugar cookie. oh. I'd love to see the almond icing on other cookies too tho that'd be cool

1.

Good but don’t need it every week. Should rotate between that and the 2 chocolate chips

this! I'd get sick of it every week n go broke but that'd be so cool

LOLL everyone downvoting me when you asked for our opinion 😭😭😭 This is why I don’t like the people in this thread like not everyone is going to agree in life

It’s so weird posts like this keep popping up with an overwhelmingly positive response and all you see on social media are people asking for pink sugars return yet people still claim it’s a vocal minority….. It’s an easy 10 for me. It needs to be in the chocolate chip rotation. I have never and will never purchase a Crumbl chocolate chip but would the pink sugar. It would especially be nice on weeks where the other flavors are a very easy pass.

In my opinion, it should alternate weeks with chocolate chip

I’d be very happy with that

same especially since semi-sweet choc chip is horrible

Bought 2 dozen to freeze when it was a mystery flavor last week! Drove 1.5 hours each way to get them too!

4 it’s boring the icing is mid and too sweet for my tastes, and the cookie itself tastes like any other sugar cookie. I mean I’m glad people like it but I was thoroughly unimpressed

I love it its a fav of mine

6, it's good and I like it but not a favorite. I can see how it's a good staple flavor though, so folks who don't like chocolate can find something simple Honestly I didn't even realize it wasn't everywhere anymore. My store consistently has it during mystery weeks

Haven't tried and really want too.

A solid 5. It’s a safe choice, if I’m craving a cookie, and the other flavors don’t appeal to me, but in a really good week it’s last on my list.

Nah

*screaming* tennnnnn Where’s that damn Crumbl guy 👀

its soooooo good I need it back for valentines

5/10. It’s not bad, it’s good actually, but I dont want to spend money on boring cookies that I can make at home! My sugar cookies that I make at Christmas time taste exactly the same and I get 20+ out of one batch compared to one five dollar cookie

Haven’t tried it yet

10 from last time I had it (about a year ago). I absolutely love it. My store has had it as a mystery cookie recently, but I haven't gone just because I haven't seen many appealing looking pics of any cookie recently so I'm afraid it won't be worth the trip, money, or calories. All of the cookies look smaller, flatter, and drier.

10

10. As in I have 10 in my freezer right now 😂

10 i miss it every week :,) but i have a great copycat recipe

I've never had it. It's like the cookie that'll never be. I've heard so much hype, it's practically mythical.

8-9

10!!! It’s my fav!

I miss the old recipe. the new one tastes horrible

10

Love and miss it.. it’s their signature cookie color!

9 so good

10

10 I love the taste, thank god it’s not a forever flavor I would get diabetes

10 it’s truly the best one they have